Opinion  Aviad Kleinberg
Best of both worlds
Aviad Kleinberg
Published: 04.03.13, 20:45
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
41 Talkbacks for this article
31. More good people and entire families
Sagi   (03.05.13)
have left Israel because of the Haredim than because of the other run of the mill stated reasons such as, army service, wars, economical hardship etc. It is time to accept this fact. They are not living by normal standards and they are a burden on society financially and they are indeed hated by most just for what they do and are.
32. This article is a lot of nasty generalistions
Jrebecca ,   Modiin   (03.05.13)
And very little investigation into what good work Haredim do. Just for example ZAKA is very much ultra orthodox, and does amazing work with the general population. One sided, hate articles like this do Israel no good.
33. #32
Mordechai ,   Beit Shemesh   (03.05.13)
Wrong! it was formed as MDA is not good enough for them, it has secular people in it and they cannot clean up body parts after a terrorist attack! Simple and a load of rubbish! What if the person who is killed is not Jewish or not religious, must only the extreme Orthodox be allowed to clean up their remains, disgusting!
34. # 32 Modi in : J Reb Ecca
Tambour ,   Eilat   (03.05.13)
Dear Reb Ecca Zaka is a function of one man who had the idea, and attracted others: Humanity driven , not a function of being Hareidi So much false mumbo Jumbo in very many aspects..
35. #26
david ,   new york   (03.05.13)
please don't put your head in the sand: reform and conservative (called "masorati" in israel in order to make it seem better) are well financed and aggressive. most of the national religious i know are completely naive about them and since they are assimilated into israeli culture, they will follow along so long as it is presented as zionist irregardless of what will be (women rabbis and homesexual rabbis like the conservatives have here). mind you, there are "messianic jews" (jews for jesus) who serve with distinction in tzahal. so how can serving in tzahal be the paradigm of "being jewish"?? FYI: i voted for mitt romney (and gave money too). i have voted republican since ronald reagan.
36. #33: you dont know what zaka is
david ,   new york   (03.05.13)
zaka was not a haredi "me too" for MDA. it was created to identify and meticulously collect the remains of terrorist attacks to prepare them for proper jewish burial. it was not created as a paramedic organization. then, since they were so quick to the scene, they often arrived before MDA did and therefore they started training and preparing to do paramedic work.
37. #31 Sagi
Keren ,   IL-BR   (03.05.13)
Perhaps you don´t like when I answer your posts,but well,this is forum... You keep saying that you are not religious,but in my view you are religious-and idolater. Why?Because haredim are your gods. Who cares ,Sagi ,to leave a country because part of the people of that country annoys one?? What´s crazyness is that?
38. Zaka does a good job
Charles ,   Petach Tikva   (03.06.13)
But they are awaiting to be "rewarded be'olam haba" for those good deeds . If it was not for the "mitzwa" would they also do it ? I'm not so sure .... Zaka can't be an excuse for the charedim to avoid contributing a lot more to the State , they have to contribute too .
39. # 10, # 13
Mike Carmel ,   Rishon le Zion   (03.07.13)
Hi Sarah. I was surprised that you actually invested your time in correcting those chaps' linguistic skills. Have you taken up a new career as an English teacher? Well, kol hakavod anyway......
40. 38Charles If a Mizva is able to ...
ORA ,   JERUSALEM   (03.07.13)
motivate to do good deeds,may be we should appreciate the Mizvot and why not ,follow them? Haredim contribue a lot by increasing the Jewish population in Israel and caring for a Jewish majority. Not to underestimate. Other reclamations,Charles?
41. #11
Baruch ,   LA, USA   (03.08.13)
Until Israel returns the billions of annual funding it receives from the U.S., American taxpayers will weigh in on Israeli politics.
Previous talkbacks
Back to article