News  Elections
Lapid's terms: Universal draft, peace talks
Tzvika Brot
Published: 24.01.13, 12:23
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
64 Talkbacks for this article
61. To the Haredi
SteveR ,   Dallas USA   (01.24.13)
Mothers and Fathers do not stay awake all night worrying their children will not come home when they are studying Torah. I saw a Haredi complained to Naftali Bennet that mothers are crying over their sons who might be drafted. Well Secular mothers cry also. Did you ever think of this? Secular mothers also cry. In the US in WWII, when there was a draft, there was no Haredi exemption for Torah. If the US put in a draft, would you dare defy it?
62. Eliezer of Chicago
Eliezer ,   Chicago   (01.24.13)
I'm not entitled to advocate an opinion about what's right and what's wrong. I do know that Jews lived in Israel long before the state was founded, and their right to live there is not predicated upon loyalty to the state. That's not opinion, that's historical and cultural fact. But leaving that aside, I was not addressing right or wrong. I was talking about unworkable truths. If a law is passed to mandate equal duty, do you think the Chareidim are going to say "ah, that's the law, where do I sign up"? The likelihood of that happening is on par with his firm plank of restarting peace talks. It makes sense from our side. But who is there to talk to? In theory, theory is not different than reality, but in reality, it is. What you're going to have is absolute, adamantine refusal by the chareidim. We're not talking Gandhi here. They may not be willing to fight the Arabs, but I guarantee they'll take to the streets to fight any such law. Am I entitled to say that?
63. PEACE TALKS
Henry ,   CaLGARY cANADA   (01.27.13)
You can not take a horse to water if it refuses to drink. The case with Arafats folowers for many years; Do not try to imitate Mr.OBAMA. Have b een around for 95 yrs.
64. Well said
Sam1am ,   Calif   (02.18.13)
Previous talkbacks
Back to article