News
Peres to petition Obama: Freeing Pollard a 'mitzvah'
Noam Dabul Dvir
Published: 01.01.14, 14:40
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
23 Talkbacks for this article
1. The US is too ill-willed to free Pollard
Noodles ,   Coney Island   (01.01.14)
But the stinking hypocrites expect Israel to free dozens of murderers, some of whom have served less time than Pollard. Let 'em be damned....
2. Don't free the AMERICAN CITIZEN Pollard
sheik rattle & roll ,   USA   (01.01.14)
Pollard is an American citizen that betrayed his country. He played the Jewish card when he got caught stealing secrets from his American employer. America separates religion from State, so the Jewish religious card or the defacto Israeli citizenship card doesn't mean sh*t to Americans. Most American Jews have no connection with Israel and consider it a foreign country just like most African Americans perceive the countries of Africa.
3. Ynetnew never publishes my Pollard comments
mea   (01.01.14)
but the reality is Pollard is scheduled for release in 2015 and the effort to free him "early" is a publicity stunt. He could have been freed all along if he had confessed and agreed to not discuss what he did. That doesn't roll with the profitable lecture circuit and the so called "folk hero" status. Pollard being used to create this illusion will further divide American Jews from Israelis. This is because in America, we see him as a traitor. The old fart Peres just wants to put this under his column. Freeing Pollard is not a mitzvah but simply a grave misunderstanding of the relationship between our countries. It will make many Americans distrust Israel and will cause commentators on talk shows go nuts against Israel. BAD idea.
4. Meretz MK's who didn't sign are traitors & Arab MK's enemies
Steve Benassi ,   Silver Bay, MN USA   (01.01.14)
5. Pollard never spied on America, only on Muslim enemies
Steve Benassi ,   Silver Bay, MN USA   (01.01.14)
6. Do you think ..
Jon ,   UK   (01.01.14)
that one year in jail for every death that he caused is just punishment ? If so, he will rot in jail. Of course, most (all ?) of his victims were not jews so maybe you are not bothered.
7. As an Israeli
Jacov ,   Tel Aviv   (01.01.14)
As an Israeli I say let Pollard rot ,he betrayed his country not Israel even if he is a Israeli citizen.
8. maybe it helps, Peres is less.....
Toledano Jean-Pierre ,   Israel   (01.01.14)
Maybe Obama will listen more to Peres then to Bibi. Peres not criticises Obama about his attitude to Israel. To gratify Peres' behaviour and to slam Bibi's oppositional behaviour towards the USA president about a lot of political matters Obama will maybe give amnesty to Pollard. Wait and see is the message.
9. We'll trade him for Vanunu? (end)
DH ,   US   (01.01.14)
10. Obama the muslim wil not free a Jew
Arik ,   Hadera Israel   (01.01.14)
unless we gice all Israel to his jihadist friends....
11. All Israel has to do
Sarah B ,   Tel Aviv/London   (01.01.14)
to free Jonathan Pollard is to name his handlers. Do that and Pollard could have been freed 20 years ago. This is the uncomfortable truth our political leaders do not want us to know about
12. I want to petition Obama to "free "Peres
Tommy ,   Tel-Aviv, Israel   (01.01.14)
13. #2 Pollard's info was vital for Israel
Tahl   (01.01.14)
Pollard never spied on America, he only gave Israel access to vital information about Arab states - information that the USA should have shared with Israel in the first place. Yes, Pollard played "the Jewish card", but only because the US Justice department played it first, sticking him with an unusually harsh punishment only because he is a Jew. Similar espionage offenders who were non-Jews got off with much lighter sentences. There is really no limit to the American hypocrisy. Spying on Israeli politicians, and forcing Israel to release Palestinian murderers, yet keeping Pollard (who never killed anyone) in jail out of sheer spite.
14. #13 Tahl
Sarah B ,   Tel Aviv/London   (01.01.14)
All our political leaders have to do is name Pollard's handlers and he can be on a plane to Israel tomorrow. Why haven't they done this? Is what you should be asking Peres, rather than whinging about another country's judiciary
15. Peres sold Pollard Out
Bill Stein ,   USA   (01.01.14)
Turned him over to the Americans
16. 11# Please Sarah B, tel us as it is
Nora Tel Aviv   (01.01.14)
The Chief Handler is above all criticism. Maybe when he will be "really old" the next generation will get to know what happened when the Israeli embassy closed its doors to Pollard.
17. Add signatures of Senators and Congressmen
Roland ,   London England   (01.01.14)
18. At least he'll get credit for 1 mitzvah in his life
Anony   (01.01.14)
better late than never.
19. no pollard no israeli arabs and if they want to go then they
ralph   (01.01.14)
Must accept and sign document giving up Israeli citizenship for ever and their families and kids.
20. Pers, do not count on it
CJK   (01.02.14)
obama will never release a jew who spied for israel. indeed, obama has hardly pardoned anyone during his presidency. obama is without a heart and without a soul.
21. You gonna impress His Satanic Majesty with this bit?
Cameron ,   USA   (01.02.14)
22. #17, AIPAC not lobbying Congress for Pollard, why? Fear.
Steve Benassi ,   Silver Bay, MN USA   (01.02.14)
"Aviem Sella recruited Jonathan Pollard to spy for Israel...Sella was promoted to Brigadier General and given command of Tel Nof Airbase, and the U.S. Congress reacted by threatening to cut aid to Israel...Sella then resigned to defuse US-Israel tensions" #4, 5, not mine.
23. #5, Were you there with him?
HeeHaw ,   India   (01.02.14)
Maybe you should be locked up too :)
Back to article