News
Hebron declared closed military zone
Efrat Weiss
Published: 17.01.06, 00:28
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
32 Talkbacks for this article
1. shameful behavior! arrest the parents 4 abusing children!
(01.16.06)
arrest the parents and charge them with contributing to delinquency of minors and for allowing disrespect of IDF!
2. truly awful!
david shaw ,   london, uk   (01.16.06)
Although i can't quite bring myself to say that the quoted arab was being completely truthful (if at all!), i cannot begin to put into words how DISGUSTED i am at how the settlers are behaving! This surely is too low, for any jew, anywhere in the world. This behaviour is so awful and i hope that the authorities come down on them like a ton of bricks!
3. Land made judenrein, by other jews
J ,   UK, London   (01.16.06)
What in the world is going on when the Israeli establishment is ordering jewish towns to be cleared of jews in order to appease muslims. I suggest the residents of Judea/Samaria re-start the Medinat Yehuda (state of Judea movement) so they can the message that they are there to stay, into the minds of the money corrupt socialists running Israel who seem to be so intent on destroying jewish history and jewish lives.
4. IDF helping Islamic Terrorists
Marcel ,   Florida   (01.16.06)
The Jihadists have always said that they would drive the Jews into the sea. How improbable that it would be Jews and thier Army that would assist them in thier goal. There is anger in heaven and it will be felt against those who do this eviil to their own as they reward terrorism. Palestinian terrorism is once again rewarded ,so we see that violence does pay.
5. To #3 J- how many Jews must die?
David ,   Karmiel, Israel   (01.16.06)
Please tell us your secret plan for protecting 400 Jewish families from 160,000 Jew hating Arab Terrorists. Those are the odds and I would like to know how many Israeli soldiers must die for this "cause". My solution is simple. Get out of the isolated settlements and give the terrorists their state where they stand now, close the door and throw away the key so that no Palestinian can work in Israel ever again. They need help, let the Saudis, the Emirates and Jew hating, Holocuast denying Iranians help them. You use the world "judenrein". Strange for someone who lives in the 3rd most anti-Semitic country in Europe! By the way, who gave Hebron away in the first place? Not the "corrupt socialists running Israel who seem to be so intent on destroying jewish history and jewish lives" but the great capitalist Prime Minister of one of the most scandalous and corrupt governments that Israel has even had: MK, Chairman of the Likud, Benjamin Netanyahu!. Remember the Wye Plantation Agreement, J?
6. David ,Karmiel, Israel - perfect answer
Gabrielle Goldwater ,   Geneva Switzerland   (01.16.06)
The UK is the last one to give advise..... it is thanks to them. They took a pencil and drew a line on the map, They took over that racist term from the Romans, and called it Palestine...... To add insult to injury, to the Jewish homeland. They did the same weherever they put foot the Brits, same thing in India, thanks to them there is a Pakistan since it was the Brits that devided there as well
7. is the prob now with the uk!?
eyal ,   brazil   (01.17.06)
come on... the main discussion in the 2 last messages were about if the UK acted correctly or not :P what about discussing the article? :)
8. Gabrielle, you are one
CZ ,   NYC   (01.17.06)
to talk, speaking from Geneva, the capital of Eurabia. I was in Geneva this past summer and there was hardly a sign, bank or otherwise, that wasn't in Arabic!
9. reply to #5 (David's simple solution)
sk ,   USA   (01.17.06)
David's simple solution is a rhetorical "lock 'em up, throw away the key." Except, alas, that there is no lock & no key. What you can do is set them up right next to you so they can attack you more effectively. That’s what David’s solution amounts to. However, David's "secret plan for protecting 400 Jewish families from 160,000 Jew hating Arab Terrorists" leads me to ask him for his plan to protect Israel (a few million Jews) when they are surrounded by how many hundred million Arabs? Clearly, David has no solution at all.
10. Traditional zealot behavior and manipulation
hiram ,   tel aviv   (01.17.06)
Of course most of those who participated in the riots do NOT live in Hebron and we knew it ! The riots are provocation from the Extreme right fringe of a population which sometimes does not even recognize the State of Israel. There hatred is based on religious beliefs and their limited approach the the world prevents thjem from understanding the situation. These " youg kids" raised in the hatred of the Non-Jewish and the non-religious( exactly like on the other side ) are tarnishing the international image of the nation and indeed should be handled as outlaws. Enough of this unruly conduct and unnecessary provocation ! This young and intellectually fragile population is being manipulated by treacherous politicians and Jewish religious leaders.
11. Who is worse, ham-ass or corrupt Jews stealing Hebron homes?
Bunnie Meyer ,   Santa Monica, CA   (01.17.06)
12. Israel punishes Jews and let's hamass members free!?
Daisy ,   USA   (01.17.06)
What a joke Israel is becoming. It might as well give all the land to the Arab land thieves and push all the Jews in the sea.
13. PUNISHING JEWISH INNOCENTS.REWARDING ISLAMOFASCIST MURDERERS
Linda Rivera ,   New York   (01.17.06)
10,000 Jews were punished for not being Muslim. The land and businesses of the hated infidel Jews were confiscated and given to Muslims. Muslim mobs destroyed Jewish synagogues where G-D was honored and exalted. Jobless and homeless Jewish refugees are forced to pay mortgages on their destroyed homes! This CRUEL and FRIGHTENING IDEOLOGY that PUNISHES JEWS for NOT BEING MUSLIM MUST STOP! An Islamic terror state in Israel is the international reward and approval for over 26,000 terror attacks against Israel in the last five years and the maiming and murdering of thousands of Jews. Rewarding those from many nations who finance the terrorists, and those who arm and train them. Rewarding Palestinian Authority Minister Mohammed Dahlan who was in charge of coordinating the withdrawal with Israel-terror master who is responsible for the bomb attack on the Israeli school bus in November 2000 in which two school teachers were killed and three children from the Cohen family lost their legs. Rewarding Islamic human bombers for blowing up Jews and destroying the lives of survivors who have nails from the bombs embedded in their bodies. The bombs are filled with metallic objects to maximize the suffering of survivors. Rewarding Palestinian Authority Muslim society who celebrate by the thousands in the streets when innocent Jews are murdered by homicide bombers. Rewarding the Palestinian Authority for teaching through their mosques, media and public education system that murdering Jews is a religious obligation. Rewarding the Palestinian Authority for hailing as heroes the savage murderers of defenseless 8 months pregnant Jewish Gaza mother, Tali Hatuel, and four little daughters in Gush Katif in May 2004. Rewarding the sermon (and many similar) of Oct 13 2000 broadcast from Gaza mosque, Dr. Ahmad Abu Halabiya, on Palestinian Authority TV (transcribed by Memri): "Have no mercy on the Jews, no matter where they are, in any country. Fight them, wherever you are. Wherever you meet them, kill them. Wherever you are, kill those Jews and those Americans who are like them..." Genocide and/or planned genocide breaks international law.
14. 7,380 DEMOLITION ORDERS AGAINST PALESTINIANS NOT IMPLEMENTED
Linda Rivera ,   New York   (01.17.06)
Jews are violently physically assaulted by the IDF and police; Jewish homes and communities are destroyed; Jews are made jobless and homeless for one reason: THEY ARE NOT MUSLIM! THIS CRUEL AND FRIGHTENING IDEOLOGY THAT PUNISHES JEWS FOR NOT BEING MUSLIM MUST STOP! 7,380 approved demolition orders against Palestinians not implemented Aaron Lerner Date: 13 January 2006 Hatzofeh newspaper Correspondent Chagai Huberman reports today that as of now there are no less than 7,380 demolition orders against illegally built homes built by Palestinians in the West Bank filed by the Israeli Civil Authority and approved by the courts that have not been carried out. In addition, Huberman notes, the Civil Authority has initiated a program under which Palestinians [but not Israelis] can apply for the head of the Civil Authority to waive the demolition orders on both legal and such humanitarian grounds as : the person invested all his savings in the house, the head of the household has many children, etc. With regard to illegal construction inside the Green Line, Huberman reports that data from the Ministry of Interior shows that during the period 2003-2004 alone no less than 352 illegal Bedouin outposts were built in the Negev. Huberman notes that the Arab MKs were rewarded for voting in favor of the retreat from Gaza and northern Samaria by the approval of the hook-up of hundreds of illegal Bedouin outposts in the Negev to electricity. Dr. Aaron Lerner, Director IMRA (Independent Media Review & Analysis)
15. my head hurts...
Marc   (01.17.06)
I dont know what bothers me more: these people getting thrown out of their homes or the way they are responding. What has this world come to...
16. YNet - Hang Your Heads In Shame
Adina Kutnicki ,   NJ   (01.17.06)
YNet should hang its head in shame for producing this libelous report. YNet knows full well that the marketplace that the authorities are trying to evict Jews from is absolutely, positively Jewish owned land. The deeds are there for ALL the world to see - even YNet. The issue is this - if the authorities were to throw YNet people out of their homes, what would your people do? Would you bring the forces flowers, candy, perhaps a marching band? The PA Arabs have been tromenting the Jews in their 2nd holiest site for years. And what do our once venerable security forces do? They turn on the Jews and placate the Arabs. And the left wing media try to paint the Jewish vicitims as the aggressor. Outrageous. Who cares if the youths are wearing face coverings so that the shabak cannot torment them for years? Are they considered the same like the Arab masked terrorists who tote assault rifles, bombs, rockets etc to kill your fellow Jews? These Jews are tossing tomatoes and paint. Surely the well protected forces and the brutal Yassamnicks can take it. I am sure that if the Jewish youths were to let the security forces and the gov't know that they too will create an intifada they would back off. Imagine that. The Arabs in Jerusalem and its suburbs have built 6,000 ! illegal structures. Do the police and IDF tear them down? Of course not. In a reverse and pervers discrimination against its own people, they have decided to tear down legal ! Jewish homes. Israel is going to hell in a handbasket due to the policies of this thoroughly corrupt regime.And YNet helps them get there.
17. To David Shaw
MARK ,   USA   (01.17.06)
The British are responsible for all of this fighting by not giving Transjordan to the Palestinians and Israel to the Jews. Instead they created a kingdom of Jordan which should go back to the Palestinians. Your country made a mistake and needs to fix it and take responsibility for once. Your country is why there is so much fighting because your country made one royal mistake.
18. the thing about the photo of the troops
sam ,   ny   (01.17.06)
the M-16 are not loaded. j
19. Learn from Gaza
Ken Dalton ,   Toronto Canada   (01.17.06)
If the Jews, who first "settled" in Hevron 3,500 years ago would only get some Qassams then the Israeli Government would stop treating them like the enemy, and leave them in peace!
20. #8, are you smoking crack?
edward ,   las vegas   (01.17.06)
i was just in geneva two weeks ago and didn't see a single word in arabic! i have been to zurich over a dozen times the past year and have never, ever, seen a single word in arabic. i have seen the right wing government in switzerland oppose softening the rules of 3rd generation swiss people gaining citizenship by posting signs in the train stations which show dark skinned hands (moslem, african) reaching into a pot of swiss passports. but no, never any signs in arabic. maybe it is time to put down the crack pipe. and on another front, heres some good reporting http://www.truthout.org/docs_2006/011606D.shtml
21. Ynet! You are Pigs!!!!
Marissa, ,   Shomron   (01.17.06)
I won't even bother commenting. This article just shows us how low you have gotten. Doncha remember the time like 4 months ago during the disengagement when u were publishing articles about what good people the settlers are? What the hell happened???? I'll tell you: Journalism
22. THE RAGE OF ISRAEL'S LEFT IS RESERVED FOR JEWS ALONE
Linda Rivera ,   New York   (01.17.06)
The terrorists laugh all the way to the bank with mega U.S. and European TAX DOLLARS. It's land for war! Displaying absolute contempt for Israel's plight of being in a state of war and under continual attack; the U.S. EU and UN are ruthless in their demands that Israel does not fight back, but give continual victory to her enemies! The Jewish Biblical heartland of Judea and Samaria has been designated next on the list by the U.S. EU and UN, for ethnic Jew-cleansing and Islamic conquest! Jew-haters, Peace Now, and Israel's left, do their job of demonizing and creating hostility towards the hated religious Jews of Judea and Samaria. False accusations of tree cutting is part of the hate propaganda against religious Jews! The Islamofascists celebrate their savage murders of Jewish children and pregnant Jewish mothers, but the rage of Israel's left is reserved for the religious, law-abiding Jews of Judea and Samaria. It's not just Islam that despises Judaism! Israeli leaders in 1967, gave control of Judaism's holiest site, the Temple Mount, to Muslims! The Jews of Judea and Samaria, are to be punished for following Judaism! 250,000 Jews ethnically cleansed; rendered jobless and homeless and their confiscated land given to Muslims! The raison d'etre of the genocidal PA society is the mass murder of Jewish innocents. Palestinian Authority society are taught murdering Jews is the highest goal in life and attains paradise: http://www.pmw.org.il/AFD.html
23. For 400 Jews, 200,000 Palestinian should suffer
Al khalil, Palestine   (01.17.06)
This is what is happening in Hebron. This is what the God of Isreal wants. A return of Jews to the Holy Land. Only Jews should live in Hebron. Others who happen to have bodies like Humans and souls like humans and humor like humans and appear humans do not deserve to live there in peace. Because they are not the Jewish Humans! This God of Israel does not care about other human beings except the Jewish Human being. Only he deserve a land to live on. Others are just their slaves and servants. Now and only now I understand the Jewish diaspora. It is something that they caused by their hands by insulting and mistreating the others. Remember Jews, you live among other human beings, and you do not live with God on this earth. Keep your fanatic views when God descend to here to live with you. But as long as their are non Jews on this earth. You simply have to show respect.
24. "That [settler] bitch is a barbarian"
Michael Steiner ,   EU   (01.17.06)
They are ALL punkass scum and barbarians. I keep saying they're not Jews and certainly not Zionists. More infuriating though is the total impotence Tzaha"l has been showing in dealing with these lowlifes. "[...] anyone who hurls even one stone at security forces will be detained", meaning that until now one could throw at least one stone at the security forces with impunity. Ridiculous. The khayalim should've broken these brats' arms or used a number of tactics they use against rioting Palestinian "children." This hypocrisy and inequity really make my blood boil. But patience: the days of the settlers are slowly being numbered. I just hope we can get rid of them without having to repatriate them to Israel. Someone suggested a deportation to Uganda yesterday. A capital idea!
25. as if there is a legitimate govt'mt!
Ben Temalion ,   Shiloh, MO USA   (01.17.06)
You Jews find every new way to hate and kill yourselves, make yourself more vulnerable to those that come to kil Tel aviviv, err yourslevesl. Those who wan't to put a fork in it and asay the Zionist are dead , forget one thing.
26. Al Kahlil you ignorant @##$@
(01.17.06)
Are you kidding me. 200,000 arabs can't live in peace with 400 Jews. This has been the way forever, not just in Hebron but in all of Israel. you make me sick, go back to Egypt.
27. Edward #20
Sivan ,   Tel Aviv Israel   (01.17.06)
I can vouch for No. 8 CZ. I was also witness to arabic signs everywhere. And does a person have to be smoking crack to make a remark that you do not approve of? Would you like us to say that you are on crack too because we don't like your talkback. Grow up.
28. Sivan + CZ , are talking off their heads
Gabrielle Goldwater ,   Geneva Switzerland   (01.17.06)
You BOTH seem to have little real information and little know-how, but you both throw your mouth offffff Geneva doesn't belong to the European Union you silly fools. But grab your own. New York and the USA in general is overrun by Arabs, you have CAIR, you have all kinds of Arab leagues that cause serious problems and possible terrorcells, you have your universities overrun by Arabs and supported and funded by the Saudis. Look at your campuses and clean up your anti-Semitism there. Clean up your Arab controlled many organizations. Clean up your State Department .. which doesn't have an American desk but looks after the Arabs wonderfully. You have plenty of Arabic signs all over the USA, esp. New York, CAIR looks after that perfectly, and not one person closes them down. Now this would be illegal in Switzerland For Israel: Israel has two official languages; Hebrew and Arabic..... So what Arabic is spoken by the large Arab minority and by some members of the Mizrahi and Teimani Jewish communities. So who are you to talk about Arabic: Edward is very right actually for a change. We don't open up our borders to immigration, as the US does, who have no control over their borders . We don't give citizenship's away as the US and Britain does, and Israel as well. We don't allow hate speech, but legally pursue same at once, not as America and Britain lets anyone use hate speech, and claims it is legal free speech. It is not free speech at all. It is pure Racism most of the time If a foreigner doesn't behave or uses racism, he will deported at once from Switzerland, no matter what and who. So, Sivan and CZ ....... worry about your own and clean same. You sit in a glass-house and better stop throwing stones. When those times I don't agree with my countries acts, I have the right for my referendum, you don't have that right in the USA. Each subject in my country the public votes on, since we have what's called direct democracy Maybe you should take that for a change to your country. This is why Switzerland has tough laws on immigration, etc. We the people assure of it. It is our people that say via the vote who can be a citizen in our home. Try that for size you ignorant lot
29. Abdul Steiner should not be allowed to use foul language
Gabrielle Goldwater ,   Geneva Switzerland   (01.17.06)
It is the limit what you call the Israeli woman. Besides calling constantly Settlers, after all they are firstly ISRAELIS I don't agree with their actions and their illegal behavior, and Israel deals with it. you have NO right to call anyone names and make demands you are totally out of place YOU FAKE
30. HEBRON - The FIRST JEWISH CITY & SECOND IN JEWISH HOLINESS
Linda Rivera ,   New York   (01.17.06)
Respect is always given to Muslims! No one ever tries to steal Islamic land and Islamic sacred places! No one is trying to force Muslims out of Mecca and Medina! This CRUEL and FRIGHTENING IDEOLOGY that PUNISHES JEWS for NOT BEING MUSLIM MUST STOP! From: The Jerusalem Post, Nov 16, 2005 'The case for Mitzpe Shalhevet' by David Wilder "...The market was finally shut down following an attempted terrorist attack: Arabs placed a booby-trapped teddy bear in a plastic bag in the market near the entrance to the Jewish neighborhood, hoping a Jewish child, finding it, would play with it and be killed in the ensuing explosion. Despite numerous requests by our community to rent the structures, the site has been left vacant. On March 26, 2001, at the beginning of the Oslo War an Arab sniper shot and killed 10-month-old Shalhevet Pass. Following the murder, Hebron children began utilizing the abandoned Arab shuk as a place to play and take cover during shooting attacks from the overlooking Abu Sneneh Hills. Over a period of time, the Hebron community invested tens of thousands of dollars to convert the former fruit and vegetable stalls into livable apartments. Presently, the former market, renamed the Mitzpe Shalhevet neighborhood, houses Hebron families and a Torah study hall opened in Shalhevet's memory. Mitzpe Shalhevet is presently on the brink of obliteration, not by Arabs, but by the government..."
Next talkbacks
Back to article