Jewish Scene
Radical haredi campaign calls IDF 'national trash can'
Kobi Nachshoni
Published: 30.01.14, 00:25
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
47 Talkbacks for this article
31. 29 Charles,Acts of Hilul Hashem...
ORA ,   JERUSALEM   (01.30.14)
are condemned by the Great Rabanim at their lectures to their students.
32. 27 Mordechai, I like it very much here
ORA ,   JERUSALEM   (01.30.14)
and we Haredim have prayed more than 2000 years for Jerusalem and now we are here to stay,if you like it or not. I am not imposing you anything by giving my opinion. Your aggressiveness shows that you are not able to defend your point of view. Mordechai is a great name.You don,t deserve it.
33. Apparently my mommy was the Yippee
Ypip ,   Canada   (01.30.14)
Quite the handful, but by no means a black widow.
34. 17 Robert If the Gedolim Hador...
ORA ,   JERUSALEM   (01.30.14)
are against such a law,there is nothing the State can do.
35. Cartoons
Avi schryber ,   Givat Zeev Israel   (01.31.14)
I am ashamed to see these cartoons! Nothing makes me prouder than to see a religious person in army uniform! It is SUCH a Kidush HAdh
36. Ora 31 & 34
Charles ,   Petach Tikva   (02.01.14)
Can you give the names of those "rabbanim" ? When and where did they oppose those radicals ? "gedolim hador' have to respect the State laws too , they are NOT above the State
37. Haredi
h.s.cohen ,   N.Y.C. U.S.A.   (02.01.14)
CUT OFF THEIR FUNDING!
38. 36 TRY2 Sherif Charles PT is back on..
ORA ,   JERUSALEM   (02.01.14)
Jewish Scene.
39. 20 Your hate is just as painful.
ORA ,   JERUSALEM   (02.01.14)
tarnishing a whole society because of some rotten apples.
40. 36 Charles,
ORA ,   JERUSALEM   (02.01.14)
I spoke with Yeshiva students who gave me this information.They too are against these despicable acts. Gedolim Hador have indeed to respect the laws of the State as long they are not in contradiction with the Tora. Shavuah Tov,Charles.
41. 40 , Ora
Charles ,   Petach Tikva   (02.01.14)
A sheriff , as you called me , NEEDS PROOFS "I spoke with ......" this is something I can't check , not a proof I can accept. Where ? who ? when ? Serving in the IDF is "din malchouta , din ...." And is NOT contrary to Tora laws .
42. Haven't quite figured it out yet
Big Yossi ,   Jerusalem   (02.02.14)
why it's OK for Adam Verete to speak in class about what he feels are the evils of the IDF, and the demonstration on his behalf, and the support he's getting from all over, including the Education Minister. Is free speech permitted only when it comes from the left?
43. 41 Charles,I do not pretend to know
ORA ,   JERUSALEM   (02.02.14)
better than the Gedolim Hador the meaning of the Tora laws. For example it is written :you shall not kill. The oral law teaches the nuances.In which case it is allowed to kill . Orthodox Jews rely on the Great Rabbis knowledge. Do you know that Sharon was during the 6 days and the Yom Kippur war in connection with the Lubavitcher Rabbi Shneerson who advised him the strategy to follow? Sorry Charles,i belief the students that gave me information.They were disgusted too.They wouldn't be so if their Rabbi wasn't against provoking secular Jews.Rav Steinman is well known for that. I am quite sure you know Tora students too.Why don't you check with them? Good luck.
44. Ora
Charles ,   Petach Tikva   (02.02.14)
Charles believes what you wrote , the sheriff NOT at all . The sheriff wants PUBLIC statements , public condemnation sources . The sheriff wants also your sources for what you wrote about Sharon .
45. Ora , NOT TRUE
Charles ,   Petach Tikva   (02.02.14)
"He would later recall that very first meeting with the Rebbe in 1968" from the Chabad website ! So your Rebbe could not have given him advice for the 6 days war .
46. 45Charles,I take my had off to..
ORA ,   JERUSALEM   (02.02.14)
your expertise in Jewish history. .I am impressed. I have read about Sharon's connection with the Rebbe a few weeks ago in the Jerusalem Post. Now i understand why everything we read in newspapers has to be checked. Would be fair if you do the same when Haredim are tarnished. Charles,you are great.
47. Ora .
Charles ,   Petach Tikva   (02.02.14)
It's not expertise , it's research on internet . I found it at the chabad.org website , read it , interesting . Sharon was impressed by Schneerson , had one of his sons's Bar mitzwa at chabad . The sheriff is still waiting for an answer !
Previous talkbacks
Back to article