News
Teenagers write to PM: We won't join an army that commits war crimes
Ynetnews
Published: 08.03.14, 23:16
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
54 Talkbacks for this article
31. I wonder who is feeding them such drivel.
Larry ,   Or Yehuda   (03.09.14)
They do not even understand what they are talking about. That is the problem with our education system.
32. ok
pini ,   israel   (03.09.14)
t do community service instead. either way serve your country. and go talk to Palestinians to get them to make rational peace proposals. in other words get off your ass and do something.
33. and don't forget
(03.09.14)
since I serve as combat I can remind you other than suppressing the Palestinians we also protect our Syrian Lebanese Egyptian Jordanian and Gaza borders. where terrorists groups on a DAILY BASIS attempt to infiltrate. you know. to kill you.... but hey well keep protecting you tel aivvians
34. #18 My thoughts exactly
American Sabrah ,   Israe   (03.09.14)
Perhaps they should consider protesting with the Haredim at the anti-draft rally since they share the same philosophy.
35. #22, Sending them a check in the morning. Advice appreciated
Michael ,   California, USA   (03.09.14)
36. Both parties:
Jake Stone ,   USA   (03.09.14)
Haredim and these cowardly punk kids should be deported (their Israeli citizenship revoked) at once! God bless Israel!!!
37. Boy are these teens MISINFORMED!
R ,   Israel   (03.09.14)
They have their facts BACKWARDS! the Arabs are treated extremely well by Israel. it is "settlers" who are thrown into prisons without cause. And MANY ARABS love being under Israeli rule (and are afraid of being killed for admitting this to their own people!) because they make a lot of tax free money from 'the Jews" and are treated kinder by the Israeli government than their own people who will execute their own people for the smallest crime!
38. # 15 Arad hit the nail: "Good luck for them to find a decent job in the future"
(03.09.14)
39. #22 not only Am.Jewish NGO's. don' forget the EU ones. Too many poisoning the brains
Aaron   (03.09.14)
40. You are courageous and conscious.
cfspirit ,   fr and dz   (03.09.14)
41. refusal to enlist in the army
yankel ,   kfar saba   (03.09.14)
these cowards should realise they live in a country surrounded by deadly enemies & they show the same cowardice as the haredi stand up & be counted
42. Jewish funded NGO ?!
yosef, phd ,   florida - israel   (03.09.14)
And who the hell is REALLY funding this "bleeding hearts" and other leftist tear-jerker organizations?! One way tickets to Gaza or other paradises for all these "nice" people - I'll be glad to chip in. There seems to be NO end to their delusions of "freedom"..
43. Send them to see suicide bombings sites
uneducated kids   (03.09.14)
44. Protesting the IDF
NYC Girl   (03.09.14)
Hopefully, in a few years, these kids will go through a process of self-examination and they'll come to the conclusion they don't know what the hell they're talking about. Because, having been on the very far left of the political spectrum when I was a student, I absolutely believed that America was the most evil country on earth, responsible for all the suffering and evil in the world. Then, one day, you snap out of your delusional thinking, because you've come to the conclusion that the lunatic fringe left has actually become the new fascism. And while I'll never be able to shake off my steadfast belief in things like abortion, gay rights and even assisted suicide, and I will always be an unabashed atheist, I'll never have anything but utter contempt for the accusation that the IDF is immoral....and my suspicion is that a lot of these kids will turn out the same way.
45. are DOZENS newsworthy?
zionist forever   (03.09.14)
We are talking about dozens of people signing this petition. Not hundreds, thousand or millions, this lot are just your traditional Tel Aviv draft dodgers who refuse to serve on these so called moral grounds. We a lll know they are out there so why write stories about them now because dozens sign a petition. This is not exactly some changing cultural attitude in Israeli society
46. Only patriots should teach our youth.
Chaim ,   Israel   (03.09.14)
The main takeaway from this vile letter, which could easily have been encouraged by adult leftists, is that we have to stop leftists from poisoning our children's minds. Only patriots should be allowed to teach our youth.
47. do their supporters have the same attitude t haredi
zionist forever   (03.09.14)
These people believe they should refuse to serve in an army that commits crimes and their definitions of crimes which is fair enough they believe they are doing right. What about the haredi who believe they should not serve because as religious men they should be studying in yeshiva learning Torah so they can be better Jews. Yeshivia isn't seen by them as some kind of attempt to be lazy they legitimately believe there lives are better served in yeshiva bettering themselves as Jews so where is the difference between the haredi and the people who wrote this letter, both are refusing to serve because its the morally right ting to do only difference is one is haredi and everybody hates haredi and one is not so its easier to be sympathetic towards them.
48. Simple solution
Aaron ,   Toronto Canada   (03.09.14)
The simple solution is to form a bank with all tehudat z numbers of all not wanting to serve and thus not able to receive any benefits from the state. Anytime they go anywhere to learn,study or work all will know who they are.
49. They're absolutely right
Dave from Brazil ,   Sao Paulo   (03.09.14)
People want to serve in an army that protects their nation, but not if it means occupying and violating human rights of a whole other nation. I hope Netanyahu reaches a peace agreement with the Palestinians and gets out of the West Bank.
50. 'We won't join an army that commits war crimes'
split ,   US   (03.09.14)
At least this time they hit the nail on the head ,...
51. SPIT,but you are willing/ready to join genocidal Islamonazis
Steve Benassi ,   Silver Bay, MN USA   (03.09.14)
52. #27 - in the past, such cowards claimed medical conditions
William ,   Israel   (03.09.14)
but then it came back to haunt them during job interviews which were limited because it was believed they had medical conditions. When the truth was revealed, they were limited because they were seen as untrustworthy.
53. #35 - please do. We will too.
William ,   Israel   (03.09.14)
California is in dire straits these days. Perhaps some funding to groups working to break CA into 7 States would be in order.
54. #50 - not proof that IDF committed such crimes
William ,   Israel   (03.09.14)
Accusation a plenty, but no proof as of yet. However, they are willing to support the opposing side that has been cited for war crimes and is listed on the global terrorist list. Depravity and naivete go hand in hand.
Previous talkbacks
Back to article