News
3-year-old critically injured by stones near Ariel
Itamar Fleishman
Published: 15.03.13, 00:50
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
79 Talkbacks for this article
31. sad
forehead1 ,   usa   (03.15.13)
i hope the little girl recovers. i ask what do you say when the gazan children suffer? is this a tragedy also?
32. Maybe also...
Yossi ,   London,UK   (03.15.13)
Maybe Israel never stole the "Palestinian" lands - maybe they were attacked by those animals and had to DEFFEND themselves ? The palestinians are great at telling lies The want peace as much as you love Israel...
33. Why didn't the Americans push the Palestinians into the sea?
Samson ,   Damascus, Syria   (03.15.13)
because they need excuses and pretexts to conquer more land!
34. the Bitons.
Rau   (03.15.13)
My deepest sympathy to the victims. May they have speed and full recovery. If it's true, the stone throwers must be brought to justice.
35. Time for another "Jews are mean to Arabs" hit piece?
BH ,   Iowa   (03.15.13)
Too soon?
36. #24
Eli ,   Newton USA   (03.15.13)
You say, "This garbage will stop when you stop yours." Unfortunately you are wrong. Arab leadership in the territories -- that is, Fatah and Hamas and assorted jihadist groups -- explicitly say that they will not be satisfied until Israel has been destroyed. No change in behavior of Israel or individual Jews will change this, because the point of view of the Arab leadership is that all Jews must go, period, just because they are Jews. Any desire on the part of Jews to see Arabs go IS based on on Arab behavior, not simply the fact that they are Arabs. Also, don't confuse instances of bad -- rarely lethal -- behavior of individual Jews with the government supported, organized, and initiated homicidal behavior of Arabs.
37. Move the nearby village across the river.
leo ,   usa   (03.15.13)
38. When the cops are tied up by the courts
Ron ,   OC, US   (03.15.13)
No separate roads, no guns for Jews and the cops get in trouble for protecting Jews with sufficient force. Very Sad.
39. 30.
Birdi ,   Israel   (03.15.13)
Absolutely correct. Kudos to you.
40. rocks are lethal
Larry ,   Los Angeles   (03.15.13)
Rocks can kill, just like guns. Anyone throwing rocks should be shot, just like anyone pointing a gun at a police officer. Stop rock throwing now!
41. I wish ppl could c how Israeli arab live here
Israeli girl ,   Israel   (03.15.13)
they have Houses bigger then most Israeli, they can live wherever they want, study, work, like the rest of us. arabic is a formal lanuage, and is on every sign on the road and public offices. they participate in tv shows (for example "The Voice" has a few girls, and in "Master Shef" an arab girl came 2nd place), in the goverment.. girls has equal right (and in Gaza they don't..). I mean, they have a good life here. they have all the rights but not the obligations.. for example - they don't serve the army to protect their contry like the jewish. And they throw rocks. at us. for been jewish. When u take an arab to the middle of Israel, say, Tel Aviv or Jerusalem, what will happen to him? nothing. But if u take a jew to the middle of Gaza what will happen? he will be linched instently. and about Gaza? Israel is out of Gaza, it doesn't rule there.. they have their own "goverment".. Hamas rules there. Israel answer to their continuess provocations, but we are not the rulers.
42. No difference between being stoned or shot by a bullet
(03.15.13)
Both with intent are attempted murder
43. some interesting facts !
Yossi ,   London,UK   (03.15.13)
To all the critics of Israeli jews who live in the "west bank" also known as Judea and Samaria,here are some very interesting FACTS : 1)The palestinians are longing for peace so much so that they target INNOCENT CIVILIANS by throwing stones at them. 2)The palestinians have their OWN Otonamy - so as far as rights go,all blame to their government please. 3)how can Israel make peace with the palestinians when they are divided to two : PLO & Hamas - which does NOT recognise Israel has a right to exist ! My conclussion : Treat the Palestinians terrorists who did this with a death penalty,no less ! A just peace will be ONLY when BOTH sides want real peace,the Palestinians want Israel's DESTRUCTION NOT PEACE! God bless the Jews and wipe away our enemies... Amen ken yehi ratzon !
44. need to stop this NOW.
michel ,   Ashkelon   (03.15.13)
Today stones , tomorow grenades and bombs.
45. Just a thought, here
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (03.15.13)
Perhaps it is time for Israel to revisit the issue of how to deal with terrorist scum. Let's go back to blowing up their houses. The prospect of having to house twenty or thirty or forty homeless individuals just might curb their terrorist enthusiasm. Just do it. Teach that terrorist scum that pain is not a one-way street.
46. I was arrested
Iossi ,   Shomron   (03.15.13)
My car is a write off. Damaged by stones. I was arrested because I shot in the air when under a barage of stones. To all you good doers in the usa or north tel aviv. Hat would you do if you came under daily attack. I dont need to answer because we all know. 1 terrorist attack in NYC and you yanks attacked andoccupy numerous countries in the middle east. As for the leftists in north tel aviv. Continue you draft dodging and complain about the high prices of cottage cheese. Its about time we made some order in Judea and Samaria. An eye for an eye. They throw stones at us. We should do the same. They shoot at us, we should do the same. The only thing that will stop this is by being strong. And before any of you start calling me a religious nutter, I can assure you I am not, just a realist
47. To Sam number 6
Markos ,   Ethiopia/Czech Repub   (03.15.13)
I agree with you on one point, The Arab people and their children who livie within Judea & Samaria have been deprived of rights, but NOT by Israel. They have been deprived of rights by their own leadership who constantly and systematically lie to their own people, and incite them to murder Jews. Children are spoonfed hatred. Are they deprived of rights, yes, by their own leaders they are deprived of the truth and are under a constant barrage of lies so what do you expect. As Golda Meir plainly put it, "Peace will come when the Arabs will love their children more than they hate us".
48. To No: 45
Mike   (03.15.13)
Another brain fart of yours eh? Good to see you are at least consistent.
49. #24
(03.15.13)
Most of the time where there is violence between Arabs and Jews the Arabs are usually the ones who start it. And there is no proof Jews threw the firebomb at that Arab taxi. The Shin Bet had to let the Jewish kids go for lack of evidence. You say you have a big heart,and your hurt when children are injured but the way you talk you don't sound like you have a heart at all when it comes to Jewish children being injured by Arabs.
50. Headlines
Robert Haymond ,   Tequoa, Israel   (03.15.13)
They are not "stones". the Arabs throw or lance rocks meant to seriously injure, cause destruction or kill. This is the usual Ynet downplaying of threat to Jewish people in Israel while still reporting the news. Ynet has become increasingly neutered over the past three years. It is no longer my first source of information nor does it contain the best Talkbacks anymore. This is because Ynet refuses to publish the most informative; as a result, the former Talkbackers have, so to speak, backed off. This newsite is deteriorating.
51. attacks
rm ,   Amsterdan, NL   (03.15.13)
another nasty talkback filled with hate. A little girl badly wounded...it shouldn't really matter if she's Jewish or Arab because all children are precious. But ofcourse in the context of the conflict it does matter. The army has already arrested 8 Palestinian suspects and I think more arrests will be made. I wonder if the same had happened had the victims been Arab... Probably not and the same people that are now so apalled would have come with excuses why it was most likely just an accident or in any case not a Jews fault....and as long as that's the case this conflict will fester on....and on.
52. Intention to commit multiple homicide
hipocrates ,   earth   (03.15.13)
book the terrorists as such.
53. wow, I dont see this
holy warrior ,   uk   (03.15.13)
Kind of grief when the idf intentionally kills palestinian babies. God bless this babies soul just like every innocent baby who becomes the victim of zionism. And there are plenty of them..
54. why there has never such stone throwing in Israel "Proper",
observer ,   Egypt   (03.15.13)
have you asked yourselves?
55. Oppression of Palestinians is a form of terrorism too
(03.15.13)
So what do you expect in return?
56. why the truck driver parked, why only Jews eye witnessed?
observer ,   Egypt   (03.15.13)
have you asked yourselves?
57. Yes, low info person #51, the reverse would and has happened
Cylia ,   Modiin, Israel   (03.15.13)
Get all the facts, not just from the lamestream media! Of course I am giving you the benefit of being a 100% human and not subhuman racist/bigot.
58. rm, Amsterdam 51
JUDAH THE LION ,   JEWS FIGHT LIKE LION   (03.15.13)
If it was an Arab girl who was hurt, you can be 1000% sure that the Israeli police will do the same to arrest the Jewish offenders. Israel have laws not like your Islamic friends mish mash laws
59. To #55
StoutViking   (03.15.13)
According to this logic, Jews should have eradicated the Arabs, as revenge for all what Arabs done since the beginning of the Islamic conquest, from Haibar till this day. "Boohoo, oppression!". They decapitated 7 people in Saudi Arabia this morning and you whine about "oppression"... Wuss.
60. Nr.22
(03.15.13)
Jarda the antisemite, how about the czechs who stole jewish property during ww2? And if someone happened to survive concertration camps & ask for their property it was the russians who had stolen everything my foot
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article