News
Palestinians: US ideas for security will lead to 'total failure' of talks
News agencies
Published: 09.12.13, 13:47
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
36 Talkbacks for this article
1. What will the Palestinians settle for ?
Roland ,   London England   (12.09.13)
Talks are futile if we don't know by now new aspect in their thinking to match the reality of the times.
2. This is Obama's "Divide and Rule" Arabia-Israel policy.
Steve Benassi ,   Silver Bay, MN USA   (12.09.13)
3. Palestinians need to accept a country like Andorra
Eric ,   Tel Aviv & NYC   (12.09.13)
4. Entitlement
paulD ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (12.09.13)
Arabs talk like they are entitled to everything they want. Problem is they are entitled to nothing, deserve nothing, and will probably never receive anything but torment their entire existence. Only problem is Jews have to deal with a world that believes peace is pacifying the savage tendencies of the Arab world, by reducing Jewish sovereignty, shrinking Jewish possession of its land, and DE-legitimatizing their historical rights. The world will never deal with their ideological and moral deficiencies until Jews stop playing their game. At that time they will stop obsessing about Jews and deal with their own miserable lives.
5. What's crucial is US making clear support for Jewish state
Sam ,   Canada   (12.09.13)
The Palestinians want to get what the black South Africans got. They want control over all the territory. (West Bank and Israel proper). They want the US and EU to boycott Israel to get it. They don't like to hear of any support for Israel, security or otherwise. If the US wants to get anywhere it will have to make clear to the Palestinians that there is no parallel between Israel and South Africa.
6. Those greedy greedy bastards
anti-bastardy ltd.   (12.09.13)
7. states are full of it
george   (12.09.13)
only security on jordan valley can be provided by soveriegn israeli idf troops. Anything else is madness. ynet is wrong in stating that israel welcomed kerry's proposals. 65 years af ther the holocaust, jews learned nothing , zero to attach their fate to some big power arrangments. What a bunch of bloody losers are the jews diskin, merridor, lvini, lapid, german, herzog whose father is rolling in his grave at the pacifist weakling son, and so on. What a state filled with chamberlains-65 years after 6 million were burned and you want to trust others on your securit y. This is a huge humiliation. Israelis shoujld get out of palestine and give it to abbas and move to states.YOu sicken me. the other side current arrangements of 1000 years- that is right,, period end of story.
8. End of israel
P. henry ,   Longmont,USA   (12.09.13)
The Arab.JIHAD will settle for the complete destruction of ISRAEL,period ! WAKE. Up !
9. What's crucial is US making clear support for Jewish state
Sam ,   Canada   (12.09.13)
The Palestinians want to get what the black South Africans got. They want control over all the territory. (West Bank and Israel proper). They want the US and EU to boycott Israel to get it. They don't like to hear of any support for Israel, security or otherwise. If the US wants to get anywhere it will have to make clear to the Palestinians that there is no parallel between Israel and South Africa.
10. treating them with indifference?
nadav ,   tlv   (12.09.13)
IF ONLY! TOO much time has been wasted on these ersatz "palestinians", who were invented by Nasser in the 1960s. they have ZERO historical claim to the region and already have a country where they are, by their definition, a majority- Jordan! They should be lucky that the world pays ANY attention to them, since Abbas is a dictator who doesn't even control half his population (Gaza is run by Hamas) and "Fakestine" is nothing but a failed, terrorist state in the making and we already have too many of them: Lebonon, Libya, Syria, Iraq, Sudan, etc. DO we really need another one? Jordan=Palestine, start from there!
11. They do not want to lose victim status
(12.09.13)
12. So take Israel to the ICC
(12.09.13)
13. US ideas fall very short of Rabin's view. The man who was...
N.L.Katz ,   Qatzrin, Israel   (12.09.13)
...called the "prince of peace", worldwide, considered the Jordan Valley, in the widest sense of the term, as an area that ought to remain under Israel's control (Rabin's speech at the Knesset, 5 Oct. 1995). It is high time the PLO, instead of attempting to find ways to avoid reaching a peace deal, address their commitment of 20 years ago and amend their Charter whose thrust, since 1964, has been: Israel's demise; the "cleansing" of the ancestral homeland of the Jewish people of its Jews; and, the use of all means possible to bring the above about.
14. 9Explain to Pals there were 5 M whites and 45 M blacks
Alan ,   SA   (12.09.13)
15. Pal leaders working for the Salafi thousands of Hebron/Sinai
Alan ,   SA   (12.09.13)
They expect whole world to hand over ENTIRE Israel to their tender care.
16. Terrorist PA ALWAYS DOES THIS.... It's called Middle East
Bla bla bla ,   Israel   (12.09.13)
bargaining... the more they complain the more they think they will get.
17. That's the Deal
Zechariah   (12.09.13)
If the Palestinians want th move forward that is the comprimise for leaving part of Area C unsettled by anyone because it will in effect be a security zone against Islamic Jihadi and Fatah Ba'ath and Facis.Eventually the Arabs are to Realize the Jews want Security and that massive security arrangements are vital.
18. Kerry / Israel
Dave Blevins ,   Deer Park, USA   (12.09.13)
Please know that most of us in America do not approve of, nor trust our government at this time. John Kerry is surely not to be trusted, and he does not represent our beliefs. We also have the very worst, and most hated president in our nations' history; B. Obama. Never, ever trust this incompetent liberal socialist.
19. support for Israel
Dave Blevins ,   Deer Park, USA   (12.09.13)
Again, do not trust ANY of America's so-called "political leaders", especially John Kerry. The Clinton woman should, at this time, start being investigated for her incompetence regarding our dead countrymen from the Benghazi attack. We, the people of America, are not being represented of our true beliefs and convictions by these incompetent individuals.
20. Obama's D/R policy
Dave Blevins ,   Deer Park, Washingto   (12.09.13)
Never, ever trust this president named Obama. He is paid to move the socialist agenda of elites, and almost all Americans despise him. After polling all of my aquaintences and friends, we wish for his impeachment, as well as for others in the current "administration", such as E. Holder. (whom impeachment charges have already been filed)
21. one can trust only on the palestinians
israeli ,   jerusalem   (12.09.13)
not our government and not the antiisraeli obama administration would save us from this 'peace' agreement. luckily everytime again, the palestinians themselves save us and even now blame the americans for it - for what could an israeli wish more?
22. Settler "price tag" on GIs will turn America against Israel.
Steve Benassi ,   Silver Bay, MN USA   (12.09.13)
#2 not mine.
23. Security measures are necessary to prevent. . .
Steve ,   AtlantaUSA   (12.09.13)
. . . Yasser Abed Rabbo and his friends from perpetrating a massacre similar to the one he perpetrated in Maalot.
24. PLO
Dave Blevins ,   Deer Park, USA   (12.09.13)
It is suggested that you "PLO" folks, and Palestinians everywhere, read the Holy Bible, and gain an understanding of Jesus Christ, and what He has sacrificed for mankind. And face up to your misguided human ideals. God gave you free will, and you have wrongly chosen to ignore Him. We pray for your salvation, and sanctification.
25. Yeaahhhh and NOW SHOVE IT !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Chris Rettenmoser ,   Bayerisch Gmain Germ   (12.09.13)
26. Land shortage!No limit to avariciousness why? Hate blinds th
Martin SA   (12.09.13)
27. #24 #24 Don't bother praying for these barbarians
A ,   Belgium   (12.09.13)
They will defecate in your church before accepting your infidel prayers.
28. Kerry & his Don at the White House should be talking details
tom ,   tel aviv   (12.09.13)
of future transfer of Israeli Arabs (wishing to live life to the hilt under Sharia) to Jordan or shall we say "Palestine", if that's how they wish to call it. That is the only viable solution, that does not include destruction of State of Israel as we know it. Anything else is waste of time.
29. To 14 Alan , SA - Rplace
Marian ,   Romania   (12.09.13)
Replace the Palestinians with Blacks !
30. If PLO Is Against It I'm Fot It
emanon ,   USA   (12.09.13)
Next talkbacks
Back to article