News
'I've been kidnapped': Police release recording of Gil-Ad Shaer's emergency call
Omri Efraim
Published: 01.07.14, 23:25
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
15 Talkbacks for this article
1. English Ynet in his typical fashion
(07.01.14)
cuts the audio short right before the gunfire is heard. just playing to the haters hands, they are.
2. to the dying fool
(07.01.14)
on the radio was Israel Radio Reshet Bet at 1025 on 12 June 2014 it was the radio program moreshet. look it up on line.
3. In the name of Palestinians
Sammy ,   Newcastle   (07.01.14)
In the West Bank and the Diaspora who abhor this despicable crime Please accept our deepest condolences
4. enough with israeli pacifism
geroge   (07.01.14)
israel cannot afford its usual group of weaklilng ministers leading the country. its time for feiglin to lead the country. His election will put the arabs on notice that the death warrant has been signed and willbe coming to them. Those that remain will have to leave voluntarily or else. it is time for feiglin.
5. If not fired, demoted to janitors.
David ,   Hartford USA   (07.01.14)
They deserve nothing more. We certainly cannot trust them to protect us in any manner. Nothing may have been able to save the boys, but the actions of these 'policemen' were so below expected performance that they must be relieved of all police duties- for good.
6. How about fines and even imprisonment?
Jack ,   San Diego, USA   (07.01.14)
7. to #3 sad Palestinian
Bluegrass Picker ,   Afula   (07.02.14)
ethnic-Palestinians are welcome to join and assimilate into our indigenous Hebrew homeland, If you conduct your lives herethe same way as the ethnic-Russian-notzrim do (ie, serving loyally in the Army, etc), you will receive the same treatment they do - we don't really admire them, but also we don't really bother them.
8. This could have been avoided had the parents
Memphis Slim ,   Memphis, TN - USA   (07.02.14)
not allowed their sons to hitch hike at night in an area that was well known to have Hamas terrorists driving up the same road as the kids were on. The security establishment wanted to build a barrier between the Jewish and Palestinian communities but the settlers leaned heavily on the politicians NOT to build the wall as they were afraid that it would become a permanent border and would end their dreams of a "greater Israel" encompassing the entire West Bank. I am pro-settler up to a point. That point is when their fanatisism endangers everyone else in Israel. As for the kidnappers and their supporters? Demolish their homes and even impreison them. Make life miserable for them,but don't mess with those Pals who do not support this type of behavior.
9. In other words the police knew they were already dead RIGHT
M.S. ,   mpls america   (07.02.14)
This latest version of the emergency abduction kidnapping distress call to the special police hot line number gives a far more advanced version the initial preliminary partial version was simply HELP WE HAVE BEEN KIDNAPPED but this new version tells us the police HEARD gun shots a lot of horrible dieing death sounds so on quite a difference in details RIGHT ??? thus the police June 12 2014 already knew THEY HEARD THE FATAL GUN SHOTS CRYS OF AGONY AS THEY DIED this tells us that the Israeli leaders the IDF the Israel Defense Forces the Israeli cabinet GENERALS knew K N E W KNEW they were already dead but SEARCHED for them as if they were possibly alive being held some place may be in a under ground storm shelter a secret basement storage room whatever thus to blame just the police here is ALL WRONG we were told the army special forces elite troops the trusted Arab Scouts used for hunting down terrorists in the IDF all thought they were looking hopefully for live prisioniers being held against their own will I KNEW IT ALL SOUNDED TOO FISHY TOO STRANGE TOO QUEER I SENSED SOME THING WAS WRONG... JUST NO MADE SENSE... no sounded like a real kidnapping abduction then June 30 2014 BING BANG they find bodys SURE THEY FOUND BODYS because they knew there were only dead bodys to be found no living boys tied up so on blind folds may be over their eyes begging to go to the toilet so on we all were lied to from Day One 1 FROM THE GET GO thus more than just the police were lieing covering up from 12 to 30 18 days searches when they knew they were DEAD D E A D letting the PARENTS FAMILYS HOPE FRIENDS HOPE all Jews Israelis HOPING for a miracle rescue LIKE ENTEBBE in AFRICA they knew WHY NO RANSOM DEMANDS WERE MADE SO ON lies the truth hidden by Netanyahu all the ministers cabinet GENERALS so on thus a COVER UP SCANDEL of the entire government no not just 3 4 DUMB POLICE OFFICERS POLICE COMMANDERS who RECIEVED THE SUDDEN MESSAGE thought it was a HOAX PRANK they ALL KNEW ALL GUN SHOTS WERE HEARD DEATH CRYS HEARD now I know how they knew where to LOOK in fields arround Hebron exactly where to LOOK the arrests of the possible Arabs who the world was told MIGHT HAVE DONE IT all pre fabricated lies they knew they were DEAD DIED June 12 no not Ten 10 days later Two 2 weeks later any way I would no not blame JUST the police who received the call I think it went HIGHER I am sorry I regret it went ALL THE WAY TO THE TOP T O P ministers even the president GENERALS who led the USELESS SEARCH the world is SHOCKED AS I AM to hear WHEN THE CALL WAS MADE June 12 GUN SHOTS WERE HEARD DIEING AGONY MOANS WERE HEARD THEN SILENCE... but they have been buryed died as martyers heroes of Israel I hope in their own honor and so memory Hamas the Arabs will pay dearly no not just because Three 3 died NO but because of the COLD BLOODED WAY IT HAPPENED WAS DONE... I got to wonder... if they had no not made that call... would the kidnappers.. have held them kept them alive used for a RANSOM MONEY EXCHANGE OF PRISIONERS like the Israeli soldier deal with Hamas in Gaza 1 2 years ago ??? and so... would they still be alive... if... they had no not tryed to call the police... no way to answer that question... but the POLICE KNEW June 12 THEY WERE DEAD thus more than just a SIMPLE DELAY IN THE CHAIN OF COMMAND... MUCH MORE... A COVER UP... who will pay... but then we are human... things played out time wise since June 12 July 1 2014 July 2 2014... the world is asking... DID ISRAEL PLAN ALL THIS... to use as a excuse... to crack down on Hamas... the unity deal... so on... serious repercussions this goes a lot higher than just 3 4 dumb GREEN INEXPERIENCED police officers in a call in center... a lot higher... I hope we can still salvage our own dignity honor this no destroys us Jews Israelis.... and so... I hope it is no not too late... RIGHT ??? Thank You... M.S.
10. # 6 fines prision will not bring the boys back to life RIGHT
M.S. ,   mpls america   (07.02.14)
I realize # 6 you echo repeat the shallow minded sentiment that the police simply bungled the whole affair but let us look at the HARD CORE FACTS evidence they receive a frantic call from a cell phone we have been kidnapped then hear gun shots sounds of people dieing then nothing silence what can they do report it to the military there probably never was such a conceived training preparation scenario they acted confused were confused it was never followed up on but seriously how do you follow up such a cell phone call they probably thought they were acting accordingly let things develop if the gun shots they heard were real so on sooner or later it would have to escalate as it did things escalated by logical developments as parents contacted the police then higher levels so on thus the boys are dead they hear gun shots sure may be they should have taken steps to contact higher levels but who where when sounds pretty strange police probably are not trained to deal with this mind of scenario events while may be there was a degree of negligence lack of action taken they waited for things to escalate develop did no not rush in to action possibly being reprimanded for overly zealous reaction this is all just how it could look and so fines prision court martials suspensions firings what crime did they committ they waited for escalation to happen contact the military what would the military do no they did the RIGHT thing based up on Israeli honor they waited for escalation parents contacted them then higher levels were contacted the news was released to the world the general public while a degree of doubt exists as to how to handle it many regard this as the only plausible POSSIBLE steps to take allow escalation the word ISRAEL A E ALLOW ESCALATION CATCH ON they moved according to the police version of ISRAEL what more can we ask ??? to find the source of the cell phone meaning of the message we know the facts they hitch hiked were picked up then they realized no not regular people terrorists they were being abducted should they have just said where are you taking us what will you do with us tryed to reason with the abductors they did a foolish thing contacting the police with a cell phone they caused the abductors to have to change their plans no safe house hostage house they had to kill them thus the gun shots ended their lives only minutes after being picked up for free rides in a dangerous area of the West Bank thus we see they were dead within minutes less than half a hour after it all started tragic TRAGIC but nothing the police military could do but find the bodys as they did the change it has made in the West Bank Gaza world media so on has altered life forever the poor boys died because One 1 of them did a foolish thing faced with the thought he was being abducted in the West Bank he over looked reasoning with the Arabs we assume Arabs any way not Europeans but just Arabs and so the boys have been buryed but that no ends it RIGHT # 6 but police action faulty thus severe fines prision firings... WILL NO NOT BRING THE BOYS OUR BOYS BACK TO LIFE... I think that given all possibilitys this has was has been handled rather well by all Jews Israelis concerned... INCLUDING THE POLICE... what the future will be like who knows but for the boys it is all over for the rest of us Jews Israelis including the police who recieved this cell phone call it is only beginning... reminds me of the bible... it starts with... IN THE BEGINNING... I know some ways of police plausible logic variations proceedings escalation thus I see where IN THE BEGINNING relates to all this any way I hope a future STILL exists... for us Jews Israelis to find a way to deal with this... and so before it is too late... RIGHT ??? Thank You... M.S.
11. Dangerous
Dave ,   USA   (07.02.14)
Even though there may have been no hope in saving those boys, the actions of the police officers put the lives of many soldiers in danger. Not to mention many palestinians got hurt.
12. #3, THANK YOU! People like are majority of Palestinians
Z. Lazkow ,   israel   (07.02.14)
13. #4, ALL the SAME: Israel needs Military Dictatorship
Z. Lazkow ,   israel   (07.02.14)
14. So the government, police & IDF KNEW they were dead
Gilad   (07.02.14)
for 2 weeks before they released this audio and told the public
15. Reply to number 9.
Sherlock Holmes ,   London England   (07.02.14)
If the police woman thought it was one of the 155 prank calls that day, why do you assume it was so convincing and everyone knew were dead? How many of the 155 pranksters will be prosecited for wasting police time?
Back to article