Jewish Scene
Italian politician making aliyah
Tali Farkash
Published: 08.05.13, 14:16
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
33 Talkbacks for this article
1. Mazel Tov Mrs.Nirenstein. Am Yisroel Chai !
Moshe ,   Usa   (05.08.13)
2. So much for loyalty ,...
split ,   US   (05.08.13)
It looks like the Jobics are right after all, loyalty is not your favored virtue ,... A member of Berlusconi's government and vice-president of the Italian Committee on Foreign Affairs is taking off for Israel. This fact should awake all those suckers that think that they can change. ,... By the way this pro-Israel 'rally' looks pathetic ,...
3. Bring Italiano Jews home
Bobby ,   Netanya   (05.08.13)
There are about 25000-40000 Jews in Italy. We should bring them home here. They have a beautiful culture cuisine women and more importatly they have a cultural/traditional/modertae Judaism which will contribute to harmonizing the Israeli society.
4. Welcome!
R ,   Israel   (05.08.13)
What an amazing resume!
5. WHy????
Larry ,   Raanana   (05.08.13)
We are facing unemployment and rising costs and we are getting another immigrant to take a job away from people here.
6. Wonderful Woman
Jordan Ariel ,   USA   (05.08.13)
I had read many an article where she would defend Israel from its enemies. Hearing this news pleases me that a woman of such Caliber is making Aliyah to Israel. Perhaps one day, so will i.
7. She can join one of the 35,244 political parties in Israel
(05.08.13)
8. Making Aliyah
Steve Goodman ,   Israel   (05.08.13)
Welcome home, I made Aliyah and although Israel is not perfect, it is where we as Jews can really feel at home, Mazel Tov
9.  WELCOME TO ISRAEL
MR CYNIC ,   SAFED CYNIC CENTRE   (05.08.13)
There are always cleaning jobs available here....
10. GREAT News.. & some positivity dear people..
Oleh Chadash   (05.08.13)
Surely I love seeing ANY Jew (halachically that is!!) making Aliyah. But especially GREAT leader-figures like Mrs. Nirenstein we can definitely use over here!! BE OPTIMISTIC dear people. Look @ what we've achieved in 'only' 65 years. We're getting there.. slowly but surely. And yes, I'm annoyed by a 100 things a day also.. but come on, the Jewish people WE WILL SUCCEED, no question dear AM YISRAEL!!
11. #5
G ,   NY   (05.08.13)
Your an idiot who needs to study basic economics. immigrants dont take jobs away they only add josb to the economy because they add to the aggregate demand. If we followed your logic Israel would be an unerpopulated country majority arab with a small economy. Further Israels economy is doing far far better than Italy is. Welcome her and more like her with open arms.
12. Great woman great exemple
Philippe ,   Raanana   (05.08.13)
Fiamma , means flame and she is exactly like that.We have to applause and help her maintain a presence on both sides of the mediterranean.Fiamma is a real mover and shaker in politics .Kol Ha kavod
13. splat #2, your circular logic is making you dizzy
Jake   (05.09.13)
You accuse the Jews of disloyalty or dual loyalty. So surely you should have no misgivings that Fiamma is resolving this apparent conflict of interest by leaving Italy and moving to Israel. No problem of "disloyaly", then. Or are you simply an evil antisemite who berates the Jews no matter where they go and what they do?
14. 2. Thank you for continuing to remind us what ...
(05.09.13)
blind hatred looks like = you split. you are the face of hatred
15. Welcome home!!!
Nick Sporek ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (05.09.13)
16. #2 split brain
(05.09.13)
i am an american citizen and was born in this country. let me tell you a thing or two about americans. they are moving in hordes to places like costa rica and panama for wonderful tax opportunities and for retirement and because they want more for their money, lower taxes and a batter quality of life than america has to offer. WOULD YOU SAY THAT THESE AMERICANS WHO ARE NOT JEWS, BY THE WAY, ARE DISLOYAL AMERICAN CITIZENS AND THAT THEY ARE AGAINST THE USA AS YOU CLAIM JEWS ARE DISLOYAL WHEN THEY MIGRATE FROM EUROPE TO ISRAEL? answer please. are these americans also disloyal? are the multitudes of lebanese christians and millions of muslims that migrate to europe from north africa, turkey, middle east NOT LOYAL TO THEIR PLACE OF BIRTH AND COUNTRY? are the millions of asians and indians that migrate to the usa not LOYAL TO THEIR COUNTRY OF CITIZENSHIP AND BIRTH? and what about the israelis that migrate to the usa and europe? ARE THEY ALSO DISLOYAL TO ISRAEL??? i would love for you to answer the above questions since you seem to pick only on jews who you claim are disloyal to their citizenship country when they leave it for israel. LET'S JUST SAY THAT IF YOU FAIL TO ANSWER THESE QUESTIONS, YOUR RANT IS BASICALLY AN ANTISEMITIC RANT SINCE YOU SINGLE JEWS AND ONLY JEWS FOR THIS DISLOYALTY CONDEMNATION.
17. 5. people like her bring wealth & jobs ...
(05.09.13)
18. 13 - You accuse the Jews of disloyalty or dual loyalty.,...
split ,   US   (05.09.13)
There's no such a thing as dual loyalty, either you're loyal or not - Tell your honey that you love her but also you're loyal to another one and show me your face,... "Fiamma is resolving this apparent conflict of interest by leaving Italy and moving to Israel" Apparently not because as a senior member of government and vice-president of the Committee on Foreign Affairs she had a security clearance an access to classified, restricted intel info that she's taking with her to foreign country ,... Vanunu knew almost nothing, confirmed only what everyone knew for years and for that he spent 18 years in prison, including 11 in solitary confinement, is grounded for life with a restrictions on his speech and movement, harassed and arrested since he got out ,...
19. #2 and #5 and the pretty lady
Larry ,   Los Angeles   (05.09.13)
Are you guys nuts? really, a very lovely looking and talented lady comes to join us and you guys sound off like empty garbage cans. Get with it. With a pretty face and talent like this, it is a certain improvement for our country.
20. at last she stated the ttruth
matteo dagostino ,   veglie italy   (05.09.13)
she was an infiltrated, even though she was born in italy, she only had one heart, an israeli heart. she used italy as a platform to serve in the interests of israel. has she decided to leave? good riddance! that's what you get from somebody like her, she belongs in israel, she says. finding so easy to turn her back.
21. #20 What's your problem?
Leonardo ,   Milan   (05.09.13)
You are an absolute racist it seems to me. Was she disloyal to Italy? No, she enriched your political world and obviously had a talent and a passion. She served her country and also represented the Jewish and Italian interests.. That is what all people do. At the right time she decided that connecting with her Jewish heritage was most important to her and now she is starting a new chapter. Be thankful that she contributed to Italy and stop acting like a Nazi.
22. Don't waste great opportunity to strengthen links with Italy
Serge ,   Montreal, Canada   (05.09.13)
A great opportunity for Israel to strengthen its trade ties with Italy. She should open up a consulting firm or trade bureau devoted to boosting Italian presence in Israeli university enrolment and research, in providing services from Israel into the Italian market, and so on.
23. Abu matteo, #20
Jake   (05.09.13)
What are you still doing on these sites, matteo? I thought you had finally made yourself scarce!
24. 18
(05.10.13)
we are all awaiting your responses to post #16. well?
25. Your Alyah
Gilbert Bokobza ,   Tel-Aviv Israel   (05.10.13)
B R A V O for your courage You understood that paroles are not enough to help Israel....We hope that hundred and thousands will follow your exemple....We need you....
26. #16 ,...
split ,   US   (05.10.13)
Have you ever hear, read or came across a term 'Italy firster', 'Ireland firster', 'Poland firster' or I bet you didn't but you have hear and read ''Israel firster', haven't you? I din't invented, Americans did and there's reason for it so spare me your stupid questions designed to deflect what I have noted.
27. Benvenuta a casa!
Dave ,   Jerusalem   (05.10.13)
Welcome to the homeland, our sister from Italy. May all your friends from Italy follow. We can use some good ,authentic, Italian restaurants here. The French Aliya has done great things for our gastronomy!
28. Razzista, D'Agostino
Davide ,   Jerusalem   (05.10.13)
Number 20 D'Agostino, tu sei un razzista!You are as racist. You are signaling out Jewish immigrants to Israel, while you will never do the same, for example, to Italian immigrants to the USA. The lady served your country with distinction and now it's time for her to serve my country. Or maybe she just wants to retire in Jerusalem?
29. 2.
Birdi ,   Israel   (05.11.13)
Eat your hear out dimwit. Jealousy will get you nowhere.
30. mazal tov
swarup ,   israel   (05.11.13)
Welcome to gods own country
Next talkbacks
Back to article