News
US experiment: Pentagon destroys replica of underground nuclear facility
Alex Fishman
Published: 07.06.13, 11:20
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
52 Talkbacks for this article
31. Why revealing this military capability now?
Alan ,   Canada   (06.07.13)
Is it normal to reveal a new military ace in your hand? The risk is that the intended target will now know what kind of countermeasures it has to considere if it had not done so beforehand. So the US administration must think there are some pluses. Perhaps it is believed in Washington it will soften the Ayatollahs into stopping their nuclear program. It is hard to think that the US really gives credit to that idea given the fanatic determination of the Iranian rulers. A more likely target of the US administration is the public opinion & the leaders in Israel which it has repeatedly tried to discouraged from a strike at Iranian nuclear installations.
32. Russia is beyond the Pale.
Stephen in New York   (06.07.13)
Until civil society and the rule of law evolve in Russia.
33. Chris # 19
Eaglebeak ,   Left Coast, USA   (06.07.13)
Yeah but if it didn't work you people in Australia would be speaking Japanese now wouldn't you?
34. SpyPutz- consistently wrong
Stephen in New York   (06.07.13)
35. Iran is a flipping paper tiger with a big mouth
Noodles ,   Coney Island   (06.07.13)
It's the Muslim way.
36. Alan # 31
Eaglebeak ,   Left Coast, USA   (06.07.13)
I don't think Iran has the ability to stop it even if they know it's coming. One good thing is that it keeps them from sleeping well at night and forces them to always look over their shoulders (or in this case look up).
37. # 20 Steve
Eaglebeak ,   Left Coast, USA   (06.07.13)
You need to learn another tune. You have no credibility and only look foolish. Just because you want something doesn't mean it's ever going to happen. You are doomed to a life of dissapointment. Your wishes are not going to be granted.
38. 8 spyguy
alsky ,   Toronto   (06.07.13)
there are no good options, only bad and worse. Letting the lunatics in Iran get the bomb would be a very big mstake and most of the world knows it.
39. A small Israeli flick is all that is necessary
Israeli 2   (06.07.13)
for Iran. All this is an over kill. World must learn to unite to just destroy radical Islam.
40. aussie
rodolfo kohn ,   BOYNTON BEACH   (06.07.13)
I see you were never in Iran.go there and then you can understand why we HAVE to underestimate this bugs...
41. so what happens after
rodolfo kohn ,   BOYNTON BEACH   (06.07.13)
After the hit cockroaches die!if it contaminates pakistan , sorry ,we were lucky!!
42. bombing
rodolfo kohn ,   BOYNTON BEACH   (06.07.13)
who cares?
43. and what if?
rodolfo kohn ,   BOYNTON BEACH   (06.07.13)
sweden has steel, iran sunflower seeds...and we are talking ayatoullahs, not brains , einstein...hope they are as slow as swedes...
44. Iran
rodolfo kohn ,   BOYNTON BEACH   (06.07.13)
go on get another bud, you are already pissed buddy...
45. To: No. 8
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (06.08.13)
There won't be much left of Iran the day after.
46. us war on iran
jaybee ,   canada   (06.08.13)
Forget it. It won't happen Hope springs eternal, and so does US timorousness under Democrats. All talk. Never action. That's policy. So Israel don't be like US. Attack. Use whatever you've got, you've got a lot. Don't waste time, don't fear the world. If the economies can't stand an attack on Iran, they have already lost. Imagine the Great Powers fearing Iran. What makes them great? Great chickens.
47. Spuguy is Right
Mark of Lewiston ,   USA   (06.08.13)
Spyguy is right to raise the questions raised. There will be no Israelis alonog on any mission sharing risk. As for troops in Afghanistan, the critic argues that they deserve to die because they should not have been there. War is no cakewalk. The US may have the capability to neutralize Fordow. But that also is the capability to start a regional nuclear war, with hundreds of millions dead.
48. #47 Mark of Lewiston
Albrecht Klein ,   Germany   (06.08.13)
The same question to you: what would you suggest - sit down and do nothing until Ahmadinejad & The Mad Mullahs have nuclear weapons? They want to kill you. Not because you attack their nuclear installations or because you help the state of Israels - they want to kill you just because you exist.
49. Nr 8.
Arn. ,   Sweden.   (06.08.13)
As according to my opinion. nr 8s oppinions are always weird.. Arn.Sweden,.
50. 48 Albrecht Klein
(06.08.13)
Iran has had nuclear power since the 1950s. The Ayatollahs have been in control since the 1979. Pakistan encouraged them in the 1990s to build weapons and gave them plans. Iran decided not to do so. If the US attacks Fordow, Israel will not go along. Israel has nothing that can keep up with or even track a B-2 and has no B-2s. Meanwhile two direct down wind countries have proven nukes and delivery systems. Both could ruin Israel's day and the US's day. Netanyahu seems willing to irradiate not only Iran, but the down winders - Chernobyl writ HUGE. Netanyahu and the Israeli right wing and you also seem inclined to give Iran every incentive to return the favor at the survivors earliest convenience, unless you are willing to occupy for a few generations as the US did in Japan. How doe a country of 8 million occupy and control and re-educate the survivors of a country of 70 million? What is your EXIT Plan? An attack might make you feel good. What happens next? Who talks Pakistan and China into believing their millions dead don't or shouldn't matter?
51. #48 - Yes, do nothing
spyguy ,   Seattle   (06.08.13)
It is long past time for you get over your irrational paranoia. First of all, Iran is holding elections and Ahmadinejad will be GONE in a few weeks (so that boogie-man is gone). Second is the leadership of Iran is quite rational (not crazy) as many non-Israeli intelligence services have documented. Iran is NOT going to attack Israel UNLESS Israel or the US attacks FIRST. No one in the leadership of Iran wants to kill all the Jews. What they do want is for the government of Israel to be replaced by a secular or Muslim government. You need to differentiate between the Israeli government and the Jewish culture - they are two DIFFERENT things. Even if Iran gets nukes (and they do not even have a program to do that), they will NOT nuke Israel because of the MAD concept.
52. #17
Get Real ,   UK   (06.09.13)
Then two bombs will be used against each facility. There is no defence against the weapons available, or being developed, for the task. Maybe the new Iranian regime will get the message.
Previous talkbacks
Back to article