News
ADL: Rabbi should apologize to U.S.
Yitzhak Benhorin
Published: 09.09.05, 00:36
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
31 Talkbacks for this article
1. ISRAEL SHOULD SENTENCE HIM
F--.GOLDBERG   (09.09.05)
HE HAS DESTROYED ANY GOOD RELATION , HE PUT THIS MARK ON ALL JEWISH AND ISRAELI PEOPLE,,,, HE IS NOT A RABBI, BECAUSE A RABBI MUST BE JEWISH, AND HE IS NOT. A JEWSIH PERSON CANNOT SAY THINGS LIKE THESE AFTER THE LONG JEWISH HISTORY.... MISCHIEF, AND SPITEFUL
2. Rabbi Yosef's Comments
A. Yehudi ,   Melbourne, Australi   (09.09.05)
Of course everything that happens in the world is will. What we are witnessing in the world is midah k'neged midah. If America was a true friend of Israel Pollard would have been released long ago, And due to Americans not letting Israel deal with the Arabs as they desrve , they are now suffering at their hands in Iraq.
3. the last poster
pat ,   eu   (09.09.05)
ur a dumb ass
4. THE HEAD OF THEADL SHOULD APOLOGIZE FOR MARRYING A GOYA...
Chaim   (09.09.05)
THAT'S JEWISH DEFENSE? YOUR KIDS NOT JEWISH?
5. Rabbi blames Bush for hurricane.
(09.09.05)
I agree with the rabbi.
6. Yosef is a Rabbi?
Jennifer B. Griffith ,   Stone Mtn., GA, USA   (09.09.05)
As someone who knows victims of Hurricane Katrina, I'm appalled that this prominent person who claims to be a holy man would say such insensitive things about its victims. He has stooped to the same level as the extremist Imams who rant against Israel, and the white supremacists who gloat over the disproportionate number of non-white people who died. It's sad that he misguides his followers as he does. Apologies are in order from him to the many victims of this tragedy!
7. A Chillul Hashem
Zvi ,   Israel   (09.09.05)
It is sad that a man of Rav Ovadia's ststure be the cause of such a chillul hashem.
8. Not Jewish?
Tobias ,   Canada   (09.09.05)
You want to talk about not jewish? That is not kicking out jews by jews. You are so worried about world opinion that you neglect the suffering of your own people. The americans continue to sacrifice jewish life to please the blood thirsty arabs. Those are the facts. Whether the hurricane was a punishment or not, one thing is for sure, the americans are not our friends. They line us up to the murder. War against terrorism? sounds a bit biased when they support a palestinian state.
9. Apologize? For what?
Joseph ,   Malta   (09.09.05)
I do not think Rabbi Yosef should apologize. What he said is a principle in the Bible. Most people who prayerfully read the Bible will see that God will judge the nations that causes Israel to suffer. America and eventually to whole world will suffer as the time of the Messiah gets closer. Be careful all you nations for the wrath of God will spare no one! The faithful Jews and righteous gentiles will live with G-d on His holy mountain.
10. FOXMAN and ADL should APOLOGIZE TO US!
rani   (09.09.05)
foxman from the ADL is a well known idiot who made himself "leader" in the Jewish community... WHO THE HELL ELECTED HIM ??!?!
11. YOU MUST UNDERSTAND , HE DOESNT REPRESENT NO ONE IN ISRAEL
Goldberg R   (09.09.05)
MUST UNDERSTAND , HE DOESNT REPRESENT NO ONE IN ISRAEL . PERIOD!! He does NOT represent Jews or Israelis... I dont call him a Jew, Because he isnt (after all what history past, a man should know better). He is not a rabbi, a rabbi must be Jewish... He is Just a hippie wich runs arround with sun glasses and dresses, and is a mixture between sheik yassin to osama bin laden... He represents hatered and darknes, he should be sent to prison...
12. what a nut job this shmo is
(09.09.05)
13. Enough with all this nonsense !!!!!
Hiram ,   Tel Aviv   (09.09.05)
As I indicated in numerous talkbacks, so called "rabbi " Ovadia is no more no less than a Jewish equivalent of any Mollahs in Islamic dicatorship, using god to justify anything, and having nothing but contempt for non Jewish human life. Numerous comments on these posts have a very distinctive " national socialist" flavor with people refering to mix-marriages, indicating also a very limited approach to the world. As for Ovadia, ultra orthodoxes, and all these Jews living abroad who allowing themselves to defend people that this so called " rabbi", they all should remember that without America's help in the last 55 years, Israel would not be where it is today...When I read such idiotic comments, when I see so much hatred, contempt, biaised statement, and sheer stupidity , especially from those who do not have the guts to be in Israel and participate in the life of this country, I am ashamed of being a Jew. Ovadia is damaging the image of the country and of the jews...not only abroad, but also within the diasporah. He is no religious man at all, he simply is a ( very rich) lunatic who does not even deserves the title of " spiritual" leader. I am not sure that Israel deserves all the money that the USA pours years and again in this country....and Yes, I believe in God, yes I live in Israel and yes, he should present public excuses.
14. Answer to Joseph
Hiram ,   Tel Aviv   (09.09.05)
Joseph, What about those who do not pray,or relate God to the daily life, which is the vast majority of the Jewish people in the diasporah ? Too much Yeshiva going can make one losse contact with the reality... Ovadia is a disgrace to Jews and presents a danger for Israel, like the Shas and all the "nazi flavored" outlaws who condem whoever is not Jewish.....like the nazi did the other way around, preaching for " racial purity"...What a load of garbage, non-sense and idiocy...This country deserves definately better than that.
15. Answer to R. Goldberg
Hiram ,   tel Aviv   (09.09.05)
YOU know that story...the rest of the world does NOT.... You very well know that with distance, the information have a tendancy to loose preciseness.. Ovadia is seen as the ( leader) of SHAS, and SHAS is a religious Jewish party.....
16. Makes you wonder...
Nathan ,   Australia   (09.09.05)
I can't help but admit a lightbulb went off in my head when the news started talking about "forced evacuations" of New Orleans. Certainly makes you wonder.
17. Humeini ALAV HASHALOM can learn from the teacher RABI YOSEF
I'm not sure that ,   OVADYA is a jew   (09.09.05)
18. Rav Ovadia Yosef is correct!
Avraham ,   Netivot   (09.09.05)
Rav Ovadia Yosef is 100% correct in what he said. Rav Kadouri predicted this storm 6 months ago if the disingagement went through. Anyone who tries to destroy Israel or remove us from our holy land will feel the wrath of G-D. Abe Foxman should smarten up. He is the one who should appologise to the Jewish people & step down. He doesn't represent me. Am Yisroel Chai V'kayam!
19. ignorance, arrogance & bigotry
Howard ,   Pacific Coast, USA   (09.09.05)
The rabbi's remarks demonstrated colossal ignorance, incredible arrogance and offensive bigotry. In any case, the rabbi has completely missed what is truly important in this situation. As Jews, we are obligated, NOT only to study Torah, but ALSO to work passionately and devotedly at tikkun olam. Bigotry must have no place in our hearts. This goes doubly for our leaders and our sages, to whom we give the gift of our trust. Ignorance + arrogance is a very destructive combination. We are responsible for understanding NOT only our own laws and traditions, but ALSO the world in which we live and the people among whom we dwell. We are responsible for listening NOT only to our own people, but to our neighbors and our allies, and even to people who make themselves our enemies. To understand, we must listen. To learn, we must set aside blinding arrogance. At a time when hundreds of thousands of people are homeless, in fear, in pain as a result of the storm, our response as Jews and as human beings must be to reach out and help, rather than to invent ridiculous, racist theories that allow one to cheer and condemn.
20. Apologies
steven ,   france   (09.09.05)
"Rabbi"Ovadia,is no more a Rabbai,than the Mollah's who preach the same rubbish,When natural disasters,occur.It is utterly unacceptable' to use humane suffering,as an excuse ,to justifie religeous belief.and as a jew ,I am totally ashamed at this so called Rabbi's attitude,For any one who pretends such statut,to use the name of G-D,or Allah,as the cause for humane suffering ,does not deserve to "SERVE in his name.The USA has come to Israels aid many times ,and has been there as a friend,with a SHOULDER to lean on,and as in other religons,when for ex:a priest go beyond certain borders ;they are revoked,so should this "Rabbi"be revoked,We are talking about a human tragedy,where hundreds of lives were lost,and this "Rav"Insults just like the Mollahs G-Ds name . Another point,to be made here,is the Jewish people know and realise the unpardonable,statement,made,and are now asking that this "Rabbi" present Public excuse,But tell me ,WHEN A MOLLAH OR SOME "RELIGEOUS "IMAM?MAKES THIS KIND OF IDIOTIC STATEMENT,has anyone from the muslim world ever asked that he present public excuses??????Rabbi's and Imams who preach such calomny,should themselves be sent to these places of catastrophy,to do humanitarian work,and just "MAYBE"they might learn,what real human suffering is all about.&then they can turn to G-D for his help.
21. To Hiram, Tel Aviv
Joseph ,   Malta   (09.09.05)
Dear Hiram, Thank you for your reply. Those who do not pray or relate to G-d in their daily life whoever they are, will all fall under the wrath of God. I am not speaking of my own, but what the Bible teaches. It is the authority. The bible in fact says that at the end, two thirds of the Jews will be killed and the remnant will call upon "him whom they have pierced" (Zachariah 12:10). But as the prophet continues to say in the next chapters, the Lord will come and destroys all those trying to invade Jerusalem and He will reign from Jerusalem. We cannot change what God has determined to happen. Hear Oh nations! God will punish those who persecute His people and divide His land. Oh Jewish friends, Remember why you have been called; your responsibility to witness to a Holy G-d. Live according to the Tanach and act on what it teaches. Build to your G-d a temple; and before all things PREPARE YOUR HEARTS for the coming of the Messiah.
22. U.S. BREAKS LAWS IN MASSIVE VIOLATION OF JEWS' HUMAN RIGHTS
Linda Rivera ,   New York   (09.09.05)
The ADL is a strong believer/supporter of cleansing Jews off their land based on their Jewishness. 22 HUGE, OIL-WEALTHY Arab states cover over six million square miles, over ten percent of the land surface of earth. TINY, over-crowded Israel, only one tenth of one percent of the Middle East. Desiring another Islamic state in Israel, America is breaking U.S. laws which make it illegal to discriminate based on race or religion. Demanding forcible removal of Jews from the Jewish homeland based on race-Jews and RELIGION-JUDAISM. Making many thousands of Jews living peacefully on the land jobless and homeless. A most frightening and dangerous precedent is being established that Jews in other countries and other NON-MUSLIM people groups will suffer the same massive human rights violations as Israel’s Jews. Does the U.S. government plan to eliminate the laws which make it illegal to discriminate based on race or religion? Or, does the U.S. government plan to add a clause stating THE LAW DOES NOT APPLY TO JEWS? Persecuted Christians in Palestinian Authority areas live under Sharia law, their human rights destroyed by Oslo-Road Map. Breaking U.S. laws-Christians are discriminated/persecuted because they are not Muslim. This MASSIVE ATTACK ON JUDAISM AND CHRISTIANITY by the Quartet-U.S. EU, UN and Russia, has ominous implications for every Jew and Christian on earth. Where are the human rights organizations??? In 1922, Britain, illegally gave Arabs MOST OF PALESTINE-80%. The area became Jordan, giving Arabs an Arab Palestinian state on Jewish land. IT WAS ETHNICALLY CLEANSED OF JEWS. This area is part of ancient, Biblical Israel, and along with present-day Israel, including Judea, Samaria, Gaza, and the Golan, was recognized by the League of Nations as the Jewish homeland. Israel - cherished Holy Land of Jews and Christians is the greatest prize in global jihad. All Palestinian Authority maps show the new State of Palestine covering ALL Israel, with ALL of Jerusalem as their capital. The Islamist goal is the destruction of the world’s only Jewish state and its replacement with an Islamic one.
23. PA & OTHER TERROR GROUPS UNITED IN ANNIHILATION OF ISRAEL
Linda Rivera ,   New York   (09.09.05)
America's leaders are fully aware that the goal of the Palestinian Authority and other terrorist groups is total annihilation of Israel. An Islamic terror state in the Jewish Holy Land enables that goal. See part of article below: To view this item online, visit http://www.worldnetdaily.com/news/article.asp?ARTICLE_ID=45917 Tuesday, August 23, 2005 Islamic Jihad says all Palestinians united Leader says total annihilation of Israel joint strategy Posted: August 23, 2005 1:00 a.m. Eastern © 2005 WorldNetDaily.com In a news conference in Damascus, the leader of the Palestinian Islamic Jihad today boasted all Palestinian groups remain united in the goal of annihilating the Jewish state of Israel. With Palestinian Authority Prime Minister Ahmed Qureia looking on, Ramazan Abdullah, secretary general of the Palestinian Islamic Jihad, said the Palestinian Authority and all Palestinian movements have reached agreement on a joint strategy after Israel's evacuation of the Gaza Strip. "This war would continue till full liberation of Palestine, restoration of the denied rights of the whole Palestinian nation and briefly speaking uprooting of the usurper Israeli regime," he said, according to a translation by the official Iranian Islamic Republic News Agency..."
24. religion is based on fear!
moi ,   Tel Aviv   (09.09.05)
Who takes this ridiculous Ovadaia guy serously?? With his stupid sunglasses and tulband on his head. It is time for Israel to separate religion and state, maybe then we can join also the 21st century.....religion is based on fear, interesting to read some of the talkbacks here, why do we have to be afraid of this so called "God"? I don't want to be a part of a religion that we have to be afraid all the time...all religions are based on fear...what a shame...when do people start to wake up, maybe there is not such a thing as "God", maybe it is all up to us to make this world a better place...
25. ADL should stick to its job
Sigfried S. Kuhn ,   Aberdeen Md. USA   (09.09.05)
The ADL is needlessly responding to the message of a zealot and judging from the postings, many share his point of view about religion, faith, and Divine retribution.The Rabbis stratements are similar to those of other religious fundamentalists who blamed European Jewry for the Holocaust because they did not keep kosher. In their minds, that absolves the nazis of their sins. No one with these views will change their opinions and they do not feel the need to apologize for what they believe to be true. They have that right, just as most people have the right to be horrified at their statements. The ADL's statement does nothing to make a bad situation better. Just let the Rabbi and his followers further isolate themselves .
26. Moi is just as extremist as the Rabbi
Drumgoole ,   Newark, New Jersey   (09.09.05)
Moi shows himself to be prejudiced and ignorant when he declares that ALL religion is based on fear. In fact, Most followers of Judaism see their religion as a force for good--a guide to moral and ethical behavior. Some, not all observant persons agree with the Rabbis interpretations just as some, not all secular people are so prejudiced against those of faith as Moi is.
27. drumgoole
steven ,   france   (09.10.05)
In a certain way,Moi is right when he says that certain clerics & Rabbi's use religeon as a power tool.And yes every one has the right to ask the most famous question ever asked.DOES G-D REALLY EXIST?and maybe he does exist & has left it up to us to make this world a better place,to live in,after all we are all here on this planet,"that he created"together ,whether we like it or not,HE has given us the tools,& now it,is up to us to build whatever life we choose to build.Is'nt it much more simple when we can talk this way,a language we can all understand,the language of love & friendship,of tolerance,and respect of acceptance and sharing.Moi is not prejudice nor ignorant,Do you know him?Where is your tolerance,your respect,he is not saying that he does not believe in G-D,he says that "he does not wish to be a part of a religeon where one has to be afraid all the time,& certainly,religeons do preach love and tolerance,but what is unfortunately happening in today's world,it all comes down to religeon &this is now being used as a Tool of power,by these Fanatic Rabbi's & Imams,to control these people who are lost ,and are looking for certain answers,So you see,It does'nt have to always come down to religeon,in order to resolve our daily problems.If we all put our tools together ,and pulled in the same direction ,then maybe,we could build a better world ,If not for us FOR OUR CHILDREN.
28. apoligize for WHAT?????????
milagros ,   usa   (09.10.05)
PEOPLE DON'T SEEM TO LIKE WHEN THE TURH IS TOLD, HASHEM SAYS IT IN THE BIBLE I WILL BLESS THOSE WHO BLESS YOU AND WILL CURSE THOSE WHO CURSE YOU THIS IS THE ONE WHE SEND THE HURRICANE AND IS THE CREATOR OF THE WORLD, PEOPLE JUST DON'T LIKE TO HEAR THE TRUTH IN THEIR FACES , FOR THOSE WHO THI NK THIS IS RACIST GO BACK AND READ THE BIBLE VERSE BY VERSE, CHAPTER NY CHAPTER AND YOU'LL BE AMAZE AT WHAT HASHEM SEND THE BN'EI YISROEL TO DO AND WHAT HE HIMSILF DID TO PEOPLE WHO CURSE ISRAEL, JUST GO BACK AND READ BEFORE JUDGING ON HIS REMARKS
29. APOLOGIZE PART 2
MILAGROS ,   USA   (09.10.05)
LET ME ASK EVERYONE AND THE ADL SPECIALLY DID THE PALESTINIANS EVER APOLOGIZED FOR JUMPING AND SHOUTING AND LAUGHING DEATH TO THE USA MINUTES AFTER THE 9/11 ATTACKS, I SAW IT IN CNN AND ALL THE MAJOR NEWS AGENCIES HOW THEY JUMPED AND DOWN LAUGHING??????????????? NOW DI THEY EVER APOLOGIZED ?????????????????
30. He'right, its g-ds will!
Morris ,   Deal NJ   (09.11.05)
Of course the Rabbi feels for the victims and prayes constanlty for them. Lets not mix up what he's saying to make the issue orthodox vs conserv & reform. The Rabbi knows torah and its laws better then us, he knows!. Lets learn from this great sage and improve our selves and encouage the rest of the world to do do too. That's what he is saying.WAKE UP! its the month of elul
Next talkbacks
Back to article