News
Deri: Haredim, Arabs need to feed their kids too
Moran Azulay
Published: 24.06.13, 17:59
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
32 Talkbacks for this article
1. Excuse me?!
Chi ,   Israel   (06.24.13)
The Haredim are fortunate to have 4, 5 sometimes 6 or more kids and those kids are being supported by the government aka MY taxes. My husband and I, who only have one child cannot afford to have another one without being close to the poverty line. Mr. Deri you want to tell me that's fair?? Fair for my child not to have siblings beause I have to support other people's who are not related to me in any way.
2. feed your children?
secular israeli ,   israel   (06.24.13)
GO TO WORK!!!!
3. There's a G-d in the world after all
Dov   (06.24.13)
The amount of money that Lapid and his henchmen are cutting from Yeshivas and Haredim, this amount and a bit more is being cut from the US aid to Israel. What do you say o that? Measure for measure. There's a G-d in the world after all.
4. Since when do you care for Arabs ? ,...
split ,   US   (06.24.13)
Mr. Deri, why don't you ask them to get a job and support their double digit families, what about some compasion for the taxpayer ? ,...
5. Excuse me?!
david ,   Netanya   (06.24.13)
To 1: what are you talking about? You get the exact same child benefits as charedim do. Have a few more kids and you'll get the same amount of money for them to. In fact, your kids cost the state much more as their schooling is subsidised more than charedi schooling.
6. Excuse me. I'm a widow. I worked 3 jobs simultaneously
Esther ,   Jerusalem   (06.24.13)
to feed and raise my kids. NOBODY gave me money or welfare and I was proud enough not to ask. How about you and the Arabs try doing the same.
7. Then work, and you will be able to support your kids
Ted   (06.24.13)
8. #1
K.R.   (06.24.13)
You're mimicking the same lies as other haredi haters do. Haredim pay taxes just like you do and it's the taxes from haredim that go to public schools and to universities. Hardly anything goes to haredi schools or to support haredi families.
9. Let g pay them, not Israeli government.
Michael ,   California, USA   (06.24.13)
Haredim live on the fringes of society and from scraps society is willing to throw away. They have way too many children for what they can afford. Welfare handouts to them only makes they situation worse. It is pathetic that an MK will want more of this to go on. Deri should think before he speaks in support of society's segment which refuses to learn modern subjects and engage in useful work. If g listens to them, IT should take care of them, not us and not Deri.
10. Need to Feed Kids
Sara   (06.24.13)
While I have no love for Deri, I do think that if we kicked out all the illegals the money used on them would go quite far to help our own citizens. What about it Government People?
11. #8
Dagan ,   Israel   (06.24.13)
Yeah, 7.2 billion shekels is hardly anything.
12. Why are MY taxes and those of MY friends
Charedi   (06.24.13)
used to pay professors teaching irrelevant subjects in colleges and universities and government grants for non charedim?
13. # 8 - Haredim pay taxes just like you do ,...
split ,   US   (06.24.13)
How? 3/4 them don't work and the rest do some work under the table or living of scams and shady business ,...
14. Mr. Deri doesn't give a rats pitutti for Arabs
Israeli ,   Haifa   (06.24.13)
What the heck is he trying to pull here? The rest of Israeli society WORKS to feed their children. #8: The Haridim have a LOOOONG history of shnoring off of government hand outs. You're not fooling anyone.
15. #11 Out of more than 430 billion shekels?
Roman ,   Lod, Israel   (06.24.13)
For the sum total of *all* Israeli society, rather than *just* Haredim or *just* Arabs? 0.0166% of the Israeli budget goes to child welfare - *all* children, in *all* of Israel. That's a tiny fraction of a percentile. And the plan is to reduce that tiny fraction of a percentile by more than half, with a drastic cutoff (meaning a very quick change, leaving no time for adjustment). This is not about "they should work". This is essentially making the poor poorer, with no immediate means of change. And that will cause prolonged harm for Israeli society and economy - moreso than any immediate budget deficit.
16. The US aid reduction is much less.
George ,   U   (06.24.13)
Aid to Israel will be reduced by "the sequestration" of 5%, just like every other US budget item. This will amount to about $150 million USD out of a total of $3 billion the US provides annually. In fact, the US aid reduction amounts to about only 15% of the Israeli budget reduction.
17. What about an honest work?
Yael Schlichting ,   currently Munich   (06.24.13)
18. You have to feed your kids?
Mira ,   Vienna   (06.24.13)
We understand that certainly, go and work for their support and don't produce more you can feed!
19. Charedim do not
Fx ,   Herzalyia   (06.24.13)
Charedim pay the same taxes? The charedim I know pay nothing and only collect welfare and 'study' Torah all day. I give 31% of my paycheck and get nothing in return from them.
20. need to feed kids
roxy ,   israel   (06.24.13)
Then work to support your kids like the rest of us, don't have more than 2 kids unless you can afford to feed and clothe them without government assistance. You can study Torah and work too the Haredi in NY and Europe manage to do both!
21. A true "jewish" democracy.
jrd   (06.24.13)
22. #11 "Irrelevant" ??
Chuck ,   SF, USA   (06.25.13)
The fact that you consider irrelevant subjects such as biology, chemistry, mathematics, engineering, physics and medicine only indicates how out of touch with reality the charedi mind really is. Thank you for your clarification of this matter.
23. We need to feed our kids too........
David ,   Tel Aviv   (06.25.13)
.....then get a job you parasites
24. Go and Work
Moshe ,   Givataim   (06.25.13)
Go and work like some of us are doing, supporting people like you and this state. It is ENOUGH. GO AND WORK.
25. than go to work, that is the only way someone
lili   (06.25.13)
can support himself/herself in dignity. otherwise Haredim just taking my tax money so they can have more children. why should I support their children when they don't even willing to work.
26. to #15 & #11 the goverment don't need to give you even one
lili   (06.25.13)
sekel the goverment money is secular tax money, seculars don't demand money from the gov and don't ask for extras, it is about time you will help all Israeli society by being productive citizens go to work and not demanding handouts, show how much dignity you have. the poor poorer, just empty slogans, they need beter school learning to be productive, I was amazed to find out they can't even caculate fractures in mathematics, and that is basic knowledge. and yes they were haredim in their 30's. sham people beg for handouts.
27. To #5: Wrong
Rafi ,   Merkaz, Israel   (06.25.13)
The haredim get subsidies on just about everything - arnona, apartments, summer camps...And for some reason, the chain stores in their neighborhoods are cheaper. Just last year, they discovered that cooking gas was cheaper in Bnei Brak than across the street in Ramat Gan. If you can't afford them - don't have them!
28. Do not make children if you cannot provide f
Jerusalem Jew ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (06.25.13)
Parents are the ones who are primarily responsible for providing a decent living fot their children. By trying to shirk this responsibility, parents with many children simply undermine Israel's economic stability.
29. 3 Solutions
Jacob E ,   Holon, Israel   (06.25.13)
1. Work 2. Work harder 3. Don't have kids if you can't afford them
30. #26, With your terrible English, you're complaining about
Esther ,   Bet Shemesh, Israel   (06.25.13)
other people's math?
Next talkbacks
Back to article