Culture
Palestinian film wins Golden Globe
Merav Yudilovich
Published: 17.01.06, 08:50
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
61 Talkbacks for this article
31. To # 29
Truely Palestinian ,   Ramallah   (01.19.06)
If you have anything worth to say than say it. Dont repeat youself. And again if you have nothing worth to say dont bother writing a talkback. Try to find an objective site to look at. dont be mislead by such sites. Just as me as palestinian, i always try to lsn to the other part of the story. Try to be open minded and if you cant then enjoy ur stupidity. And im sorry to tell you that YES Palestine do exist. Go visit the Holocaust museum in Washigton (A totally Jewish side) there is a big map showing Palestine ;) Enjoy your visit and dont get mad of what you will see :)
32. "Palestinians" don't exist and never will!
Palestiniansareamyth ,   USA   (01.19.06)
The map you are referring to is a map of Israel which was re-named "Palestine" by the Romans and has no Arab connection.
33. truely Arab; Jews were the first to be called "Palestinians.
Palestiniansareamyth ,   USA   (01.19.06)
Because that is what the Romans re-named Israel. It never referred to an ethnic group like the Arabs claim. This proves that "Palestinians" don't exist.
34. #32,33 - Dont be Bothered by my name :)
Truely Palestinian ,   Ramallah   (01.19.06)
Check your info about history. We were there before the romans did. I guess you are totally out of knowledge in history. By the way ppl as closed minded as you are dont deserve my time. Im sorry and disappointed that there are ppl as extremist as you are. If you werent, you would not think about history. You would think as about a fair and permenant solutions for both nations. With ppl like you Israelis and Palestinians will suffer forever. Enjoy being a part of the reason of killing and bloodshed for both nations.
35. "Paradise now film"
Roy S. Gillinson M.D ,   Alexandria VA U.S.   (01.19.06)
Totally outrageous lying propaganda by anti- semitic enemies of the Nation State of Israel
36. Truely Arab; You are from Arabia!
Palestiniansareamyth ,   USA   (01.19.06)
Jews were in Israel thousands of years ago! You need to learn history!
37. Finally this kind of story...
Selma ,   Seattle, USA   (01.20.06)
I am so happy that finally there is a story of this kind. Not one that "glorifies terrorists", but simply humanizes them. We FINALLY get a look at human beings- not just a label.
38. Selma; Terrorists are not human beings!
Daisy ,   USA   (01.20.06)
Once you decide that you want to blow up little children and women just because they are Jewish you are a sub-human piece of trash. If you think that terrorists should be treated like himan beings then you are ethically and morally corrupt or maybe you just hate Jews.
39. To Daisy: Of course suicide bombers are human beings
Daniel ,   Amsterdam   (01.20.06)
That's why they are such an aweful terrible crime. Not only the deed of the suicide bomber is a crime but also the indoctrination it depends upon. One day Islamists -and among them Arafat- will be seen for what they are: The worst child abusers in recent history.
40. Hollywood
Jonathan and Mollie ,   Pennsylvania   (01.21.06)
What do you expect from a culture that idolizes a phony like Michael Moore, supports a cop killer like Mumia, makes a fortune with gangsta rap, and worships morons like Harry Bellefonte and Danny Glover?
41. to 36
(01.21.06)
if you can tell where there is a place called Arabia and where on the map can i find it and how to go there , i promiss you not to write here any more ... but if you don't know ... please don't show your ignorance too much ... because you are boring .
42. to the Daisy the ignorant
(01.21.06)
and the one he gave the order to kill thousends of women and children in Sabra and shatila is human being ? the IDF who shot died many children are humanbeings , the one who shot the child Mohamed el Dora he is a human bieng ... i will not mention Jenin , Kana .. and and ... this is to heavy for you ... you are not yet that intelegent to understand such heavy things .... i told you many times ... write about Donad Duck better .... lol
43. Don't judge America by Hollyweird
Bill ,   USA   (01.21.06)
Hollywood does NOT represent the USA. Look at the other golden globe winners - best drama for instance. They are pushing agendas, not mirroring what America thinks or wants to see. Golden Globe awards are given BY actors TO actors. Not by vote of average Americans. Heck, we don't even recognize California as part of America.
44. 36
(01.21.06)
jews MOVED idiot. MOVED_!!!! they went into diaspora and had kids with other 'races" and settled all over the world- Russia, Germany, Poland, Usa, BROOKYN- the jew/zionist wants Israel now, 9 fort some jewish headquarters) so they are selling this entitlement land ownership thing to the detriment of the NATIVES and PEOPLES that have live in the PALESTINIAN/ israeli area for 2000 years- ISRAEL was a DISMANTLED COUNTRY_ for over a 1000 YEARS_ so if you, as a jew propogandist are going to go lie about this fact- I will make sure more people know the true story- how the zionist club baked a plan to get the jew to take over the Palestinian land- P.s. and STOP BUMMING USA TAX DOLLARS- we are sick of it- sick of it!!!! you dont deserve our support let alone $$$- get a frickin job!!
45. Incredible FILM
USA   (01.21.06)
This is so exciting that the Americans are finally seeing the Palestinian view point- Most of the terror by the Jews against the ARAbs is hidden in our media- the checkpoints, torture- the "wall" the bulldozing of homes, the killing of children by the IDF and settlers-.- the humiliation the jews do against the Arabs- daily- No one understands the true picture- the pain of both sides- Hopefully this film symbolizes the turning point of blind prejudice the USA had in its relations with the JEWISH IMMIGRANTS-and its supporters actions!! CONGRATULATUINS PALESTINE
46. bigots and idiots
Drumgoole ,   NJ   (01.21.06)
There are no excuses for TARGETING and DELIBERATELY murdering innocent civilians. There are no excuses for encouraging your children to kill themselves by murdering innocent civilians. Those who make excuses or rationalize their depravity are monsters, just like those who plan and implement the horrors of a suicide bombing. Those bigoted morons ( Like #16 ) who babble about understanding both sides are evil and foul.
47. #41; Hey stupid Arabia is part of Saudi Arabia and Yemen etc
Palestiniansareamyth ,   USA   (01.22.06)
Get a map and look idiot!
48. #45; The only ones who saw the film in America are Arabs!
Palestiniansareamyth ,   USA   (01.22.06)
Keep dreaming slimeball. Americans will never support the evil terrorists who murder Jewish children and women.
49. #44; Are you as stupid as you sound?
Palestiniansareamyth ,   USA   (01.22.06)
Probably. Here I go again. ISRAEL EXISTED THOUSANDS OF YEARS AGO. IT WAS RE-NAMED PALESTINE BY THE ROMANS AND HAS NO ARAB CONNECTION WHATSOEVER! IN FACT JEWS WERE THE FIRST TO BE CALLED PALESTINIAN. THE ARABS ONLY STARTED USING THE TERM A FEW DECADES AGO TO STEAL THE JEWISH HOMELAND. THE CO-FOUNDER OF THE PLO, ZAHIR MUNHEISEN, EVEN ADMITTED THAT THE "PALESTINIAN PEOPLE" WERE A CREATION OF THE ARAB PEOPLE TO GET JEWISH LAND. SO YOU SEE THERE HAS NEVER BEEN AN ARAB COUNTRY CALLED PALESTINE OR A PALESTINIAN PEOPLE. THE ONLY NATIVE PEOPLE WHO LIVED IN ISRAEL WERE THE JEWS. MOST THE ARAB OCCUPIERS IMMIGRATED TO ISRAEL AFTER IT WAS FORMED TO GET EMPLOYMENT. THE JEWS DIDN'T DISPLACE ANYONE. STOP BEING PSYCHOTIC AND ACCEPT THE TRUTH! By the way I'm not Jewish but I have no problem giving Israel money. I do have a problem giving Arabs like yourself money that is used to murder innocent Jews. Arabs are the welfare bums who need to get off their lazy asses and do somthing productive insteading of whining. Everything I wrote is true so you can't debate me with facts so go on make something up.
50. Agree to 46
(01.22.06)
But the root of the conflict has to understood, meaning both perspectives.
51. 49- are you in denial?
(01.22.06)
Pre- 1948 , when the UN declared Isarel was now a state-there was only 17 percent jewish people in the area now previously known as PALESTINE- AND may I remind you- there wasnt really alot of conflict when the jews were 17 percent and the area was called PALESTINE. so read and research- so tell me, what HAPPENNNED what a whole lot of jews from Brooklyn and Russia IMMIGARTED to PALESTINE and lived off of USA generosity?
52. #51; I live in reality not fantasy.
Palestiniansareamyth ,   USA   (01.23.06)
Did you read my post? The name Palestine has nothing to do with the Arabs. Jews have always lived in Israel and there wasn't conflict until the Arabs immigrated and started murdering the Jews to take their land. That is a fact. All the Jews are indigenous to Israel because that is where their ancestors came from. The Arabs are the land thieves and occupiers.
53. #52
Truely Palestinian ,   Ramallah, Palestine   (01.23.06)
Have you heard about kanaanites????? These are people who came from the Arab world. They are ARABS. And they were in Palestine before you even knew anything about it. Go study history please. Im really sorry about your Ignorance. You live in a big lie that you created and then believed :) By the way i inteded not to respond to you coz i believe that this is going to no where. If you have anything to say then answer my 34 talkback and try to understand what im saying. Even though i know we have the right more than anyone in this land i still (as many Palestinians do) offer to find a solution with Israelis as our partners. This is because Palestinian are not and have never been as closed minded as you are. This is the difference between an inhumane person (you) and a peaceful person (me). I represent Palestinians, while you represent Israelis. Im not saying all Israelis are like you (i dealt with many that i consider as my peace partners). But this is the picture that you are showing.
54. #51; Are you psychotic?
Palestiniansareamyth ,   USA   (01.23.06)
Jews have always lived in Israel and their descendents have come back to their indigenous land. The Arabs are the occupiers and immigrants who came from another land. Their the ones who started killing the Jews and stealing their land. The root of all the trouble in the Middle East are the ARABS! End the Arab occupation of Jewish land!
55. 54 Respect yourself... if not end of discussion
Truely Palestinian ,   Ramallah   (01.23.06)
Get civilized and then discuss issues. If you are willing to live in reality then welcome to discussion if not then i dont have time to waste with such ignorant, disrespectful, uncivilized ppl like you :) again enjoy your ignorance.
56. 54
Truely Palestinian ,   Ramallah   (01.23.06)
You dont even have the courage to answer me. Before answering 51 answer me. Truely Palestinian is waiting for ur response. If you do know how to answer
57. Truely Arab; Your people are uncivilized, disrespectful.
Palestiniansareamyth ,   USA   (01.23.06)
Your name calling is hypocritical after seeing the way your people act. I already answered all the questions that were asked of me. If your too stupid to realize that then that's your problem not mine. Why haven't you answered my questions? If the so-called "Palestinians" exist then why were Jews first called "Palestinians?" Palestine is a Roman name so are you Roman? You people are insane and need medication for your sick fantasies.
58. www.palestineremembered.com
(01.24.06)
59. Again you are so uncivilized!!!!!!
Truely Palestinian ,   Ramallah   (01.24.06)
I really really cant talk to someone as impolite and disrespectful as you are. But still check this web site to make you even more upset :D ENJOY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! www.palestineremembered.com
60. Truely Arab; The website is for psychotic Arabs.
Palestiniansareamyth ,   USA   (01.25.06)
You need medications for your psychological problems. "Palestine" and "Palestinians" only exist in the minds of totally insane people!
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article