Opinion
Don't vilify, unite
Aryeh Deri
Published: 25.04.13, 11:28
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
50 Talkbacks for this article
31. THE SHAS PARTY TAKES ADVANTAGE
AA ,   New York   (04.25.13)
THE SHAS PARTY HAS TAKEN ADVANTAGE FOR SO LONG . THEY ALSO ONLY SERVE THERE NARROW INTERESTS . THEY COULD HAVE STOPPED OSLO. THEY COULD HAVE STOPPED THE GAZA DISENGAGEMENT . THEY ARE AN EMBARRASSMENT TO THE SEPHARDIC WORLD .
32. 1
zionist forever   (04.25.13)
Deri's record is certainly nothing to boast about but this is not about him its about Lapid whose only policy since taking office has been attack the hared. He has done very little to actually benefit the country but he is regularly picking fights with the hared over something or other or supporting secular groups like Women of the Wall and doing it all very publicly. Lapid knows secular voters like to see him tear the haredi apart more than anything else and his thinking is give the people what they want to see that way they will vote for you on election day. Lapid knows eventually if he is going to be in politics he will eventually have to make choices that will make him enemies so counter that by keeping the war on the haredi front page news, get people to see him as the man who is not afraid to take on the haredi rather than a another politician. You don't have to like Deri or the haredi but all Lapid is trying to do is boost his image, give the secular audience what they want to see.
33. Opposition with no teeth
Wade ,   NYC USA   (04.25.13)
Deri's bluster may sound good, but it's one big bluff. The opposition in kineset is powerless since it is outvoted by the coalition. Deri "will do all in his power..." He has no power. The coalition also answers to the people. May their policies be sound and do justice.
34. #32, In other words,Lapid is doing what's expected very well
Michael ,   California, USA   (04.25.13)
35. #3
Alice ,   Israel/Canada   (04.25.13)
Sarah, in Morocco they also played violon. By the way, Jews of Morocco whom are mostly of spanish descent, knew about music , art and of good manners long before their Ashkenazis brothers. Stop calling Mr. Deri a thief, He did techuva and has already paid for his mistakes. One more thing Sarah I'm very surprised at you, You alway write more elegantly and what you wrote about Deri is not your style.
36. WE SHOULD RESIST GIVING MONEY TO
AA ,   New York   (04.25.13)
THE MEDINA SHOULD NOT SUPPORT ANYBODY NOT WILLING TO VOLUNTEER AND JOIN IN THE COUNTRY
37. # 35 Not only a thief
Sagi   (04.25.13)
but a thief par excellence.
38. Deri not qualified for politics but he can be a rabbi.
Michael ,   California, USA   (04.26.13)
Why is Deri a Knesset Member? Like quite of few of his friends, Deri proves religion and state politics should not mix. Go to your synagogue, Arieh, close the door for privacy, and achieve whatever you want with your g. If you are missed, I'll let you know.
39. 17 Ora
robert ,   Antwerp Belgium   (04.26.13)
You may be right, Ora, that Deri has to follow his voters and their Rabbi, but according to what I see, they are far from being unified on the matter. In addition to that, what I say about Deri counts also for the Rabbies who should work toward a compromise that doesn't put Thora learning in danger while preserving unity in the Jewish people. Around 23000 soldiers have died in the line of duty in different wars since independence. It's only just that haredim drop their opposition to participate in the defense of Eretz Israël. See, Ora, solidarity is not a vain word. We are one people. My son volunteered for army duty in Israël, even though our passport is not Israëli. In the name of solidarity. So everybody should do his part
40. 29 Trying to preserve
robert ,   antwerp belgium   (04.26.13)
No Ora. Is a law that exempts 1800 students in Yeshivot every year from army duty and allows all the others to postpone till 21 a law that tries to demolish the little judaism left? It's only those who keep saying no to participation in the state of Israël that are a danger to the survival Judaism. We are a small people and unity should be foremost in the mind of all Jewish leaders, wether in government or Rabbies. That can only happen with the willingness to compromise
41. mr deri speaks
mr ,   nj, usa   (04.26.13)
Mr Deri, quite simply, is a man without shame.
42. ONLY HATE HERE IS: getting caught with your hand in the till
Trader Jew ,   nyc ny usa   (04.27.13)
NOTHING IS MORE EMBARRASSING OR HUMILIATING for the Ultras: than getting caught with their hands in the till, thieving and lying, to cover your tracks...time is past to admit errors of judgement, (or greed) or financial paranoia... Pull up your Tzizis and act like menches, admit the past errors and try to fit in MORE BETTER with the rest of the 85% DEMOCRATIC country!
43. Dear Mr. De'eri:
M. Davison ,   Ra'anana, Israel   (04.27.13)
Since your entire party was built on hatred for Ashkenazi Haredim and all secular Israelis, one would think you would have the good sense to keep silent for a change.
44. 39 robert
ORA ,   JERUSALEM   (04.27.13)
Kol Hakavod for your fantastic son. I don t feel i know enough to tell Rabbis who learn Tora during their whole life what they should do.
45. 44 Ora
robert ,   antwerp belgium   (04.28.13)
Thank you Ora, Not all Rabbis do believe haredim schould not go to the army or have a minimum program in math and language. I think only a minority do. But you seem to be defending the most extreme while attacking the Israeli government. Maybe you should think on your own with common sense which Rabbis you want to follow.
46. 45 robert,those who read my TBs ...
ORA ,   JERUSALEM   (04.28.13)
know,that i am for ALL Jews in Israel to study Tora and Science , join the IDF and work force,with the exception of the very gifted Tora students,which should be allowed to devote their life to Tora. The Secular and not only Orthodox Jews ought to ,in my opinion, do the needed steps, to join the Golden Middleway. Having said this ,i don t allow myself to judge the"Gedolim Hador"who,i am sure ,have a much wider than my short-sighted vision. Anyway ,let us remember,divided we fall,united we stand.
47. 43 Please back up your statement
ORA ,   JERUSALEM   (04.28.13)
that Deri s party was built on hatred of Ashkenazim.
48. Deri and #3
R ,   Israel   (04.28.13)
Mr. Deri, you would have my children believe that they are second-class citizens. You would have them complain about being discriminated against. You would have them sit back and hope for hand-outs. Luckily you didn't educate them and they can and do achieve whatever they set their minds to. So it is funny to hear calls for unity coming from you. Re #3 Sarah, Moroccan music rocks. There is no reason to think that European classical music has any inherently superior qualities.
49. Don't like Deri, but he is correct here
Larry ,   Los Angeles   (04.28.13)
He may have stolen, served time and who knows what, but here he is correct. Lapid and Co. are using their time in K'nesset to vilify the charadim unjustly. It is like Hitler in 1936 except Lapid is Jewish (?).
50. 46 I agree with you Ora
Robert ,   Antwerp belgium   (04.28.13)
I agree 100% with your latest statement, Ora. Unity and solidarity are of utmost importance for the Jewish people
Previous talkbacks
Back to article