News
Iran: Israel should be moved to Europe
Yitzhak Benhorin
Published: 08.12.05, 23:46
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
160 Talkbacks for this article
1. Ssorry, mister, but G-d gave us this land...
Rachel BenDavid ,   Peduel   (12.08.05)
The man is a raving lunatic, but he did bring out a good point. We, as Jews, do not have a right to Israel because the Europeans killed millions of us. We have a right to this land because G-d gave it to us.
2. What's the difference ?
Shafiro   (12.08.05)
As a Christ follower I want to give my blessing to Israel. May GOD be with You!
3. Oppressed people in Iran..
Ahmadinejad ,   Tehran   (12.08.05)
in East-Kurdistan, West-Belutchistan, South Azerbaidjan etc. Will Ahmadinejad also remove Persians troops from the territories of those oppressed people?
4. Ahmadinejad
Jane ,   New York   (12.08.05)
It is he who should be relocated. We should relocate him to hell ASAP! I'm serious. Time is obviously of the essence.
5. We suggest you see our mushroom cloud.
(12.08.05)
6. strike
roland ,   brooklyn   (12.08.05)
israel should not waste anytime with this moron. Israel needs to strike iran as soon as possible and to shut his dirty iranian mouth..
7. sorry, your excellency
sam ,   potomac md usa   (12.08.05)
Sorry your excellency--Jews have been in the Middle East as ong as everyone else--in fact there were Jews in the Arab world before the Arabs even got there! Your problem is that you are repulsed by the very idea of dhimmis --"protected" non-Muslims--having any rights other than what Islamic law allots to them. Foirtunaely, there are some very nice people in Iran who do not agree with your extremist views--and as soon as you and your band of murderers are thrown out--Israel and Iran will be close friends as in the past--and your persecution non-Muslims--such as Farsi Zoroastrians and Bahais--will cease--and your persecution of gay teenagers--(you have hanged them in public executions) will be the subject of a trial in which YOU will be the defendant. Long live Israeli-Iranian friendship--and death to the meshiggeneh mullahs!
8. As a follower of CHRIST
(12.08.05)
I sya the jews have got to get their act together- They SHOULD NOT BE IMMIGRATING TO PALESTINE- they are not from ISRAEL-
9. Still searching for trouble
AMIR   (12.08.05)
It's obvious that the "young" Mr. Nadjad still searching for trouble for his country and his people, he won't back off untill he gets to know that what he was tought in his chilhood about the children of Israel isn't true, because G-D gave this land to these people not the UN nor the eurpeans. He seems he still doesnt get it yet, he believes in force, and he will see it soon, but just wait a little while. On the other hand, it's not a bad idea to have 2 Jewish states one the Middle- East and one in Europe, and why not in South America that's make it 3 and Africa where the diamonds are... Well Mr. Nadjad you are not bad after all!! you give good ideas! and what about a Jewish state in Iran?!!!!! Zé yeled tov Nadjad!!
10. The Big Push
Marcel ,   Florida   (12.08.05)
This replacement nazi has toned down from his first declaration to wipe Israel out ,now it's just move Israel. He sees that the Bush Road Map is working so well at moving Jews out of their land that he has jumped on the bandwagon . I'm sure he see that if the Jews are dumb enough to allow themselves to be moved out of Gaza ,Judea and Samaria ,that they will eventually succumb to complete removal.
11. Muslims out of Persia
Kyle ,   Southpark, CO, USA   (12.08.05)
Jews have more of a claim to Persia than Muslims do.
12. I propose all Muslims move to the moon
Zionist ,   Haifa   (12.08.05)
13. I feel sorry for the Iranian people
Tai ,   London   (12.08.05)
14. Follower of Christ
Jane ,   New York   (12.08.05)
If that's the case, then neither was Jesus the Jew. By the way, your praying to a Jew, moron.
15. The moon is too close
Ionatan ,   Argentina   (12.08.05)
I propose all muslims move to a galaxy far far away.
16. Ahmedinijad is worried about the Israeli State
J K ,   NYC, USA   (12.08.05)
and the rest of the world, including his own bosses, the mullahs, worry about his mental state. This guy actually does believe everything he says about destroying Israel or relocating the Jews or whatever. It's good to have people who 'telegraph their passes' so to speak because at least he isnt double talking. Destroying Israel isnt likely as he would also destroy and make uninhabitable the Qods he purports to love and want for Palestinians. Oh yeah, and he'd murder most of the Palestinians as well. Sounds like this moron really thought out his battle plan. Seriously, does this guy have a 3rd grade education or what?
17. The abyss is in the next corner.
Varei ,   Spain   (12.08.05)
Strike Iran it´s not a good solution. Iraq will turn into hell, and the entire Middle East will burn in flames. Iraq---Shia population will join Sunni against US troops.Iran could send hundreds of thousands "human waves" to Iraq.Thousands US casualties expected in days. Syria---Syria will join Iran against Israel and US. Lebanon--Hezbollah will strike Northern Israel. Egypt--Muslim Brotherhood will turn the country into chaos and will take the power.. Pakistan, Saudi Arabia---Potential uprisings.Fanatics extremists leading Pakistan after a coup will produce a Nuclear war. This is not a US attack against a weak and unpopular country like Irak.It would be a Israeli attack against a powerful Empire, and it could produce the most devastate Arab-Israeli war ever seen.Ahmadinejad knows it, and will lead the Islamic world against Israel, if Israel attacks. I don´t see any solution that Iran will have a few N-bombs.But it is worrysome that Iran really wants this weapons to be used.In that case, I don´t see other solution than strike Iran...and pray.
18. Purim !!
yoel ,   Switzerland   (12.08.05)
The only concern Iran has with jews is related to our celebrations during Purim. I just wish him a happy end as it was done to Hamann !
19. And so the fools keep giving the idiot importance
Miss Muslima ,   london england UK   (12.08.05)
Sigh.. Carry on giving Ahmedinejad the headlines he can't get any other way! What is Israel his free publicity machine? Or do you have some kind of secretive deal? Enough with the nonsense!
20. Let him keep talking...
Gil ,   Tel Aviv   (12.08.05)
It will be good that he says these things publicly so that the world will sympathise with Israel after it sends in the IAF to fuck Iran's nuclear factories.
21. Great idea
Peggi ,   Fr   (12.08.05)
It is really great idea.Most of the jewish are originally from Europe, it is better for all the world if this state been transfered to Europe. By the way, we welcome them in France.....
22. Welcome to this site Jew haters
Ram ,   London   (12.08.05)
To those who agree with this psychopath, it is sad you cannot see how mad this guy is. You are just blinded by hatred. For him to be elected President just shows what kind of people populate Iran. No doubt Israel has to deal with the Iranian threat no matter what the consequences. We know in the long term what consequences will follow if Israel does not act. The US and the EU carry on babbling without action but Israel will be the first to suffer the consequences. Give the US and EU an ultimatum to stop Iran from attaining the bomb. One month is enough. If they do not act then Israel MUST. Worry about the consequences later.
23. Peggy
Jane ,   New York   (12.08.05)
Yeah, we know what kind of welcome Jews get in France - awful. Furthermore, a large percentage of Jews DO NOT come from Europe. They come from the Islamic lands they were thrown out of.
24. Keep talking...
Frenchie   (12.08.05)
25. Digging up his political grave
Hiram ,   tel aviv   (12.08.05)
There are good chances that economic sanctions will be imposed upon Iran , thus contributing to a change in the government unless the change takes place faster than planned. Mahmoud the nazi continues , like his supported in the middle east, to spread national socialistic and populist views. Iran is in economic shambles and cannot be considred a nation worth of maintaining political relations with. Dicators do not last for ever . Mahmoud the nazi 's life may be shortened before long.
26. IRAN
DANIEL RIMOKH ,   LOS ANGELES   (12.08.05)
WHO IS THIS NUTS......THIS CANCER SHOULD BE DESTROYED.....POOR IRANIANS PEOPLE HOW THEY LET A NUTS LIKE HIM TO GOVERNE THEM.....IT IS NOT WORTED TO TALK EVEN ABOUT HIM...HE IS A LOST CASE....THANK YOU...DANIEL RIMOKH
27. Peggi
Ram ,   London   (12.08.05)
Go educate yourself Peggi and "get a life".
28. International Law States Pre-emption Allowed
Adina Kutnicki ,   NJ   (12.08.05)
I dream of the day that this monster meets the same fate as Rantisi and Yassin. Why is Israel allowing him to breathe a moment longer? Afterall, he is the one who proclaimed his genocidal intentions for all of Israel. In this regard, according to international law it is permissible to pre-empt him before he acts on his genocidal intentions. International laws are NOT death pacts. There are no ifs, ands, or buts about this law.
29. #22
NP, Israel   (12.08.05)
We cannot deal with them as we know that's exactly what he's trying to acheive, if we will attack the whole islamic world will turn on us, he won't really shoot nuclear bombs at us, he's not that stupid. We have the 'hez' (Arrow) missile that disables ballistic bombs before they even return to earth, if it's through a plain it will be shot down before it even comes near israel as we have sohpisticated radar systems, at least in IDF.. It's impossible for them to attack us as well because then the good part of the islam will turn against them, or at least that seems logical..
30. Good idea but not to the UK please!
accessol ,   Spelthorne, England   (12.08.05)
We have more than enough enough ex-Apartheid-supporting white South Africans here in the UK without an influx of another lot of racists; if the Zionist settlers have to go somewhere I suggest Australia; that country is far away from the civilised world and has a long experience of absorbing the unwanted and the criminal rejects of society. And its current government is part of the Sharon-Bush-Blair-Howard axis of evil, an ideal destination for Zionist refugees.
Next talkbacks
Back to article