News
Settlers say ‘No’ to notices
By Ynet reporters
Published: 15.08.05, 15:15
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
14 Talkbacks for this article
1. Black uniforms of troops- just like 65 years ago
Avi ,   Jerusalem   (08.15.05)
Not a coincidence.
2. To: Avi, Jerusalem #1
Rafi ,   Raanana   (08.15.05)
You are either a provocateur or you have simply gone out of your mind.
3. To Rafi, Raanana #2
Shlomo   (08.15.05)
Since when did IDF soldiers- or police, start wearing black? Ethnically cleansing Jews is provocative and insane.
4. People of Gush Katif WE SUPPORT YOU !!!
Yair ,   Israel   (08.15.05)
5. To Shlomo #3
Noa ,   Tel Aviv   (08.15.05)
Nobody is ethnically cleansing Jews. They need to move out of Gaza and into a part of Israel which isn't part of the territories. To compare this with ethnic cleansing is disgusting at best.
6. Re: #1 You're extremely outrageous
Blue Monkey ,   Haifa   (08.15.05)
I'm guessing that you never served in the military and are just here as a North American yeshiva "tourist". I suggest you share your opinion face-to-face with some of the people who actually protect this land, and we'll see if they appreciate your opinion.
7. Settlers, sharon and IDF are one in the same bed
Sal Azam ,   Chicago USA   (08.15.05)
Settlers are like ravening wolves in sheeps clothing. Thieves,murderers, hypocrites, liars just like Sharon and those who are supporting them. They are praying, crying like hypocrites occupying and stealing someone else is land and not leaving it at all. This is a sham game prepared to introduce a fake messiah who will be killed by the real one. Israel is on the path of self destruction and extermination.
8. Reality
LG ,   London   (08.15.05)
1940 Jews loaded onto cattle trucks against their will to take them to the gas chambers in a planned total genocde against the Jews 2005 Jews offered financial compensation packages to voluntarily leave their homes and relocate to new ones in Jewish state, where they are full citizens.
9. Ethnic cleansing!!
Big Bad ,   Toronto   (08.15.05)
The issue is no longer the rationale of disengagement,(which I believe is a terrible mistake when viewed in context of its appeasement to terrorism in the post intafada environment), but rather the crass mafialike way in which a corrupt so-called Jewish democratic government is handling the program-- the firing of some ethical cabinet ministers with pro Zionist views, the refusal to allow the people of Israel to have a say in this watershed decision despite the fact the anti-disengagement rallies numbers ran into the hundreds of thousands,the removal of the rights to protest of the "little people"(the stopping of buses,the incarceration of minors, the goonlike tacticts of the police, the stifling of the truth by a controlled media etc etc.), The by now well known disgusting conflict of interest scenarios involving shameful supreme court back room deals having to do with the PM and his family and Greek Islands,the promise of lucrative contracts to cronies for the rebuilding of Arab Gaza and its planned "Synagogue replacing casino"?? It is this shocking and disgusting background in which this retreat is taking place which makes this period one in which every Jew worldwide ,(no matter if he has left or right political leanings) ,can only hang his head in shame!!!
10. Blue Monkey Jobnik: I was in Sayeret Egoz
Avi ,   Jerusalem   (08.15.05)
You guess wrong. I have shared my opinion many times with many people- and most agree. Noa- It definitely would be considered ethnic cleansing. See the discussion here: http://www.ynetnews.com/articles/0,7340,L-3127505,00.html
11. Ethnic cleansing
Abu Ali ,   Sun city   (08.15.05)
first of all whose cleansing who ? last I checked 100's of thousands of Palestinians lost their land for security , settlements or bypass roads . I remember the case of An Arab doctor (who served in the IDF as a medical dotor) who was denied the rigth to purchase a flat (condo)in Tel-Aviv just because he was an Arab - oh no he was a Druze of an Arab origin .what a shame ,arogance and disrespect ,and you are talking about ehhnic cleansing . Ethnic cleansing is demolishing people homes for the lack of PROPER permits in their own land . Ethnic cleansing is when you forbid little kids from their schools in the name of security or make sick older people wait in check point under brazing Sun just for fun ...... have a nice day
12. My heart cries out for the settlers
T. A. Adams ,   Oklahoma City USA   (08.15.05)
And my prayers this day are for God to intervene in this madness. Sharon won in 2003 only because his opponent planned a unilateral withdrawal from Gaza. Sharon declared back then: "A unilateral withdrawal is not a recipe for peace. It is a recipe for war." The Jewish people of Israel cast their vote for this plan to caste Jews out of their homes when they voted for Sharon and that vote was NO TO WITHDRAWAL!! For him to lie to the people and stab them in the back this way is more than enough reason to call for his impeachment from office. Instead of cleansing Jews from Jewish land, they need to cleans the enemy from their office of Prime Minister!!
13. TO: Abu
T. A. Adams ,   Oklahoma City USA   (08.15.05)
How dare you!! The Jewish people know better than any other people in the world what "ethnic cleansing" is. They have been cleansed from every continent on this planet and the HEATHEN ARABS have cleansed and slaughtered more of their people than anyone, including Hitler! Now, this so-called Israeli government in this back stabbing roadmap to self-destruction has caved into the illegal demands of yet another bunch of land grabbing HEATHEN ARABS in an effort to cleanse them from their own land. So don't even try to preach your poor little arab camel crap to these people or anyone else!!
14. Get real
Chrisona ,   Chicago.IL   (08.16.05)
Jews are being expelled from Gaza because they are Jewish, and no Jews will be permitted to live in Gaza when they leave. That's ethnic cleansing. The fact that Jews are ethnically cleansing other Jews means that the world supports the action. In fact they like it so much that they'll want more of it, I'm sure.
Back to article