Opinion  Sever Plocker
Ben-Gurion was right to legitimize the 'other Germany'
Sever Plocker
Published: 18.05.15, 11:08
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
9 Talkbacks for this article
1. the key - which seems to be overlooked here - is that...
Rafi ,   US   (05.18.15)
... post-war Germany provided the new State of Israel with critical financial and military aid that allowed the latter to SURVIVE INTO THE FUTURE...
2. Germany and Israel
ed snider ,   Milwaukee usa   (05.18.15)
Nazism did not fail to deliver on its promises, but was absolutely successful. Hitler promised to remove the Jews from positions of power and influence in German society, in the arts, finance, science, ethics, etc. etc. The reason the Germans became acquiescent after the war was because they had achieved their war aims, and the tensions caused by their sense of inferiority to the Jews were relieved.
3. A day in the park, walking the dog
David ,   Australia   (05.18.15)
I vividly remember my trip to one of the lesser known concentration camps. My body felt a horrific chill from the suffering of the souls who had been there. Looking around, I saw a man from the local village casually walking his dog on the grounds of the concentration camp, enjoying the spring weather. This to me exemplified the complete lack of understanding by Germans regarding the magnitude of human suffering and devastation that they inflicted. Their so-called remorse rings hollow, like the remorse of a criminal AFTER being apprehended. I wonder how remorseful Germans would be had they won the war? Nobody ever seems to address that. This also highlights the extreme hypocrisy of the world. It's business as usual with Germany, while the entire world seems to feel that out of all the countries on the planet, those Jews need to be boycotted yet again.
4. To Jens Becker of Germany
David ,   Australia   (05.18.15)
who wrote "And if I have a look on the "most popular countries poll" they do every year worldwide, Germany is for years Nr.1, while Israel is right before Iran, perhaps there is still space for improvement for Israel." Pity that you don't hear, or want to know, what most Europeans think of Germany in private conversation. It goes along the lines of "we in Europe say that Germany started 2 world wars, who says it won't be 3 world wars. So yes, we can sit and have a beer with them, but we don't trust them in the least". There is a reason that the entire world does not want you to be re-armed, and that you still have foreign troops on your soil 70 years after the last world war that you started. So much for your smug, repetitive, parroted Israel/Jew bashing.
5. "The Jews' willingness to forgive..."
Avi ,   NYC, USA   (05.18.15)
Was motivated by two factors: 1. there was nothing that the Jews could do to Germany once the chaos of the first years after its defeat ended. 2. There was money involved. If the Germans were weak and poor then the story could have been different.
6. Terrible Error by Yishuv
Zechariah   (05.19.15)
The Yishuv had the capacity to hunt down and kill the hundred worse Nazis that escaped justice but did not do this .It would have been far better to train a Few hundred Shoah survivors to do the Task of Justice .
7. to david, australia
david ,   EU   (05.19.15)
Why so many people from australia I met think they understand europe and try to tell us how things are running here and what countries are friends or not. Sorry but you are all wrong, you understand nothing about europe, same as we do not understand australia, sure there exist stereotypes about all countries but in the end we are all europeans and we love to be!!
8. What's the big deal here?
ARNE ,   CHICAGO USA   (05.19.15)
iSRAEL'S RELATIONSHIP WITH GERMANY IS FINE AND THAT'S A GOOD THING--if YOU WANT TO GO BACK IN TIME WE JEWS WOULD HAVE A RIGHT TO HATE THE WHOLE WORLD-LET'S LEAVE WELL ENOUGH ALONE AND CHERISH OUR GOOD RELATIONS WITH THOSE WHO WOULD BE OUR FRIENDS TODAY.
9. THE UNITED STATES
LARRY ,   USA   (05.20.15)
as i recall the US pardoned and set up VON BROWN AND 12 MORE NAZI V2 SCIENTISTS TO WORK ON THE ATLAS ROCKET MOON PROGRAM KENNEDY BLESSED THIS. when i was stationed in west germany in 1982 a 20 year old replied to my question about hitler quote I DO NOT KNOW THE JERK WAS BORN AFTER HE DIED AND COULD GIVE A SHIT ABOUT HIM . if you think about this would a 20year old in the us be responsible for what his great great grandfather did as a union soldier to the american indians
Back to article