News  World News
Obama: Israel security depends on Palestinian state
Yitzhak Benhorin
Published: 24.09.13, 16:42
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
108 Talkbacks for this article
61. #18, Benassi, NO state was created by the UN
Jake   (09.24.13)
The UN General Assembly issued a resolution, the text of which explicitly calls it a "RECOMMENDATION", recommending the establishment of 2 states, one Arab and one Jewish, and international corpus separatum. The Arabs rejected it, the British refused to implement it, and the UNSC refused to adopt it, passing instead Res. 44, urging the General Assembly to go back and reconsider. Nothing came out of the UN deliberations, and the partition plan was an abortion. Israel exists only because it survived the onslaught of invading Arab armies detemined to wipe it out. Israel succeeded, the Arabs failed. Get over it.
62. Obama, Israel will survive despite of you
CJK   (09.24.13)
the jewish state of Israel has survived much bigger threats than a malicious american president.
63. the inevitable betrayal
gambino ,   ny usa   (09.24.13)
My sense is the likelyhood of this "america has israels back....unconditionally" will degrade as the economy degrades. If Obamacare passes, the economy will not flourish. Syria will become a trap. Iran will become a black hole. That seems to bring Israel as an offering of peace and refinancing to the 'Temple of American Interests' and they'll trade their ace (Israel) for a global reset, for peace ( world domination) and global refinancing. Russia will be forced to object and ww3 b in the cards. Israel will prevail, becoz the western infidels believe in credit, they dont (honestly) believe Gd.
64. Pals don't deserve any state while trying to destroy Israel
Sam ,   Canada   (09.24.13)
Obama and the EU want to give the Palestinians a state in the hope that that will shut them up and stop terrorism. What they want is an Israeli patsy leader and government that will make that easy. Netanyahu tries to act tough but always backs down in fear of the US. Israel has to make very clear that Palestinians get nothing so long as they endanger Israel, Obama or not. Israel has already caved in with the release of murderers for nothing and that's enough.
65. Israel's security relies on preventing a Palestinian state
Jake ,   USA   (09.24.13)
There Mr. Obama, I fixed it for ya.
66. # 40 Dan ~ and to Americans
Grace ,   USA   (09.24.13)
67. Let Obama return to Gehenna where he came from
Noodles ,   Coney Island   (09.24.13)
68. # 10 Jake please forgive Benazzi
BUILD BABY BUILD !!! ,   United States   (09.24.13)
this is the only job he can get and although it pays little, he's nothing to worry about, a poor muslim living in a car behind the public toilet. He's not being paid for brains just copy and paste.
69. Ben ASS aren't you that strange little freak starring at
BUILD BABY BUILD !!! ,   United States   (09.24.13)
kids on the playground?, no kids and you still here? Love Jews? A pedophile? What'ya doing here? Only job you can get, loser?
70. # 61 Thanks Jake Love it!!!!
BUILD BABY BUILD !!! ,   United States   (09.24.13)
71. # 65 LOL Jake for Presidente of America!!!!
BUILD BABY BUILD !!! ,   United States   (09.24.13)
You make me laugh thanks.
72. # 6 Au Contrar
BUILD BABY BUILD !!! ,   United States   (09.24.13)
Neither Republicans or Democrats agree with obama, that's why he's on the road campaigning as he can't govern. When he is in town, he'd rather golf than govern. He leaves that to the Saudis.....
73. Obama
Lou ,   Rishon   (09.24.13)
Obama is such a stupid man. How can a community organizer be the President of the United States of America. He doesn't even know the history of the Jewish people in this land. He is a great lover of the Muslims, and might be one himself, even though he calls himself a Christian. How stupid can a President be, and how stupid the people of America were to elect him. He is nothing but a "coloured".
74. How about a couple of minor issues Mr
J.K. ,   Brooklyn USA   (09.24.13)
Obama,Iran to get out from Lebanon,Iran,to stop the incitement,the financing,the arming of Hamas,Hezbulla, only than will the sanctions be removed ,are those requirements to much to ask ?.
75. According to this rag you mean?
BUILD BABY BUILD !!! ,   United States   (09.24.13)
I believe it's called 'yellow Journalism' for a reason.
76. # 36 SK Touche" Bravo!!
BUILD BABY BUILD !!! ,   United States   (09.24.13)
how obama can utter such mindless drivel makes us all want to vomit.
77. # 37 Gambino good point...
BUILD BABY BUILD !!! ,   United States   (09.24.13)
But, you know how the Muslims lie, lie, lie. Or, they die, die, die. My, my, oh my.
78. ONLY 3 MORE YEARS FOR THIS LAME DUCK
stude ham   (09.24.13)
HANG IN THERE ISRAEL! you've survived longer than that!
79. I want mashiaj now!
daniel ,   the world   (09.24.13)
you are not longer a good pacifist you annihilate violent,from my faith was driven to conquer those dominant inglorious bastards that have no law for existing of the beings in this life,romanticist,anti frontiers and anti imperialist fanatic,looking for how to be a little more human I am along with my brothers,if i can save every man for himself that is what they say there outside,that is the motto of my poor lost culture that you not wake up for a new purpose,to begin the life!romanticist anti frontiers and anti imperialist,environmental zealots,anti facist! listen rulers bondage!
80. Obama has no strengt anylonger..
Beary White ,   Norway   (09.24.13)
He is turning to what every enemy of Israel loooves to talk abouth, rising his finger; Israel has to ..whatever. He do not have the same intense focus on Iran and Syria. I think most of the public do NOT remember the Iran-Irak war he is talking about... "Jews slaughter in .." is a low-level expression of something very serious which should be mentioned in other words... And how many of todays politicians have knowledge about the WWI except people with interest in history abouth WWI. Summary, Obamas actions cannot be strengthen by his speeches...his speeches are weak..
81. Trying to talk to and reason with benASSi
Jerome ,   Basalt, Colorado   (09.24.13)
Is as hopeless as talkingand reasoning with hafefilled Iranian mullahs. Jakes talkbacks are really great and worth the read.
82. #50 Mutual Assured Destruction Policy
Passerby ,   NL   (09.24.13)
Bill Stein I your post is at least one step ahead (though it is just my humble opinion) of most talkbacks I read here. Those are just in flat denial and in contrast you are regarding this as a serious issue worth putting thought in (maybe from your perspective to generate options to counter a threat - i think on this level one would speak of thinking over Best Alternative to a Negotiated Outcome or BATNA in terms people skillful in negotiations would use). Though for a feasible alternative option to negotiations, i wish you more wisdom - South Africa had the means to pay for it's own security and defence and they managed to sit out a few decades even (though for a economy significantly smaller in economy and size imagine the sacrifice in economic terms alone one would have to make even if it would be possible to foot that bill - hardly any disposable income and sacrifice of the economy that goes with it - in any case there will be a steep price). This is not take all and leave the rest with nothing - there won't be a take all (not in your option as far as i can tell). So my guess you need to think of a better one. Another poster raised alliances with Russia (not oil dependent - does tolerate force to a certain extend the West would regard immoral) - another poster crossed that option off perhaps. Which leaves China. This year China also invited Abbas during Netanyahu''s trade mission and presented a 4 stage peace plan based on 1967 lines (almost on Jerusalem Day - not the most sensitive approach). China so far has been even handed. Though keep thinking and i wish you wisdom and insight (regarding the alternatives to negotiating is also part of the process and confronting is probably always better than denial -it is a next step also in accepting any outcome - which might not be status quo..).
83. Mashiaj comes from israel.The me$$iah is not from u$a
daniel ,   the world   (09.24.13)
84. The Security of any sovereign entity
BM ,   Israel   (09.24.13)
Is dependent only on it's millitary and economic might, not on the creation of another such entity.
85. in Israel G-d values I trust
daniel ,   the world   (09.25.13)
86. Obama vieuw on Israels conflict
Dik ,   Spijkenisse   (09.24.13)
with Palestinians is wrong. The root of all evil is the latters refusal to recognise Israel. It has to do with islamic caliphate rule of the land of Israel and restating in 1948 into the State of Israel for the jews. The Arabs/Palestinians will never accept this fact. Shalom from Holland
87. #83, you mean the Antichrist
BM ,   Israel   (09.25.13)
Whom will be Jewish and will be view as their Messiah.
88. Oh, for pity's sake!
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (09.25.13)
"He added that his country is determined to resolve the Israeli-Palestinian conflict" Wrong. His administration is determined to write itself into the history books at Israel's expense and very much in violation of international law and convention. "that there is a consensus within Israel that the occupation harms Israeli interests" Wrong. Most Israelis do not consider the Israeli presence in Judea and Samaria to be an "occupation." We simply reacquired what has always been ours in the course of fighting a defensive war against Jordan. "and that Americans are committed to both the Israeli interests and to the idea that the Palestinians deserve their own state." President Obama hasn't checked the latest polls. Israel enjoys the highest support in its history among the American people. The American people are not as stupid as is Obama, and most recognize that it was the ersatz "Palestinians" who rejected partition in 1947, and instigated six wars, all of which were won by Israel. Moreover, most Americans are likely aware that the ersatz "Palestinians" in Judea and Samaria are Jordanian citizens. There is a groundswell of support in the United States for Israel to annex Judea and Samaria and to repatriate the illegal Arab squatters to Jordan. Obama really has gone 'round the bend .....
89. #87 yes
daniel ,   the world   (09.25.13)
study u$a evil history worldwide and analyze today u$a evildoers
90. #87, Christ was unknowm when Jewish Messiah concept was born
Steve Benassi ,   Silver Bay, MN USA   (09.25.13)
How can it be AntiChrist? You are deluding yourself as usual
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article