News
US: No plans to free Jonathan Pollard
Attila Somfalvi
Published: 26.03.14, 12:21
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
73 Talkbacks for this article
31. To: No. 28
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (03.26.14)
What right does the United States have to tell Israel to free mass murderers as a "good will gesture" to the "Palestinians?" What right does the United States have to tell Israel that it should not build in nonsovereign territory reacquired by the State of Israel in the course of fighting a defensive war? What right does the United States have to tell Israel that a priori recognition by the "Palestinians" that the State of Israel is a Jewish state is "unreasonable?" Here's a news flash: The United States needs Israel far more than Israel needs the United States. Our economy is strong, we are considered the top country in the world in terms of information technology -- there isn't a computer, laptop, notebook or smart phone sold anywhere in the world that does not depend upon technology developed in Israel and patented and owned by an Israeli company or individual. Moreover, did you know that approximately 70% of the chemotherapy protocols in use throughout the world today were developed in Israel? On a more practical note -- if Israel were to stop sharing its intelligence with the United States, you wouldn't have any intelligence at all. The United States' foreign intelligence is worthless. So, on balance, I think you need to shut up. You don't know jacksh*t about anything.
32. This says it all
Sidney ,   USA   (03.26.14)
Wall Street Journal July 4, 2012  “I recommended against clemency for Jonathan Pollard early in the first Clinton administration when I was director of Central Intelligence “There is absolutely no reason for Pollard to be imprisoned for as long as Ames and Hanssen, and substantially longer than spies from other friendly, allied, and neutral countries. For those hung up for some reason on the fact that he's an American Jew, pretend he's a Greek- or Korean- or Filipino-American and free him. R. James Woolsey” James Woolsey, a Presbyterian, says what Jewish leaders fear to say.
33. @ 9 Birdi
sheik rattle & roll ,   USA   (03.26.14)
Why do u say I hate? Pollard is an American citizen that was caught betraying his country. What right does the State of Israel have to demand his release. He is an American and like I said before, the USA doesn't recognize his post conviction citizenship. If he was an Israeli citizen I would be on his side, however he is an American that betrayed his country and it doesn't matter if it was from a "friend". Please leave our American prisoner alone and let him complete his life long sentence in peace. Also if Israel would of quietly asked for his release maybe it would of happened, but to make him a hero is disgusting at best and is equivalent to the USA demanding that Israel releases VANUNU from house arrest and release him to the US. Sounds absurd doesn't it?
34. Just a reminder
Sarah B ,   Tel Aviv/London   (03.26.14)
The reason Jonathan Pollard has not been released is the inability or the point blank refusal of Israeli politicians naming Pollard's handlers. If our politicians named Pollard's handlers he would be free to return to Israel
35. Unlike Israel
(03.26.14)
Jews are not above the law or is there a separate justice system for Jews.
36. wow, lots of hate here
courtney ,   usa   (03.26.14)
were partners, not enemies. some of you are downright insane with your remarks. in my late 20's i strongly considered aliyah, i am VERY glad i did not considering the current state of affairs
37. Barack Obama sat in a racist church for twenty years...
Steve Klein   (03.26.14)
Obama's spiritual mentor is Rev. Jeremiah Wright. Obama listened to anti-Semitic, racist, anti-American sermons for many years. Only when Wright became a political liability did Obama dissociate himself from his long-time friend and pastor. A true friend of the Jews does not run with anti-Semites.
38. Obama only releases Islamic terrorists
CJK   (03.26.14)
obama also blackmailed netanyahu into releasing hundreds of convicted mass murdering muslim terrorists. obama also wants al-sisi to release murderous muslim brotherhood members.
39. To: Arne at No. 27
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (03.26.14)
Were I to hazard a guess, I would say that the poster at No. 18 made his prediction in 1947. He was wrong. But he is not alone in that.
40. 10, 20, 23, not mine.
Steve Benassi ,   Silver Bay, MN USA   (03.26.14)
My fan club is growing.
41. Cheers !!! I can drink to that ;) ,...
split ,   US   (03.26.14)
42. Pollard's release?!
yosef, phd ,   florida - israel   (03.26.14)
...A pitiful, tasteless, last-ditch effort to force Israel to "exchange" Pollard for convicted murderers !!! The white house is really scraping the bottom of its miserable barrel ! No wonder Obama is becoming the laughing stock of many political leaders: Putin, the Ayatollahs, Netanyahu (through his defense minister), Saudi king, Merkel, Lech Walesa - to name a few.
43. Keep noses out
jalili ,   nyc, ny   (03.26.14)
How about we give Pollard back to Israel, but at the same time cut off all aid to Israel, eliminate the free trade agreement with Israel, and abstain on all future UN votes concerning israel. How's that for a deal?
44. 31.
Birdi ,   Israel is ours.   (03.26.14)
Sarah B. to the rescue! Thank you from 1 Israeli Jewess to another, for your excellent post. Never stop, Sarah B. you have my respect. Kudos to you.
45. # 43
Eaglebeak ,   Left Coast, USA   (03.26.14)
In some ways that would be doing Israel a favor. Actually the U.S. should abstain from the U.N. period. They are a waste of money and time.
46. America the impotent
(03.26.14)
First of all the United States should not be mediating any negotiations regarding any sort of peace deal between the Palestinians and Israelis. Secondly the Israeli government should in this case arrest, try and imprison all CIA operatives within the nation, which btw Mossad knows about. Third id like to say this, if the Palestinians receive a nation and east Jerusalem I will guarantee you that no filthy idol worshipping pagan in the US will be safe or ever know the meaning of the word peace...
47. Let him rot...or
Sally ,   UK   (03.26.14)
..send him to Israel in a casket.
48. Bombama is delivering right now another long, boring speech
Steve Benassi ,   Silver Bay, MN USA   (03.26.14)
49. Courtney # 36
Eaglebeak ,   Left Coast, USA   (03.26.14)
And you think the state of affairs here is good? The U.S. does not treat Israel like partners. In our arrogance we dictate to them and interfere in their affairs. Israel is not our lap dog but that is how we treat her. We would not tolerate Israel if they treated us in kind.
50. Harold # 17
Eaglebeak ,   Left Coast, USA   (03.26.14)
Speaking of which, why don't you take your own advice? This is NOT an American web site. Birdi adds to this thread and I can't say the same for you Harold.
51. # 30
Eaglebeak ,   Left Coast, USA   (03.26.14)
You won't live to see Israel go up in smoke because it won't happen. Anyone that goes against Israel will rue the day. Israel will outlast everyone. The God of Israel will see to it.
52. #40--steve
arne ,   chicago usa   (03.26.14)
how am I to know Who's on first and What's on second--this is driving me crazy?must be driving you nuts too!
53. Shot down in flames that squeeze play
Cameron ,   USA   (03.26.14)
On his running wheel he stays. Attempt another maneuver.
54. 34.
Birdi ,   Israel   (03.26.14)
For a simple little housewife from London you sure do know alot of state secrets.... & intelligence. You dont fool me!
55. #43 Now That's A Good Deal
World Citizen ,   the world   (03.26.14)
Give back one Israeli backstabber and rid the USA of a whole nation of bloodsucking backstabbers. I bet the USA would even throw in Sarah with Pollard to pull in a sweet deal like that.
56. #53 Small price to pay to make monkeys out of Kerry & Obama
TaylorT ,   TrailerTrash   (03.26.14)
And their idiotic framework agreement
57. To: No. 34
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (03.26.14)
Because to do so would jeopardize Israeli assets in any number of countries, and the American intelligence and counter-intelligence agencies are mole-ridden enough to do MI6 proud. By the way, Jonathan Pollard has made it abundantly clear that his freedom must NOT be sought at the expense of Israeli intelligence assets. Unlike you, he has principles. All YOU can think of are swimming pools. What do you think that says about you, chica?
58. To: No. 41
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (03.26.14)
You're a Polack. You can drink to anything.
59. # 34
Eaglebeak ,   Left Coast, USA   (03.26.14)
Who is your handler?
60. #52, Means my message is working, Israel bad guy, invading
Arne Redman ,   Chicago, IL   (03.26.14)
...Arab world, stealing land, killing natives, bombing neighbors, committing suicide by hubris, again.
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article