News
‘Allah turned girl into dog’
Published: 11.06.05, 16:01
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
60 Talkbacks for this article
1. Still in the 7th century...
JJ   (06.11.05)
Maybe one day they can join the 21st century!
2. Sad , she wont be able to bring kids to the world...
Yonatan Arbel ,   Israel   (06.11.05)
well pupys are cute also especialy when they are arab puppys... but they always bite
3. WHAT IS THE ROMERS SOURCE
Hamedy ,   Germany   (06.11.05)
Hello, the sourece of all romors is israeli shabak, and later on one guy is saying they live in 7th century, ,
4. To 3
(06.11.05)
Of course this must have been started by the zionists conspiracy Now don't drop any korans, just in case LOL
5. hahahahaha
barcagrl ,   Tel Aviv   (06.11.05)
hahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahaha!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Finally something in the news we can laugh about....:) also #3 comment is very funny
6. to#2
rani ,   Gaza   (06.11.05)
Words of a racist pig.
7. Racists on Ynet news
Ahmad Abouali ,   Nablus, palestine   (06.11.05)
I can not beleive the racist slurs on this website! I had hoped that Ynet would have a higher standards than allowing openly , in the day light, some one , like post # 2, attacking the Arab nation on such low and vile diatribe?!?! Although the rumor is silly and out of this world of 21st century, most Arab muslims did not beleive it, nor they would...but mysterious rumors are an integral part of every society, whether it is modern or developing, for example: America has talk shows, shows (like the X files) and real TV shows!! so many Americans and many Americans do believe in them. In Britian there is the monster of a lake somewhere in Scottland (can not remember the name of the lake!) however, it is well known that stories, witch craft, and vodoism is well and alife in the West, incluidng Israel. maybe we have people who believe in the 7th century farey tales, and God's "wrath", and that is bad. But what is worse is to have an entire state & a nationhood based, SOLELY, on myths, and stories dated back to 3000 years ago, and that is a catastrophe, indeed!
8. i dont peleave that
jamal ,   nablus   (06.11.05)
its an israeli story to make islam like stupid one we dont bleave in this say and dont have any commit from jewish peaple arab and moslems one day lead the world and the will lead it again
9. Most Muslims don’t believe it?
Boaz ,   Ramat Gan, Israel   (06.11.05)
Hopefully that is the case, however, we have seen only recently how many Muslims (maybe not most, but definitely a lot) are willing to believe that a book, the Q’uran, had been flashed down a toilette. Flashing a book down a toilette will only jam, cause a flood, and damage the plumbing system around. Which is why believing in such nonsense is as ridiculous as believing that a girl had been turned into a dog. However, buying such nonsense has nothing to do with ignorance, an educated person can apply sound judgment and rational to the world around him just like a university professor, or even better. It’s hate and fear that make people believe in such things.
10. punishe
nana ,   genin   (06.11.05)
here in jenin need god justice .please god let all the dogs bite us before to change to human .it is fair to us and others
11. "Portable logic" by Boaz
Ahmad Abouali ,   Nablus, Palestine   (06.11.05)
No sir, the toilets you are talking about are not like the ones you use in Ramat Gan, the ones in Guatanamu bay are the type of the portable ones, i.e a whole in the ground, with prtable removal of ....... so, spare us your "portable logic" You can throw in these toilets (the same ones you can find in some parks in your "israel") litrary anything with out back "fire" on you. Sort to speak!!
12. Gitmo toilets
Sherman ,   St Louis, MO USA   (06.11.05)
Ahmad is correct, they are portable toilets, aka portajohns. I was stationed in Guantanamo Bay, Cuba for 3 months in 1992 during the Haitian refugee crisis. We had 14,000 refugees there at that time, and many toilets. The problem comes when people throw things in these toilets. The sucker trucks (that's what we called them) use a small hose to vacuum the contents of the toilets into the truck's tank. Anything, including pebbles, would clog up the hoses. Books, shoes or anything bigger than 1 inch would cause many problems. Even if there were several Qurans torn and flushed, does that warrant riots and murder? Let's talk about how Saudi Arabia treats Bibles found there.. they confiscate them and burn them regularly. They have probably torn and burned thousands upon thousands over the years. Compare that to 2 or 3 Qurans. It's not apples and oranges here, folks. It just sounds like people creating a reason for violence. I haven't heard of any Christians rioting and killing other humans because of the Muslims burning Bibles or burning churches. Sherman
13. Of course is propoganda
(06.11.05)
AGAINST ARABS by the jews- the NAZIS did it too- its not a new technique. I believe Someone should send this article to the ADL- the anti-defamtion league- though Abe Foxman does not seem to be the most even handed guy, he should see what Jewish people print to slander ARABS- www.ADL.org
14. Allah is Fair
Ahmad Mohammad ,   Palestine   (06.11.05)
Allah is fair , just, and mercyfull. Wjhoever made up this story is SICK.
15. So you see Ahmed, even with portable toilettes, the argument
Boaz ,   Ramat-Gan, Israel   (06.11.05)
Thank you for your correction Sherman
16. Vell said my muslim brathers
Ubul Kassim   (06.11.05)
This is yet another lie of the unbelievers to tarnish our beautiful and merciful society. How anybody in the world can believe that muslim people is supersticious, that such an improbable slur can take place in the same culture that believes, as stated in the Holy Qur´an that the unbelievers (christians and jews) are "sons of pigs and apes", or as it happened just today in Pakistan, a good muslim father killed his two daughters because he felt insulted by them, when they refused to bring him a glass of water. Nobody can give credit this is happening in the Ummah, the same Ummah that believes in "djinns", that glorifies the beheaders of civilians calling them "heroes". Those jews....
17. To Sherman from St Louis
Paulie ,   USA   (06.11.05)
Sherman, you're right. Bible burnings might be happening in places like Saudi Arabia, but I don't agree with you for being content about doing nothing to stop that. Muslem rioting when their holly book is discrated while chrisians do nothing whwn their holly book is burned only means that Muslems are more jelous about their religion and care more about it. Doen's the Bible mean anything to chrisians? I by no means promote violence. You don't have to be violent to get your point across, but you could at least complain and march peacefully to show your concern for your religion. Moreover, their is a truth that everyone for some odd reson ignore. Bible is not only attacked by muslims, it is also atacked visiously by jews. What jews do to the chrisian bible is worse than burning or flushing. jews attack the core and credibality of the bible, and if you don't believe me check this out, it's a story from the New York Times, March 9th 2002: http://www.simpletoremember.com/vitals/ConservativeTorah.htm Moreover it is also necessary to understand your enemy and know a little more about them before you attack them (many unnecessary wars were initiated for misunderstandings). Saudi Arabia for example don't like bible hanging around in their country, so they burn them however, burning a bible to the muslims is not a disgrase, it is a proper way of disposing of unwated holly books. When the Koran get old and falling apart, or when a verse of the koran has been hand witten on an unwanted piece of paper, muslims dispose of it by burning it. We must think unbiasely before we act.
18. to all the idiots
mike ,   tel aviv   (06.11.05)
all you idiots who can't read. this is not a ynetnews story, this is a story reported by an ARABIC NEWSPAPER. so all this silly crap about "israeli propaganda", "they invented it", bla bla bla bla bla, you can direct at your own arab brethern. The only think i left wondering is this: why is it that arabs always always believe in conspiracy theories, always trying to find different "explanations" and never face the truth. this tendency for living in fantasy is exactly why arab world looks the way it looks today. instead of dealing with the reality you deal with fantasy so while the world moves forward you're left stuck behind in your own dream world. how very sad
19. Yeah it's funny, but......
thegolem ,   Los Angeles, CA, USA   (06.11.05)
There are foolish Israeli Jews and foolish Muslim Palestinians. But the cause of keeping people from killing each other is ill served by repeating stories that show the worst of each other.
20. why act surprise ?
omar   (06.11.05)
jews were turned monkeys when they ignored God's rules. so there isn't anything amazing about this story...
21. Distorting image
Ricky ,   Nazareth   (06.12.05)
From all the events that you could have covered about the Arab Sector in Israel, It's a shame to see that you choose this useless one. Your coverage gives a distorted and negative idea to the reader about the Israeli Arabs that are educated and law aboding citizens.
22. Yiiiihooo!
Markus ,   Stockholm, Sweden   (06.12.05)
If Allah turned every arab that violated the word of the quraan into a dog, well, let´s put it like this, all the rest of us would live in a giant kennel. Seriously, It´s a fact that rumours and middleage beliefs keep many arabs back from the rest of the modernized world, wich is just a blunt pity!
23. why you are laghuing
(06.12.05)
you are not too much better in Israel , till now i can not forget when a TV chanel showed us some of the Jews praying on the crying wall with the mobile telephon on the wall that someone els on the line can pray too from far away .... can any body tell is it not for laughing ... cheating God by the new high tech ... it can be a new good buisniss , someone stay by the wall and the people calling him to pray ....gg... 1min. 1000shikel ... more expensiv than sex tel. ... did you like the Jocke ? of course not ... but you see it's hurting when when you try to hurt somebody in what's he belive ... try to learn how to be humanbeens not only Jews
24. Propaganda?!
Isac ,   Boca Raton   (06.12.05)
Yeah, yeah blame it to the others! It is something Arabs have in their blood: blaming others for their misdeeds, pursuing vengeance and violence!!! That's why they live still in such misery!!
25. Book desecration
Paul ,   USA   (06.13.05)
God is not a book. People burn books, tear books, even put books in the toilet, but people cannot do any of those things to God. God is not a book. We must worship God even if we have no books. In this way we cannot be trapped by material things. If we are in prison, and the guards take away our books, beads, cloths, rugs, crosses, or whatever other thing we call holy, we can still worship God, for only God is holy. If material things are holy, it is only God who can make them holy. Therefore worship God, and not the material things that men call holy. God is not a book. God is God.
26. wonder why its hidden from Hebrew readers
Ariel   (06.13.05)
all the western bloggers got it, English readers get it, but I guess Hebrew readers need protecting by the great wise people of the propoganda-masters.
27. Into a dog?
Pieter ,   The Netherlands   (06.13.05)
Why am I not surprised, when I read some of the defensive reactions on this story? It is like reading the reactions on an article about muslims in a Dutch newspaper. When they feel offended, and that’s kicking in an open door, the first thing they do is accusing the newspaper of bringing a rascistic article and after that they talk courage to themselves with slogans as: "arab and moslems one day lead the world and the will lead it again". Those poor muslims, they all live in denial. And they probably will react on this state of mind with: no we’re not!
28. Thank you Pieter #27
sherry ,   Florida USA   (06.14.05)
Finally a voice of reason amid all the BS. Why can't people just live in peace! Believe what you want to believe and let others do the same. There is one God over the universe and this God loves all equally. Nobody is better than anyone else and nobody has the right to insult people by calling them pigs. The whole thing was a stupid rumor and if you read the stupid tabloids in the USA (The Star, The Enquirer) their stories are just as stupid. Get over it and move on to more important things in life! Pick up the Quran, dust it off, kiss it and put it back on the shelf. That's what we would do with a bible or a Torah. Now go take a nice walk in a park somewhere and have fun!
29. Allah is fair
Michael ,   Austin, TX   (06.14.05)
I truly, honestly mean no disrespect to Islam. But, if Allah could do this to a bratty child...couldn't he also assist the Arabs in winning a war against Israel? I mean, the Arabs have lost every war with Israel...EVERY WAR. Perhaps Allah is trying to say to them "hey, I gave you lots and lots of land....I gave you lots of oil for wealth (would be nice if you shared...but that's too much to ask, I guess) and you have a population of over a billion. Why not let the Jews have tiny, little Israel...come on" Maybe Allah is trying to say that.
30. wha??
hhakim ,   ohio   (06.15.05)
its a rumor.. who knows could be true.. or not.. allah's will.
Next talkbacks
Back to article