Jewish Scene
Alice Walker book deemed 'anti-Jewish'
Daniel Koren
Published: 22.06.13, 09:19
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
65 Talkbacks for this article
1. Walker, through her words and deeds alike, has demonstrated
Jehudah Ben-Israel ,   Qatzrin, Israel   (06.22.13)
to the world what a racist is, anti-Jewish racist at that. Jews of North America ought to shun her, on the one hand, and expose her nature, on the other, as they ought to do with every well known person eager to promote her/his sense of anti-Jewish racism.
2. What a pathetic hatemonger Alice Walker has become
Marwan Khoury مروان ,   Montreal, QC   (06.22.13)
Her obsessive hatred of Israel and apologizing for terror against innocent Israelis show that she has lost all moral conscience she had. What a sad pathetic person she has become.
3. I am just wondering
Isac   (06.22.13)
what would have happened if a well known white person would have said horrible things about negroes. That person would have had to resign his/her post, being scared of being killed, beaten and insulted. But here we are talking about Jews who have to be civilized (the people of the book), and quite frankly I am fed up with that crap of those people who think we have to hold back ourselves all the time! Enough already. I am unwilling to stay silent!!!
4. Alice Whatever
shelly   (06.22.13)
IGNORANT, SHAMELESS WOMAN CANT AND WONT SEE TRUTH SHE IS BRAINWASHED AS ARE THE PALIS. WHO CARES ABOUT HER I HAVE NEVER HEARD ABOUT HER
5. I hope Israel gives Alicia Keys the biggest welcome ever
Devorah   (06.22.13)
6. in US black people are 4 times more anti-semitics than white
(06.22.13)
than white people
7. The color purple author's true colors
Fred Nerks   (06.22.13)
Infectious in her hatred, the very nature of her intent is seeded by pure evil.
8. Expel Alice Walker for the USA!
Mina ,   Haifa, Israel   (06.22.13)
Ms. Walker, Your shocking lack of historical knowledge, your disturbing lack of education on this subject, and your obvious pathetic lack of willingness to learn the facts, are no excuse for being the dangerous anti-Semite that you have be become. You should be expelled for the USA for what seems to be your Nazis like views and incitement against the Jewish / Israeli people So just in case that something in you is genuine enough to keep an open mind and actually learn the truth: There has never been a land, state, country, called Palestine. Not before 1967, not before 1948, or at any other time in history. The Jewish people / Israelites / Israelis never colonized anyone. If Israel is still holding unto lands (that used to be occupied by Jordan and Egypt before 67) then it does so to keep its citizens secured. The Jewish people / Israelites / Israelis did not deliberately rape, murder, enslave and conquer others as a group, nation, country. What has and still is in the front and centre of Israel's behaviour is: - Major contributions throughout history to every people and field in our world e.g. in laws, medicine, technology, science, philosophy, literature, you name it! The technology that you have been use to write and publish your anti-Semitic rubbish, was invented in Israel and/or by other Jews. - Israel is one of the most developed, democratic and humanitarian countries in the world. Repeatedly placed in the top 20 best countries to live in (see UNHDI) and the only country in the Middle East where Arab/Muslim women are free and being treated equally. Ms. Walker, take this advise from an Israeli/Jewish woman: Stop defaming and slandering Israelis and Jews. Stop inciting against Israelis and Jews. Stop lying about, and hating Israelis and Jews. The real bully and racist here is you! It is you who tell lies about people just because they are Israelis & Jews! It is you who incite violence against people just because of their religion and national origin! It is you who bully others to adapt your racist and anti-Semitic views. Your racist views and incitement against Israelis and Jews are sickening, immoral and unethical, they are illegal in the USA. You should be expelled!
9. Alice,Who The X is Alice?
Zoe ,   Rishon Lezion, Israe   (06.22.13)
10. To Walker the racist antisemite
Maurice ,   Montreal, Canada   (06.22.13)
"The rapes, the murders, the pillaging, the enslavement of the conquered, the confiscation of land, the brutal domination and colonization of all." Aren't you ashamed of your blatant lies? Do you think reasonable and enlightened people believe you? You are part of the ugly and despicable racist garbage in this world. I am calling here all Americans to boycott all the trash you wrote. By the way, Israel is here to stay and prosper, and you can eat your heart out!
11. Alice...who the xxxx is alice ???
Yossi ,   UK   (06.22.13)
Just like the song says,lady you're waay out of line. You are a racist,biggot and a disgrace of a writer. Better learnn the history and realize Israel' reasons as well !!!
12. Africa is a mess
Zechariah   (06.22.13)
Tribals War The Rwandan Massacres Haiti there all a Mess Brutal Vile .Even the whites there are Arse holes except for a Few .The Arabs are Fighting Islam against Islam Europe Produced Two World Wars Genocides I think it's Pan Human a Predator Gene not only Jews.People form Tribes Cults Its Frightning.
13. Alice Walker vs Paula Deen
Arielush ,   Ramat Ha Golan   (06.22.13)
At the moment, there are two parallel instances of racist behavior in the headlines: Paula Deen and Alice Walker. There's Celebrity Chef and writer Paula Deen who is being lambasted for having admitted to used the "N" word in the past. Then there is Alice Walker who is aggressively promoting anti Semitic propaganda. The former is unashamed, whereas the latter has apologized, the latter is completely unrepentant. May I also add the former has lost her job, while the latter will probably be lauded on Oprah. where's the justice.
14. #2 Marwan, I don't know if you are real
Yossef   (06.22.13)
but if you are, you are already my friend.
15. Alice Walkers’ behavior can easily be explained...
jdl   (06.22.13)
Alice Walkers’ behavior can easily be explained. I've been through a number of conflicts in my life and it is always the same story. Many people are liable to two psychological mechanisms. The one is that they tend to favor the underdog, no matter what is right or wrong. The other mechanism is that people tend to project their own conflicts (either personal or corporate) into each new conflict, especially when they identify with the underdog. Consequently, they are not really interested in the 'new' conflict, except for the sake of getting over their own frustrations, again and again. These people are most fanatical and, sadly, most harmful. They are not open to reason. If you read Walkers’ BDS advertisements you see it right before your eyes. If possible, ignore such people or else try to hit them (pressing on and on!) at their weakest point: their failure to give a fair account of the facts.
16. Let her talk
Harvey ,   London   (06.22.13)
This wretched woman is a leading light of the Palestinian Solidarity / BDS Campaign . Every antisemitic epithet by her reflects on the cause she supports . Her hatred exposes yet again the seamless inter relationship between so called anti Zionism and antisemitism Most Palestinian supporters are careful to conceal their primary hatred with terms such as The Zionists when they mean Jews . However there are those whose hatred is so deep , so visceral that they dim
17. the Anti Democracy League is pathetic
Holy Warrior   (06.22.13)
Everyone has the right to free speech, its a basic human right. Some people expose the truth whilst oher organisations try desperately to hide it. The worldhas had enough of this bs..
18. Devorah,
walt K ,   Sherbrooke, canada   (06.22.13)
You are cynic, but she have to know the thruth and write another book to correct the first.
19. Surprise
marian ,   Romania   (06.22.13)
Probably in the future we will have the Surprise to see her undergoing a surgery operation in Israel. We already see syrian fighters and palestinians from Gaza doing so.
20. all the respect for Alice Walker
adam adam ,   earth planet   (06.22.13)
who don't like this woman knows she is talking right.
21. ADL hysteria
Ben Alofs ,   Bangor, UK   (06.22.13)
Alice Walker as a black person naturally identifies with the Palestinian people, who have been robbed of their homes and now live under the boot of the Israeli occupier. Anti-Arab racism in Israrl is strongly on the rise, which is a fact that should worry the ADL much more than Alice Walker's latest novel. The hysteria of the ADL cannot hide the present day ugly reality of Israel. Alice Walker is a courageous woman, who will not be silenced.
22. Let her talk
Harvey ,   London   (06.22.13)
This wretched woman is a leading light of the Palestinian Solidarity / BDS Campaign . Every antisemitic epithet by her reflects on the cause she supports . Her hatred exposes yet again the seamless inter relationship between so called anti Zionism and antisemitism Most Palestinian supporters are careful to conceal their primary hatred with terms such as The Zionists when they mean Jews . However there are those whose hatred is so deep , so visceral that they simply cannot contain themselves . Walker is one such person . So let her talk . Every word she utters is counter productive to the BDS cause . Use to good effect , publicise and tweet in order to emphasise the embedded antisemitism within the Palestine Solidarity network .
23. We should all know,,,
Linda ,   New Haven, Conn.   (06.22.13)
We should all know,,,, even the Chinese, the relationship, history and commerce, between the so-called Jewish people(no pun) and black peoples in the Americas, north and south. Slavery was an evil that many want to forget and many want that those that were enslaved to forget also,, but it is a sad part of our history, human history. Human rights injusticises have no color and the hurt that any compassionate being feels indicates that we are all one family. No one can doubt that many aspects of Palestinian life are tainted by human rifgts infractions. Sad that Miss. Walker has to come out as such but for her it is maybe a healing for her soul and the crimes perpetrated upon her ancestors that is in her DNA, geneitcs and hereditary, slavery was very traumatic and destructive and lives like a virus that just doesn't seem to leave some black peoples bodies. Most writers go thru various transformations in their lives and carrers,,,,,, maybe she is just looking for some justice and the sense of it all and why,,,, why me, why did I have to be subject of these inhumanities by blacks,, Africans, Arabs,, whites and yes,,,, Jews.
24. #20 adam - it’s very simple
solomon ,   bklyn   (06.22.13)
You’re wrong, and ignore the facts as much as she does.
25. Thanks, ADL....
Ben Alofs ,   Bangor, UK   (06.22.13)
for directing my attention to Alice Walker's new book of essays "The Cushion in the Road: Meditation and Wondering as the Whole World Awakens to Being in Harm's Way". I had a quick look through the content of her book. The essays on Palestine are just one part of it. I have just purchased a hard back copy on Amazon and am looking forward to reading Alice Walker's views on a whole raft of subjects. I have read some of her work and she is a powerful author. Have any of you Talkbackers here read the book or are you just sheepishly repeating ADL's rant without you having even read one chapter? I am going to read this book with an open mind. I don't need the ADL to tell me what is right and what is wrong.
26. ALICE WALKER WHO?
DENNIS ,   NJ USA   (06.22.13)
Never heard of this Schvartzeh until her anti-semitism became somewhat famous. Please let her crawl back from whatever dark hole she came from. She, for sure, has never been to israel to witness what actually goes on. Probably learned what she spouts from Rev Wright.
27. Well if the ADL
Ivor Evenbiggergun   (06.22.13)
is trying to censor Alice Walker's book then she be right I suppose.
28. Foxman is pi***ng into the wind
Ivor Evenbiggergun   (06.22.13)
A desperate attempt to prevent the American people especially the black core vote from knowing the truth in the Israeli Palestinian conflict. AIPAC are going to have to dig even deeper into their pockets to buy The Senate and Congress at the next elections. And of course Ms Walker is protected by the First Amendment, she is able to write books about any topic she likes. And if Foxman organises a book burning, then he will have proved her right.
29. To # 8 Mina , Haifa, Israel
Abu Yussef al Yahudi ,   Bue_Aires-Argentina   (06.22.13)
Madam , I wish to congratulate you for your brave and clever post # 8. I stronly agree with your clear statements regarding this despicable Anti-Jewish woman that is Alice Walker. Kol Hakavod! Shabat Shalom
30. Just wait...
Robert ,   USA   (06.22.13)
she'll get the Nobel peace prize AND the Nobel literature prize, along with a ticker tape parade in Dublin, Oslo, London, Berkeley and assorted other charming spots. This all comes with one big hug and kiss from Bishop Tutu and Jimmy Carter.
Next talkbacks
Back to article