News
Top MKs say Livni hinted that Israel could be 'in for a surprise' over Palestinian recognition of Jewish state
Moran Azulay
Published: 09.02.14, 15:12
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
31 Talkbacks for this article
1. If Lapid doesn't recognize Israel as a Jewish state
John   (02.09.14)
why do the PA need to?
2. HOLLOW words mean NOTHING...!
Chris Rettenmoser ,   Bayerisch Gmain Germ   (02.09.14)
ANNEX JUDEA AND SAMARIA NOW !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
3. And Nero fiddles
david levy ,   tel aviv   (02.09.14)
while Rome burns
4. Hamas said Israel will be gone in 8 years
David ,   On this planet   (02.09.14)
I think they are very generous , With ministers like we have who needs enemies, What a bunch of losers
5. King (Queen) Solomon, 2014?
ASTRONAUT ,   SC, USA   (02.09.14)
"...if they would be willing to acknowledge us as the national state for the Jews, would you be willing to divide the land then?" Who are you Miss Livni , "Queen Solomon" dividing the baby? Acknowledging Eretz Yisrael as The Jewish Homeland means AM YISRAEL, INTACT.
6. Israel Jewish State
Harold ,   USA   (02.09.14)
I don't believe Mohamood Abbas will recognize Israel as a Jewish State because one fourth of Israeli population are Christians and Muslims.
7. Complicated problems need simple solutions...
Robert ,   USA   (02.09.14)
The main problem is that there are a few temporary political leaders of Israel and the PA trying to solve a complicated problem with a more complicated solution that they assume will last indefinitely.. Whether you liked President Reagan or not, the simplicity of his thinking was refreshing and surprisingly solved complicated problems that Jimmy Carter had only made more complicated with his convoluted solutions. Either two states along the 1967 border on one state. The answer is clearly the latter.
8. Livni is a menace to Israel and must go.
Chaim ,   Israel   (02.09.14)
There is no excuse to let this total incompetent, who hurts Israel almost every time she speaks, represent Israel in any capacity. She cost Israel victory in Lebanon with her idiotic cease fire. She disgraced us at Annapolis. She keeps trying to give away Jerusalem. Livni must go. "Palestinian" recognition is unneeded, irrelevant and simply another evil trick.
9. If the Pals recognise Israel as a Jewish State -
Arn. ,   Sweden.   (02.09.14)
- the resister of the division of Israel will be swept away. I Think. Evil will come to Israel by this, as hinted in the Word of HASHEM. Arn.Sweden.
10. PI, Palestine Israel, 2 States, 1 Country, 6M Jews, 9M Arabs
Steve Benassi ,   Silver Bay, MN USA   (02.09.14)
11. I'm sick of this non issue
Ed ,   USA   (02.09.14)
This is ridiculous and has gone on way too long. Israel is a Jewish state, and will continue to be a Jewish state so long as the right wing doesn't insist on holding on to the entire land. The Palestinians don't have to say anything. However once the outlying settlements are evacuated, land swaps fix the rest of the settlement issue, and the right of return is nuanced into financial compensation the demographic reality will keep Israel a Jewish state. What a ridiculous non issue, only existing to keep Bibi from having to show leadership and actually do something.
12. Sory, Tzipi, but...
milwaukeebroad ,   Haifa, Israel   (02.09.14)
Israel is through with negotiating. It's time for Israel to start taking back the land that's originally theirs. No more peace talks!
13. Jewish state education
Non Jewish immigrant ,   Haifa   (02.09.14)
So the state of Israel wants to brainwash its kids into believing that non Jews have no rights in this country or just the minimum. Israel supports therefore separationism and elitism of its population, giving de facto advantages to some and less to others. If not an apartheid state then what is it?
14. #8
Lynx ,   Palestine   (02.09.14)
You may repeat the same mantras over and over...and keep claiming that we've been vanquished, or that we don't exist, and the usual Hasbara. However, 100 years of agression and colonialism, yet we're still standing tall and proud. We are here to stay.
15. Will NOT happen. EVAH!!!
Gideon Reader   (02.09.14)
How blindly stupid is this woman, that she does not recognize the historicaally proven fact that the Palestinians want Israel gone' replaced with their own chaotic state of Palestine and ALL of the former residents, i.e. the Jews, DEAD or forcibly converted to Islam.
16. @11. Worse than a non-issue
Rube Vogel ,   Jerusalem   (02.09.14)
By building up the importance of this non-issue, in the end Israel will be forced to make real concessions in return for a few insincere words of recognition by Abbas.
17. #6 Abbas recognizes Iran as Islamic state
Benji ,   US   (02.09.14)
While not all the residents of Iran are Muslim. It's only an issue when you have no intention of reaching a peace agreement.
18. #11 Good points
Sammy ,   Newcastle   (02.09.14)
In a strange way these huge Palestinian Israeli talking sessions gradually begin to crystallize what are the priorities are what are not. Issues that might have seemed insurmountable become surmountable And from the Palestinian perspective gradually its the realization that Statehood is not just an emotional badge of identity weve gone beyond that - its about the practical building of a successful and prosperous country that can fulfill its potential Whats more important for the self national interest of Palestine are not the dogmatic definitions of Israel as a Jewish State – it is the development of a vibrant Palestinian Society and Economy and for that we need Peace and Security, Free Trade Access to Israeli Markets, Israeli Technical Support and Know How especially in Water, Energy, Agriculture and Roads and Rail and full and proper International Israeli and Arab Financial Support for any Palestinian Refugees wanting to make a new Life in the new Palestine in the West Bank And we have no demands on a Deadline – Just demands for the talking to continue for however long it takes
19. OMG !!!
Mike ,   NZ   (02.09.14)
Have they consulted with Lydia from Brisbane ??
20. I would like to meet Chaim @#8 in person
(02.09.14)
We need REAL people. Not politicians! Not Lieberman! Not Bennet! Please forget BI-BI and no more LIKUD! Or is it Lick it?!!
21. non-issue
Gershon ,   London UK   (02.09.14)
I agree totally with Rube Vogel (16). What on earth has palestinian recognition of Israel as the Jewish State have anything to do with peace and security?! Do we need any nation on earth to recognize who and what we are? It is this pathological lack of national self esteem that Bibi encapsulates that forces him to make this total non-issue a "crucial" part of his agenda, instead of doing what any decent leader would do: to clearly and proudly (and politely of course) announce to the world that Israel has lost all faith in any "Peace Talks" as the Palestinians backed by most of the world, relentlessly demand territorial concessions from Israel which will inevitably lead to more conflict and war. (Indeed it was precisely the territorial configuraton of the Palestinians controlling all the West Bank (with no settlements to block them) and half of Jerusalem that led them to wage a war of extermination and destruction on tiny Israel in June 1967. Israel cannot and will not allow a return to this possibility as it would lead to more bloodshed - for Jews and non-Jews. Palestinians already have their own state in all but name - Jordan. So let the Palestinians living in JOrdan (70% of all the people there!) give King Hussein an ultimatume. Either cahnge the name to Palestine or we will throw you out like many other arab countries have done recently.
22. #21. Expose Piece Talks as laughing stock they are.
Chaim ,   Israel   (02.09.14)
The Piece Talks are completely fake. Palestine is fictional. Abbas is a fake with no real power. He is not even legit by the P.A.'s own constitution. The only thing real about these talks is the enormous danger they pose to Israel. The Kerry spoofs are excellent and we need to do more to expose the Piece Talks as the laughing stock they are. Republicans will be able to use these spoofs against the Obama regime in the upcoming midterm elections and in 2016. We need to make it clear to the Obama Regime that it can only lose with these Piece Talks.
23. First Israle Insisted the Pals Must Recognize Israel Before
Doug ,   Rochester, USA   (02.09.14)
they can have their own state. The Pals recognized Israel and Israel renigged on their promise. The Israel insists that the Pals recognize Israel as the Jewish State. Now it sounds like the Pals are willing to do that. Will Israel renig again? Of course they will. Israel has become addicted to occupation, colonization, land theft, water theft, Apartheid walls, checkpoints, roads, buses and to ready access to a near-slave market of cheap labor.
24. Lynx # 14
Eaglebeak ,   Left Coast, USA   (02.10.14)
If I couldn't stand on my own two feet and had to live on the charity of my enemies I wouldn't be standing tall and proud. Are you proud to beg money to make Sufa Arafat and others like her rich while you remain poor? Israel made the deserts bloom. Israel improved the land and improves the world with it's science, technology and hard work. You improve nothing and add nothing to the world but grief. You can't even get along with each other. You may think you are here to stay but you will have nothing to be proud of until your attitudes change and you start to contribute something ANYTHING to others or even to yourselves.
25. #23, You're addicted to blood libels, lies, antisemitism
Jake   (02.10.14)
No difference between what you are accusing against Israel today and what your forbears accused the Jews during the Black Death. Medieval redux P.S. The PLO only ever recognized Israel as a party to negotiations, never as a sovereign state with legitimate borders and territory.
26. The Palestinians become nicer and nicer ...
Robert ,   Belgium   (02.10.14)
After noticing what's happening in their Arab brother's countries for the past three years, they understand that Israel and the territories is Disneyland.
27. ONE WORD: TAKKIYEH
(02.10.14)
28. Palestine economy
David Zohar ,   Jerusalem   (02.10.14)
Today the shekel is legal tender in Gaza and West Bank. If the Palestinians really want independence they must be ready to have their own currency which would mean the near collapse of their economy- which is largely dependent on Israel's. Can they afford it?
29. to 13
Jennie ,   Israel/US   (02.10.14)
Yes, Israel is the smallest sovereignty in the ME & most likely in the world. A democracy with no prejudice to any of their residents & Olim/newcomers .. And if Israel wanted to brainwash, in their own country,they would have the right to do it...The fact, that so many "won-a be" immigrants, of none Jewish religion are flocking there, speaks for itself...If Israelis are "brainwashing their kids", etc...,why don't you leave and go where you came from or anywhere else...? You are Free to Go...And We'll even help you with the ticket...
30. to 14
Jennie ,   Israel/US   (02.10.14)
WOW !!!
Next talkbacks
Back to article