News
Report: Kerry suggests defining Israel as 'national homeland for Jews'
Roi Kais
Published: 29.03.14, 11:00
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
87 Talkbacks for this article
31. # 8 Concise and to the point. Thank you.
Advah Harel ,   Kibbutz Dalia   (03.29.14)
32. Kerry ought to know: Israel has been recognized by the
Tomer Giladi ,   Haifa, Israel   (03.29.14)
international community not only as the homeland for Jews, but as the homeland of Jews; indeed, as the sovereign nation-state of the Jewish people. This was understood by the San Remo conference, 1920; the League of Nations, 1922; the United Nations, 1945; and again by the United Nations in 1947. Attempting to appease the Arabs who act as a Mafia - give me what I demand or else... - is simply despicable and ought not be even considered by any person of reason and good will.
33. "Redefined Kerry"
BUILD BABY BUILD!!!!   (03.29.14)
once was a Cohen now is a Catholic.. Enough with 'redefinition' Israel is defined, it was -and it is- and shall remain the only Jewish nation in the world.. BUILDING ISRAEL !!
34. Clueless Kerry
Stuart Wilder ,   Doylestown, USA   (03.29.14)
Seriously? Doesn't he understand that they are throwing this "Jewish state: thing up just to gun up the works? Forget what the PA is doing on its own to mess things up for a moment. Israel survives for more than 60 years without having to bring this thing up, and all of a sudden it comes up now just so they can put on the table a meal too big for their opponents to swallow. Kerry acts like he is trying to comfort two year olds. He should man up, tell Netnayahu take it or leave a lot of the aid behind, because right now, with everything else going on in Eastern Europe, North Africa, and Asia, he's got better things to do.
35. Fool
Sam SM ,   UK   (03.29.14)
So lets just change a word here and there! And then the Arabs will stop baying like crazed hounds for Israel's demise! Yeah that will work! Cough! Snigger! What an idiot!
36. Building 3rd temple
(03.29.14)
Get busy and build 3rd temple and there is no question of recognition from anyone.
37. Build the temple
(03.29.14)
Build the temple at least to way off interest in east Jerusalem.
38. #3 chris
solomon ,   bklyn   (03.29.14)
What does your post have to do with the article? Whether Israel is representative of Jews or not doesn’t matter. It is representative of Israelis and they are the ones who decide. Are the PA and Hamas representative of the “Pals”? They demonstrate that they don’t want any compromise whatsoever. Translation: they do not want any peace whatsoever.
39. Israel is like your kid on drugs....
TaylorT ,   Earth   (03.29.14)
...sure you want to help him. Of course you know he's going to blame you and do everything possible to maintain his unhealthy lifestyle. But after awhile you have to give up--knowing it will lead to his death. Especially when he keeps stealing from you to support his life-destructive habits and ruining your life (the 9/11 ringleader, KSM, was directly motivated by America's support of Israel.) So it's probably best Israel is allowed to self-destruct. Any people who go to such lengths to attack their only ally on the planet really don't deserve to pass on their genes. Just like the junkie...
40. well, it's the case of two teenagers stating
Erin ,   USA   (03.29.14)
"I don't want wannu", isn't it, again, and Isay let them be Mr. President, this will all work out in due time, let them pass, they'll come back to it when they're ready. Teenagers have a voice, too, they have a voice, too. Thank you. Sincerely yours, Erin Dyann Priest-Rhodes, and I hope you mean that-Jewish homeland I mean. Thank you, and have a nice day. Erin, aufedersein, forever, and ever, Amen.
41. Drugs?
Max ,   Washington DC   (03.29.14)
Guess you are on QAT like the rest of your Brotherhood, Taylor. 9/11 had nothing to do with Israel. The Islamic Murderers code is to kill infidels in the US, Israel, England and all Countries that oppose their fanatical beliefs!
42. What a pity
Michael ,   Haifa   (03.29.14)
I rather like the name of my country being Israel. A much more sensible name than "The National Homeland of the Jews". If somebody asks me from where I am and I have to answer from the "National Homeland of the Jews", I would fill a little silly about it. Filling out forms would be very inconvenient. A football match between Spain and the National Homeland of the Jews. Maybe we should stop being stupid and demand that we be recognized as Israel.
43. Pull the plug on the sick evil charade NOW!
Chaim ,   Israel   (03.29.14)
Polls show Kerry's self aggrandizing "peace talks" fool very few Israelis. Most don't trust Kerry and know the talks are a dangerous sham aimed at destroying Israel. Let us pull the plug on the sick evil charade NOW!
44. Taylor T #39
Eaglebeak ,   Left Coast, USA   (03.29.14)
With allies like you who needs enemies?
45. # 32 how true!!!!!!!!!!
Amir Geva ,   Beer Sheva, Israel   (03.29.14)
46. If you want an answer Kerry,
AD ,   Toronto, Canada   (03.29.14)
Ask the palis if they would agree that their state not be referred to as the Palestinian State but only recognized as the "National homeland of the Palestinians". Then you'll know why it's important that Israel be recognized as a Jewish State.
47. Absurd gymnastics for "peace"
(03.29.14)
How long will the charade continue. the arabs want land, not peace. after getting some land they will look for more. they are an intolerant set of people who can live with no one in peace. The will always be at war with the Jews, a standing army will always have to be maintained. Better to maintain an army to keep them out than keep fighting them inside. transfer makes sense.
48. "And the heavens and the earth tremble...
Steve   (03.29.14)
But the LORD is a refuge for His people And a stronghold to the sons of Israel.
49. You Jews......
Susan ,   USA   (03.29.14)
....behave OR ELSE. Well well, for those who are Jews familiar with a history of being *chased, persecuted, slaughtered, accused and threatened longer than any living religion, group of people and or ethnicity we should understand. Excuse me for laughing but this newest suggested stinks. Ok, Israel is not a Jewish state but a 'homeland for Jewish people?" Mr. Kerry and the rest of the world: I ask, what is wrong with telling the truth and hurting the tender sensibilities of others for a change? Oh yes, just a simple change of wording is all it takes........and...presto, chango, all will be well. We will live in peace and the obsession will end. Anyway, "You People" control the world so you people better accept this, or else. After all, according to the last heaven knows how many US Presidents, 'Peace will come to the ME when the Palestinians have their home land.' News Flash: We have pretend friends and that's about it. Oh yes, "my best friend is Jewish." Oh yes, "We will never abandon the state of Israel"...and on and on. Even our supposed best friend warned Israel "Palestine must be contiguous and not resemble swiss cheese." We should get smart and realize we are all we have, put our foot down and reverse the BS we have been fed since time immemorial. *chased, persecuted, slaughtered and threatened longer than any living religion, group of people and or ethnicity: Except to a certain level the Kurds who no one gives a damn about except of course if they were neighbors of Israel all of a sudden they would be the victims in need of a homeland. Hope you students of history get my point. Again, it is all about the 'obsession' first and foremost....mixed with hocus pocus.... mixed with lots of soap detergent for whitewashing...topped with a generous helping of BS. (of course as Jews we are not stupid, however for this charade to have continued ad nauseum, perhaps we are!?) Please excuse the length of this post however how could I make my point in 50 words or less?
50. 4 Sarah B.: The Holy Lands deeded to Abraham, Isaac and Jac
Rivkah   (03.29.14)
Jacob were to all the descendants of Jacob, not just the descendants of Judah (Jews). There are 13 tribes of Israel and all are inheritors of the land Elohim gave to Abraham and his descendants through Isaac and Jacob. The Jews which include the tribes of Levi and Benjamin as the ancient Judea are a chosen people for preserving the Torah and Tanahk and the seventh day Sabbath. But Joseph and his two sons as well as Judah and Benjamin were not disinherited by Jacob. Levi came back into the inheritance at the time of Moses since Moses was from the Tribe of Levi. 13 Tribes were in the wilderness and entered the Promised Land. It is possible that only Joseph (Manasseh and Ephaim), Judah, Benjamin and Levi have a right to the land if all the others were disinherited and not restored. But all 13 tribes entered the Promised Land long ago which indicates a possible restoration of all the tribes at that time. But Jerusalem does not belong to the Jews only. The outer court is the Gentiles' in Scriptures in the time of the end of the era. In the Millenium King David will again be Malek of Israel and at that time Jerusalem will be Jewish and owned by a Jewish King and a Jewish Messiah Yahoshua.
51. Refugees homeland
Zizi   (03.29.14)
Kerry needs to understand that the land Israel Was built on is the homeland of the palestinians. That is why they are REFUGEES. CAN anyone of you say why the REFUGEES ARE REFUGEES.
52. History shows...greed, hubris are the Jewish drugs of choice
Steve Benassi ,   Silver Bay, MN USA   (03.29.14)
...and like an alcoholic, or drug addict, Israel will "hit bottom" (Holocausts, Exoduses) again, and again, until they give up their self-chosen "dwell alone" drugs, and join the rest of us mere mortals. 1,39, not mine. 1,39, not mine.
53. Mr. Kerry, you are pushing us, Israelis, to implenet Plan B,
N.L.Katz ,   Qatzrin, Israel   (03.29.14)
which I suspect you'll not like, but we would have no choice if you don't know how to distinguish between friends and foes, and can't situate yourself on the right side of history of demanding of the Arabs to accept Israel's RIGHT to be, to exist as the sovereign nation-state of the Jewish people.
54. Our identity, Mr. Kerry, and that of our national home is
Jehudah Ben-Israel ,   Israel   (03.29.14)
not for sale, and certainly not by you, a man who, opportunistically and deceivingly has attempted to bring down our nation-state of Israel to its knees so that you would please your allies in Ramallah and Damascus. ...
55. Oh yeah Sarah B Israel is the Jewish state?
Non Jewish immigrant ,   Haifa   (03.29.14)
Now is it? Then why it's not officially defined as such? Why is that Jerusalem is not recognised by any courtesy around the world as the capital of Israel? Why the laws of the Torah ARENT Israel's official laws?
56. Ketchup Kerry - a genius in his own mind
Jhan   (03.29.14)
And in Obathhouse's mind
57. To: No. 39
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (03.29.14)
I'm sorry you had a son who was a junkie. But the sovereign State of Israel is not a drug addict, not your son and it is very definitely not your place to assume that you know what is best for the State of Israel. If you knew anything at all, perhaps your son would not have turned to drugs. The foregoing notwithstanding, I wouldn't count out the State of Israel just yet. But you should keep in mind that if we go ... so does everyone else. Capisce, sluggo? It is called Matarat Shimshon. We will pull down the temple walls. Count on it.
58. #52 Not mine
Steve Benassi ,   Silver Bay, MN USA   (03.29.14)
59. United states and Israel
Sjoerd van der Velde ,   Hoorn, Holland   (03.29.14)
Israel is the land between the river and the sea, with Jerusalem as eternal, undivided capital, period. Israel forever and always!
60. Simpy an idiot
gregg bowman ,   Parksville, Canada   (03.29.14)
Quite frankly Kerry, you idiot!! How about this?! The Country of Israel and maybe we should change your status to the land of Americans and scrap the United States aspect of your country or maybe call the US the regional district of Americans. That would work. Your lack of intelligence is unsettling!! Very unsettling....warm regards, Gregg Bowman from the Country of Canada. A true friend of the Country of Israel.
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article