News
IAF strikes in Lebanon
Hanan Greenberg
Published: 22.11.05, 08:43
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
26 Talkbacks for this article
1. strikes
(11.21.05)
BH
2. The Reason US Calls for Restraint
Marcel ,   Florida   (11.21.05)
It's always the same message of restraint to Israel and the same empty demands to the other side. The reason for this is that the U.S. is afraid Israel might win another decisive war against the enemy and this must no happem in order to placate the dejected losers of the past five wars. Israel must be restrained and never allow to defeat another arab army. This is the overriding agenda of the U.S. towards Israel.
3. & Israel has made it very clear too Mr. McCormack...
a gentle reader ,   Israel   (11.21.05)
"ve hadesh yamenu que kedem" "and renew our days as before" May the G-d of Israel hold His Mighty Hand over boys of the IDF-IAF! and somebody please say "Amen!"
4. Bomb Beirut- THEN Ask Them To Reign In Hizbullah
Yishai Kohen ,   YeShA, Israel   (11.21.05)
It's THEIR problem in THEIR country. They want responsibility over their country? Fine. Let them have it. WITH the consequences.
5. What does it mean to be a UN member state?
Howard ,   Pacific Coast, USA   (11.21.05)
First of all, the UN is composed of national governments. A government, by definition, has a monopoly on the use of force from its territory. If a government makes no attempt to prevent non-governmental terrorist/criminal gangs from attacking neighboring countries across international borders, it may be classified as a "failed state." Perhaps the UN needs a special probationary classification for such crippled regimes. I don't like to say this, because I respect the Lebanese civilians who risked their lives to push Syria out of Lebanon, and I think that if Lebanon were left alone by Syria, then Hizballah would have to quit this nonsense and Lebanon would make peace. Unfortunately, my preferences do not change the fact that Lebanon's government is NOT acting like a government, any more than the PA does. A government maintains a monopoly on the use of force and takes responsibility for conducting both war and peace. Period. Lebanon is once again headed toward civil war. The Lebanese should have learned the lesson last time around; terror gangs have no "off" switch, and once a country becomes a place that allows independent militias and terror gangs to run around freely with military hardware, conduct their own foreign and military policy, and face no sanction or arrest, these armies of gangsters will eventually create a situation of anarchy. What is inexcusable is that the Lebanese KNOW this; the last time they permitted this crap, it destroyed their previously successful country. Lebanese KNOW that terrorism always eventually consumes the country that hosts it, having watched this process in the broader Muslim world over the last few decades. And yet they are making the same mistake again. A country cannot have it both ways. It can either have a stable country with rule of law, OR it can let armed gangs control chunks of its territory and conduct private wars against the neighbors. Sadly, Lebanon is choosing the latter. So whatever Israel does, Lebanon is going to fall apart again.
6. U.S. TO ISRAEL: RESTRAINT, RETREAT, SURRENDER
Linda Rivera ,   New York   (11.22.05)
U.S. instructions to Israel in the art of war: Make your people jobless and homeless for your enemies. Give your enemies your land and assets. Abandon all your security measures. RESTRAINT RETREAT SURRENDER Israel, STOP LISTENING TO THE VOICES THAT WILL BRING ABOUT YOUR TOTAL DEFEAT! Please listen to tapes of Winston Churchill's speeches. Churchill said: "We will fight in the hills. We will fight in the streets. We will NEVER surrender!
7. what are u talking about?
(11.22.05)
its usa $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ and military aid that has made the tiny jew state powerful. and if you disagree- then give the BILLIONS of dollars back- and the equipment also-
8. #7
AK   (11.22.05)
Why is it that I never hear from people like you about Koreans giving back the billions we have been spending on them + the troops, while they demonstrate against us; or about the Egyptians giving all those billions back, since they were dancing in the streets while our people were taking dives off the 110th floor of the WTC and never support us; I don't hear anything about Turkey being asked to give back all the bucks after they had stubbed us in the back in Iraq. We're supporting the whole bleeping world of bitching ingrates, yet people like you only see the Jews and our help to Israel, even though only from Israel do we get anything back. Why don't you stop and think for a sec. And while you are at it, isn't funny that all those "things" keep happening to people and countries that attack Israel. Look at Europe and France and the mess they're becoming, after they have turned against Israel; and isn't it strange that after Bush started going after Israel, his popularity plummeted and he got problems at home and we got them abroad. I dread it when he and Condi open their mouths, and then I just don't watch the news .Yeah, the things about cursing and blessing the Jews may have something to it, after all.
9. Lindah! "whose we white man?"
(11.22.05)
as I recall you yourself have said on many an occassion t hat you aren't Jewish -- so exactly what are you talking about? secondly -- Now I understand why you cut and paste all the time -- you are a little low on the battery operated brain cells! goodness... nevermind just go away!
10. #7 PALESTINIAN AUTHORITY CALL FOR MURDER OF JEWS & AMERICANS
Linda Rivera ,   New York   (11.22.05)
Billions of American and European TAX DOLLARS have been given to the PLO/Palestinian Authority. PLO/PA thank the American people by calling for our murder on official PA TV. WHY DOES THE U.S. CONTINUE TO FINANCE THE PA WITH U.S. TAX DOLLARS? Sermon of Oct 13 2000 broadcast from Gaza mosque, Dr. Ahmad Abu Halabiya, on Palestinian Authority TV (transcribed by Memri): "Have no mercy on the Jews, no matter where they are, in any country. Fight them, wherever you are. Wherever you meet them, kill them. Wherever you are, kill those Jews and those Americans who are like them..."
11. #7 - Israel already repays the Amarican loans
Howard ,   Pacific Coast, USA   (11.22.05)
So what exactly are you asking Israel to return? And should Egypt, Jordan, Saudi Arabia, etc. also return the weapons they purchased from the USA? How about Germany and the UK? Should they also return the weapons systems they bought from the US? What about Japan, South Korea, India and Pakistan? Then there is the home-grown Israeli military technology, such as the Arrow missile defense system, which the US purchased, and Israeli drones, which other countries are using, and even BULLETS AND HIGH TECH BANDAGES, which the US military is buying from Israel. Should the US stop using it? Should Israel stop upgrading with Israeli technology American weapons for American allies such as Turkey? On the other hand, let's talk about Syria. Syria is a charity state and an economic basket case. Without constant help from the Soviet Union, its Arab buddies and others, it would sink into the desert. Without constant diplomatic protection by countries like Egypt (which convinced Iraq to stop criticising Syria for sending suicide bombers against it -- G-d alone knows why) it would be completely isolated in the world except for Iran. And it uses its arms to support terror gangs and destabilize every neighboring country. Why don't you call for Syria to give back the grants that have been made to it, and return the weapons systems that it is using against Iraq, Israel, Lebanon, Turkey and Jordan?
12. #7 - you are not very up on the truth
Christopher ,   Boston MASS USA   (11.22.05)
You really should look at just how much the USA really gives Israel and how mush is actually a loan. Then look at where that money HAS TO BE spent: the US. Yes, that's in the regulations Israel has to follow. By the way, shouldn;t we talk about the money given the terrorists known as Palestinians? According to the UN and EU, they are the largest per capita recipients of aid in the world. Yet they miraculously use the money only to buy weapons of terror and mansions for their leaders in Paris and Algeria. The people on the streets see nothing and are encouraged to kill one another, and anyone else, to make it appear they are wanting. Why not ask their leaders to give back the billions they have siphoned off and return it not to the donor states, but perhaps to the people that need it, rather than their Swiss bank accounts
13. Time To Finish Of These muslum Monkeys
MJ West ,   Philly, PA   (11.22.05)
it is high time
14. Re: #7 - U.S. "aid" to Israel
Fabia Fiortina ,   Los Angeles, CA   (11.22.05)
Israel receives no economic aid from the U.S. The approximately $3 billion in military "aid" comes with very stringent conditions attached. ALL of this so-called "aid" must be spent in the U.S. for the purchase of pre-approved weapons and materiel from pre-approved suppliers. These purchases create jobs for American workers, who would otherwise be jobless. Israel is forced to purchase goods from the U.S. that could just as well be purchased from Israeli suppliers, thus creating jobs for Israelis. All equipment obtained by Israel has been purchased and paid for - with the enormous profits going into American coffers. In addition, many of the advanced systems in use by the American military was either purchased from, or developed by Israel. Examples of this are the military drones employed by the U.S. in Afghanistan and Iraq - saving the lives of U.S. soldiers. As for U.S. "aid" having made Israel powerful, the War Of Independence was fought and won without a single gun or bullet provided from the U.S. In fact, the U.S. maintained an arms embargo against Israel until after the Six Day War (1967.)
15. Caused by syria but most importantly...
Jake ,   Germany   (11.22.05)
caused by brutal savages hell bent on destroying Israel. Hizbullah needs to be wiped out once and for all. Fuck what the rest of the world thinks. And while Israel is at it they need to strike Syria hard. The rest of the world is once again giving Syria a pass and in the mean time Syria continues business as ussual. Makes one wonder if this is a game or a sleazy many act play.
16. #7...misinformed ignoramous
Elliott ,   Tel Aviv   (11.22.05)
Hey genius #7....if you knew anything about the Israel US relationship you would know that Israel is REQUIRED to use most of the loans they get from the US to purchase US made weapons, planes, etc.... So it's already true that Israel 'gives the billions' back. Do some homework before you spout off your hatred.
17. at the end Israel ennemies will be disappear
gil ,   Israel   (11.22.05)
at the end , these who are proning the destruction the fear and the obscurantism and the middle age will disappear as so many Israel enemies in the past . Our force is coming not from dollars but our rage to survive and our intelligence to contribute to a better world. Rich Iran and its subcontractors have a totally different agenda The world should put an end to Iran agressive regime , not hesitate as their goal is clear : Domination of the arab world and then in a 2nd phase ....
18. to #7 we give them equipment and training too
(11.22.05)
thats why theyre kicking your ass
19. #7
Joe ,   Vegas   (11.22.05)
#7 is correct, but the "tiny jew state" comment seems over the top. We should all stop whining. Israel has handeled this incident well. Apperently, one young soldier from the 202 Paratroop Batallion killed all 4 terrorists in the infiltration attempt at the village. That young man deserves a medal.
20. #19 it was gdud 101 tzefa
(11.22.05)
21. America first
(11.22.05)
Israel is NOT america- its a state of problems, by its philosohy alone. it is based on RACISM. this is not USA's karma- let us go. find you own way.
22. #7
Sam ,   Jerusalem forever   (11.22.05)
Israel earns every cent it gets from America. Israel gives back a million times more then the billions they feed the third world dictatorial Arab nations. If you can tell me what they will give back other then jihad and suppressing their own people then you win! Until then, go to your medicine cabinet and empty all your drugs which keep you healthy and alive for they almost all were developed here in Israel. Take your cell phone and dump that too. Hate to tell you where that technology came from. As for your computer. Burn it. The genius of the lousy Jew state you so hate gave you the technology you use on your computer. Dumb ass I sure hope you don't have a Pentium chip in that computer of yours! Next time you check through an airport or ride a subway or need protection from the police make no doubt whose technology and training they use to help you and keep you safe. And btw: before you go to the hospital for a lifesaving scan or diagnostic procedure, hmm.....remember who most likely developed that. We keep you and your family alive. The irony is that we keep you alive so you can continue to slam the hand which feeds you. Israel cares for the entire world. When sick Arab children need surgery to save their lives Israel welcomes them with open arms. Even when their hate overrides our goodness and one or two slip through after they are cured and try to slaughter the innocent who saved them. We give the world a million times over as example in science, the field of medicine, mathematics, pharmacology, agriculture, up to the minute unsurpassed technology and vital raw intelligence the world needs to stay alive and function. Tell you what, turning the victims into the victimizers one of these days will backfire big time on people like you. Don't bank on the fact you can spit on us with your ugly comments and blackened heart and we will continue to reach our hands out to you. One of these days you might just come begging. It would serve you right.
23. BBC anti-Semitism as usual
Lemar ,   UK   (11.22.05)
I find it sickening that BBC TV news has not mentioned the attack by Hezbollah yesterday and the BBC website headline is "Israeli troops kill at least three Hezbollah fighters during a guerrilla attack close to the Lebanese border." when Hezbollah started the biggest attack for 5 years since Israel left Lebanon. The headline appears to mean Israel started the attack. This is blatent anti-Semitism and the person responsible should be named and sacked. Anyone know who this person is.
24. " give the Billions back!!"
Nomlas Fisher ,   Vancouver,B.C. Canad   (11.22.05)
That $$$ given by the U.S. was given so a lonely Democracy could surrvive!! So why should Israel start to kiss U.S. Tuchases(spell??my apology!) You don't Help a Neighbor Fight his House Fire,and then Excpect a return!...then again! if your the U.S.A. you do!!
25. #21
bobby ,   new york   (11.22.05)
all nationalistic movements have elements of racism. that's what makes it a nationalistic movement. howver, only zionism is considered racist. why? let's just say it's a french thing.
26. to #7 YOU GET MONEY FROM US AND EU AS WELL
(11.22.05)
ONLY YOUR LEADERS DESIDE TO BUY VILLAS IN ITALY FOR THEMSELVES AND NEW PORSCHES INSTEAD OF SPENDING IT ON YOUR PEOPLE WE SPEND IT TO DEFEND OURSELVES FROM YOUR SUICIDE BOMBERS GO JUMP IN A LAKE YOU IDIOT
Back to article