News
Katz: Bomb Strip, make Gazans flee
Ynet reporters
Published: 21.12.05, 11:50
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
26 Talkbacks for this article
1. Katz's brilliant idea
Michael ,   Haifa   (12.21.05)
Fatty Katz could chase them out, shedding kilos in the process...maybe Sharon could join him in the chase and Israel might yet enjoy a really healthy leadership
2. Katz ...another brainless being
Nabulsi   (12.21.05)
For any decent human being with brains it is very clear that there will be no military solution to this problem, so lets stop the nonsense and stop the occupation!
3. Proof positive
Michael Steiner ,   EU   (12.21.05)
that the Liqud has turned not only into an extremist fringe group but that it is now a racist sect whose top members openly advocate committing war crimes against humanity. FIRE KATZ IMMEDIATELY!!!
4. Well, there is no occupation... ;-)
(12.21.05)
5. #2Katz ...another brainless being
sam ,   ashkelon   (12.21.05)
he has more brains than than all you left wingers put together, i live in ashkelon and would like to continue living there, we left gaza when ashelon was not being bombed and now we are so where's the logic of giving up more land, and you talk about being brainless!
6. racists?
(12.21.05)
For a jew to say it is okay to kick a Jew out of his home and then say it is a racist policy to transfer arabs has his head in his behind. Why is it okay for one and not the other. If Jews and arabs are going to disangage from each other, so lets do it. All arabs out of Jerusalem and Jews out of the shomron and judea. Or how about all arabs go to neighboring countries and let Jews live in peace in their g-d given land. Your double standars are anti-semetic. Lets not fool ourselves, Islam has a goal to take over the world, we can see it everywhere right now. They are calling for a holy war, it has started already and has no boundries. Lock your doors EU, learn from the French.
7. i envy jews for the number of psychos they got
Khaled ,   Jerusalem, Palestine   (12.21.05)
if we arabs had that many psychotic politicians among us, israel would be a mere myth now.
8. I'll fly the plane...............
ari ,   Eretz Yisrael   (12.21.05)
9. Extreme Solution for Extreme Enemy
Marcel ,   Florida   (12.21.05)
The ONLY thing that will bring Israel peace is the sound defeat of the Palestinian Terrorist Army.Eventually it will come to this. It will take the death of a few thousand Jews though before the apeasers and fools get serious and clear out the terrorist swamp of Gaza. Those who side wiith the terrorists of Gaza will have their day as did the vichy French finally did.
10. Look who's talking
michael ,   Israel   (12.21.05)
\Your the ones who beat off your fore skin with a blunt rock at age thirteen, and if that's not bad enough what about the women who bee toff their citorus as well at age 12. and all because of a mistranslation of the hbrew holy texts
11. I do not agree
Robert Goldman ,   cooper city Florida   (12.21.05)
and I served for 2 1/2 years in Gaza. in the begining I sad let them have what they want just wall it off! (1986) in the End I said "Rent it to "SAC" as a bombing range (1989) but now I say give it back to the Egyptians and let them deal with it. Hell they bitched and moaned for TABA we should have said Sure you can Have TABA as long as you take GAZA!!
12. #7
Robert Goldman ,   cooper city Florida   (12.21.05)
Hell son you have had Millions of Psychos on us since before 1948 and you never beat us yet!! we chased your sorry asses all the way back to Bagdad and every other country the psychos came from to distroy us. PS look at the psychos blowing themselves up daily on the news. you have millions of them and Israel is still here!!
13. One set of rules
Yossi ,   Canada   (12.21.05)
Either it is acceptable to fire on civilians or it isn't. Black and white. If the arabs shell our civilians then we MUST shel them back. No gray - just one set of rules.
14. khaled you moron
(12.21.05)
keep living out your stupidity, we love to read it
15. Goodman,Robert
Marcel ,   Florida   (12.21.05)
What happened ?Did you drink the water in Gaza. You don't see the,mortal danger ,the insanity of having Egypt up your pant leg ? Even with all the transfer of terrorists and weapons into Gaza from a helpful and knowing Egypt, you go along ? What is wrong with so many of you ?
16. Why not
Yohn   (12.21.05)
Tell the civilians to their will be a bombing and go ahead
17. Response to Khassams
L A (Michigan) ,   Grand Rapids MI US   (12.21.05)
So far, the onlly shelling has been of empty fields...Shelling of empty fields is to military action what masturbation is to sex!
18. Learn to accept Israel
Adrien ,   Detroit U.S   (12.21.05)
The Jews have their state, they have valiantly fought for it, and arent going to leave. The Arab people need to get over it
19. Gazans wont learn until...
Gil ,   Tel Aviv   (12.21.05)
we bomb them into submission. But that wont happen until they set off a mega terror attack in Israel taking out hundreds.... the "us and them" reckoning will eventually happen, it will never be resolved peacefully.
20. LOSER
Salameh ,   Gaza, Palestine   (12.21.05)
A guy who couldn't even impress his fellow right wingers at likud to tail the list for 5.5% should go and hide for months in shame ! But being a hateful he is, he comes back and attempt to join Fegilins and his likes to incite against us. My advice to this loser is, go buy yourself a miserable flat in a moshav and don't show your face to no one LOSER.
21. #8
caro ,   beaver,usa   (12.22.05)
don't wait too long to get your licence. :)
22. LDS is the only way
alan ,   san francisco   (12.22.05)
I know that the LDS have a plan for Gaza and it is coming don't you worry. There is someone who foresees all, who knows what will happen. It is coming from Canada to you. And it is called Team America to your front door. Off we go into the wild blue yonder.... off we go into the air now we dive heading to meet that thunder have the boys.....
23. Sinai
Sinai ,   Sina   (12.22.05)
Exodus of the Gazans to Sinai? Sinai is not empty desert. After Gaza bomb the Sinai. When Gazans flee to Egypt, bomb Egypt. Get lost, Katz. Solve YOUR problem at the homefront. Is this the real idea behind the Sinai travel warnings? Keep the Sinai Israeli free to have the Gazans go there and then give Israel the right to complain about insecurity and danger in Sinai?
24. Mine fields
TRUMPELDOR ,   eurabia   (12.22.05)
Israel shoul deploy an extensive minefied all the way from beit hanoun to officel borders Palis would not be able to launch their kassams...
25. #17 - Crudely put - but accurate
Avital ,   Los Angeles   (12.25.05)
26. A reasonable, moderate response
Fabia Fiortina ,   Los Angeles   (12.25.05)
Minister Katz states that “The government has to adopt a more useful deterrence policy. If there is no calm here there will be no calm there." This is no more than stating the obvious. You cannot have peace and safety on one side while the other side suffers under constant bombardment. He goes on to state "If the options are that Israeli southern communities suffer rocket fire or Gazans flee to Sinai under Israeli bombardment, I prefer the second option.” He does not say forcing the Gazans to flee to the Sinai is desirable, he merely says that Gazans need to be made responsible for their behaviour. 'You will have peace if we do.' He further clarifies his aversion to the involvement of innocent civilians, “I never said we should hit civilian population centers, yet there is no escape from hitting launching sites, even if they are situated among civilian populations, as long as we warn the population that we are about to fire.” Far from calling for irresponsible military action against civilians, Mr. Katz merely states that use of residential areas from which to launch missiles at Israel cannot confer immunity from response. In fact, he calls for giving the civilian population prior warning of Israeli intentions. Unfortunately, the Israelis under attack do not receive similar consideration.
Back to article