News
Kerry: Mistake to make Jewish state demand a peace deal decider
Ynetnews
Published: 13.03.14, 23:07
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
81 Talkbacks for this article
31. Dear Mr Kerry
James ,   USA   (03.14.14)
Did Mr. Obama of muslim heritage pass this on from, hamas, al quds, and whatever liberation army. Until they accept that condition, the PA charter still calls for the destruction of the Jewish State. Even if they did accept it, I don't think it would mean anything as the hatreds is too deep.
32. #28 you should be a comedian!!
Elan ,   Ramat Gan, Israel   (03.14.14)
How are you comparing actual countries with actual leaders, with real borders, to the Palestinian authority ? So you actually bother to read Israeli news, look at all the rockets being launched at us?stuff you well hardly EVER read about on the BBC. And why? Hamas claims Tel Aviv is theirs, as well as ALL of Israel, and we are occupying it, and they're the "resistance"! Really? Hamas, has gotten Gaza all to them selves, we don't step foot inside there, unless they attack us ! Israel, and Netanyahu have learned their lesson! They will not allow the west bank to mirror what has happened in Gaza. Whether or not you agree we have that right, is irrelevant, because we didn't ask you! In the end, Mine and my Countrymen's Lives are at risk, not YOURS! This demand may be new, but it does not mean it is less important! Like the Palestinians, we also learn what works and what doesn't, we adapt! This demand, is no less than you would find in a contract covering all bases, to protect each party from future made up claims! cheers.
33. Ingathering of Jews in the Jewish State
Norbus ,   Jerusalem   (03.14.14)
Kerry , you and your likes left a Jewish fold chosing to assimilate, and live a life you considered better for you. Fame, women money song.. As such you are not fit to advise those living the miracle of the Jewish State GO back to where you belong. You can spin a better story for Climate Change.
34. Jewish wasnt important to K's granpa,but important to Israel
Alan ,   SA   (03.14.14)
35. Kerry, you are ridicules. Go home and stay there
Rotem ,   Israel   (03.14.14)
Idiot!
36. What Kerry says
Abraham Nachmias ,   Petach Tikva IL   (03.14.14)
What he means is that whatever we ask for is nonsense, unimportant nonsense. Just what Abu Mazen ask for is important. This is because Kerry knows that Abu mazen won't surrender, so he presses us! Please Mr. kerry, don't come here any more, we don't like you and we don't want you!
37. #4 what i do not understand
Rau   (03.14.14)
If it is so clear that Israel is a Jewish state why it is so difficult for the jews to accept that Israel is a jewish state.
38. Egypt and Jordan
Dave ,   Miami USA   (03.14.14)
Are countries, and Israel is another country.They don't need to reconize Israel as a Jewish State, but pals never had a state , they want to create one, inside Israel.Jordan is the solution for the conflict.
39. Palis waging war on this issue.
Lemmings Hotline ,   sd usa   (03.14.14)
The PR campaign against the Jewish nature of the state is being wag ed in many countries in the form of boycotts and antijewish legislation. The requirement to recognize the Jewish state is aimed at putting an end to this war. So, Mr Kerry, yes they need to just come out and say it again.
40. But no Rap for 60 Islamic state calls?
BUTSeriously ,   Sydney   (03.14.14)
41. Kerry is desparate
CJK   (03.14.14)
kerry is desparate to give the arab palestinians a state, regardless of the consequences. kerry does not care about peace or the welfare of israel's jewish population. kerry sides with the arabs and hopes that the jews will not notice.
42. The Ukraine is about to blow and this guy
Al   (03.14.14)
only has Israel in his sights. If he is not a case study in sociopathology, I do not know what is. He is hell bent on putting Israel to its knees. And to think he wanted to be President of the USA. Of course Obama is no different, only he was put up by that schmuck Emanuel from Chicago. The dim witted Jews of America voted for Obama twice. I pray for Israel and its defenders, the gallant soldiers of the IDF, the only ones who will safeguard the country.
43. Kerry is a moron and Herzog is a Traitor
NYwoman   (03.14.14)
Herzog should be charged with treason against the state. He is a disgusting idiot. Meet with Kerry and tell him that Israel should not have any demands of Abbas and the PA does not need to recognize Israel as a Jewish State. This disgusting traitor has no idea of the intentions of Abbas. The PA wants one state. A muslim state controlling the entire area of what is Israel. Mr Herzog they want you home in Tel-Aviv.
44. NEVER trust Kerry, the anti-Semite!
Reuven   (03.14.14)
45. kerry is unbelievable
david ,   new york   (03.14.14)
he wont even require the palestinians to recognize israel (??!!!??) -and here's the kicker - because arafat already recognized israel (!!) well, we saw how much THAT was worth when he started blowing up buses. clearly, the palestinians recognition for israel's right to exist is quite questionable. even if abbas said it, i wouldnt believe it until they actually stop teaching their schoolchildren that the need to expell the jews from israel. kerry - please stuff it "where the sun dont shine"
46. Cali lib-tard the Temple Mount is called so for a reason
Joe Fraser ,   MTL, Canada   (03.14.14)
And there is no East Jerusalem. East of Jerusalem is A place called Abu Dis.
47. If the Arabs agree to recognising....
Robert ,   Australia   (03.14.14)
....Israel as a Jewish state I'm sure Netanyahu has another objection up his sleeve.
48. Remmeber your place Kerry--you are an o.u.t.s.i.d.e.r!
mea   (03.14.14)
49. There goes any shred of Kerry's credibility
Memphis Slim ,   Memphis, TN - USA   (03.14.14)
I mean really...is there nothing he won't do or say in order to get his own Nobel Peace Prize. Look wlhat good it did for the 1947 U.N. recognition of a Jewish state, look what good it did for Arafat to recognize Israel as a Jewish state. By-the-way Kerry, didn't the USA guarentee Ukraine's soveriegnty when they gave up their nuclear capibility? The US governement under Obama is made up of fools.
50. Big mouth Kerry just paid to mob to kill people in Ukrain
Miron ,   USA   (03.14.14)
they unloaded from trains and buses, went to city square, armed with nail tipped bats, and started hitting people in the square yelling them to go out of Ukrain. US is instigating ethnic cleansing in Ukrain and formeting genocide.
51. "Jewish State" with 6M Jews, 9M Arabs, not going to happen
Steve Benassi ,   Silver Bay, MN USA   (03.14.14)
#1 not mine.
52. This guy is really stupid...
Shlomo   (03.14.14)
As if this isn't the ONLY request that these primitive animals reject. They reject Israel, Jews - everything. What's more they have categorically pledged themselves to the destruction of Israel. Full stop. This has never changed - even well before 1948. If it is not the "pals" it is Iran and Hezbollah - and a continuing list of islamic countries who all want Israel and Jews - DEAD. What is so hard for Mr Kerry to understand???
53. Kerry attempts to fool all: Arafat, niether in 1988 nor in
N.L.Katz ,   Qatzrin, Israel   (03.14.14)
1994, accepted Israel's RIGHT to be, to exist as the sovereign nation-state of the Jewish people. He merely, in 1994, and only in English..., accepted Israel's right to exist. Also, UN General Assembly resolution, 181, 1947, was not part of international law, only a UNGA recommendation. But, even as a proposal 181 was categorically rejected by the Arabs precisely for the reason that they reject Israel's RIGHT to be, to exist as the sovereign nation-state of the Jewish people today.
54. YNet is great with their pictures.
Israeli 2   (03.14.14)
Kerry is depicted as a real dufus 'cause that is what he is.
55. No Jewish state
Walter Cole ,   Tucson, USA   (03.14.14)
Abbas' two-state solution: two states, one Muslim, the other Islamic, living side by side in peace.
56. Um, Kerry, Arafat is dead ya know.
Nora ,   Israel   (03.14.14)
57. John Kerry and a Jewish State
Bill Bender ,   Los Angeles, USA   (03.14.14)
It should be instructive to Kerry that in 1947, though it was in a UN resolution that there should be a Jewish State, It was never recognized by the Arab states. In addition, Arafat never signed an agreement which recognized Israel as a Jewish State. While Israel doesn't need any country to recognize it as being Jewish, the refusal of Abbas to do so proves his malevolence towards Israel and his hope that eventually it will be over run by Palestinians.
58. If Arafat agreed and Abbas doesn't ....
Ehud   (03.14.14)
...this would be a hardening of position and a u-turn, which would definitely be a deal breaker. It would also be interesting to hear what Abbas thinks about Kerry's interpretation. Seems, every time Kerry doesn't get Abbas to agree on something essential and substantial, it becomes suddenly not smart to insist on it. Works for Abbas, works for Assad, works for Putin - doesn't work for us!
59. Re: Kerry
Adam Bennett ,   Los Angeles, USA   (03.14.14)
The conflict was sown by refutation to recognize Israel as a Jewish state. The Arabs never recognized UN resolutions in 1947-48. Of course to end a state of war and sign a treaty you must recognize that which you have denied for so long. That Kerry cannot see this shows his state of mind ... he'll do anything today to make his proposals work. But Israel is signing a treaty that needs to be valid tomorrow, not a meaningless piece of paper. Do you really believe a Palestinian state will be viable and functional to keep its promises?
60. Sounds exactly like the 'after effect'
K? Nay!   (03.14.14)
of eating too many tins of 'Beanz means Heinz' :)
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article