News
IDF: Either we go further in or back out now
Yoav Zitun
Published: 30.07.14, 00:45
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
30 Talkbacks for this article
1. obama's hatred for israel
(07.30.14)
obama's hatred for israel has enabled the jihadists to flourish.
2. TISHA B´AV
(07.30.14)
The Tisha b'Av that is approaching has two meanings: it can mean complete destruction or sublime and eternal victory -a true ribirth. Israel has no more alternatives in her present conditions and needs to win (or perish). Win Israel!
3. Israel is a real government
Ron ,   oc us   (07.30.14)
That is why there is a conflict between the politicians and military. It is very tough to get a clear military victory given the nature of asymmetrical warfare. Without additional reserves called up, additional casualties and additional resources the ground op can't go forward. Better to keep hitting hamas from the air now that the tunnels can be neutralized. It is cheaper, very destructive for hamas and keeps Israeli casualties down. Let hamas claim a great victory, they always do. No need for Israel to make this a fair fight.
4. Into Gaza
Advise   (07.30.14)
Set up checkpoints, find all the weapons, find the underground hideouts of the Hamas leaders, arrest them.
5. Blame game
Philip ,   Afula, Israel   (07.30.14)
Lets deal with this issue AFTER the war has finished.In the meantime leave Bibi alone and let him do the overall managing. P.S I am not a Bibi voter but think it destructive to attack him now.
6. Terror Tunnels
Chutia ,   New Delhi, India   (07.30.14)
Needs extraordinary courage to search these tunnels. A lot like Vietnam
7. i told you bibi was not competent
arieh   (07.30.14)
8. Hamas are cowards. Sewage dwellers.
Fides ,   Nigeria   (07.30.14)
Noor I wish allah sends you such victories forever. 1000 dead on your side and ruined infrastructure. No matter what the outcome hamas will claim victory.
9. Ronald Reagan Would Say "Win One For The Gipper!"
David H ,   Marietta, USA   (07.30.14)
Do the job. Finish the job. The lives of Jewish children are at stake! Wipe this cancer off the face of the Earth. Maybe other countries will get the message. And don't worry about Barry. He's vicious. But he's harmless.
10. Army knows what is best.
DOV ,   USA   (07.30.14)
11. It has been wery obvious to any military experienced -
Arn. ,   Sweden.   (07.30.14)
- that Israels political leadership, are amateurs leading a professional army to defeat of their intent. Arn.Sweden.
12. Better intelligence and defensive layers should be built
(07.30.14)
The Gaza border communities should receive better defensive layers and technological detection measures against tunnel incursions and other threats.
13. Tzahal must be allowed to finish the war
C   (07.30.14)
the terror tunnels must be destroyed. hamas, Islamic jihad must be defeated.
14. Tunnels of ..."love?"
DvorahTheProphetess ,   SC, USA   (07.30.14)
Imagine if all the effort, all the time, all the money and materials that were spent digging these tunnels were spent, instead on constructing SCHOOLS, HOSPITALS, UNIVERSITIES, HOMES, THEATERS, LIBRARIES . . . oh, how proud I am to be a Jew; how proud I am of Am Yisrael.
15. Unfinished Job
(07.30.14)
The sacrifice so far in protective edge has been high and dangers of leaving the threat unremediated is high. The likelihood is that the campaign could be risky if continued but it is possible that the resistance is seriously weakened to allow the mission to be completed if done with careful planning and execution with good intelligence and the best application of technology and precautions.
16. yes! i know it sounds too radical
les ,   canada   (07.30.14)
but in an war of existential survival for the nation, leaders of the IDF/IAF should take over calling the shots. a divided cabinet, and a knesset in chaos can not defend israel. let them finish the job, then back to the barracks. can you imagine that government fighting a war against hizbo and iran???
17. There is no "op", might be an "oops" expansion.
Miron ,   USA   (07.30.14)
Op was during Olmert. When 2 weeks into the action Hamas lost ability to fire rockets at Israel. This is not an "op". This is "oops". Well, what else can we expect from Yahoo. By the way, we also killed fewer civilians when it was "op". Many times fewer.
18. @12 Yahoo will need more defence lawyers, not layers.
Miron ,   USA   (07.30.14)
When Israel pulls the moron by the neck to guillotine for cutting IDF funds when Army needed to train for war with Hamas.
19. Searching tunnels
Raphael ,   Netanya   (07.30.14)
Is a dangerous task due do booby traps. Everybody in Netanya can see on the Kikar Haatsmaut the damage created by a single gas bottle, that blew up the northern side of the square. Wouldn't it be wise to fill the tunnels with propane gas? this would have the same effectiveness as a firedamp in a coalmine and save our soldiers' lives.
20. Visible Tunnels
D. Fault ,   NYC, USA   (07.30.14)
The U.S. has satellite technology which has identified the location of the tunnels that are not directly under building. They can see where the tunnels going out of Gaza into Israel are located. If the U.S. can be persuaded to hand over this information, Israel can then fill the tunnels with natural gas and explode them. The gas will fill all the branches and connecting tunnels and destroy everything. It's just a matted of getting Pres. Obama to had over the information.
21. Now what . .
Jacob ,   NZ   (07.30.14)
Time to build an underground barrier (100mtrs deep) around Gaza. This should be booby trapped with thermo nuclear warheads and poison gas. You think I'm kidding . Consider this . . Hamas will rebuild the tunnels within the next year or so, and what then . . Watch this space.
22. 4
yonatan Allon ,   adelaide/Israel   (07.30.14)
Oh,really?
23. it's truth or expansion, silly
oferdesade ,   israel   (07.30.14)
whoever added the op in there deserves to be a news editor...
24. Separate the bad from the worse!
zelig ,   memphis,u.s.a.   (07.30.14)
Israel needs to separate the inveterate haters of the present from the haters of the future.That means separate the hamasian women & children from the monsters [their fathers,husbands,brothers,uncles etc. Use non lethal gases,loud sounds,etc to do so.Put the women and children into internment camps.Let the kids watch Lassie.Let the women watch Rachel Ray or read Ladies Home Journal.Give 'em a/c,food,tents,and decent drink.And keep doing this until the embers of the hamasian fire start to burn out.It might take a few years to do. And as for the fat family of North Korea who earn their living on the death and destruction of others...maybe someday we'll all be happy to read that they've had a few hotel "accidents". Maybe their cargo ships will run into mines or icebergs.. or stuff! Maybe their Swedish prostitutes will accidentally bring them smallpox ..or stuff.
25. Unpredictability demands safeguards
Zechariah   (07.30.14)
The basic is defence of the Jewish people and army and minmilization of jewishcasualties and Arab Civilian Casualties .Given the Hamas Fanatacism this is a tough aim .We can only realize that now the Jews have arms and can hit their enemies who Did not differ when the crunch came. .Although Hamas is not fully nazi they allied with the nazis through the Islamic Brotherhood and the Grand Mufti who had Lemon juice with Hitler agreeing on Genocide in Europe and for the Jews in the Yishuv. .
26. Catch 22 -cannot take out all tunnels
Dan ,   Kefar Saba   (07.30.14)
Aluf of Southern Command just said on channel 2 that they will take out all tunnels that cross the Israeli border. He did not say they would take out all the tunnels, and they can't. I am sure that there is an entire sub-city under the Gaza landscape and if the tunnels under hospitals, schools mosques and homes are taken out, the buildings above would collapse.
27. #20. Unaceptable to Jews
Dan ,   Kefar Saba   (07.30.14)
It is unacceptable since the tunnels traverse under schools and hospitals. If Israel fills the tunnel with gas and ignites it, they cannot warn the people above to get out. For all we know all the tunnels are interconnected and the explosion would remove Gaza from the world map.
28. Nr. 11.
Arn. ,   Sweden.   (07.30.14)
The Politicians could set a goal for a Militaru operation but, leave it to the Military to carry it out according to their Miltary professionalism. This Halting and Stopping an operation every now and then, leave the initiative to the enemy when one loses the momentum. Why does those Civilians dont understand this, or why does not the Military tell them that. You can not wage War or Military operations like that. Civilian Politicians should not interviene in militarry operations untill its goal are reached. Arn.
29. 20
(07.30.14)
the us will not hand over that information. obama hates Israel and he hates bibi.
30. Ironicialy Hamas wants Israel to committ more atrosities...
M.S. ,   mpls america   (07.31.14)
Ironicially Hamas wants Israel the IDF to committ more atrosities shell more U N schools U N hospitals so on good P R public relations for them they want the IDF to keep doing this bombing shelling so on for at least the next 3 4 months thus ironicially I doubt if Israel could with draw even if the Generals and so Leaders want to try to even order the troops out... RIGHT ??? Thank You... M.S.
Back to article