News
Settlers disrupt Palestinian olive harvest
Orly Popper
Published: 16.11.05, 14:30
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
39 Talkbacks for this article
1. disgusting, yet is anyone surprised
dave ,   herzliya, ISRAEL   (11.16.05)
It's a shame soldiers have to waste their time defending villagers trying to make a living. Why do the religious zionists never acknowledge this sickness that exists among them and fight it?
2. Olive harvest
Lee Lipman ,   England   (11.16.05)
We as Jews need to remember how we have been treated for generations by our persucutors. If true there is not excuse for the army not to take immediate control of the situation and protect the Palestinian olive pickers. If our army and police can be seen to be fair and even handed in situations like this then maybe, just maybe it will help improve relations in these areas.
3. Could it be incitement?
Matthias ,   Switzerland   (11.16.05)
What I am missing in the above mentioned article are some more testimonies from sources other than Arab and the ultra-left. Also I miss the name of the Binyamin community which should not be very difficult to find out. Finally I suspect that this is just another slander by the media against the Jewish residents of Yesha. Bet that it will soon be buried in the depth of the website!
4. Show the evidence or shut up.
(11.16.05)
5. girls and olive harvest
moussa suwwan ,   France   (11.16.05)
I know not why Israelis do not like olive trees, this is not the first time you cut olive trees and agresse the harvesters..what a shame...
6. PA media constantly make evil false accusations against Jews
Linda Rivera ,   New York   (11.16.05)
Quite some time ago, Arab Muslims accused Jews of damaging their trees. What was the real truth? The Jews were completely innocent. The Arab Muslims pruned their trees and then accused the Jews of damaging their trees.
7. Go Harvest In arabia
MJ West ,   Philly, USA   (11.16.05)
I will incentivise you mushlums to get out
8. To musan asawa in france
MJ West ,   Philly, USA   (11.16.05)
Are you taking a break from rioting? Don't you have a beheading to attend?
9. moussa
ditty ,   USA   (11.16.05)
what olive trees are you talking about, there is no mention of olive trees being cut in this story. It is not that Israelis dont like olive trees, they dont like the palistinians who are harvesting the trees. And their dislike for palistinians is well justified since, the palistinians fire missles, while the israelis interfere with olive harvest.
10. to # 5
gil ,   ashkelon   (11.16.05)
I dont know too why Arabs dont like human beeings,endlessely killings and maiming Jews,Christians,Moslems and Buddists as well,as far as early days of Islam.Not mentionning burning cars in your country,blowing buildings everywhere,setting fire in churches,synagogs.Ah,sorry,it is not agression,it is a fight for euh..dignity
11. to # 5
dave ,   herzliya   (11.16.05)
But notice Moussa, how Israeli society looks internally and condemns those responsible for these aggressive acts (the hebrew site provides a better example). Seems very different from what I read, Moussa, of your communities defensive response to reaking havoc on France.
12. 5
Jared ,   Toronto, Canada   (11.16.05)
Taking a break from rioting to criticize Israel eh?
13. Ascherman & his olive gripe
Adina Kutnicki ,   NJ   (11.16.05)
Big freakin deal! Ascherman opines about olives, yet cares not a whit about Jewish blood spilled by his "poor" Arabs. Shut up Arik and get some self respect. By the way, the Arabs think you are a useful idiot, and so do I.
14. #5-YOU HATE CARS, I GUESS WE'LL BURN OLIVE OIL.
(11.16.05)
15. reply to 3, 4, 6, 7 and others
Steve Bann ,   New Orleans   (11.16.05)
you are talking about incitement, but this site is ISrael ! and it is brave enough to report on Israeli violations, and attacks against the reisdents living under Israeli occupation, and agression of the occupiers and settlers who stole the land
16. will wonders never cease?
(11.16.05)
yeah! right! of course the wild and wooly settler girls are innocent and the media is out to get them. It never fails -- the settlers get caught red handed and the right wing "back talkers" abroad are always 100% certain that the settlers are innocent. Well...once just once I would like to see the settlers and the "back talkers" take responsibility for their racists actions!
17. and iam sure you don't call this terror
aa ,   london ...uk   (11.16.05)
18. teenage thugs
david lazarus ,   london   (11.16.05)
we as jews given the torah to set an exemplary behaviour. I would like to know what there Rabbi has to say about these teenage thugs. Settlers you are a disgrace to the diaspora . how do you expect us to defend your rights. I thought it was forbidden to distroy the fruit of a person@s labour.
19. Why the arabs harvest our olives in our land?
Uzziel   (11.16.05)
20. # 6 & 13: Lind & Adina the Worier Princesses
Codi ,   USA   (11.16.05)
Its jews like you who hurt israel more the the terrorist. We can deal with the terrorists, but it is a hundred fold more difficult to clean the dirty picture your likes give about the jewish people.
21. To #8 Hilarious!
Dan ,   London   (11.16.05)
MJ West, your post made me laugh...nice.
22. Reality/morality check
George W ,   Chicago, IL   (11.16.05)
Hey Matthias and Linda, did you read this article? You say you can't see any proof beyond the radical left and the PA media-- what about the last paragraph, in the IDF's own words? Or do you consider the IDF to be a bunch of radical leftists in league with the PA? Given what settlers seem to think about the Israeli government these days, that wouldn't surprise me.... What drives me nuts about this conflict is how people on both sides become so totally devoted to their own side that they are absolutely incapable of seeing anything wrong with their side at all. Every time a bomber blows up a bus there's the same tired refrain about how the occupation started everything. That may be true (or not) but if you can't condemn a suicide attack on a bus full of kids, you're sick. It's the same thing on this message board. The settlers may have their reasons for moving to settlements. Those reasons cannot justify endless harassment and even murder of innocent civilians. (And no, that's not radical left propoganda, unless you count all the IDF reports on settler violence in Hebron, Itamar, Ma'on, and on and on as left propaganda.) People in anti-Israel protests often compare Sharon to Hitler or some nonsense, and in addition to being totally inflammatory, it's factually incorrect. People should be especially leery of comparing Jews, who survived the Holocaust, to Nazis. But let's be honest. The extremist hilltop youth, with their apocalyptic racism, genocidal transfer philosophy, and brutality, are no different than neo-Nazis and ultra-nationalists that exist in every country on earth. Read the stories of what these kids do, and then read about what the Hitler Youth did on Kristalnacht. It's basically the same story, and I'm fully aware of the significance of that comparison, but it's the truth. These people unfortunately exist everywhere, and the hilltop youth, Kahane Chai, etc. are Israel's version. And the fact that certain people on this board don't have the basic humanity to say any of that is wrong is disturbing. Thank God most Israelis despise people like this. I only wish the IDF and the courts would show some guts and punish people who need to be punished (rather than let everyone get off scot free, like they did yesterday--twice).
23. A bit of perspective needed perhaps
Mikael ,   New zealand   (11.16.05)
I'm amazed that a story of teenage vandalism makes the front page of your news. Compare the crime of cutting the Pals sacks to the vandalism of over 70 cars in one night in one of our main cities by a gang of 4.
24. #23 Mikael Your perspective is excellent!
Linda Rivera ,   New York   (11.16.05)
Jews get blamed for things they have not done all the time. Nice to hear from a New Zealander! Please comment more often! Which New Zealand city did the vandalism occur and who are the perpetrators?
25. USA needs to know
(11.16.05)
what they are welfaring- this is dispicable. ugly and gross. what kind of kids are you raising? I will send this to US congress.
26. just sent article to congress
(11.16.05)
Americans need to know that this allowed racist abuse by jews against PAlestinians makes no peace here-
27. to Linda
Mikael ,   New Zealand   (11.16.05)
Thanks for that and Shalom from NZ. Like I said I guess here teenage vandalism and bad behavior is not so much a big deal as it has failed to even make the main national newspaper. It only rated a small mention on one newspaper. Not alot of comfort for the 7o vehicle owners who have face huge repair bills. One homeless man was sleeping in his vehicle when it was attacked. He recounted his story of being terrified for his life and he has injuries as from broken glass. I believed it happened in Christchurch and the man identified them as being Maori. They haven't been apprehended. Not all is peaceful in this earthly paradise either.
28. #26-I urge fellow Israelis to buy Chinese it tastes better.
(11.16.05)
They'll let us deal with these vermin, like they do in Xingjiang with the Uighars.
29. were any of you ever there ?
elchonon ,   jerusalem   (11.16.05)
I was in tapuach during the olive harvest for 3 years... i have seen leftists set fire on the fields then blame the jews. i have seen arabs attack jews under the guie of harvesting olives, i have seen jewish property stolen and damaged...
30. You shouldn't talk moussa
???   (11.17.05)
The way your people have been aggressing the french citizens is deplorable and you should be ashamed
Next talkbacks
Back to article