News  Mideast News
Morsi aide: Holocaust a US hoax
Ynet
Published: 30.01.13, 00:14
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
36 Talkbacks for this article
1. Make no mistake.
Jules   (01.30.13)
Holocaust denial is not just a blatant antisemitism. It has a clear purpose: to deny Israel its legitimacy (!) The idea behind this campaign is to "explain": if there was no Holocaust, then the Jewish people don't need a national refuge (which was just one of the ideas behind the Ben-Gurion's decision to declare independent state). If no safe refuge is needed - then, according to their reasoning, Israel should not exist.
2. Someone...
marcelo tuchman ,   RIO,BRAZIL   (01.30.13)
in Egypt are trying to help Muslim Brotherhood. Cairo is risking peace deal with Israel.
3. Staying on good terms with Egypt's new leaders
Rhonda ,   Chicago, USA   (01.30.13)
And my tax dollars (much to my horror) are subsidizing the gift of F-16 fighter jets to Egypt to stay on good terms with it's new leaders. Hey any Israelis reading this...just letting you know we are paying attention to this stuff. It's not all about the Superbowl.
4. The sad truth
David ,   Israel   (01.30.13)
Is that not even enough time has passed where survivors are still alive and still bear the physical and emotional scars of such events and yet people deny it. The worst part about telling a lie is that if you tell it enough, soon even the liar believes it. The even worser truth is that only time will tell how long the truth can be proven as history is only told by what remains.
5. I cannot wait till the Sinai is returned to Israel
Chaim Ben Kahan ,   Efrat, Israel   (01.30.13)
We now realize that Camp David was a historical mistake and handing over our beloved Sinai to Egyptian occupying forces needs to be remedied. Every time Israel cedes it's land, whether it's the East Bank, South Lebanon, Gaza, Judea and Samaria or the Sinai it is met with terror and hostility. Lets learn our lesson and return the Sinai to it's rightful owners.
6. Not even worth commenting on!
Maurice ,   Montreal   (01.30.13)
7. Enough of the crap!!
Belinda ,   Texas, USA   (01.30.13)
I'm SO sick of hearing about countries denying that the holocaust even happened. Do they have a brain? Do they have a single thought of their own? The evidence is right in front of your face!!! If your religion has taught you these things then, IMHO, that's not a religion, it's brainwashing & it makes people look like absolute idiots. Enough already.
8. mental disease...
yosef, MSc' ,   usa - israel   (01.30.13)
This is extreme paranoid schizophrenia - living in a La-La land of wishful thinking. In the West people like this are generally locked up in an asylum - at the U.N. they call the tune and head governments!
9. Same to me
Walla ,   USA   (01.30.13)
It's so sad to hear such stupid comments but to me it's the same as some Israeli claims that Palestinians never existed. All ignorants.
10. 20 F16's
Ronnie ,   Australa   (01.30.13)
20 F16's ....Go to Egypt from the USA. It is all to much for the human unit.
11. Never Forget
Zechariah   (01.30.13)
The Jews ought never forget how the Islamic Brotherhood with violence and Oil BlackMail stopped the escape of Jews from Nazi Europe even to Islamic Lands.
12. Is Fox so called news reliable
ben   (01.30.13)
13. 27 people i my family were murdered in hollocaust
Fred ,   nYC   (01.30.13)
Where are theory if it's a hoax. Just watch Spielberg's shoah foundation
14. Fathi Shihab-Eddim in Bed with Goebbels
ltrail ,   United States   (01.30.13)
Fathi Shihab-Eddim, says, 'The myth of the Holocaust is an industry that America invented' . No surprise here. He is following in Joseph Goebbels' footsteps; who was his mentor. Morsi's government is losing credibility moment by moment.
15. arabian knights
ik ,   USA   (01.30.13)
Why does Ynet and the media in general give valuable space and time to such egregious screed???
16. Egypt wants financial aid from U.S. and this
Barbara ,   Haifa Israel   (01.30.13)
idea that Holocaust was invented by U.S. intelligence is insulting to the U.S. Why would U.S. give money to aid Egypt if Egypt in turn is insulting the benefactor.
17. Egypt... is no more.
Sarah B. ,   U.S.A./Israel   (01.30.13)
18. APPALING!
celine woland   (01.30.13)
look at egypt---the "zionist puppet" mubarak is gone and the country is governed by "democratically elected" islamists--the result is that egypt is about to collapse...and all this idiot has to say is an anti-jewish remark.. the remark has nothing to do with israel and shows once again how much they hate jews in general.
19. Admission to holocaust museums are now half price!
Edithann ,   USA   (01.30.13)
Even if it is a concerted effort to undermine Israels legitimacy...it's working... TATA
20. HOLOCAUST AND EGYPT.
SJOERD VAN DER VELDE ,   HOORN NH, HOLLAND   (01.30.13)
THIS IS PURE HOLOCAUST DENIAL. EGYPT HAS BECOME A FAILED STATE, PERHAPS JUST LIKE SOMALIA
21. #16 Ask Mr. Obama, he seems to have trouble
A ,   Belgium   (01.30.13)
deciding who his friends are.
22. #19 Admission to the closed ward in institutions
A ,   Belgium   (01.30.13)
for those with severe mental disturbances, as yourself, is free.
23. it seems
daniela   (01.30.13)
That re writting history according to their convenience is usual among dictatorships. It is the only way to keep the masses under domination-thru lies. To deny the Holocaust is a way to denigrate once more the jews.
24. President Obama....
Moi ,   Ici   (01.30.13)
If you sell those 20 F16 airplanes to Egypt, and the Egyptians will use it against Israel, its your blood on your hands....why the opposition can't stop this ridiculous deal....
25. Who is President of Egypt???
Debbie ,   Miami, Florida   (01.30.13)
Morsi??? This shows the ignorance and submission of this country and who is running it!!! You must be kidding? In this day and age??? He looks like a pig and ape!!! Morsi get some education! You are just showing your hate for Jews who you are your offspring too! I don't know what school or level of education you have? Shut up sit down look, listen and learn and stops making a fool that you are!!! EDUCATION IS KEY ELEMENT FOR WORLD PEACE!!!!
26. Thank you for speaking your mind
ky   (01.30.13)
When holocaust deniers open their mouths to speak they add a brick towards building the Jewish state. You cant deny the truth however hard you try. In this case it comes in the shape of a brick
27. I guess that the 'Arab Spring' is a myth also?
bUILD BABY BUILD ,   United States   (01.30.13)
and Syria, Sudan, Yemen, Libya, etc. Just rumors?
28. #22 - Classic! Touche - say no more
NudNik69   (01.30.13)
29. The US created the Holocaust in order to destroy Hiroshima?
William ,   Israel   (01.30.13)
Talk about grasping at straws. Guess the Egyptians forgot that the US didn't really listen to the intelligence about the Holocaust and didn't hit the train tracks used to take millions of people to their death. In that regard, does that mean that the Nazis were working for the US against themselves in the war? They kept meticulous records and touted their systematic genocidal actions. Hitler even wrote a book justifying it which is a best-seller in the very Arab nations that deny the Holocaust ever happened.
30. #12 - the majority of Americans think so
William ,   Israel   (01.30.13)
and FoxNews has a much higher viewership than CNN. If we use the liberal claim of "everyone knows", then yes - FoxNews is reliable. They even covered Hamas' crimes during Cast Lead and Obama faults in policy when CNN, NYT, and MSNBC didn't.
Next talkbacks
Back to article