News
Jordan Valley seeds domestic division in Israel
The Media Line
Published: 31.12.13, 08:59
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
20 Talkbacks for this article
1. Doesn't it kill your argument, Erekat....
William ,   Israel   (12.31.13)
knowing that Jordan, the ARAB neighbor on the other side of the Valley, supports Israeli presence there?
2. Third Generation Ashkenaz forgot Holocaust
(12.31.13)
And do not really know the Arab's lust for blood.
3. whole land
(12.31.13)
Whole land belongs to God not anybody else to give for peace with Palestinians what belongs to Palestinians were their criminal prisoners.
4. Water rights
daz ,   uk   (12.31.13)
The River Jordan is Israel's main source of drinking water. Israel also has control over water in the Golan Heights but not Lebanon's river Litani which they failed to acquire after the 6day war.
5. Why bill to be defeated?
Israeli 2   (12.31.13)
They already annexed it perhaps? If not, do it now. It is new year.
6. daz , uk (12.31.13)
(12.31.13)
Israel is one of the world's top players in water desalination technology, thus it generates huge quantities of potable water
7. Do you believe Livni or Ya'alon
Norbus ,   Jerusalem   (12.31.13)
The answer , you guessed, is a no brainer. Livni is driven by hormones, emotions, and dreams whereas Ya'alon has to secure Israel's borders and defend the Jewish State. BELIEVERS like her, and Ehud Barak before her, and to a very large extent Ehud Olmert for different reasons, find out after it would have been too late the error of their way. Rabin made clear what we need to secure our State and Ya'alon agrees That is good enough for me.
8. to #6 that is not true, big cities base their
lili   (12.31.13)
water system on the fresh water from the Kinneret still, like Tel Aviv, the sea water in Tel Aviv are poluted so they can not be used for drinking.
9. If this topic is creating a "divide" then we don't deserve
tom ,   tel aviv   (12.31.13)
this Land at all!
10. Settler "price tag" on GIs will turn America against Israel
Steve Benassi ,   Silver Bay, MN USA   (12.31.13)
11. Fukestinian attacks on US GIs will turn Americans against
Steve Benassi ,   Silver Bay, MN USA   (12.31.13)
12. No more games. This land is ours.
Chaim ,   Israel   (12.31.13)
Judea and Samaria belong to Israel as New York belongs to America. End of discussion.
13. US GI's have no apetite to be killed to save Muslim butts
Steve Benassi ,   Silver Bay, MN USA   (12.31.13)
14. US GIs enter Gaza & transfer ForeignArabs to Mecca for Peace
Steve Benassi ,   Silver Bay, MN USA   (12.31.13)
15. #2,no name, no country moron thinks Holocaust was about land
Steve Benassi ,   Silver Bay, MN USA   (12.31.13)
16. 36% of valley settlers want to leave
sharpshin ,   USA   (12.31.13)
Poll reported today.
17. #! - all wet
sharpshin ,   USA   (12.31.13)
Jordan objects very much to any such move as annexation of the Jordan Valley by Israeli. Get a grip.
18. Shaked, another Israeli academic fool
Cowboy Joe ,   Calgary, Canada   (12.31.13)
Paradoxically, those who live in ivory towers shouldn't be teachers. How does he suppose missiles would get into the West Bank to target his house. Many would be shipped through the Jordan valley, of course. What an idiot! Is this a typical example of Israeli intelligence?
19. #15 Thick as 2 planks
(12.31.13)
Even a dunce would have realised the 2nd Holocaust can only be avoided by retaining land and secure borders; You are getting tiresome with your stupid posts
20. #16, The supposed poll author denied today that it was done
Steve Benassi ,   Silver Bay, MN USA   (12.31.13)
Minah Tzemah named as the author of the poll by a Leftist Organization said that she never conducted such a poll.
Back to article