Jewish Scene
Haredi weekly censors female Holocaust victims
Yitzhak Tessler
Published: 28.03.13, 13:16
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
53 Talkbacks for this article
31. Changes in modesty
Akiva ,   NYC   (03.28.13)
Back in the 1950's and 60's I recall mainstream Jewish papers using photos of girls only in engagement and wedding 'social notices'. Men considered it vain for men to be photographed!!! When a new generation published photos of the bride and the groom together we thought it very odd indeed! I would note that brides back then were fully covered in their photos, unlike the 'sleeveless and strapless' style of more recent times.
32. And they talk about the Africans illegals
genderinequalitycry ,   <>   (03.28.13)
These savages in suits, the Hareidi woman has to be most brainless creature on this planet to allow herself to be demeaned to nno end.
33. #12
jeff ,   new york   (03.28.13)
You are a fool. Stupid and dangerous but a fool just the same. It would have been better to have the nazi soldiers faces obliterated, as they, like you, were evil. As to obliterating the faces of dead victims...those who do suchare stupid and fools.
34. Heheh ;) ,...
split ,   US   (03.28.13)
Our Creator have a paculiar sense of humor, first He gave you a tiny piece of rocky wasteland then he added these freaks that like to rule but don't like to work or serve ,... Good luck, it's your turn to put up with their crap now ;) ,...
35. #19 - They are a minority,...
split ,   US   (03.28.13)
For how long acknowledging the fact that they procreate 4x faster than the rest of Israelis? ,...
36. a slow day at ynet
david ,   new york   (03.28.13)
hey, no news today - no problem! let's bash the haredim, that sells. most haredi newspapers always avoid publishing women's faces. now, its not my style, but its a free country (or so i thought). it has nothing to do with the holocaust and ynet knows that. they have written this same article multiple times. clearly it sells (by eliciting hatred), so no need for a slow news day
37. #10:Good one if one want's to have fun with the subject but:
tom ,   tel aviv   (03.28.13)
unfortunately it is that very same "god" that is the cause of this (and every other) religious insanity. The only way to cure it is to educate from the cradle. That is why haredim do not want education by any means. Knowledge is dangerous to their cause. Unfortunately we shall not live long enough to see world freed from the scourge of religions.
38. Cults are dangerous
Raptor   (03.28.13)
and this one particularly so. Mark my words, tragedy will happen one day, it is inevitable.
39. Haredim
Sam ,   Belgium   (03.28.13)
Very surprising that this is such important news that it as to be on the front page of a newspaper ,,,!!!! Now they aren't allowed to read newspapers which the editor is Mk Rabbi Mier Poresh Why is it that everything is blamed on the Haredim ??? You want it reminds me of ?.?? We have to do some soul searching Everybody hates us And we hate each ther This has to stop !!!!
40. Stop the Madness!!
Cohen,Israel   (03.28.13)
If they want to practice Sharia laws they are free to move to Afghanistan or Iran and leave Israel. Just get out of this country instead of take us all back 700 yrs into the past....!
41. Haredim to Brooklyn Heights
Zechariah   (03.28.13)
42. Modesty issues? Where? How?
NO to Talibanism   (03.28.13)
Could someone kindly explain how a picture of Nazis herding their Jewish victims for deportation (and probable extermination) violates any biblical "Modesty Rule". Censoring this photo because the poor woman's hair is visible is an attempt to erase the facts of this tragedy...this is the ultimate insult to the memory of the victims. Shame on Bakehila's publishers!
43. #22 Nick, All Jewish women should be disgusted & voice it.
Michael ,   California, USA   (03.28.13)
It surprises me very much how mellow are Jewish women when it comes to oppose those abhorrent racists and chauvinists. Look at these replies, only seven are from discernible women. Why so few, why so gentle? Why are women not getting their anger out in large numbers? Why aren't Haredi and non-Haredi women uniting in opposition to this ages old discrimination?
44. They are sick
Sam ,   Belgium   (03.29.13)
I really don't understand what's going in here,,,,,,, Such hatred !!! It's a private newspaper ,, and they don't publish pic of women,,,, They really didn't wan anything with it So what's the whoe uproar ?? Whatever they dithery are criticized !!! Come on guys tere re much more problems that we Jews have Wake up !,,,
45. So, women don't matter?
BUILD BABY BUILD !!! ,   United States   (03.29.13)
What nonsense and ridiculous norms' that leave women with no faces or identity. Only men deserve respect while women don't warrant even a picture after their dead? OY VEZ MER!
46. Woman heading towards their death arose these morons?
Jew1 ,   Ashdod   (03.29.13)
47. #5, to be honest, these Taliban leeches are not my
geshmardo ,   jerusalem, israel   (03.29.13)
brothers, my brothers are in the trenches, fighting for our country, they're schoolteachers -not these theocratic so called teachers-, they're nurses, etc.
48. Why is the Nazi Remebered
Mark ,   New York City, USA   (03.29.13)
Strange the honest Jewish girl and women are oblscured but the crimnal Nazi is visble. The religion is turned upside down.
49. Sin of dephotocation
ik ,   USA   (03.29.13)
There was no photography for this to be an "ancient tradition"!. This is the sin. Being perpetrated by the bible mongers who spend their lives staring into books without pictures while lusting in their mind. To be eager to dare deface those g-dly lost souls. That is the sin.
50. A freedom of speech issue
R Narz ,   Toronto   (03.30.13)
OK, I admit that perhaps I have over the years seen a few too many of the photos of the era. But still, it becomes a bit of an educational experience to look at them, as one can, to at least some degree vicariously experience the emotions of people on both sides of this. This censorship is essentially depriving the women of their voice, their ability to be "heard" by people of the future; and saying only men's expressions are worthy. What a bunch of macho chauvinist pigs, I feel utterly disgusted by this.
51. Edithann, USA
MR   (03.31.13)
You do your own version of it, so don't lecture us. The "world", ha? I remember one prestigious news site which had only ONE article about Haifa being hit during the whole 2006Lebanon war and even that one had a photo showing some Lebanese village. There never was a picture showing the damage on the Israeli site. Contrary to this talkback, there was no comment protesting this fact. Makes me wonder why are you so proud of your "world".
52. "Ancient Tradition"?!?!?!?!
yehudha ,   jerusalem   (04.02.13)
"Daily newspapers in the haredi sector work under the direction of "spiritual commission," an ancient tradition that does not allow the publication of photos of women." There is NO such "ancient tradition"!!!! Haredism is a very new religion!
53. Charedim
Sylvia Navon ,   New York,NY USA   (04.02.13)
The newspaper that censored this very well known photo is read by a fairly small population. If they need to "protect" their males from viewing female faces or clothing, that's their problem. What really infuriates me is the treatment of a little eight year old girl in Beit Shemesh while she was walking to school. Charedi men cursed her, spat at her, terrified her because they were more than mildly aware of what she was wearing. That event was horrifying. She was dressed modestly, but it was more important for these vile men that she be dressed in a style they approved of than her emotional health and sense of security. They were brutal and self righteous. If this is the Judaism charedim practice they can have it.
54. Right on Sylvia, TB #53
Scarborough1414 ,   Scarborough, Ont.   (04.08.13)
I have been grousing about the Beit Shemesh incident since the day it happened. Hareidi apologists say I "don't get it". Here's something: If they do this again to a small child, we should fight back using any means necessary. We're not going to let Israel be run by religious street gangs!
Previous talkbacks
Back to article