Opinion
Obama's Israel experiment
Avi Zimmerman
Published: 15.03.13, 14:34
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
60 Talkbacks for this article
1. why boycott 500 of Ariel Univetsity's Arab students
(03.15.13)
Shouldn't Obama try to appeal to all students from all sides of the student communities in Israel?
2. Obama visit
graczek ,   Maryland, USA   (03.15.13)
President Obama demeans himself and America by visiting the illegal Zionist state. I hope that one day in the near future, however, he will have his chance to visit a liberated Muslim-Christian Palestine, the way the Holy Land should be morally.
3. Obama is plain evil.
Chaim ,   Israel   (03.15.13)
Obama never had any integrity in the first place. His loyalty is neither to the U.S. or Israel.
4. Obama=Jeremiah Wright in a coat and tie
Steve   (03.15.13)
5. The America President insults everybody
Gee ,   Zikron Yaakov   (03.15.13)
When he went to Egypt he insulted their President by forcing the outlawed Muslim Brotherhood to be at his speech. Now he wants to practice American apartheid here in Israel. Perhaps we should insist that the KKK or Aryan Brotherhood be at his next State of the Union speech. Oh wait he will invite CAIR and that is close enough
6. US doesn't respect any sovereignty
Rob ,   NY USA   (03.15.13)
Of course they applauded Netanyahu. All he kept saying was how great America is, and Israel will do anything for you. Since 5 nations at the UN run the world. After the fall of the USSR, Israel should have went with better ties with Russia. They have ties with all the neighbors, except the Saudis. But Russia has oil and arms. And then it would be in their interest for real peace. We are both indigenous of our lands and a common enemy of nazis and fascists. Russia lost over 20 million to the crazy nazis.
7. Why do American Jews vote for him?
Bert ,   Bushnell, USA   (03.15.13)
Obama does everything to impower the muslim nations. So why do the Jews vote for him?
8. Right move
Giora Me'ir ,   USA   (03.15.13)
Just hope he sticks to his guns and not cave as he usually does. Students at an illegal university in the west bank have no business being invited. It would just reward a violation of international law.
9. Not inviting Ariel students undermines integrity of visit
Michael Steiner ,   Bahrain   (03.15.13)
LOL!! Sure it does :)))))))))))))))
10. To: No. 2
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (03.15.13)
So, you still haven't given up your wet dream of exterminating the Jewish people and destroying the Jewish state. You must have the nastiest bedsheets in the world.
11. To: No. 6
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (03.15.13)
Russia has oil, most of it under the permafrost in Siberia. What Russia does NOT have are drill bits capable of penetrating the permafrost. Only three or four countries have the requisite technology -- Israel being one -- and it is not for sale. Russia has arms -- most of them pretty lousy. What isn't lousy has not been maintained and is rusting away. Even their nukes are questionable (remember Chernobyl? How about the Kursk?). Five nations run the world? Well, perhaps we need to pick a new five. The present ones seem to be running the world into the ground.
12. Obama visit to Israel
Stan Betsi ,   London UK   (03.15.13)
Some Israelis are putting too much scrutiny into Obama's visit. Its just one head of state visiting another country, he doesn't run Israel nor is he a god. Just cant understand why some Israeli people criticize Obama, just because he is bold enough to point at Israel's short falls unlike other past American presidents, he suddenly becomes unfriendly to Israel. I think its time some Israelis looked into the mirror and accepted that the time has come to be in touch with the reality of the modern world where the treatment of the Palastines and the occupation of land belonging to other nations cannot be ignored or spoken of as if its not important .
13. #2
Walter E. Burke ,   Atlanta, GA, U.S.A.   (03.15.13)
Keep dreaming, you and Abbas both!
14. Critical Thinking =
Harriet ,   U.S.A.   (03.15.13)
If as your article states, Israeli students are taught critical thinking skills, then it should be a no-brainer for them to suspect what P. Obama is doing in excluding students from Ariel University, and to support the inclusion of all Israeli students by (if they are still excluded when he comes) boycotting his talk and making it known why. Why allow themselves to be manipulated and insulted by P. Obama.
15. Now hopefully all the theatrics have been played out
Sammy ,   Newcastle   (03.15.13)
With Israels Election over With the UN Vote over With the Netanyahu and Abbas spoiling tactics...OVER There is hopefully a new sense of purpose and urgency to TALK WITH rather talk TALK AT each other then we might get somewhere We know this is not an overnight project but talking will help get started on the long road to Palestinian Statehood and peace But is not only about talking its about changing mindset and culture of Israelis Palestinians and their supporters ..and the media and supporters of peace have a great deal to offer..by supporting not one side or the other but of urging both sides to settle their differences and put the past behind them
16. Obamas messianic glory
Mira ,   Vienna   (03.15.13)
has got a bit less shiny to the Arabs as well as to the Jews. He misjudged the Arabs and he mistreated Israel. I doubt if he really can make up for it. Israeli have got suspicious of him and Arabs straightforwards hate him.
17. That its Obama is what undermines integrity of the visit.
Dr. L. Brnd ,   San Diego, USA   (03.15.13)
"Barack Obama" and "integrity" do not belong in the same sentence. That he is boycotting the Israeli university with the highest percentage of Arab students - and WB Arabs at that - speaks to the phoniness of his "peace ideology". The guy is all about insulting Israel, jews and Israelis, no matter what the cost to his claimed objectives: look at his initial visit to Egypt to "apologize" to the Arab world for the US defending itself for 911, while refusing to visit Israel right next door. Look at his visiting 14 muslim and Arab nations (some twice) during his first term, while refusing to visit Israel. Look at his flimsy efforts to stop Iran's nuclear bomb program - continuing on the same failed path that didn't stop N. Korea. Look at his record sale of 80 billion in jets to the saudis (total Obama deliveries to Israel - 6 propeller-driven training planes). Look at his decision to deliver 22 F-16s to Mursi, despite the man's sickening anti-semitic diatribes. Look at his wailing over Israeli building on the WB and the "occupation", while remaining silent on muslim Turkey's occupation of northern Cyprus. Look at Obama's continued efforts to blame israel for lack of a "peace process", when the actual obstacle is that the "Palestinians are divided, 50% of them under a Hamas ruler who rejects any recognition of Jewish israel, meaning Abbas can not deliver on "peace"no matter what israel does. Obama is a phony and a fraud, and Israeli university students will be the first to evaluate the facts and recognize that.
18. To #7 Because he is the best president to the US
Jon ,   USA   (03.15.13)
I would not invite visit or talk to the Student of Ariel, and I am an Israeli, so you want the President of the US to do it ???? Well, he is the best president for the US, and this is the only criterion the American Jews used when they voted for him. Do you elect Prime Minister according to how good he is to England ??
19. Obama is right, he is not there to endorse settlements.....
Cali Cal ,   Los Angeles, USA   (03.15.13)
would Israel allow Obama to meet Abbas in the Orient House in East Jerusalem, I bet not since it would give the impression that Obama endorses the division of Jerusalem. Stop playing politics. He's there to listen to what both sides have to say and thats it. Its up to Israeli's and Palestinians to solve their mess.
20. graczek # 2. Too bad you will not get what you desire
Arnold ,   Canada   (03.15.13)
Obama will visit Israel and do all the things expected from him including visiting Jerusalem , the heart and soul of Judaism as well as the spiritual center of Christianity and the 3rd holy site of Islam. The fact that you left out Judaism in your final point about the way the Holy Land should be morally leads me to believe you are biased against my Jewish bretheran .... but then again with the pollack name of graczek I understand why.
21. Banning the students fro Ariel
Philip ,   Afula, Israel   (03.15.13)
Sounds to me a bit like tampering with the jury, and not really very democratic.
22. Obama's divide and conquer strategy
Yoel J ,   NY USA   (03.15.13)
It is clear that Obama's whole point with this trip is to frame himself as a progressive leader in touch with the youth while ignoring the rest of the Israeli public, lead by Netanyahu, who he despises. Divide and conquer - oldest play in the book. He's going to babble on and on at every opportunity he gets about how enamored he is with this new young generation of Israelis, so advanced, so global, so in sync with modern sensibilities, so full of new possibities- always the new, young generation though- watch carefully and you will see. That is why he is speaking in a hall filled with college kids instead of at the Knesset, and giving these weird comments about hanging out with college kids in Tel Aviv. It is really a devious insult if you think about it. The message is - Most of Israel today is not where the solution lies, at best I will talk to your 17 year old kids, maybe they have more sense. It's not even that he wanted to come, but once he is coming this is the obvious play. Also, Pollard should go free, Obama is heartless. I wrote an article about it here: http://www.wordsillustrated.com/2013/03/13/pollard-and-obamas-israel-trip-missing-a-golden-opportunity-for-peace/
23. @#18
Anshel ,   Canada   (03.15.13)
You have certainly sold your soul the liberals in the USA. You may have been born in Israel, but your demagoguery statement toward Jewish students from Ariel University is a disgrace and amounts to a apartheid by Jews towards Jews. You have been infected by a dangerous poison and it is slowly but surely spreading to your mind.
24. Facebook Page
Bill Stein ,   USA   (03.15.13)
Look like the Ambassadors Facebook page seems to be deleting Protest against the boycott of the Ariel University so much for Democrocy.
25. arab students attend ariel university too!
scott ,   ramat gan, israel   (03.15.13)
Obama is petty & narrow-minded. worst president ever!
26. graczek # 2
Eaglebeak ,   Left Coast, USA   (03.15.13)
You demean America and yourself but by now most of us are used to it.
27. #10
Harold ,   USA   (03.15.13)
If number two's bedsheets are nasty my bedsheets are extra clean and I invite you for free.
28. Obama visit Israel
Leib ,   Maryland   (03.15.13)
Remember that all of the America's belong to the American Indians that the white man killed , so when you say the land of Muslims palistine that is wrong it is the land of Israel that the lord gave to the Jews not the Muslims
29. egypt
eva goldschmidt ,   frankfurt am main   (03.15.13)
The last time he addressed students had been in Egypt and we know the result of his speech. I wonder what he has to say to young well-educated Israelis as the president of a morally and financially and intellectually bankrupt country. I am very glad that he has up to now no intention to come to Germany. We have enough radical Muslims we need no visitors to encourage them.
30. #2. who are you to use the words "holy" and "morallly"
A ,   Belgium   (03.15.13)
You have no conception of either.
Next talkbacks
Back to article