News
Three suspects in murder of Arab teen confess to crime
Attila Somfalvi, Omri Efraim, Itay Blumental
Published: 07.07.14, 10:49
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
31 Talkbacks for this article
1. What about the murder of OUR Sons?
Moshe ,   Tel Aviv   (07.07.14)
2. #1 who cares?
(07.07.14)
There is no justice, there is no law. Shelly Dadon or the three boys don't matter: they are Jews. And if the killers were found, Netanyahu would make sure to release them as soon as he could.
3. zero tolerance
bernhard ,   germany-israel   (07.07.14)
Innocence and righteousness received dark stains by nationalist Jews. What a pity and bitter disappointment. In their efforts "to bring back our boys" Shabak, ZAHAl aND POLICE did a good job eventually, if even at the beginning their was misjudgment of the phone call. We should leave the punishment to the approriat bodies of Israel. Now, the two Hamas killers have to be found ASAP and brought to justice. When hooligans, rioters and killers begin to rule the country the end can be disastrous. And zero tolerance for any of them, the blind nationalists and racists. Not helpful, just morons who pour even more oil in the fire.
4. Pathetic little quilt ridden Israel can't deal
Al   (07.07.14)
with an event that is almost a daily event in AMERICA. For those who don't get it and there are many. Israel is facing a life and death situation. The Arabs both in the territories and in the country are all one and the same. They wish to destroy the Sate and to kill the Jews therein. Nationalistic crimes happen all the time, almost on a daily basis. The Arabs wish to harm Jews constantly. Israel has lost its very will to be a nation. They have allowed themselves to be anything but a proud Jewish nation. And so we have 6 million Jews standing at the abyss with nay a government willing to defend itself. Israel is being bombed day in day out while the government does sweet bugger all. Yet should an Arab be killed as Jews are being harmed almost on a daily basis , all hell breaks loose and Jews cry themselves silly.They mope about like they just went through Auschwitz. Its as if the nation is in collective mourning. You just buried three young proud Jews and all is forgotten. Its as if they didn't matter in the least. Stop the self flagellation and get on with being a proud Jewish nation. You will be destroyed should you not start protecting yourself against the enemy both within and without.
5. That judge from the Petach Tikva
A Jerusalemite ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (07.07.14)
Magistrate's Court should be investigated. I wonder if he supports the murder of innocent Arabs in revenge.
6. the Jews are acting like the Arabs ad the Europeans
k ,   US   (07.07.14)
It is the Arabs and the Europeans who will kill for their pleaure and without morals, so here is a case of the Jews taking after the Arabs and the Europeans ahnd the world is showing their crocodile tears
7. #1, 'Would you be pleased if ...
Harri ,   EU   (07.07.14)
Would you be pleased if IDF acted like in the jewish Sons case? IDF could level the houses of the murders and arrest 400 right wing lunatics, killing some if they fight back. Would that be better?
8. #1 Do you have any?
Hammer   (07.07.14)
You should be using contraceptives. Humanity is not something to do with you and your offsprings.
9. Come on, let's be fair - the murderers of
barbara ,   Haifa Israel   (07.07.14)
this Arab boy are in custody, will go to trial and probably prison. Now give us the murderers of the three Israeli boys. Only fair that Israel has these murderers under lock and key, also.
10. Is a confession from a minor w/o an attorney legal?
Allon   (07.07.14)
The police are creating a situation where they can have a public arrest, but destroying the foundation for a trial. After publicizing too much about the events of the murder, they then coerce a confession from minors without the right of having an attorney present. I'm not sure what is worse, that this will not stand up in court and killers will go free, or that it will be accepted by the court and thereby showing that our legal system is a sham.
11. So there is a situation of KIDS WITHOUT LAWYERS!
Riva ,   Israel   (07.07.14)
KIDS WILL SAY ANYTHING IS THE RIGHT PRESSURE IS EXERTED! HOW DO WE KNOW THEY WERE NOT BEATEN TO CONFESS TO A CRIME OR INVOLVMENT THEY MAY NOT HAVE DONE!? HOW DO WE KNOW IF THEY WERE TREATED PROPERLY. THEY ARE STILL CONSIDERED CHILDREN UNDER LAW. BOTH PARENTS AND LAWYERS SHOULD ALWAYS BE PRESENT! OR JUSTICE IS ABSOLUTELY NOT SERVED!
12. no lawyers allowed
Jhan   (07.07.14)
sniff sniff something very fishy here, like the moon landings, the 9/11, the assassination of OBL, the mindfuqs are just getting more and more unbelievable...
13. Their houses have already been demolished....
Robert ,   Australia   (07.07.14)
....even though they were only suspects.
14. ....and ynet calls them "suspects"....
Robert ,   Australia   (07.07.14)
.....even after their confessions.
15. Ah, they will get away with a slap on the wrist as usual.
Dilbert ,   in the office   (07.07.14)
In no time they´ll be the heroes of the settler movement and Bennet will find them a nice and well paid job: Probably as police officers in the West Bank.
16. Misleading "frame"!
Scott ,   USA   (07.07.14)
"One of them confessed and framed the others." Does that mean that the five others are innocent, or that YNet meant to say "One of them confessed and *implicated* the others."
17. #1 Moses
Sarah B ,   Tel Aviv/London   (07.07.14)
The murder of the three settler children was inexcusable and wrong and the perpetrators should be brought to justice The murder of Mohammad Abu Khdeir was equally abhorrent and the perpertrators should receive the same justice as the people who killed the three settlers. That includes demolition of their houses
18. Israeli govmnt MUST demolish their homes
Jew   (07.07.14)
19. YOUR SONS, MOSHE?
mike o'diomasaigh ,   USA   (07.07.14)
YPUR SONS, from the moment they went missing, ceased being YOUR SONS and became nothing but political propaganda, used by YOUR PEOPLE, the people of ISRAEL, the JEWISH STATE, to demonise a whole culture and heap scorn upon a whole people and scream for bloodlust. i have never seen such a disgraceul display in my life. there was no quiet mourning, only a raucous, deafening scream of blood lust and revenge, and you got that....and then, you used the death of a ypung palestinian boy, MOHAMMAD ABU KHDEIR to furtjer demonise that culture, blaming a his mourning family of killing him in an honor killing because he was gay. HELL IS NOT HOT ENOUGH NOR ETERNITY LONG ENOUGH FOR YOUR PEOPLE, the people of israel, the people of the JEWISH STATE, moshe.
20. This act was horrible but what about Shelly Dadon?
she was murdered too   (07.07.14)
21. They're not settlers they're from Jerusalem and Bet-Shemesh
not settlers   (07.07.14)
22. Where are All the Zionazi Talkbackers Who
Doug ,   Rochester, USA   (07.07.14)
Who claimed it was an honor killing or claimed they had proof it was Hamas that killed the teenager? Three Jewish terrorists have confessed so far. How do you explain that and reconcile it with your earlier lies? Will you now apologize to the family and to Hamas? Blood libel!
23. Must be allowed to have Lawyers present!
Son of Cyrus ,   UK   (07.07.14)
3 Israeli boys are brutally murdered, but when one Arab is murdered so much fuss!!!!!!!
24. Molotov Cocktail=attempt to burn alive
Palestinian"fire" ,   Jerusalem Israel   (07.07.14)
Are not the hundreds if not thousands of Molotov Cocktails thrown in the past and today in the Galilee and elsewhere not attempts to burn alive a Jew ? Why are those throwing them not arrested and charged with attempted murder Does anyone still remember those burned or killed by a Molotov Cocktail like the mother and her 4 children on the bus passing through Jericho a few years ago How do they get away with this attempted murder by fire of Jews almost daily ???!!!!
25. 3 suspects in arab teen murder
tomer ,   jerusalem   (07.07.14)
our jewish value system is broken. After goldstein,amir,the inhuman burning of an arab teen alive,the animal like beating of his relative by border police,the hate speeches against "goyim" and the "death to arab" calls mark this value break downdown. it is mind boggling and frightening. we are not different anymore from extremists on the arab side. we are just like them. How we get out of this Mr. prime minister? Its time for us to get up,go out on the streets (not to reduce cottage cheese prices but) to demonstrate for annother political leadership with direction and values. An end has to be put to this "anarchic tribal behaviour". No more leadership without vision and the guts to end the israeli palestinian issue. We owe this to the 3 slain jewish kids ,but more we owe this to us.We deserve better,we are better than this and we can do better than this and we have to try ...
26. They were just doing what Rabbi Noam Perel asked them to do
Miri ,   Holon   (07.07.14)
Rabbi Noam Perel of Bnei Akiva Jewish Youth movement issued a statement after the 3 Jewish boys were kidnapped and murdered by terrorists " Three corpses of our youths were found dumped in a field; an entire nation and thousands of years of history demands revenge... The humiliation will be atoned by the blood of the enemy and not by our tears.” It was just a matter of time before one of these brain dead zombies acted on his words. And we are surprised when something like this happens?
27. If they'd take the mother and the father in for questioning
(07.07.14)
and beat them like they did for those 6 "suspects", no doubt the mother will admit that Arabs were once again behind the murder and these 6 Jews are guinea pigs. The mother doesn't look very sad that her son was murdered.
28. After hours of torture, most people will confess to anything
(07.07.14)
Those who live in fantasy, believing that the GSS/Shin Bet do not fabricate evidence against Jewish nationalists (quietly dropping most of these "arrests/detentions" after this and that comes out) for political dictates, well, you don't know what's really going on. .any "confessions" reportedly beaten out of those they scoop up (having a list of "suspects" at their fingertips, the so called "extremists")...even as their attorneys are NOT allowed to see them, violating EVERY manner of due process imaginable.
29. Four Jerusalem women
(07.07.14)
While Israel quick to make arrest Palestinians were just numb over three Israel teenagers so we can only say jealousy is the root of hatred of Palestinians knowing very well the price their teenager paid by burning alive but we don't know the price Israeli teenagers paid.
30. Q&A
arik ,   usa   (07.07.14)
Q: When will their houses be demolished? A: Never.
Next talkbacks
Back to article