Opinion  Ron Ben-Yishai
Why Israel needs to go into Gaza
Ron Ben-Yishai
Published: 11.07.14, 01:16
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
19 Talkbacks for this article
1. EXACTLY. good analysis.
Rafi ,   US   (07.11.14)
But all this will require strong nerves & inspired leadership - qualities Netanyahu & his govt are not noted for. Right now, there is no force in the world that can stop Israel from moving ahead - except itself.
2. post script to my previous comment
CJK   (07.11.14)
just as i had written that iran is the puppet master, hezbollah has started firing missiles from the north. this was very predictable.
3. Once In - In for Generation
Mark ben Josef ,   USA   (07.11.14)
Nobody will take over once the invasion is done. Israel will be there until Israel helps create a generation to govern the place the way Israel wants it governed.. And occupation generates hostility. As much or more than the siege has generated.
4. Israel must retake Gaza permanently.
Chaim ,   Israel   (07.11.14)
Israel's lunatic retreat from Gaza is the root cause of ALL the Gaza wars, rockets and terror. Just as Israeli retreats are the cause of virtually all Israel's problems. Israel needs to retake our lands.
5. go after the tunnels
Mark ,   USA   (07.11.14)
By this i mean the launch of a ground offensive into gaza should set as a goal to totally take all tunnels by setting a say a five mile band along boarder with egypt as a combat zone per UN standards, with the stated aim to controll area so that every square inch is investigated for tunnels, and said tunnels are destroyed thus the price Hamas pays is the lost of all tunnels. With that set as a goal idf has a concrete mission, pocession of strip of gaza, devoid of population( force evacuation population), and say a twelve week window to demolish tunnel infrustructure through totally controll of area to do as you will, thus when leaving area at end of operation, Hamas is left with no tunnels.
6. gantz is not alone
marv   (07.11.14)
gantz is not alone like halutz who had no checks on one dimensional air force views. Yaalon will bring the idf and gantz into a ground operation which sadly is necessary. it need not be terrible if idf uses concentrations at points after launching huge fire, drones, armored bulldozers, robotics and arab spies to set the area. Then idf can go in and kill it,This can be done sector by vital sector. rabbis need to educate brainwash idf soldiers much as nasrollah did his operatives. and make no mistake. Israel has to got to think to slaughter any operatives opposing it. decide whehter you want to win or not. haaretz writers of course feel guilty about winning and want israel to lose.
7. my two cents worth.....
les ,   canada   (07.11.14)
let the so called "politicians" authorise the IDF/IAF to go in to that viper nest, in the shortest time possible, eliminate most of the known terrorist leaders, most of the weaponry and manufacturing infrastructure and get out. 48 hours the most. and if they are still firing rockets, repeat it till there is no more infrastructure left. trying to keep "collateral" damage to a minimum.
8. and you are naive to think that
observer ,   Egypt   (07.11.14)
Palestinian haven't learned the lesson of the past regarding land incursion.
9. Cast Lead was a half assed attempt...
Koose E Mack ,   NY USA   (07.11.14)
The violence against Israel will not cease until Hamas and Abbas' miscreants are eliminated from our world! Though we put our sons and daughters in harm's way, there is no other solution. Gaza should be leveled and its population exiled to Sinai or Jordan! They elected Hamas, let them live with their choice!
10. No need for invasion.
Aryeh Leib Baruch ,   Elad, Israel   (07.11.14)
Turn off the electricity, water, etc. first. First things first. If they don't pay rent (loyalty), initiate eviction proceedings. Please don't endanger our boys without an exit strategy. Invasion only feeds their media strategy.
11. Take ground and keep it.
Ezra ,   USA   (07.11.14)
Israel needs to take land they've been allowing Hamas to live on. Take portions of the land; and don't give it back.
12. Israel must go to Gaza
Brod ,   USA   (07.11.14)
This is a Must for Israel National Security and Defense. Defeating HAMAS quickly and decisively is a Must to preserve and strengthen Israel's deterrent. Failure to do so will be a national disaster for Israel. It will lead to Israel being terrorized and bombarded incessantly. It will further strengthen Israel's surrounding enemies to achieve their Charter of destroying Israel.
13. I disagree
Rabbi Yakov Lazaros ,   USA   (07.11.14)
Why risk the safety of even one soldier? Every Jewish life is precious. Instead what needs to be done is intensive bombing of the areas where the rockets are being fired from. Also stop supplying Gaza with fuel and electricity without these they will be unable to fire rockets.
14. What should be the only true goals?
Eli Bodie ,   USA   (07.11.14)
1: Total destruction of all terrorists. 2: The re-taking, annexation of all Israeli land: Gaza, Judea and Samaria. Any Jew who thinks that Israel should give any part of Israeli land to the Arabs should be deported. The Abrahamic Covenant should be the only guideline. God bless Israel!
15. Stopping the Rocket Fire
Joe ,   Israel   (07.11.14)
Israel has a.deadline so- far unmentionedi. deadline in stopping the rocket fire. The resumption of school. in the fall
16. According to Ben Yishai Israeli citizens security is in the
tom ,   tel aviv   (07.11.14)
hands of " International Community". Now it makes sense why we're the Chosen People!
17. The longer we delay...
Yehuda ,   Holit   (07.11.14)
The more prepared they will be. Each one of these "yo-yo" wars we have they learn more and we loose more initiative. We need to get out of this "What will the world think?!" mind set and get our hands dirty. That is the same mind set that brought us the Yom Kippur War. We need to go in and finish this.
18. Iran terror state is the puppet master
CJK   (07.11.14)
the terror state of iran is the one which has supplied hamas and islamic jihad with advanced missiles. the terror war started by hamas at this time is not a coincidence. iran is facing a deadline of 20 july to come to some sort of deal with the p5+1 on its nuclear weapons program. iran is trying to deflect attention from this date. iran is also trying to assess israel's military capabilities since it fears an israeli attack on its nuclear sites. the islamist terrorists in gaza are willing to sacrifice any number of their civilians to gain a propaganda victory. israelis should not help them by openly showing sympathy. it must not be forgotten for one instant that they would murder every israeli if they could. nor should it be forgotten that the terrorists have attempted to destroy the dimona nuclear reactor and thus cause a nuclear holocaust. israel must do whatever needs to be done to destroy as much as possible of the terror capabilities of hamas and its partners.
19. 10
C   (07.12.14)
it is not possible to turn off water or electricity for more than a day or two. jews do not murder civilians.
Back to article