News
Punishment withdrawn for Israeli-American soldier who indulged in pork
Yossi Yehoshua
Published: 02.06.15, 17:44
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
21 Talkbacks for this article
1. 1 Kosher Restaurant in all of Boston
EndOfBostonsJews ,   Boston Ma USA   (06.02.15)
The once proud Jewish community of Boston has grown so rich and acculturated to gentile society it is no longer even recognizable as a Jewish community other than a very small Orthodox community huge "Temples" rarely hold services in their main sanctuaries as no one comes another Jewish tragedy
2. So, the "law" of people that are not serving our country is
(06.02.15)
the one prevailing in all walks of our life? I know it is, still: it's bloody galling!
3. Which Army regulation forbids to eat
Avi L.   (06.02.15)
Which Army regulation forbids to eat whatever you want? Please publish it. Are we already in par with Hamas and ISIS?
4. IDF vs. pork fare
Cameron ,   USA   (06.02.15)
These dietary rules seem some ridiculous baggage to drag down the road, but as you will.
5. How can Israel expect Heavenly assistance with pork eaters
IDF cowards   (06.02.15)
in the Jewish army, or so-called Jewish army? He should have received 11 years, not 11 days. Shame on the IDF for releasing him.
6. There's a reason Hashem created swine! Those who don't
(06.02.15)
indulge in this "practice(!?)" are acting against Nature & His Plan. Torah is plain wrong on this subject, I know because I talk to God on a daily basis, when giving Him pointers about Middle East, imagine: poor guy, after all these years and He still doesn't see where He's made mistake then, in the desert & burning bush'n all!
7. Pork sandwich
Pat Irving ,   Morgan Hill, CA USA   (06.02.15)
The military is to be complimented for providing its Military with a Kosher kitchen/kosher food. Perhaps some education is required for those who do not know the rules of Kashrut..."when in Rome do as the Romans" do...a Jew from Boston should not be surprised at this!
8. In some towns Synagogues even close for the Jewish Holidays
Alan ,   SA   (06.02.15)
9. Pork.
Gabe ,   Canada   (06.02.15)
Nobody cared if the food was kosher or not when I was a starving child.
10. Kosher @ IDF
Zvi ,   Toronto   (06.02.15)
Is that the onlyconcern at IDF. The person who convinct this soldier just simply show his enormous stupidity
11. 1 EOBJ of Boston: The failure to obey food laws and observe
Rivkah   (06.02.15)
the Sabbath was a factor in the Jews of Europe losing their hedge of protection and being persecuted by Nazis. History repeats, sadly. Isaiah chapters 65 and 66 say haShem will not protect swine eaters and those who eat unclean foods. Observing the Shabbat of haShem not Emperor Constantine's Sunday Sabbath of man, puts a person in a special category of protection by haShem that is missing if the Sabbath is not observed.
12. On what basis was he a convicted/disciplined?
N ,   N   (06.02.15)
As Israel is a country for all their citizens: Jews, Muslims, Christians, Druze, Atheists, ...there is no room for a (de facto) sentence because of eating pork! This is a clear form of unlawful punishment. Those who wanted to imprison him must answer the question "What was the legal basis for this (outrageous) punishment?" Their illegal action must be investigated and perhaps it will be necessary to try them -- because it is very dangerous when there are people in the military who make their own laws, based on their own understanding of religion (or whatever).
13. Why was eating pork prohibited back then?
N ,   N   (06.02.15)
I think the most important reason was that swines eat the same category of food as man. Therefore the rich people who wanted to eat pork would have fed their swines vegetables, corn and fruits humans could eat, too. The price of this food would have increased because of the "lust" of the rich people. Pig husbandry in a semi-arid countryside was therefore a social no-go. But now there is no need of pig husbandry because pork can be imported, eating pork now isn't anti-social at all.
14. I will go with......
(06.02.15)
The New Testament decision on this. Peter was told to eat and not say unclean what G-d created. That means G-d issued disclaimer on unclean things, that He has not created anything unclean. We told you so!!!!!! The two states are; clean state versus unclean state. G-d will save the animals for our food and will not give to our enemies no more.
15. Booyaka! on the supercilious snitch & know it all ...
just saying ,   Israel   (06.02.15)
commanding officer. Booyaka...as well as on all of the superior Jews who think they know what should or shouldn't happen on an IDF base. All y'all need to learn that you can catch more flies with honey than you can with vinegar.
16. Pork Aversion
Dan ,   Canada   (06.03.15)
I read a book some years ago that tried to explain such cultural and religious sensitivities and it postulated that a few thousand years ago meat preparation and storage was atrocious in many parts of the world as you can well imagine (the Innu in northern Canada had natural refrigeration whereas in the Middle East salting your meat was the easiest option) and trichinosis was a real danger so religious leaders enacted a edict forbidding consumption of pork. Since, according to Fox News, even the goldarned poors have refrigerators now thes sorts o edicts could be researched and relaxed.
17. Freedom from other peoples religion
Lior   (06.03.15)
What ever next? Now they are telling people what they can and cannot eat? They want to be more concerned with what comes out of their mouths and not what goes in to it
18. Not a complete story
dan ,   kfar sava   (06.03.15)
To complete the story we would need to know: 1)was he in the mess hall 2)is there a sign not to bring in food (to the mess hall) 3)is there another place to eat
19. That's what he gets!
sheik rattle & roll ,   USA   (06.03.15)
He should of joined the US Marine Corp. He wouldn't have to bring food from home. On top of that he could earn a few thousand dollars a month instead of $50.00 a week, not enough for 3 meals at McDonald's in Israel, unless he eats a happy meal for a 5 year old. Now he is serving a theocratic government influenced by religious fools that don't serve. The US should enact a law stating that if you serve in a foreign military you have to renounce your citizenship whether it is the Chinese, Russian, Martian or Moonman army.
20. 13 N, N: Swine do not sweat, so the toxins are in the meat.
Rivkah   (06.03.15)
Also, swine have parasites like trichinosis that are still infectious after cooking the meat! So it is best for one's health's sake not to eat pork or even touch pork.
21. 14,16,17: HaShem is not a liar and haShem does not change!
Rivkah   (06.03.15)
Please read Hezekiyah Haas' book, "On Health and Holiness" to see the harmful aspects of not eating clean foods approved in Scriptures. Such unclean foods are dangerous to one's health and well being. To the poster who said the New Covenant books say it is all right to eat all animals, he/she needs to read the entire chapter of Peter's vision of wild animals in a sheet being lowered from heaven. He is told to eat and not to call any of the wild animals unclean. The wild animals represent NATIONS not food groups or species of animals. Peter is told to go into the Gentile (wild beast nations) world and preach the GOSPEL not eat the flesh of wild animals! You also need to get a Hebraic Roots Scripture translation from the Hebrew and Aramaic since most Scripture translations contain a lot of errors from being translated from Hebrew to Aramaic to Greek to Latin to Old German to Old English to New English and Newer New English. Go to the translations closest to the original language of the Scriptures. The Aramaic-English New Testament is a translation from the only New Covenant books text that passes the ELS Scripture code tests for authenticity. Most New Covenant books say Gentiles don't have to be circumcised when circumcision is an everlasting commandment that will be done even in the Millenium reign of Yahshua the Jewish Messiah! The Apostle Paul (Shaul) circumcised Timothy before allowing him to accompany him and preach the gospel. But most Christians who are going to hell because they sing the song of the Lamb but not the song of Moses, say they don't have to be circumcised! Yahshua the Messiah said if people love Him they will obey the Commandments. Picking a different Sabbath and refusing to circumcise male babies is picking and choosing what to obey! Eating pork and shrimp and other unclean foods and regular meats dedicated to Allah which are called halal meats is forbidden for Gentiles and Jews who love the Messiah Yahshua! Wake up! You have been brainwashed to refuse to obey the everlasting laws of Moses (Song of Moses) and that will send you to hell! Read Revelation 15:3 and get a clue! Read Hebrews chapter 4 and get a clue! Read them in the Hebraic Roots Version Scriptures or the Aramaic-English version Scriptures!!!!! Don't go to hell!!! Obey the Commandments and believe in the Lamb. Only those who sing both songs go to heaven!!!!!
Back to article