News
Lapid to haredi MKs: Israel doesn't belong to you
Moran Azulay
Published: 22.04.13, 19:05
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
58 Talkbacks for this article
1. Just Think,,,,,,,
Ricky ,   The Bronx   (04.22.13)
Just think,,,,,,,,If Iran had one of these,,,,,,,,,,,Yair, Yair, Yair,,,,,, this man has "The Holy Ghost", best wishes and much success in dealing with these undercover "Mullahs".
2. Breath of fresh air, this sort of talk is long overdue
R Narz ,   Toronto   (04.22.13)
3. Lapid not Diplomatic
Zechariah   (04.22.13)
Israel the Jewish State with one quarter Gentile ought move to War Rations Mode not commo not fascist like The Old days of 1947-1949 .Diaspora Jews ealize do the same .Will be hard for the rich and wealthy but need to r
4. Made for TV moment..stop the grandstanding and start
Al   (04.22.13)
governing. A true leader doesnt engage in nonsense but leads. Of course in the Knesset kindergarden where you have dysfunctional dimwits showboating, we cant expect anything less.
5. Yair, go go go!!!
grp ,   tel aviv   (04.22.13)
What a breath of fresh air. A little more of this and we'll all be tuning in to the Knesset channel for some decent entertainment.
6. Lapid
dan ,   jerusalem,IL   (04.22.13)
Well done ,Lapid.Keep on !
7. Rabbi Simon Ben Yochanan
Zechariah   (04.22.13)
Believed in Torah and Extreme Poverty live just enough to survive Fled from Romans .Now Jews have much more independence .Complex challanges and Hard Choices ..Need to be Rich Weapons Expensive Army Training Tough .Spread out the military and economic Burden .Galus ought Double Their contributions Vigilance against corruption Stringently.
8. I agree with number #5 100%
amos ,   Israel   (04.22.13)
I love Lapid response to the opposition especially the haredim who only suck in the tit of the state of Israel and complain about every thing
9. besides Charadi bashing, what does he have to say?
Larry ,   Los Angeles   (04.22.13)
It is a shame that this man who was basically elected to help the poor and down trodden middle class has, instead of doing help to his voting public, chooses to vent his personal anger towards the charadim. Yair, get to work and help us sinking stinking middle class!
10. Israel belongs to Haredim....
ORA ,   JERUSALEM   (04.22.13)
too, since they are Jews.
11. love this guy
dani ,   DC   (04.22.13)
but will it help? also its a balance...the haredi growth rate helps israel. the challenge is to decrease the money spent without decreasing the birth rate.
12. lapid is absolutely right
marcel   (04.22.13)
the religiouis have to be independent, pay for their kids and do their idf duties- the healthy ones that is. Now as for the study of torah is concerned, what has that done for the jews collectively: a collective submission,weakness, resilience of the jewish people? Not much. In fact the haredi invite bullies by their meek appearance and their physical attitude which is one of submission. You want to study torah-fine. That is Ok provided you can earn a living and do your national service. Lapid is dead right on this issue.
13. Yair your my man,your the main man,just
dyslexic..... ,   Israel...   (04.22.13)
keep up the good work your doing
14. I LOVE the Words...
Daniel ,   Tel Aviv   (04.22.13)
GREAT speech! About time someone said the truth and told it like it is. The only thing to do now is to ACT. ACTIONS SPEAK LOUDER THAN WORDS So MK Lapid THANK YOU. Now we count on you to bring about the change for which you are calling. In the mean time can you export your rhetoric and abilities and teach those in other western facing nations how to do as you do...especially the US and UK
15. this is the breaking point
Aharon ,   Israel   (04.22.13)
of years and years of sweeping these issues under the rug. The charedim contribute a lot to israel through Torah study, tfila, and having large families. But Lapid is right that each person needs to find financial independence, and not live of off tzdaka. Another issue is that charedim are so insular that many secular israelis rarely meet them. I hope that the integration of more charedim into the work force will not only make this country more financially stable and productive, but also more integrated across the religious spectrum. Charedim should embrace the opportunity to work along side chilonim and in the process share Jewish traditions and Torah wisdom. It could bring many Jewish back to G-d. Rather than passing laws and forcing the Torah upon people who reject it (busses not running on Shabbat etc) the charedim should be friends with secular Jews and over time most people will agree with them without being forced
16. A few more years of Lapid and I'll be coming home.
Michael ,   California, USA   (04.22.13)
Israel needs to be rescued and Lapid is carrying the banner at the moment. He needs many to help him, including Tzippi Livni and Zehava Gal On. More power to you Yair Lapid. Very glad to hear the truth is being told to the Haredim.
17. By cutting expenses ..
ORA ,   JERUSALEM   (04.22.13)
on children and defence, Lapid is dehumanizing and weakening Israel.
18. Straight talking . Call a spade a spade.
(04.22.13)
Very unusual to hear an MK telling some home truths. Do we want a fair society or a dependent society, where the .genuinely poor working people are supported.
19. attacking the haredi is all Lapid knows how to do
zionist forever   (04.22.13)
The entire Lapid political platform has been hurt the hared. Get them in the army then look for some new anti hared crusade to fight and just keep looking for more and more things to attack the haredi on and the reason is its popular, there is nothing seculalr Israelis love more than haredi bashing. Sadly though thats all there is to Lapid and this is the full extent of his promised new politics. With any luck next election he will be leading just a fringe party and people will vote for mainstream parties, not as popular as somebody who has made it his mission in life to destroy the haredi but at least mainstream parties are not foccused on popular issue and care about the country more than the careers of individuals. Vote mainstream and you keep both the likes of Lapid and Shas out of power and we get responsible policy not populist.
20. Minister Lapid is great!!!
Mark ,   Cleveland USA   (04.22.13)
Finally, someone who speaks for regular people. Israel can become a much wider tent for all Jews if this man succeeds. Best wishes for a long and prosperous career in politics!
21. Lapid is the man Israel needs except...
Maurice ,   Montreal   (04.22.13)
...for one thing. I don't think it's right to put a freeze on infrastructure which is fundamental for a well functioning country. Otherwise everything he says is 100% correct. It's high time everyone paid his or her dues in Israel.
22. Finally/////
zeboss ,   israel   (04.22.13)
someone elected in charge has the balls to speak up around here and speaks words for so many in this country/ "I post on Shabbat because I don't keep the Sabbath. I'm not telling you what to do on the Sabbath and you won't tell me " Lapid. I really start to like you! good luck and keep it up until your last session> Do not become poisoned by those old devil current...
23. Lapid go,go,go to...
nelly ,   israel   (04.22.13)
hell!
24. The Leftist's Are to Blame!
yoni ,   Shomron   (04.22.13)
Unfortunately, Lapid is wrong in claiming the Haredim are the cause of the deficit. The problem goes back a little further than that. Poor and haphazard financial management from all the leftist/socialist governments, from Ben Gurion on, is the basis of today's deficit. On this one, we have no one to blame but the leftists!
25. negotiation better than no's
Robert ,   Antwerp Belgium   (04.22.13)
What we hear mostly are no's from the haredim. No to the army, civil duty. No to a basic school curiculum. No to lower stipends. When are the haredim going to come with proposals that go forward to lighten the burden on the majority of the population? Haredim should not give the impression of being only takers.
26. charadi hate
ma nishma ,   modiin   (04.22.13)
I am shocked at all of the talkbacks that show such hatred of the religious people. How did it happen that the European antisemitism got transplanted from Europe to Israel? sick, sick, sick, sick
27. Bennett must be quaking
S Judah ,   Jerusalem   (04.22.13)
At what he has supported. It won't be long before he is under pressure from the Nationalist Rabbi's to split if this continues. Listen closely to Lapid's words. They are actually an attack against religious jews including those from Bennett's camp and the traditional mizrahim who tend to have larger families. I am not sure how Lapid came about , but most people believe the Almighty plays a part in child birth.
28. #26
mark ,   ca   (04.22.13)
Don't be shocked.There is a reason for hatred.Nothing to do with antisemitism.Many haredim ARE freeloaders and this is a fact of life!
29. Leiberman also calls a spade a spade...
Malone ,   Hfx   (04.22.13)
...yet everyone condemns him...could be that he is not as pretty as Lapid?
30. Barging about Chilul Shabbos??
Badbob ,   NYC USA   (04.22.13)
That is sick!! If you want to have a Jewish state rule 1 should be-Act Jewish. The only diffrence between him and is father is Yair is a self-hater with charisma.
Next talkbacks
Back to article