1. 
Bingo, hit the nail on the head
100% on mark!  (05.26.09)
2. 
assumption #4 is incomplete
Danny  (05.26.09)
3. 
Truthful bu missing one profound point
Paul ,  Jerusalem, Israel  (05.26.09)
4. 
Excellent.  (End)
shadoil ,  Jerusalem  (05.26.09)
5. 
If not a Palestinian state, then what?
Jacob ,  Cambridge, England  (05.26.09)
6. 
Eiland ignores one basic premise
Laura ,  Israel  (05.26.09)
7. 
#5, actually you are wrong
Danny  (05.26.09)
8. 
Human mistake, believing others are rational
Kerwood Derby ,  Frostbite Falls, MN  (05.26.09)
9. 
If this is true
James V. Cohen ,  Phildelphia  (05.26.09)
10. 
Idiot Savant without the savant part
Gideon Reader  (05.26.09)
11. 
Point that is missing in all these excellent points is this.
Alan ,  SA  (05.26.09)
12. 
No. 7
Smith ,  TA, Israel  (05.26.09)
13. 
Good article, but...
Juan ,  Spain  (05.26.09)
14. 
Obama makes mistakes that can ruin Israel  (End)
Robert  (05.26.09)
15. 
Re: to author & to talkbackers
Ariel Ben Yochanan ,  Kfar Tapuah, Efraim,  (05.26.09)
16. 
Giora is absolutely correct.
Mike Carmel ,  Rishon le Zion  (05.26.09)
17. 
American Mid East policy is old and stale
 (05.26.09)
18. 
There is no solution in the near term
Gee ,  Zikron Yaakov  (05.26.09)
19. 
Only #15 Talks sense.  (End)
Abe  (05.26.09)
20. 
peace?
MC ,  UK  (05.26.09)
21. 
really great and simple analysis
svietka ,  eli,shomron  (05.26.09)
22. 
The one glaring assumption left out
Said ,  London, UK  (05.26.09)
23. 
#12
Answer  (05.26.09)
24. 
MAIN issue: How to ensure Isarel's survival.
Bill Hartford,Ct ,  usa  (05.26.09)
25. 
The real peace process
Frank ,  Canada  (05.26.09)
26. 
It would be cheaper just to buy out the Palestinians.
Scott ,  USA  (05.26.09)
27. 
false assumptions
Colin Nelson ,  Ottawa, Canada  (05.27.09)
28. 
#12, so the only solution is the one that doesn't work?
Danny  (05.27.09)
29. 
Israel should not listen to Obama
Terry Traub ,  Phoenix, Arizona USA  (05.27.09)
30. 
even
injad ,  america  (05.27.09)
31. 
Pragmatism and Assumptions
Joe ,  Israel  (05.27.09)
32. 
5# They could give them Great Britain and the killing
Steven Wilson ,  Anchorage, Alaska  (05.27.09)
33. 
Herzl like solution for Arab-‘Palestinians'
Nurit Greenger ,  Los Angeles USA  (05.27.09)