Opinion  Ben-Dror Yemini
Israel bashers, let's talk about proportion
Ben-Dror Yemini
Published: 18.07.14, 12:34
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
22 Talkbacks for this article
1. Treat "Palestinians" as mortal foes they are.
Chaim ,   Israel   (07.18.14)
Israel needs to stop coddling "Palestinians" and treat them as the mortal foes they are. Treat them as the WW II Allies treated German and Japanese civilians. Make no mistake. "Palestinians" would massacre us all, in a heartbeat, if they could. Israel needs to totally defeat "Palestinians" and transfer most of them out of our land.
2. Warning
Jim ,   Canada   (07.18.14)
Hamas already warned all isrealis to leave before sending its rockets, so they don't target civilians, they already in underground shelters, that's why there is no casualties among Israelis people.
3. Stop the trifle
(07.18.14)
All this terror and bloodshed is a logical consequence of the fact that after almost five decades of occupation you have not divided that damn land. Until you divide it your right of self defense will be severely restricted. There are no rights without corresponding obligations.
4. Yes...but here Jews are involved!
Maurice ,   Montreal   (07.18.14)
Antisemitism is what is driving these hypocrites (such as the Erdogans of this world) to accuse Israel of genocide and other crimes. This article is entirely correct!
5. Stop confusing me with facts...
Liberal Lefty ,   Eurabia   (07.18.14)
Four legs good, two legs bad, Four legs good, two legs bad,Four legs good, two legs bad.
6. Proportion
Mario ,   Raanana   (07.18.14)
You still didn't understand that Hamas, Hizballa and every terrorist group against Israel are (and will be) the military wing of the European antisemitism.
7. Factually correct truthful article
Adi ,   Israel   (07.18.14)
Factually correct truthful article
8. Trying to convince the inconvincibles!
tiki ,   belgium   (07.18.14)
A waste of time for the majority of the army of 'Humanists can't deal with strong Israeli's & living Jews!
9. Jim
Óscar ,   San pedro Honduras   (07.19.14)
Are you for real? You don't even read what's going on let alone understand it, CRAZY!!
10. Israel-Gaza war and international human rights
Dan ,   Montevideo-R.O.U.   (07.19.14)
Only to establish that israeli also Haaretz newspaper wonders if this last time wont be different at the end for Israels Army in this subject at an international level if dosnt take seiouslly preserving civil lifes./Death and revenge seems not be a very good virtuosism for anyone in any ocassion of life ( for hebrew side or arab side) . SHALOM
11. As usual: Yemini is right on the dot
Yossi   (07.19.14)
but the venue makes it little more than a background noise. Being correct matters little in the vicious propaganda war waged by lefto- and islamo-fascism. All that counts is being heard far and wide. Yemini seem to be in danger of falling in love with himself crying in the wilderness.
12. To Yossi, 11: Many people from US read YNET
Ron, NY ,   NY, NY   (07.19.14)
What r u trying to say, that Yemini shouldn't write, even if he is right? What's your point? Anyway, many people are thirsty for this kind of factual articles, and share it among their friends
13. Proportion....or distortion.
Ruth ,   Jerusalem Israel   (07.20.14)
Where was the indignant reaction to disproportion when the Hamas demanded, and got, 1,200 prisoners in return for one Gilad Shalit? Or did they suddenly forget their maths?
14. To Ron, 12
Yossi   (07.19.14)
My point is this: this is preaching to the choir. You and your friends are the choir. Doesn't change anything. And yes, he should write, I literally adore the man. If only he devoted one-tenth of the energy he devotes to writing, to absorbing McLuhan's adage about medium being a message, then he would have accomplished something. Sorry, but writing pieces in YNet doesn't cut it. Just as his being right in his appearances abroad with his pitiful broken English and whimpy attitude don't count for squat. Just look what the qatari creeps accomplished with al jazeera and compare this with ynet. it's not even pathetic.
15. #13 I wonder what is the proportion
(07.20.14)
of Palestinians sitting in Israeli jails versus Israelis sitting in Palestinian jails.
16. To Yossi: The lecture of Yemini was great
Dana ,   Boston   (07.20.14)
I went to a lecture of Yemini in Boston. His English wasn't perfect, but his lecture was one of the best I ever heard
17. And now I also read that Human Rights Group
barbara ,   Haifa Israel   (07.21.14)
is coming to Egypt to check on the war crimes and casualties in Gaza. What about the war crimes and casualties in Israel ? No Human Rights Group for us ?
18. numerical proportions
Greg ,   Washington DC   (07.21.14)
I posted these numbers to another article but it seems appropriate here as well--if were talking about proportion then these numbers are ones people should become more familiar with: 14 people were shot dead in various incidents in Chicago over 4th of July weekend alone and over 80 shot that weekend in total. This is extreme but not unusual for many American cities. Over 10,000 Americans die every year in street violence which is really just an informal combat. That's 4x the amount that died in Afghanistan and much more than will die for either side in this conflict in Gaza. This is EVERY year. I love America--it's a great country in many, many ways--but Israelis should be made aware of the hypocrisies that are leveled at them. The depravations of Europe in the realm of violence is beyond the scope of this talkback--but they are kidding themselves if they think they have any moral authority or even substance at all. They have soaked the world in blood and hate for centuries including their worst in the recently past 20th century. They should STFU about everything.
19. no common sense
Zsolt ,   Wanganui,NZ   (07.22.14)
Logic or common sense is never applied when Jews or Israel is concerned. We always initiate "out of proportion reactions" and the expectations placed on us are very unique. I don't think we can escape trying to figure out what our unique role/purpose in this world is, what others, even unconsciously are expecting from us?
20. #17 In this diproportionate slaughter....
Darren Ben John ,   Townsville Australia   (07.25.14)
There are very few caualties in Israel, and the Palestinians have not comitted any war crimes in Israel. Hang your wrinkled head in shame for your accusations
21. The serbian example...
Adrian ,   Nottingham UK   (08.04.14)
"Among the NATO forces, it should be mentioned, there were zero casualties. Were you looking for proportion? Well, NATO has shown it to us." Well, let's forget about the Kosovars then hey ! Serbian nationalism was dreaming about the great Serbia, look what happened next ! Food for though
22. Israelis were warned..
Dan ,   kefar saba   (08.10.14)
During the elections in 2006, Hamas warned Israelis that they would kill any who stayed. So where do you get off saying Israelis were not warned? Jews need to return to where they are welcome, Poland, France, Prussia, Galacia, UK, etc.
Back to article