News
Israel slams Indyk accusations on peace talks
Reuters
Published: 09.05.14, 20:50
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
36 Talkbacks for this article
1. CLUELESS???
JHL ,   USA   (05.09.14)
IS this individual supposed to "BE IN THE KNOW" or something like that. Has this Idiot even visited Yehuda and Shomron. Another clueless American idiot. Just like HERMAN MUNSTER who just left !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
2. take it off the table
Dan ,   DC   (05.09.14)
annex the settlement blocks israel "intends to keep" in a final deal. take them off the table.
3. INDYK IS A NIT
tTEL EM STRAIGHT ,   SAFED OBVIOUS   (05.09.14)
We DO NOT need his input nor his opinion thank you very much.
4. I take offense to that last comment, "In
Erin ,   USA   (05.09.14)
the Middle East, it's never over." Who are you? Who are you...........? Are you telling me that you are a spokesperson over the entire Middle East, a people who suffer without water daily, and you wish to save "face" in front of a thinktank? (I thought everyone agreed to "pause" for awhile.) It's being handled by someone else, and I pray He is more judicious than you. Stop harming Israel, my people, whom I love. Stop harming them.
5. A part of the whole thereof,....
Gideon Reader   (05.09.14)
...on behalf of the Obama Administration to apply diplomatic pressure on Israel as the guilty party for not agreeing to national suicide in order to benefit and aide the US in relieving the scrutiny for it's min, mal and non feaseance in the decline of the nation. Ignore the futile and febrile attempts to squeeze Israel for the political gain of others. Indyk. Rice. Kerry and the minions of the left the J-street walkers, who have let a penchant for getting down on their knees become an art form.
6. Umm, isn't Martin Indyk Jewish, and isn't
Erin ,   USA   (05.09.14)
John Kerry also Jewish? If so, that would be the 3rd, maybe even the fifth, Jewish spokesperson President Obama pitted against Israel to get acroos his agenda, if that is true.....then Obama used Jesus' own words to back the Jews into a corner, but through false prophecy since this isn't the era of 'brother against brother' anymore, it's the generation of reconciliation, to one another, and to Father in heaven. So, what's President Obama doing? acting contrary to Yahweh's Word? Why is he going out on a limb and doing this? What is so worth the risk?
7. liberalist appeaser!!!!!!!!
(05.09.14)
Nothing new,,, This liberalist idi-t has always thought himself as someone "IN THE KNOW". Just another poser and liberalist appeaser!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
8. I bully 6M Jews to pretend defending 350M weak Arabs
Steve Benassi ,   Silver Bay, MN USA   (05.09.14)
9. Distrust anyone who obeys, works and lies for the WH Muslim.
Steve Benassi ,   Silver Bay, MN USA   (05.09.14)
10. Martin Indyk
Harold ,   USA   (05.09.14)
Indyk is right. When Israel keeps occupying and building on Palestinian's lands means NO LANDS LEFT FOR A PALESTINIAN STATE. Why Netanyahu is not presenting a blue print of Israeli/Palestinian borders.
11. Govt. Slams Indyk
J Sagett ,   Bonita Springs   (05.09.14)
Does the Israeli government really think we're all too dumb to get in out of the rain? Anyone who thinks the settlements was not the primary cause of the collapse of the negotiations has an IQ in single digits. And before everyone gets all excited, I do support Israel, and I am Jewish, and NOT anti-Semitic. I do not, however, support the continuing occupation and subjugation of the Palestinians.
12. irksome, meddlesome elitists
CJK   (05.09.14)
people like indyk think that they can put on the same plane a sovereign state with a group of people who are rootless, who were never sovereign, who are engaging in terror. indyk and his superiors think that pm netanyahu, hugely accomplished as a military man, prime minister twice, can be compared to some men whose only accomplishments are terrorising civilians, denying the holocaust, setting for goal the genocide of the jews of israel. the underlying assumptions of indyk and his ilk are an insult to morality, logic and historical precedent. never before had the united states leadership treated an ally, a democracy, with so much contempt. never before had a us president assumed that he could dictate to the sovereign jewish state of israel how to define her own national security interests. never before had a us president ordered a sovereign nation to release convicted mass murdering terrorists and then expect that nation to thank him.
13. 11
y Allon ,   adelaide/Israel   (05.10.14)
For a Jew you have no understanding of the situation in Israel.Please educate your self before posting.It is the Arabs who have Jordanian passports that are occupying Israel's land.There is no Palestine.
14. And you are asking me why I am getting mad?
Joe Asfour ,   Burke, Va   (05.10.14)
Just reading the comments of readers expressed here I am left aghast. Either the people are a bunch of ignoramus, or are deliberately playing the idiot or are simply agents provocateurs who jobs is to stir hatred left and right.Otherwise how to explain these extremist, rejectionist views as if Israel is the world and Israel determines the fate of the world.Fortunately for Israel these people who are spewing hatred against anybody who does not agree with their extremist views represent but a minority. I wonder whether this people are paid to display the arrogance portrayed here.
15. Strange, posts in response to this....
Robert ,   Australia   (05.10.14)
....type of news item are usually riddled with anti semitism rants.
16. 10
y Allon ,   adelaide/Israel   (05.10.14)
There is no Palestinian land you fool.The whole point of the negotiations is that maybe Israel will grant part of Israel(where the squatters led by Abbas live) to the ersatz Palestinians who hold Jordanian passports some land that they will call Palestine But seeing that Abbas" mob have joined Hamas thugs then we shall see what develops.Go post your stupidity elsewhere Harold the Arab.
17. So now is Indik fault? you had 50 indikless years.
israeli chutspa ,   has no limits!   (05.10.14)
18. ""What was true then is also possibly true today,"
Mira ,   Vienna   (05.10.14)
Indyk said. Well, guy, and the sun is still revolving around the earth because this was believed once? Obama uses all of his representitives to do harm to Israel. He will bang his head though eventually.
19. No. 10 Harold
Madeleine ,   Israel   (05.10.14)
Read the FB posts above and learn about the still valid - never been superceded - San Remo Agreement. Learn that Jordan was indeed created - out of all of Eastern Palestine, no less - as a homeland for the Arabs of Palestine. You have no clue what you are talking about but just repeating the palis fiction.
20. The outcome
Gita ,   Kibbutz, Israel   (05.10.14)
What did the Palestinians get from this peace-process-business? Exactly what they wanted - the prisoners (most of them anyway). What did the Israelis get out of it? Absolutely nothing, as usual, --- if you don't count the blame.
21. peace?
fred ,   USA   (05.10.14)
Thoughn I am convinced that the Palestinians do not want peace, at least peace that is an equitable understanding between the two people, nonetheless, Israel has never stopped building settlements, when asked to halt so that talks might proceed. Never ever stopped. This was not a show of good faith.
22. #11 Complain, object, demand
Benji ,   US   (05.10.14)
That's the Abbas and Erekat mission. When that failed, they united with Hamas to call for Israel's destruction. Settlements had nothing to do with failed peace efforts. Not now or over the past decades. Indyk knows that and it's unfortunate he takes the low road of dishonesty.
23. Indyk: a proud heir to the Judo-Quisling Kissinger!
tom ,   tel aviv   (05.10.14)
24. Indyk failed to harm Israel...!
Chris Rettenmoser ,   Bayerisch Gmain Germ   (05.10.14)
Too bad for him...
25. Indyk is nothing but an agent of the Obama/Kerry team, ...
N.L.Katz ,   Qatzrin, Israel   (05.10.14)
... serving his bosses who have thought to veil their arrogant goals with a "Jewish" front man. The ideas - totally detached from reality, from any moral or legal grounds - that the Obama/Kerry front man was to promote have been: the pushing of the sovereign nation-state of the Jewish people, the State of Israel, to the indefensible 1949 armistice lines (utter by Obama, wrongly, the "1967 borders); the "cleansing" of Samaria, Judea, the Jordan Valley and Gaza of its Jews; and, the setting up of a Muslim-Arab sovereign entity whose leaders have etched in their hearts, minds and charters the demise of the liberal democratic and sovereign nation-state of the Jewish people, the State of Israel and the "cleansing" of the country of its Jews. Sadly, Indyk has been doing the job for which he has been hired, now by demonizing the State of Israel and its freely elected leaders, and by de-legitimizing its government. And, this is the administration that came into the White House on the shoulders of the Jewish community of America...!!
26. Israel slams
Why?   (05.10.14)
Indyk, kerry, obama, livni, pope, Rice, Arabs, muslims, christians, russians, chinese, leftists, .......
27. Long Term Security .
Zechariah   (05.10.14)
Millions of Islamic Jihadi in Judae and Samaria is Crazy .And the Jordan valley Area Needs a strong IDF contingent highly Trained and Committed for Eternity .
28. So, let me get this straight . . .
Dean Concannon ,   Sydney, Australia   (05.10.14)
So, once again, everyone is at fault other than Israel. And this despite the fact that Indyk is a long-time supporter of Israel, even in the face of the most egregious transgressions by the country's political class. Get over it and get on with it, as my Mum used to say. It's unlikely in the extreme that the rest of the world is in error and Israel has it right.
29. # 25 Really excellent post. Thanks.
Yael Gefen ,   US/Israel   (05.10.14)
30. #16
Harold ,   USA   (05.10.14)
Fools like you don't check the world's maps and don't read the history of the world where the word Palestine is mentioned millions of times. The word Israel is mentioned since 1948. Are you trying to change the history of the world you dummy. I am not an Arab but your Jewish ancestors lived in Arab countries for thousands of years and were educated there and learned civilization but people like you deny all that because Zionism changed you.
Next talkbacks
Back to article