Opinion
Waters lost his way
Noga Gur Arieh
Published: 25.07.13, 10:07
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
72 Talkbacks for this article
31. Wake up Noga, Waters did not 'suddenly' change
Bobk ,   Orlando USA   (07.25.13)
The writer is utterly naïve to have "respected his words" and think Waters just became evil. Several years ago Waters visited that part of the security barrier near Bethlehem which is a wall to keep Palestinian suicide bombers from getting into Israel. Waters wrote on the wall: 'this wall has to come down'. Anyone who wants the security barrier removed prior to ending all Palestinian terror and full acceptance of Israel by the PA and Palestinian terror groups also wants these Arab suicide bombers to kill Israelis. Waters should take down his own wall of hatred against Jews and Israel.
32. Pay no attention to the madman!
Koose E Mack ,   NY USA   (07.25.13)
Roger Waters is not worth mentioning....let him fade into oblivion. In the end, he will be "just another brick in the wall". Eventually, his self deception and hatred of Israel and The Jews will be his downfall.
33. Water messanger of truth!
USA   (07.25.13)
34. In 2010 Waters showed the same racist slurs
Jerry ,   Tel Aviv   (07.25.13)
During his performances of "Goodbye Blue Sky," in 2010 an animated scene projected images of planes dropping bombs in the shape of Jewish Stars of David followed by dollar signs.
35. That's just very cheap marketing replacing true music !
Ibrahim Sued ,   Rio de Janeiro   (07.25.13)
36. Compare "Jews", "Israel", Star of David, as protest symbols
Steve Benassi ,   Silver Bay, MN USA   (07.25.13)
Which one can be used as legitimate criticism of Israel on a flying inflatable pig? Clearly "Jews" would be anti-Semitic. Clearly "Israel" would be a legitimate protest symbol. Star of David...does it mean "Jews", or does it mean "Israel"?
37. People just tired of Jews and whining
Doris   (07.25.13)
We don't care if yo uare stabbed or shot or if hated or your holocaust we are simply tired of your nonsnese and go to somebody else who cares. We don't anymore, and holocaust is a lie.
38. Do you know what's your problem ? ,...
split ,   US   (07.25.13)
You're not capable to take a good look in the mirror and do some soul searching, that's all you do it's pointing finger and blame the rest of the world for your shortcomings.
39. He stole land-burned mosques-uprooted trees-prevented harves
miki ,   tampa   (07.25.13)
ts exiled brides from our United Jerusalem where 300,000 Arabs pass by unseen by the municipality all in the name of Zionism?
40. #29. Ethan: Read the news right here
Tom W ,   USA   (07.25.13)
Your whining is hypocritical when just today 15 people got hit with stone throwers. Based on your faulty logic we must just submit our life to Pali children who are trained to kill with stones. The Western Leftists and their Israeli shill will keep demonizing Israel if she protects herself - so you'd better pack up and move where you are hated even more.
41. #17. Dee: You're right about the British
Tom W ,   USA   (07.25.13)
It's worth noticing that probably the most vicious attack on Israel is emanating from Britain. Even British Jews too are infested with animosity, most posters from there preaching the '60s "peacenik" nonsense and shilling for Muslims.
42. to Polakus at 38
PolaKus ,   Warsaw   (07.25.13)
You sure told them Jews...
43. Waters has no where to hide
Dror ,   Haifa, Israel   (07.25.13)
Waters does not need to hide from us. Waters needs to hide from the One God of Israel that has His eyes on him now.
44. #18 adam adam
Norman ,   Boca Raton   (07.25.13)
You may have touched on something. Israel has very few friends in the world. It can't all be anti-Semitism, or envy of the "chosen" people. Israeli-Jews should pray to Hashem to make them more popular. It would make life a lot easier for them.
45. Waters
Gad ,   Mexico City   (07.25.13)
What he did is not new, he did it more than a year ago in his concert in Mexico City. It is not that he lost his way, he knows exactly what he is doing. He is an anti-semite and he wants to people to go with him. That simple.
46. #18
Alice ,   Israel/Canada   (07.25.13)
The fake Palestinians and people like you are thieves. As a matter of fact, the Arabs are stealing our Land and are trying to steal more of It G-d forbide. You are such an ignorant. We the Jews are beloved by The Almighty G-d who gave us this Land for ever and ever to eternity. who cares what you and other people say you are all irrelevant.
47. #17 Dee Bee
Norman ,   Boca Raton   (07.25.13)
"Jews defend themselves from the Palestinians who are intent on destroying Israel and the Jewish people" Hey Dee Bee, I don't think the Palis want to destroy the Jewish people. They just want their land back. The Germans wanted to destroy the Jewish people. You have things mixed up.
48. #34 Jerry
Norman ,   Boca Raton / USA   (07.25.13)
Hey Jerry! Did you finally find BALANCE and move to BIG ISRAEL???
49. More Waters - Less You
george ,   nashville   (07.25.13)
More Waters - Less You
50. Less George - Less Waters
Robert ,   NY USA   (07.25.13)
Less George - Less Watters
51. #29 You have lost your way.
Eaglebeak ,   Left Coast, USA   (07.25.13)
What occupied people? Do you mean Egyptians like Arafat and others from Egypt, Jordan,etc. that decided to take the title Palestinian away from the Jews? What other country allows children to throw stones and do nothing? It is people who think like you that are a major embarrassment and it's only worse when it's a Jew that should know better.
52. # 27 Ethan YOU have lost your way
JewsWhoLoseThePlot ,   Jerusalem Israel   (07.25.13)
Go back to the West where you evidently came from you don't belong here You are on the wrong side of Jewish history You don't deserve to be part of the nation building process Go home and home is not here
53. #47.Norman: You have short memory
Tom W ,   USA   (07.25.13)
Your hatred renders you blind: Palestinian terrorists indiscriminately kept murdering everybody who is Jewish. It did not matter if the victim was a baby or an old, their blood lust is documented every day in the news. Besides "their land" was part of Ottoman Turkey and British afterward. They were content to submit to the Turks or the British who are infidels, kuffars like you. Hopefully the La Raza people will get their stolen land back.
54. #38- You know what your problem is?
Koose E Mack ,   NY US   (07.25.13)
You're an Anti-Semite, Anti Zionist, Pig. Your shortcomings are too numerous to mention in this forum; but I do believe your greatest short coming may be found in your hand when you relieve yourself!
55. #37 Dorass
Eaglebeak ,   Left Coast, USA   (07.25.13)
There is plenty of film documenting the holocaust and proof it happened. Only fools can say it was a lie and believe it.
56. Doris...#37
Koose E Mack ,   NY USA   (07.25.13)
How many generations of inbreeding do you have in your family tree? If it has more than one branch, I'd be surprised. Go back to chasing greased hogs and enjoy your next KKK rally. Oh and Doris....I truly believe that what you wish on others will happen to you and your family!
57. Norman #47
Eaglebeak ,   Left Coast, USA   (07.25.13)
They just want their land back? Then why does their charter (Hamas and PLO) call for the destruction of Israel? Are you calling the Palestinian Pretenders liars? Would you care to explain how it is Arafat wanted his land back when he was an Egyptian? Dee Bee isn't mixed up, you are.
58. #53 - Tom W, USA
Norman ,   Boca Raton / USA   (07.25.13)
Good one Tom, however, the Palestinians never bothered Jews until losing their land to them. Those who, per you, they were a part of did, not dispossess them (Turks, Brits, etc). Because they were not officially a country does not mean they cannot own land. Remember, the Jews were long gone from there, living in Europe, Ethiopia and elsewhere. Hmmm... do I detect a tinge of racism when you mention La Raza???
59. #58. Norman: Learn world history
Tom W ,   USA   (07.26.13)
Wars changed the map everywhere. Germans from the old city of Konigsberg were expelled and now it's Russian city of Kaliningrad. Germans and Hungarians were expelled from the Czech Rep. see Benes decree, Jews were expelled from ALL Arab countries, Russians expelled the Japanese from the Kuril Island and the list is long. You are rooting for the Palestinian but the close to 1 million Jews who lived in the Arab-Maghreb countries and lost everything means nothing to you. You will come up with some PC reasoning like stating that Jews left "voluntarily" and rendered themselves destitute willingly. Please drop the Obamista "racism" crap that is overused and carries no meaning anymore. La Raza people are indigenous to the So. W. U.S. and if we have to choose between antisemitic, leftist Americans then we'd rather speak Spanish, because "Yes we Can".
60. Roger Waters
Etienne Prinsloo ,   Nova Scotia Canada   (07.26.13)
Another delusional artist that believes he has the right to decide on the fate of nations. Or maybe he has fallen under the spell of Islam as so many so called European liberals have.
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article