News  Magazine
The Defense Ministry's failed handling of Hezbollah drone threat
Shahar Ginosar
Published: 02.02.17, 23:33
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
9 Talkbacks for this article
1. Great ,assuring Hezb&Hamas Israel is defenceless.Censor is
ab   (02.03.17)
either asleep or it's a deception .....
2. Simple: buy a few Phalanx systems for the borders.
David ,   Hartford USA   (02.03.17)
At sea, the Phalanx® close-in weapon system—a rapid-fire, computer-controlled, radar-guided gun system—is designed to defeat anti-ship missiles and other close-in air and surface threats.

The land-based Phalanx weapon system is part of the U.S. Army's Counter Rocket, Artillery and Mortar systems used to detect and destroy incoming rounds in the air before they hit their ground targets. It also helps provide early warning of attacks.

If it can shoot down an artillery shell, (and it can), it sure as hell will be able to vaporize a stinking drone.

You don't send up a 25 million dollar fighter to shoot down a thousand dollar drone. You sit in your office and direct Phalanx to shoot it out of the sky.

What, exactly, are Israeli radars tuned to detect? 747s? Fix the holes in the radar umbrella and put a few Raytheon Phalanx systems in place. The drone threat will be handled and the IDF can get back to real work.
3. israeli dumbells
beryl   (02.03.17)
you tear down ammona and its agricultural fields so yvette can make a point. what do you get? Car ramming attack injuring 3 israelis. stupid. bibi says lets wait for trump on settlements. now trump says don't build. dumb. you should do what is good for you. no one but you and the jewish commomwealth has your back. assert your interests or they will soon ask for tel aviv.

what a hapless bunch of leaders at the top.and you reflect israelis who would an olmert clone, a loser, lapid as pm. this would even be dumber.

It is time for feiglin that his anemic leadership.
4. The terror org Hamas has Jewish & Israeli supporters
Alexander Scheiner ,   Israel   (02.03.17)
The Islamic terror organization Hamas, as well as the PA with their terror organizations PLO and Fatah, are members of the Islamic Uma, about 1.6 billion Muslims.

Hamas, as well as the PA, are determined to destroy the Jewish State Israel, and if possible, the Jewish population. It is, therefore, no wonder, that Hamas will try to obtain weapons, hoping it might help them to achieve their goal.

From simple rockets to guided missiles to drones is not the end. Ultimately, Hamas will aim to obtain WMD, from the Islamic Republic Iran or North Korea, or from the IS.

Having said that, I wish to emphasize, that certain Jewish and Israeli NGO’s are supporting the PA and Hamas at least politically: The “new Israel fund”, Breaking the Silence, B’tselem, Who Profits, Zachor, Jews for Piss, JStreet and RHR.
5. HaShem will use the wind to blow the drones out to sea like
Rivkah   (02.03.17)
He did with the missiles from Lebanon in 2006. None hit Tel Aviv which was a miracle.
6. DRONES ARE GOOD FUN
MR CYNIC ,   SAFED CYNIC HOUSE   (02.03.17)
Drones are fun to fly and youngsters love them , especially ones with cameras on . Seriously though , israelis are too busy with their endless and nonsensical bureaucracy to care about any threats .
7. drone problems....
tomer ,   jerusalem   (02.03.17)
in order to deal with relatively slow moving drones maybe its an idea to go
back and use "spitfire" and machine gun to take them down...Low tec solution.
8. new threats need new weapons
zionist forever   (02.05.17)
Trouble with drones is they can stay up there for a long time making observations and bellow radar which a manned fighter does not so whilst the IAF have plenty of time to scramble because they can fly bellow radar they might be in and out by the time they are detected assuming they are detected.
Back to article