1. 
Who is a Jew
Raymond ,  South Africa  (12.01.06)
2. 
What nonsense
Sidney ,  USA  (12.01.06)
3. 
I Disagree Totally
Dave Levi ,  Burbank. USA  (12.01.06)
4. 
A solution lies with the R & C leadership
Debbie ,  Jerusalem, Israel  (12.01.06)
5. 
Weird logic as only 20% of Israelis are observant !
redmike ,  tel aviv & london  (12.01.06)
6. 
The "Who is a Jew" ? must be solved!  (End)
Mark ,  usa  (12.01.06)
7. 
#3 Are 200,000 converted away a year?
Mark ,  USA  (12.01.06)
8. 
Question for Reb. Brackman
Nathan ,  Netanya  (12.01.06)
9. 
For those who disagree
 (12.01.06)
10. 
Location does not equal observance.
Avi ,  Binyamina, Israel  (12.01.06)
11. 
You sure it's not defined by Satan?
George W ,  Chicago IL  (12.01.06)
12. 
#4 More weird logic
Sidney ,  USA  (12.01.06)
13. 
What is a Jew?
Dave Levi ,  Burbank. USA  (12.01.06)
14. 
Did Solomon, the King of Israel fail us as race or he armed
Anna ,  Canada  (12.01.06)
15. 
MORON - WE WERE A NATION BEFORE WE WERE A RELIGION  (End)
andrew ,  miami,fl  (12.01.06)
16. 
Rambam said
Sagi ,  Israel  (12.01.06)
17. 
Who is a Jew: Beyond the Jewish Religion
Aharon  (12.01.06)
18. 
Brackman's Intellectual Blackmail
Avi ,  USA  (12.01.06)
19. 
Wake up, it's the neshamah!!
Shiloh ,  Israel  (12.01.06)
20. 
JEWISH SECULAR STATE
RCA ,  USA  (12.01.06)
21. 
So the leaders of the Religion would sacrifice
Steven Wilson ,  Anchorage, Alaska  (12.01.06)
22. 
is he a jew?
YedLita ,  USA  (12.01.06)
23. 
Turned OFF
efi g ,  Washington Dc  (12.01.06)
24. 
Backwards Logic
Zhenya ,  Atlanta GA USA  (12.01.06)
25. 
Who is a Jew?
David Nowlin ,  Redmond Oregon, USA  (12.01.06)
26. 
So stupid article, Levi !
Ezra ,  Canada  (12.01.06)
27. 
So secular Israelis (80% of the country) shouldn't be ...
Yael ,  Haifa  (12.01.06)
28. 
so me being baptized
wonder ,  germany  (12.01.06)
29. 
really, mike, logic & religion?
oferdesade ,  israel  (12.01.06)
30. 
Sorry, too simplistic
Terry ,  Eilat, Israel  (12.01.06)
31. 
Brachman you are the reason I left Orthodoxy. Twisted logic.  (End)
Steve ,  Tel Aviv, Israel  (12.01.06)
32. 
Rabbi Brackman's logic...
Edan ,  Israel  (12.01.06)
33. 
I disagree completely
Leo ,  Tolosa  (12.01.06)
34. 
Points of Contention
Helen ,  Cape Town, SA  (12.01.06)
35. 
defined by Hitler?!
Barry ,  Ft. Lauderdale, FL  (12.01.06)
36. 
who is a jew
Ronald Field ,  usa  (12.01.06)
37. 
#36 Ronald  (End)
Avi ,  USA  (12.01.06)
38. 
The crucial importance of antisemitism
Larry ,  Eastbourne, UK  (12.01.06)
39. 
who is jew???
Daniel ,  Santiago, Chile  (12.01.06)
40. 
#36 Ronald
Avi ,  USA  (12.01.06)
41. 
Who is a Jew
robin ,  israel  (12.01.06)
42. 
To #15 Actually the truth is...
Daniel ,  Austin USA  (12.01.06)
43. 
the law of return-a reality or a sham?
debra ,  usa  (12.02.06)
44. 
why not be a bit controversial?
marilyn  (12.02.06)
45. 
this rabbi is a sick man
new york ,  new york  (12.02.06)
46. 
Be a Jew in G_ds eyes
Grafted Wild Olive S ,  Sojourner  (12.02.06)
47. 
R. Brackman's untenable postulate
Michael Imperator ,  USA  (12.02.06)
48. 
Torah and Hashem make the Jewish People
 (12.02.06)
49. 
I agree with the Rabbi
Michael U ,  SF,CA  (12.02.06)
50. 
#3 & 13- Dave Levy - Realy good points Dave.
Dr. Rick ,  USA  (12.02.06)
51. 
#33- I'm with you LEO. Making good sense !  (End)
Dr. Rick ,  USA  (12.02.06)
52. 
#38- Larry. As always, another great contribution !  (End)
Dr. Rick ,  USA  (12.02.06)
53. 
True Jews
Mosher ,  East  (12.02.06)
54. 
what a nonsense
tasc ,  Israel  (12.02.06)
55. 
We are Race, Religion and Ethnicity
Joshua ,  Jerusalem  (12.02.06)
56. 
Jewish mother. This is the deciding factor...
yonatan ,  nyc  (12.02.06)
57. 
Mosher and others
charles ,  petach tikva  (12.02.06)
58. 
Who's a Jew?
Petra ,  USA  (12.02.06)
59. 
Traditional, Modern, Jew, Any Jew
Rafi ,  Truthland  (12.02.06)
60. 
David haMelech
leon ,  Grand Rapids USA  (12.02.06)
61. 
#59 - Rafi - Great Viewpoint!
Helen ,  Cape Town, SA  (12.02.06)
62. 
Yonathan Ny I agree
charles ,  petach tikva  (12.02.06)
63. 
Pls. Don't Misunderstand USA Jews
Marcy ,  NYC, USA  (12.02.06)
64. 
#43- Debra. Right you are ! Very important point !  (End)
RCA ,  USA  (12.02.06)
65. 
#27-Yael. Very amuseing, yet something to ponder !  (End)
RCA ,  USA  (12.02.06)
66. 
THE ORTHODOX ARE BEGINNING TO TREMBLE !!!
RCA ,  USA  (12.02.06)
67. 
#59- Right on, Rafi !  (End)
RCA ,  USA  (12.02.06)
68. 
Excluding converts makes Israeli law more like Hitler's
Pete Eriksen ,  Anchorage. Alaska  (12.03.06)
69. 
What or who's a Jew
M. Hartley ,  Atlanta, US  (12.03.06)
70. 
#19-Shiloh. Excellent of you to bring that up !!
RCA ,  USA  (12.03.06)
71. 
Torah hijacked
Josh  (12.03.06)
72. 
i do not know, but i think
maysa ,  jerusalem  (12.03.06)
73. 
#53-Mosher. INSIGHTFUL !!!  (End)
RCA ,  USA  (12.03.06)
74. 
Re: Jewish Secular State #20
Yael ,  Haifa  (12.03.06)
75. 
No. 69, M. Hartley
NYC Girl  (12.03.06)
76. 
ERADICATE THE TERM "JEW"
al mann ,  Jerusalem, Israel  (12.03.06)
77. 
Kvod HaRav Amar is good for Israel..
Abdullah ,  Morocco  (12.03.06)
78. 
al mann
charles ,  Petach tikva  (12.03.06)
79. 
Torah = No to Racism = Love to Converts
a  (12.03.06)
80. 
My Israel
Kate ,  Jerusalem  (12.03.06)
81. 
Judaism
Petra Blumenfeld ,  USA  (12.03.06)
82. 
Rishon LeZion
Abdullah ,  Morocco  (12.03.06)
83. 
petra from usa
nawal ,  jerusalem  (12.03.06)
84. 
Kate , you are so right
charles ,  petach tikva  (12.03.06)
85. 
Yael, Haifa, 27
Aviel Ben Eliyahu ,  Jerusalem, Israel  (12.04.06)
86. 
Who is a Jew equals who is Israel
Menachem Petrushka ,  nyc USA  (12.04.06)
87. 
i agree with the rabbi
Chavah ,  u.s.a  (12.05.06)
88. 
#74- Yael. Israel was hijacked and Shang-hai 'd
RCA ,  USA  (12.05.06)