Opinion
Excuse us for existing
Elyakim Haetzni
Published: 10.04.13, 21:12
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
59 Talkbacks for this article
1. WOW!!!
Brett ,   Florida   (04.10.13)
Tell it like it is Elyakim! The best op-ed I have ever read here. Bravo!!!
2. HaEtzni
nanne ,   Paris   (04.10.13)
Never a truer word said.
3. Mr. Haetzni, maybe it's you twisting the truth?
Rachel Rabin ,   TA, Israel   (04.10.13)
That is why you haven't heard any denial, whether tweeted or not, whether polite or not. I'm afraid you cannot support your arguments. Peace for all.
4. Excellent article
Sidney ,   USA   (04.10.13)
Shame on the Israeli government for being so weak or cowardly.
5. Truth & Nothing But The Truth
ACortez ,   Anaheim, CA, USA   (04.10.13)
Why won't Bibi and others say the same? I like the direction Bibi has taken Israel but would love to see him say as much to western leaders, especially the euros. Time for the west to either stand for democracy or cower before the islamic terrorists. Either way, Israel would finally know who its true friends are.
6. They never will.
ramon machtesh ,   galutnya, tfutsotia   (04.10.13)
The name "Palestinian" was used by the British of Jews to deny their national aspirations legitimacy. The Arabs use it of a subset of themselves today for the same reason. What do Sinai, Gaza, and the Lebanon security zone have in common? That's right: Judenrein, a key element in any Arab plans for "peace".
7. Kol hakavod!
Aharon   (04.10.13)
8. Israel as an Apatheid state ?
Tomi Budapest ,   Hungary   (04.10.13)
Thanks for the author. A short , precise and a real analysis. The frequently defeatist attitude from the the Israeli side helps only the enemies of the State of Israel,including the so called friends, as the present American president. It is time to teach the word for the truth,too. Thanks for the author.
9. you hit thenail on the head
milson   (04.10.13)
short of an earthquake type event, the apologists in israel will have to die off because theyhate power, they think israel is wrong for stealing arab land, they deny the fact that arabs are sittiong on israeli land, all of it, they hate their fathers. You know the group[- all of haaretz writes, olmert, livni, ramon, sarid, haber, even bibi, barak, peres, beilin, ben ami, merridor. They cannot be convinced. so when they die off, israel will be rid of their influence. There isn o other way. T this day, livni thinks the UN blocked arms shipments to hezbollah. get the point!
10. Are you kidding me...
hans ,   germany   (04.10.13)
is this a joke??? this article twists all facts against the victims and this writer is living in lala land... GOD HELP US>
11. Advice from Germany?
Joe ,   USA   (04.10.13)
Nice to hear advice from Germany explaining who the "victims" are. GOD HELP US indeed.
12. Blame the victims!
michael Pielet ,   Israel   (04.10.13)
#10, hans, this is an old german, nazi, trick, blame the victims, the jews for the crimes committed by the germans and the arabs against the Jews.
13. Fantastic Article
Jordan Ariel ,   USA   (04.10.13)
This was quite a surprise to read. Wow was also the first word that came to mind. The author mentioned that we have basically been accused of giving Hamdiyeh Cancer. The author forgot to mention that Egypt claimed that the Mossad trained Sharks to go to Egyptian waters and eat Egyptian citizens. (i cant help but think of austin powers, with sharks with lasers mounted on their heads) What about multiple Pal leaders stating that there will not be a single Jew/Israeli in Palestine? To Rachel Rabin: (one of my favorite YNET Leftists) Israel and the Government of Israel are not the greatest evils in the world. For everything you and people like you feel that Israel does wrong to the Palestinians... you refuse to admit or recognize when Israel does something Humane, or good, or when Israel is not being treated fairly. Israel isnt perfect... but by constantly saying sorry for existing and not standing up to double standards that apply to Israel but no one else including the Palestinians... does not help Israel or its Arab neighbors. The Arabs and Palestinians have made some terrible choices, which has influenced their situation. Putting all of the blame on either side is not helpful
14. finally someone tells the real and only truth
Ilana   (04.10.13)
Thank you. I am shocked. It is about time.
15. Palestinian PR
Get Real ,   UK   (04.10.13)
Israeli PR does not,has never, matched that of the Palestinians. They have utilised all forms of the media to publicise their view, including Pallywood and have organised pro-active groups and moved on to de-legitimise Israel.The media is now quick to publish anti-Israeli reports but ignores most positive aspects, including those mentioned in this article. Time for Israel to move up a gear and not remain complacent just because it knows it is acting humanely.
16. Israel has always lost the PR war to the arabs
A ,   Belgium   (04.10.13)
The attitude of "no one likes us, no one is going to listen to us" has to stop. If an Israeli is hurt in by a rocket or a rock, it has to be plastered all over every media outlet continuously, Israeli spokespersons (and they have a few very good, native English speakers) must be condemning every act of violence until the message sinks in that the "palestinians" have no interest in peace, only violence. Israel should play the game the way the arabs play it , but with complete honesty and without lies, distortions and photoshop.
17. # 10 Yes, unbelievable
Keren Il-BR   (04.10.13)
The General Attorney has just canceled funding to a Yeshiva in the West Bank due to the vicious attacks of hilltop students on aged Palestinians and the author said Obama lied. Articles like this is destroying Israel from within. Each time an israeli try to hide our moral faults and mistakes we are just feeding violence and corruption in our Jewish standards. And when someone who lives here, that watchs racism and intolerance grows by simply opening a newspaper and still denies it, then, yes, the future is hopeless.
18. to Hans
litvac120   (04.11.13)
What facts does this article twist? Be specific, or otherwise it's your post that is in la-la land. litvac120,usa
19. Mr. Haetzni
Obsessive ,   Turkey   (04.11.13)
Feeding Arab is not a duty of a Jew. They have trillions of dollars. They don't need charity or Tzedakah. Arabs have to accept Israel's right to exist only. Spain was the enemy of the Ottomans & North Africans. Dome of the Cordoba mosque still a cathedral. Today over a million Muslims live in Spain. Spanish tourists choose Estambul. Turkish kids are learning Spanish at the Instituto Cervantes. 2004 Madrid train bombing(s) had killed 191 people and wounded 1,800 (higher than in any other terrorist attack in Spain) Nationwide demonstrations followed the attacks. The Aznar administration lost the general elections. Spaniards have shown much dignity. Did you see any Spanish attack on Mosques, Muslims or Arabs? Can you imagine if this happened to the northern Europeans? God forbid! I'm only human Of flesh and blood I'm made Human Born to make mistakes. No one is an angel. Peace.
20. keren 17 your unbelievable
(04.11.13)
Yes all violence should be condemned,but why don't people like you ever criticize the Palestinians for vicious,violent attacks against Jews like the Fogel family massacre,or the daily rock throwing assaults against Jewish women and children,like the ones that left an elderly Jewish lady seriously injured several months ago,or the 2 year old Jewish girl who was left in a coma by Arab rock throwers. Don't the Arabs have any responsibility to act like decent human beings as well? Why is it "racism" according to people like you when people condemn Arab violence against Jews? Maybe it's because your a selfhating Jew?
21. #3. The truth is obvious to any literate school child.
Chaim ,   Israel   (04.11.13)
Any literate school child, capable of reading a map, can see that Judea and Samaria make Israel viable. Without Judea and Samaria, Israel would be a 9 mile wide concentration camp. Former Labor P.M. Abba Eban, and many others, admitted this. The leftist plot to cede our ancestral heartland of Judea and Samaria to our genocidal enemies is plain lunacy.
22. well
hmm ,   usa   (04.11.13)
you are from Germany, the end.
23. @10
(04.11.13)
sorry to say but as a german tourist and an activist for peace, i visited the areas the author is talking about and you are completely wrong. have you been there? did you talk to both arabs and israelis? did you visit the only arab roads? i guess not. otherwise you wouldn't show how uninformed and ignorant you are. actually, it is YOU who is wrong and mr. haetzni id fully correct in his assessment and reality on the ground. i am no saying that israel is 100% right. but what you wrote is such bs and has no value in the truth unless you come here and live in that area like myself and then you can scream and talk...when you know what you are talking about. henrick helfgott munich
24. Excuse us for existing
Al ,   US   (04.11.13)
Elyakim is a lier. Every word President Obama spoke was the truth. Palestinians in the WB are being subjected to unspoken cruelty, home demolition, restriction of movement, apartheid, ethnic cleansing by evicting 700,000 Palestinians in order to create Jewish majority in the present day Israel. Just to mention few.
25. #10 Care to back up your accusation?
Expat ,   Adelaide   (04.11.13)
How is this a joke? Exactly how does the article twist facts? Please elaborate. Please show how each and every fact the author brought up, is supposedly 'twisted'. Of course, it is much easier to write empty slogans without actually backing them up with a solid proof.
26. "Palestinians" would mass murder us all in a heartbeat.
Chaim ,   Israel   (04.11.13)
Excellent article. This is the type of self respecting journalism we need to see much more of in Israel. It is utterly absurd to engage in phony "peace talks with Palestinians" who would mass murder us all in a heartbeat if they could. Israel needs to treat them as the genocidal enemies they are and get them out of our land permanently.
27. SOME GOOD POINTS BUT ..
Iranian Jew ,   LA   (04.11.13)
pprejudice does exist in Israel in all forms. Jews are favored in the society since we had so many wars. But peace will not happen unless Isreal reaches out to the Palestinians with more economical incentives and help. That can be achieved in WB. Gaza is a lost case with HAM ASS ruling it. We can't change that and we can only hope that Egypt will rise up and will accept Gaza as their land. It is a tough road and we are going to get slapped once in a while but we will be rewarded at the end. We must make Palestinians realize that Jordan and Egypt should share the burden as well. We must come to an agreement with WB and Jordan and release WB to Jordan as Palestine or whatever they want to call it. That is our only hope to stop being called occupiers and such. Palestinians are on the verge of realization that their problems are economical and not so much about authority over land. Year by year they realize that they too could have shared the land with Israel. I know I'm dreaming, but why not!!!
28. #17 I do agree with you 100%
Iranian Jew ,   LA   (04.11.13)
We must recognize our limits or we are no better than Hitler or the Monkey in Tehran.
29. We do support you, Israel.
Luiz F Haddad ,   Niteroi, Brazil   (04.11.13)
Jewish brothers and sisters. The article above is right. Decency, Humanism and Ethics have been basic principles of Israel, since her begining. There is no reason for guilts. Lies will not prevail over Truth. While Arab Palestinian rulers don't respect their neighbor, they will never have a State. Warm salutes.
30. No, excuse US for staying on OUR land that you STOLE!
Ramzi Jaber ,   Palestine   (04.11.13)
Next talkbacks
Back to article