Opinion
Excuse us for existing
Elyakim Haetzni
Published: 10.04.13, 21:12
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
59 Talkbacks for this article
31. Anyone who puts "Palestinian" in quotation marks...
Michael Steiner ,   Bahrain   (04.11.13)
...is SERIOUSLY detached from the real world.
32. Obamass jJerusalem speech!!!
Beary White ,   Norway   (04.11.13)
His speech was just like coming from an islamic follower, and so he is, just look at his ring..just listen to his Cairo defences speech for islam..and..take a look at some pictures from saudi, king.. Then his words is just pussy..
33. Of course, there is another option
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (04.11.13)
Let us deny medical care to West Bank Arabs and Arabs from Gaza. If they die; they die. Too bad. If they have no access to Israeli health care, they'll have nothing to complain about with respect to the quality of that care. Of course, they'll be dead .... but that would be their problem, wouldn't it?
34. Does Georg Bombach exist? Who fled to Palestine sanctuary.
Steve Benassi ,   Silver Bay, MN USA   (04.11.13)
Adopted a fake Hebrew name. Joined a Zionist Terrorist organization. Drove native Palestinians out of their houses, off their land in 1948. Now an illegal settler leader. This is how Georg Bombach thanks Palestine for saving his family from the Nazis.
35. No, Sorry to share Humanity With you
Refugeeee ,   USA   (04.11.13)
#12, 1st Q. Does king David Hotel Bombing, to kill British Officers,1947-1948,RING A BELL,, DINGDINGDINGDING,, 2nd ,, Do you Really and the writer deep in your hearts THINK The Palestinian has the right to exist on that land ( where THEY WERE BORN ) ??
36. my thoughts exactly
(04.11.13)
sick of Germany
37. Without a doubt
Gee ,   Zikron Yaakov   (04.11.13)
One of the finest articles I have ever read. Direct and on target. Now we can support the facts of the Levy Report as well. That the land is ours and that the Arabs do not have any claim to it whatsoever
38. Evident truth, but tell it to the Judeo-Quislings !
tom ,   tel aviv   (04.11.13)
39. #31:All right,alternative: Fakestinians, no quotation marks!
tom ,   tel aviv   (04.11.13)
40. Manipulative and defensive article
Yossi ,   Tel Aviv   (04.11.13)
What about the hundreds of thousands of pals who cannot enter Israel to pray in their Aqsa? what about the farmers who are not allowed to reach their lands? the checkpoints? the settlers attacks? the author is playing the victim and forgets the other side of the story. totally immoral speach!!
41. typical
rm ,   Amsterdan, NL   (04.11.13)
piece of rubbish by someone completely blinded by Zionism. It has no base in reality....there's no doubt palestinian face daily hardships. There's no doubt that Israel calls all the shots and there's no doubt that Israeli settlers are amongst the most spoiled part of Israeli society.
42. What's sad
Jarda ,   Czech Republic   (04.11.13)
is the basic fact, that you exists on the land you stole from Palestinians. They won't exuse you existence as long, as you don't agree with their return to the stolen homes and land.
43. Bravo! Bravo! Bravo!
tiki ,   belgium   (04.11.13)
44. #34. Twist your lies all you want, Benazzi
A ,   Belgium   (04.11.13)
Fact is, Haetzni did what every self respecting Jew fearing persecution did, he returned home...at the age of 12. In 1948, he was wounded fighting the war of Independence, which was a war of self defense, not pushing the non-existant "palestinian" (who were only invented in 1967) squatters out of Israel. He studied, became a lawyer, fought corruption in the Israeli government, in short, is an asset to Israeli society. You, on the other hand, are simply an a$$.
45. Haetzni, the myth-maker
Michael ,   Haifa   (04.11.13)
Haetzni is one of Israel's most prolific myth-makers, as evidenced by his consistent vested interest in the "Greater Israel Myth"
46. "Greater Israel" is another demented leftist concept.
Chaim ,   Israel   (04.11.13)
Judea and Samaria legally belong to Israel and have for more than 3,500 years. This tiny land is ours. "Greater Israel" is yet another demented leftist concept. A healthy teenager could bicycle across our land, including Judea and Samaria, in two to three hours.
47. Only brain dead Israeli comments are posted here.....TATA
Edithann ,   USA   (04.11.13)
48. Universal Rule #1: Never ever, trust an israei
James   (04.12.13)
49. 17.
Birdi ,   Israel   (04.12.13)
Brazil awaits your return. Bye bye.
50. Israel is the one nation in the Middle East
Reuven   (04.13.13)
that does NOT practice apartheid.
51. 30. Ramzi
Allen ,   Toronto Canada   (04.13.13)
How dare you claim it is your land? Just because you were told that? If you get any land back in any agreement I suggest it be given back the way you "left " it , i.e. arid, bug infested and infertile. Or would your "honour" be insulted to actually rebuild your country rather than rely on handouts from the rest of the non Muslim world?
52. Apartheid in Islamic lands
AMERICAN HINDU ,   USA   (04.13.13)
Every Islamic nation practices some form of RELIGIOUS APARTHEID. Yet the world is silent. We Indians will never forget the help Israelis gave us after the earthquake that hit Ahmedabad, Gujrat.
53. To post 52
Rajesh ,   India/ USA   (04.13.13)
Get off your knees for Gods sake. Its people like you who give Hindus a bad name
54. New vision: non violence
Pal Pal Pal   (04.13.13)
Of course Haetzni is wrong. He and all people of Israel and Palestine should address one sore point: Bring in the non-violence!!! Together at the same time. It must include the Arab and Muslim nations. Leaders like Morsi, Ahmedinejad, Erdogan, Haniya, Meshal must be charged with crimes against humanity. Palestinian leaders must work on elimination of the curse of violence. And let us enjoy the future peace together.
55. To: No. 54
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (04.14.13)
Well, you just lost your last best hope. Fayyad has resigned. Your so-called "leadership" is now made up exclusively of terrorists. Where do you think that will take you? Certainly not on the path to non-violence. Your "leadership" is sworn to violence and terror. It is their very reason for being. Israel will win that one. You know that. Better start packing.
56. To: No. 47
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (04.14.13)
Well, they posted your brain-dead comment, didn't they? There you go with your absurdly inaccurate generalizations -- yet again. Why don't you kick yourself to the curb, Idiotann, and save us the trouble?
57. To: No. 30
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (04.14.13)
Oh, please. Stop with your nonsense. Israel did not steal ANYTHING. Israel was quite content with its tiny fraction of land. It was YOU who decided to go to war -- six times -- and LOST. If you lost land in the process -- well, that's what happens when you wage wars of aggression and lose. Cry me a river for your stupidity and short-sightedness. Besides -- the land was never yours to begin with. It was YOU who stole it from the Jews. We're just reclaiming what has always been ours. Don't like it? Tough. Leave. No one is stopping you. Care to try yet another foolish war? We'll kick your asses even harder than we did the first six times. All the way to the Hejaz in the Western Arabian desert, where you come from. Forget that very much to your peril.
58. The Yishuv and the State
Zechariah   (04.14.13)
The Yishuv was created because of Pogroms and Hate Mainly from Tsarist Russia then from Nazi Europe .Israel was created out of the Barbarism of the Holocaust and World Jewry in 2013 is still less than 1939.In 1939 the Arab Palestinian Population was one million now it is Ten Million So who are the Nazis?
59. #57 enough hateful warmongering
On the Balcony ,   Akko/NY/Kyiv   (04.14.13)
How many wars have you fought in? How much shrapnel do you carry in your body? How many of your friends and family members' names are on the Wall in D.C. or being mourned in Israel this Memorial Day? How many of your family members are in the IDF today? Enough of your vile venemous hate-spewing. You are truly a disgrace to the Jewish people. G-d forbid you have children...
Previous talkbacks
Back to article