News
US report: Israel discriminates against Arabs, women and migrants
Yitzhak Benhorin
Published: 20.04.13, 19:41
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
88 Talkbacks for this article
61. huh
b ,   us   (04.21.13)
discriminates against non-orthodox Jews?!
62. discrimination
FF ,   Brazil   (04.21.13)
Would State Department accuse the police manhunt in watertown of excessive force 2 days ago? because in Israel is "Boston" everyday. For sure the State Department is descriminating against Israel. Lets not talk about Guantanamo.
63. The reports on the neigbor states...
Beary White ,   Norway   (04.21.13)
..are much worse. So the local reporter who made this criticism of the State of Israel seems to have in mind, not to make Israel to be too attractive compared to islamistic countries. As always I am amazed how the jewish people makes critical reports abouth themself (a la Goldstein..) And..we are getting closer to the moment when Obama reveal his true face as an islamic follower. His speeches in Cairo and Jerusalem were just softening up the edges of surprise, and now his personal opinion glides into the open as some of us are waiting for, sunni or shia??
64. and we here in the U.S. have no discrimination whatsoever
mira ,   nyc   (04.21.13)
Yes, and we here in the U.S. have no discrimination whatsoever, not based on race, not based on gender, and certainly not based on sexual orientation, immigration status, or economic status. Therefore we have the right to sit and judge others.
65. To: No. 1
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (04.21.13)
Why? Because the United States says so? Doesn't the United States also claim that native American tribes are treated equally? Perhaps you ought to visit some Oglala Sioux reservations in South Dakota. Let us have your thoughts then; right now, yours are entirely irrelevant. Doubt you've ever been to Israel, so shut up, ignoramus.
66. Curious timing
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (04.21.13)
Can it be that the Moslem-in-Chief is embarrassed because the perpetrators of the massacre in Boston ARE MOSLEM? Why doesn't he goe to Jeff Bauman's bedside, and express his views there?
67. Appropriate force: 7 M Jews: 1.5 B Muslims.
BUTSeriousy ,   Sydney   (04.21.13)
68. US State Dept
Sherlock Holmes ,   London England   (04.21.13)
The US State Dept closed the gates to Jews fleeing Nazism even before the quotas for Jews were filled. The US State Dept advised President Truman not to recognise Israel. The US State Dept, like the British Foreign Office, has always been concerned to keep the Arab oil flowing, with human rights off the agenda lest it interfere.
69. # 29 Improved relations with Iran?? Are you daft
BUILD BABY BUILD!!!! ,   United States   (04.21.13)
or just another mindless twit employed by Iran our enemy?
70. HELP! GET ME OUT OF HERE!!!
DavidR ,   USA   (04.21.13)
Please Israel, forgive the stupidity of our government and pray for our deliverance from them! Please, everyone in Israel who knows the Holy One of Israel, please pray for Him to get me out of the US and bring me to the land I love. Israel! I am so embarrassed by my ignorant government. I disown them!
71. #38
MONA ,   US   (04.21.13)
Bla bla bla
72. #38 Anti-semitism
Robyn ,   Montreal   (04.21.13)
That's right Jason. The whole world is anti-semitic. According tho Darwin's theory of evolution and adaptation,humans adapt to their environment. After two thousand years of anti-semitism it must be in their DNA(genes) by now.
73. Boston and A Choice
Ron ,   OC US   (04.21.13)
Let me ask anyone is the State Dept. Would you rather be an Arab in Israel or a Jew in Araby. I am all ears. And yes Boston was a tragedy however, a few years back over a thousand Israelis lost their lives to Arab terrorism. If our casualty rate was that high you can bet there would be restrictions on Arab movements. And, there ought to be anyhow. Our INS in this country should be fired and in some cases shot outright for the damage done. I could go on....
74. Israel could compose a similar report on America:
Rotem ,   Israel   (04.21.13)
A report about - its treatment of illegal aliens, shooting Mexicans on the border, dispossessing Native Americans of their lands, discrimination of blacks in the work force, lack of sufficient social services in the inner city slums, the racism in the deep South, the virtually non-existent racial integration between whites and blacks, the treatment of prisoners in Guantanamo and other hidden detention facilities, the constant infringement of personal privacy in the name of National Security, the lack of regulation on the Internet which allows the blooming of neo-nazism and antisemitism on American websites, and the buying of American Congressmen by the ultra-rich. How would America react when someone else were to put a mirror to their face?
75. Calm down, kids
Cameron ,   USA   (04.21.13)
No "sea change" here in US-Israeli affairs. The State Dept. has always been somewhat inclined toward favoring wider relations with the Arab states, and under the current progressive regime in DC, they currently have the encouragement and latitude to release such a report. A report tailored emphasizing "rights" and sourness on Israel so as to mirror and please the progressive quality of those in the White House. The interests & mutual needs of the alliance are as sound and intact as ever, and this "snarl" out of the State Dept. signals no threat or altering. Liberal wonks in the State Dept. indulging themselves under Obama. The US-Israeli fundamentals do not change.
76. Israel discriminates against Arabs,women and minorities
(04.21.13)
No country is perfect because there are no perfect people. Israel should be criticized when it deserves to be criticized,but why wasn't there a report on any other countries human rights in the region? The Syrian Government tortures and murder their own children but as far as I know there is no State Department Report criticizing them.
77. My fellow Israeli Jews
Rami of Nazareth ,   Israel   (04.21.13)
Anyone living in Israel know that what the report states is true. It is no surprise to anyone. As a matter of fact, this is an annual report and is almost the same every year. Instead of denying the facts, let's all work together, Israeli jews,Israeli Arabs,men,women, Ethiopians to make this a better and stronger country were we everyone has equal opportunity to succeed in life.
78. If ALL countries in the world (including the US)
tiki ,   belgium   (04.21.13)
would discriminate as much as Israel does, the world would be 'nearly perfect. Does discrimination happen? Of course it does, as it does in ALL countries in the world. The US State Department should be quiet, very very quiet, for it's own history is not what one would call 'a clean slate.....and still isn't!
79. (7) Mike from BELGIUM
tiki ,   belgium   (04.21.13)
Or should I say Flandria, Wallonia, Germanic Belgium & Brussel? In a little country with 10 million people, is officially divided in 4 parts, three governments, three languages and a true '''language barrier'' over which wars were fought & peace hasn't been found, government crises occur till this day and people refuse to speak the language of the other. In a little country where a Maroccan & other (non white) Belgium citizens, who are applying for a job will get the answer that it's taken, while it's not, apartments have 'just been rented, when they are not, where non white youngsters are not allowed in disco's and where this week-end results came out over the enormous discrimination & racism in the country. In a little country where the Media officially call those few Jews living their the ''Jewish Lobby", are biased and lying about Israel and where even national überjournalist Rudi Vrancks had to admit that his reporting is sometimes not completele neutral, because his bosses require it. A man from this kind of discriminatory country should know when to speak and when not! Every civilized person knows this rule for ages!
80. To: No. 77
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (04.21.13)
I have a better idea. If you feel so discriminated against, why not just leave? You can go to Egypt. You can go to Syria. You can go to Lebanon. You can go to Jordan. You can go to Libya. You can go to Morocco. You can go to Algeria. You can go to Tunisia. You can go to Saudi Arabia. You can go to Iraq. You can go to any Arab country you want. Israel is not your home, so amscray. If you're that unhappy in Israel, wouldn't you feel ever so much more comfortable living among your own kind? Marauding Arab land thieves? Bad idea to bite the hand that feeds you, Rami. VERY bad idea.
81. Mirror to their faces? Mirror and they are cracked.
Big bad Jew ,   United States   (04.21.13)
America has made many wretched decisions, slavery, women's rights etc. however, as a young democracy it has also been a part of our past and present to correct the legal inequities and, hopefully, make a better America. We may have gone too far when it comes to being 'liberal' - proof being an amateur pro muslim in the WH who, ( supposedly ) is a constitutional lawyer who isn't well acquainted with the laws. For one example only the obama 'health care' which is about to remove most employees 40 hour work week and be replaced by a 30 hour week, in order to avoid paying for the employees insurance. So, the bottom line is, a good employee loses a fourth of his income and has no insurance. Way to go oybummer! 31/2 more years of this nightmare
82. given a choice, arab israelis still prefer to stay Israelis
mary of bethany ,   singaporer   (04.21.13)
isn't that enough, that given a choice, many arab Israelis still preferred to stay as Israelis, while continuing their whinning to humna rights groups and tourists and foreign press how bad are the Israelis treating them. many will not even dream of being ruled under Abbas. they proudly said they want to remain a thorn in Israel's flesh, in truth they enjoy all the benefits of a citizens, without the contribution of a citizens... Ask the human rights groups to research on how the Arabs countries treat their own arabs citizens, need not even check on how arab countries treat their minorities !
83. Annual Required by Congress
Mark ben Josef ,   USA   (04.21.13)
State Department reports annually on all 194 countries, as required by Congress. Congress specifies the subject matter of the reports - same issues for all countries. The reports can be read at the Department website - all 194 of them.
84. Israel discriminates
Ron ,   Lacombe   (04.21.13)
Israel discriminating against Arabs! No wonder the US is inundated with such violent Arabs-because the liberals there with their half Islamic leader think that appeasement is the best way to go with criminals! And they reap the wrath of these people. Let them try going to Saudi, Iran, Yemen or any such Arabic country and seek to be a plain westerner.
85. Everyone that know our state dept
Isabella1709 ,   Tampa USA   (04.21.13)
calls it the Arabist state dept and has for decades. It never utters a word about human rights abuses of Muslim Countries, especially Saudi Arabia that has a virtual revolving door into the US, Yet works through their mosques and schools built in America to subvert our freedom. Whatever hold they have over my government has all parties guilty, and it never changes. They have nothing true to say about Israel!
86. Are you sure all this is from a SD report
Get Real ,   UK   (04.21.13)
and not from the UN? Or maybe it was just copied from the UN ?
87. The chosen can do no wrong, they are
(04.21.13)
only children of Hashim. The rest of world is wrong & jealous, they are here to serve the jew
88. State Department report on human rights
Rogerlen ,   San Bernardino USA   (04.29.13)
What no condemnation against Syria, this is ridiculous and a joke. the administration that released this and approved this should be reprimanded and or sued... it is just stupid... here you have Iran building a nuclear bomb and laughs at this administration, along with the mistreatment of its people. and Syria who is murdering its people thousands so far and not one lifts a finger to help. even over to the Jordanian / Egyptian Arabs that call themselves Palestinians The government for these people oppress then greatly just to make good for news against Israel.. after all how can one small people get billions of dollars in financial aid from governments and over a million a month ( from Israel taxes collected on their behalf) and not be as well off as other countries? the poverty we see on the news is not what is really on the ground. if you go to Israel and observe across the border you will see multi unit 2 to 6 story homes ( not apartments) for a single family they are not impoverished, Israel has been on the hook for their electric bill which they have refused to pay, yet their leaders still have enough money for foreign travel, live plush life styles and work in very nice offices. but all the world sees is an impoverished people... and Israel as the aggressor. who sends suicide bombers ? not Israel.. we stopped them almost up to 99% by building a very large wall between us.. otherwise it would be a different story and we would be doing more cast lead adventures to stop the terror. Palestinians are a terror group unlabeled . just very media smart.
Previous talkbacks
Back to article