News
Edelstein: Palestinian move is 'outrageous violation of basic agreement'
Ynetnews
Published: 03.04.14, 01:14
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
13 Talkbacks for this article
1. Jews blame PA's unwillingness to be cheated, again and again
Steve Benassi ,   Silver Bay, MN USA   (04.03.14)
2. Choices..useless Nobel Peace Prize, or repatriation to Mecca
Steve Benassi ,   Silver Bay, MN USA   (04.03.14)
3. elkin slams livni
zioness ,   USA   (04.03.14)
Good for him- where are the other brave souls- does he stand alone?
4. Learn a lesson, never trust your enemy
zioness ,   Universal studio, LA   (04.03.14)
if we had a lick of dignity we would tell Obama and Abbas to get lost, built rout all of Judea and Samaria and meet these weasels head to head, now. We still have the borders, unless Bibi cracks. the man is seriously stressed, and this is where the true leadership needs to come into play- Liberman, Bennett and Feiglin need to come to his side and give him their support to pull out of these talks, and take our own course, which is to build the great nation Israel. Who is going to stop us, if we are resolved to have a great future for our children.
5. The lesson
Taxpayer ,   Hod Hasharon   (04.03.14)
The Palestinians do not have a state because they have always demanded all or nothing and got nothing. How tragic for us that our country is going to go downhill because Netanyahu is not willing to stand up to the fanatics in his government who demand all are willing to give nothing and who are smiling today because they have done their share to collapse the peace talks that the country needs. Why does Netanyahu do such a great impression of a lemming as HaBayit Ha Yehudi rush the country over the cliiff? Do we realy have to sacrifice our country on the fale altarr of the graven image of Eretz Israeli haShelma Ve Ha'Reka M'aracim?
6. ah dont it feel good to be a friar !!! shame on bibi blood
naftulee ,   jerusalem   (04.03.14)
Bibi now has blood on his hands again. released murderers , people who killed kids and innocents, released them for NOTHING. Those poor families of the murdered, watching them go free knowing nothing would come from this !!!SHAME ON YOU BIBI, HOW CAN YOU SLEEP AT NIGHT ??? We have been tellling you all along Abbas was just faking us out to get his terrorists out of jail for free. And we are FRIARs again !!!
7. Paradox
Michael ,   Haifa   (04.03.14)
The Palestinians have nothing to lose, which is why they have a good chance to win. The only thing they have to do is to rely on the stupidity of the present Israeli government, which, currently having everything, has much to lose.
8. Great Time to face UN Hipocrocy
maddad ,   JHB   (04.03.14)
It's the perfect time for Israel to face UN hipocrocy in things like the ICC. With it's neighbours barrel-bombing their own citizens, others planning mass executions, Crimea and Putin, the environment has never been better for Israel to face the ICC and the like. Let the PA drop their inevitable ICC nuke - now - rather than later. IMO
9. agreement????
(04.03.14)
When an agreement is unenforceable and there is no penalty for violating it, it has no meaning. The PLO has publically and continuously stated since 1964: we will destroy Israel and eliminate the Jews. Now Edelstein is whining about the naughty PLO violating an agreement because they did exactly what they promised? I never thought Edelstein was a sucker.
10. give them civil status and you give them israel on a plate
zionist forever   (04.03.14)
The ones who say lets give the palestinians civil status same as the arabs on E.jerusalem or FORMERLY annex Judea & Samaria are proposing the creation of a binational state to replace the Jewish state concept. We live in a real world not a idealistic one if we do any of those things than we will be obligated to give them full citizenship and that means the demographics will put arabs on around the same sort of number as Jews overnight. This is what both Hamas & the PLO see as their favoured solution. Arabs have more children than the average secular Jew and the law of return is one of the first things that would have to go in a binational state so give it 10 years and arabs will be the majority. Binational means chafing everything from the national symbols to probably the name of the country itself. The idealists are falling into an arab trap. We cannot just give Abbas everything he wants he has become a hardliner since he got his UN upgrade but we must not annex all Judea & Samaria or give the arabs civil status or any other status or we can kiss goodbye to Israel.
11. Israel didn't break the agreement
michael redboun ,   Lisbon - Portugal   (04.03.14)
Each prisoner release was to enacted if there was progress in the talks, but no progress was made. Israel actually went far beyond it's obligation by carrying out prisoner releases three times in spite of the lack of progress.
12. #7, they have plenty to lose
Danny   (04.03.14)
They have the billions in aid that they can lose, they have the autonomy that they can lose, they have the land that they can lose
13. stop condeming
Gershon ,   London uk   (04.03.14)
Do you honestly think the pals care about any Israel's condemnation - they love it !! I say do something that will stop them in their tracks and think. For every UN agency organization they join start a new settlement!! For every attempt to delegitimize us we build and create more facts on the ground till they are reeling from so many settlements they wont know what to do.
Back to article