News
Did Netanyahu propose resettling Gazans in Sinai?
Roi Kais
Published: 15.09.13, 10:51
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
14 Talkbacks for this article
1. I hope so!!
(09.15.13)
2. best
dahlin ,   israel   (09.15.13)
best idea ever
3. Did Bibi think that Egypt would accept them ?
Charles ,   Petach Tikva   (09.15.13)
Gazans were not allowed to settle in Egypt , as INDIVIDUALS , during the Egyptian occupation from 48 to 67 . Egypt didn't annex Gaza either , they didn't want the Gazans to become Egyptians . No country accepted them , in Kuwait they were second category inhabitants with no right to own a business 100 % , only 49 .
4. Resettling "Palestinians" is definitely the answer..
Chaim ,   Israel   (09.15.13)
The real answer to Israel's life threatening problems with "Palestinian" poseurs is to resettle them elsewhere. Jordan is the most natural choice.
5. Said it before and I'll say iy again.......!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Dov ,   Tel Aviv   (09.15.13)
It's an absolute No brainer. Resettling/Relocating ALL (so called) Palis to the Sinai is the ONLY change for PEACE. ONLY way Israel can have defensible borders. Anyone who disagrees wants Israel's destruction...not a lasting peace.
6. Dov and Chaim . To DEPORT them ?
Charles ,   Petach Tikva   (09.15.13)
in the same way as our parents were a 70 years ago ? Do you think that any SANE Israeli politician will do it ? Do you think that any country will accept them ? Do you think that they will leave their homes voluntarely ? Of course it would be a GREAT solution , but only insane people can think that it's more than a dream .
7. 6
john Darren ,   cairns-Austraalia   (09.16.13)
I agree with Chaim-resettle Pals.Resettle is not the same as deport.I am not going to go into any details about how to resettle Pals to Jordan-that has been answered many times before.
8. Gaza XXL
spondres ,   France   (09.16.13)
Mass deportation of the Gazan population would be unacceptable, but encouraging the excess population to migrate down the Sinai Mediterranean coast and establish new cities could provide both an economic boom and relieve demographic pressures. UNRWA could actually do something useful before it was wound up. I guess Egypt would have to re-annex Gaza, though.
9. 7
Charles ,   Petach Tikva   (09.16.13)
Resettle means the same as deport if it is done AGAINST their will . They want to stay there , in places where some of them lived since generations . We are talking about Gaza and Egypt , not Jordan
10. 8 , before writing , think a little bit
Charles ,   Petach Tikva   (09.16.13)
Egypt NEVER annexed the Gaza strip ,so they can't "reannex" , that's one . Secondly they didn't allow , as i wrote , gazans to settle as INDIVIDUALS in Egypt . So they most likely won't allow masses of gazans to settle in their country . Third , they don't want hamas terrorist , have enough with their own in the Sinai .
11. Give every Gazan $1m to go
Dan   (09.16.13)
99% of them would quietly accept, and it would be worth it.
12. Dan 11 . Did you think a little bit ?
Charles ,   Petach Tikva   (09.16.13)
one million US$ x one million people , makes THOUSAND billion US$ . That's approx the Israeli expenditures for 13 years [ Israeli expenditures for 2012 were a 73 billion US$ , CIA factsbook ] And what will you do with the , as you wrote , remaining one % who will not accept your proposition ? Give some SANE propositions , if you can .
13. Relocating Gazans
Maggid ben Yoseif ,   USA   (10.15.13)
Just the reverse. The Zechariah Plan presented to Sharon shortly b4 his stroke, calls 4 mutual disengagements, Israelis from Gaza and contiguous areas such as fertile Shlfelah and cities of Ashquelon and Ashdod to provide infrastructure 4Pal St.. in return Pals leave JudeakSamaria enabling return of House of Joseph to ancestral homes in Samaria.
14. Saint Bibi
Mt ,   San Francisco, CA   (10.20.13)
If Judaism had saints, he would be the next one.
Back to article