Jewish Scene
Nazi's relative turns Israel lover
Eyal Marcus
Published: 20.01.06, 12:00
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
51 Talkbacks for this article
1. This would make a great movie.
Daisy ,   USA   (01.20.06)
God does work in strange and mysterious ways.
2. this proves settlers are Nazis!
(01.20.06)
3. LOL
Chris ,   Toronto   (01.20.06)
21st Century Nazism is in... Israel! I'd love to sit in a meeting with her and some right-wing Israelis, as they talk about the "Arab question"
4. Gershon Fon Schwartza did it before ;) brauch haba ach sheli
Desperate Israeli   (01.20.06)
And #2 you are a ****ing idiot, I will personally punch you in the face if I ever came across you.
5. What a nice story, I enjoyed it
Yonatan ,   Knoxville, Tn. USA   (01.20.06)
6. to n 2
stephane ,   france   (01.20.06)
this proves that even our worst ennemies understand that jews are right.god bless this man and israel.
7. FINE LINE BETWEEN LOVE AND HATE
Seth ,   Washington, DC   (01.20.06)
8. I'm a little confused
CZ ,   NYC   (01.20.06)
Did he actually convert or does he just consider himself Jewish? Either I missed something or that wasn't made clear in the article.
9. #2
yossy hershkop ,   n.y   (01.20.06)
how dear ynetnews put #2 sick talk back and i agree with#4 its sad that a german is smarter then the israeli gov
10. I think Eytan Fox already made it (sort of)
Barbara   (01.21.06)
I refer to the movie "Walk on Water." The main female character who had a Nazi grandad moved to Israel, became a kibbutznik, and lived happily ever after with an Israeli husband, albeit a secular one.
11. Ok, he DOES have a screw loose
Zach ,   Israel   (01.21.06)
anyone who is convinced God is talking to them is a nutcase.
12. Excellent!
Digital Heretic   (01.21.06)
I understand his drive to defend Isael and the jewish people. One day you wake up with a mandate from God to love His people...and you do...unconditionally. I can't explain it either.
13. #4
Digital Heretic   (01.21.06)
HAhahahaha.
14. MATIAS GOERING
DEBRA ,   USA   (01.21.06)
HE SOUNDS LIKE A SMART AND DECENT MAN.
15. Voices
alan ,   south africa   (01.21.06)
If you talk to Gd you are pious... If you say Gd talks to you you are Meshuge.
16. And what are you, # 15?
Gerd ,   Germany   (01.21.06)
Something in between or simply -sorry- nothing?
17. no convert
barbara ,   washdc   (01.21.06)
it actually is clear that he has not converted. he mentions no contact with any jewish organization in switzerland. also note that this new found "love for the jewish people" only dates from 2005. such an extreme love can also turn to extreme hate. i hope he is sincere and will eventually convert, but i wouldn't put any money on it.
18. Nice bedtime story
Sam ,   Alquds, Palestine   (01.21.06)
I wonder in which language god talked to him? German? or Hebrew? it is interesting where Israel is getting the support nowadays. Ex-nazis really suit you guys. Ideas at least are very similar, chosen people, best of the best, we know better, others hate us, etc.....
19. GoeringSTEIN or GoeringOWITZ, WHICH ONE?
DACON9 ,   ITS A THIN LINE   (01.22.06)
20. barbara , washdc (01.21.06)
DACON9   (01.22.06)
BARBARA, WHO KNOWS IF EVEN THIS REPORT IS TRUE. IN ANY CASE A POTENTIAL CONVERT MUST NOT OBSERVE SHABBAT 100%, HE MUST BREAK IT IN SOME WAY BUT HE MAY OBSERVE MOST LAWS OF SHABBAT TO GET IN THE PRACTICE. HE CAN OBSERVE THE SEVEN NOAHIDE LAWS, WHICH MAKE HIM A RIGHTOUS XTIAN, MAYBE ITS WHAT HE IS DOING... I DONT KNOW, AND I DONT CARE, BUT IT IS A 'FUN' CONVERSATION. SEE YA AT THE PARTY TONIGHT.
21. Sam , Alquds, JEWISH ISRAEL (01.21.06)
DACON9 ,   MY FRIEND SAMMY   (01.22.06)
THESE IDEAS''' ARE PEACEFUL IDEAS. YOUR IDEAS ARE HOW TO MAKE A BOMB THAT WILL NOT BLOW UP PREMATURELY. I ONCE ASKED YOU,, >HOW MANY HUMPS ON A CAMEL? >WHAT DO CAMELS EAT IN THE DESERT? >CAN YOU RIDE SIDE SADDLE? >DO CAMELS SLEEP STANDING? AND WHY ARE YOU OBSESSED WITH TRACKING JEWISH NEWS SOURCES?
22. Dichotomy of Prayer
Shimon ,   Kfar Saba, Israel   (01.22.06)
When Man speaks to G-d, it's called prayer. When G-d speaks to a man, it's called schizophrenia
23. to sam (18)
stephane ,   france   (01.22.06)
so good night,and please...sleep 4 ever.
24. so we agree this is a crazy Nazi supporting lunatic settlers
(01.22.06)
25. to # 4 from #2 bite me babe! hahahahahaha!
(01.22.06)
26. 2 #9 its called free speech! bite me babe!
(01.22.06)
27. Sam...
Jacob Best   (01.22.06)
It's kind of hard for you to be in "Palestine" when the place, or name doesn't exist. There is no Palestine, and there are no Palestinian people. The term "Palestina" was invented by the murderous Roman emperor Hadrian. The Romans wanted to rename Eretz Yisrael (the Land of Israel) after the Philistines, the longtime enemy of the Jews. Hadrian believed that by renaming the Jewish homeland after the Jews' archenemy, he would be able to forever break the bond between the Land of Israel and the Jewish people. The name Philistines in Hebrew is plishtim, which comes from the Hebrew verb polshim (foreign invaders). So those who call themselves "Palestinians" are using a term that actually means "foreign invaders." The claim of the Arab Muslim Nazis that they lived in the Holy Land for 2,000 years, until the Jews came, is a lie. Arabs only came to the Land of Israel in large numbers after the Jews returned in the 20th century and started to rebuild the nation, thereby creating economic and employment opportunities for Arab immigrants. Prior to 1870, when Jews started to return to the Holy Land in large numbers, there were fewer than 100,000 Arabs living in what is today the State of Israel - including Yesha (the Hebrew acronym for Judea, Samaria and the Gaza District). This small number of nomadic, tribal Arabs who lived in the Holy Land before the modern Jewish return never considered themselves to be a separate people or nation. The Arabs who lived in the Land of Israel were not "Palestinians" but Arabs - part of a huge Arab people with 22 very large independent nations that control one-ninth of the land mass on the planet Earth. Back on topic, G-d works in mysterious ways in regard to the beliefs in different family members. Sort of like America in the Civil War time, brothers and brothers, sons and fathers, mothers and daughters were on oposite sides.
28. Ynet
Sam ,   Alquds, Palestine   (01.22.06)
It seems Ynet agrees with your ideas deca'on. Whenever I write something to make you and your friends shut up, they do not publish it, but this is typical in the "Democratic state of Israel" where the freedom of speech is kept for you and the settler thugs. The mere idea of calling Nazi ideas peaceful makes me puke.
29. Mr. Jacob Best
Sam ,   Alquds, Palestine   (01.22.06)
So you really believe all that what you wrote? You think seriously that the Arabs did not inhabit Palestine until the Zionist settlers came from overseas? I wonder who lived in Jerusalem for a thousand years since the Crusaders were kicked out of the city? Did the Arabs kick them out to leave the city in ruins? What about bethlehem? What about Jaffa and Haifa? So you are totally convinced that the Zionists came to a land with no people. If this is meant to be a propaganda campaign for some rednecks in texas, it might work, but if you want to come to decent people with brains in the rest of the world, I doubt you will have any audience. Zionists are actually the ones who fabricate a lie and then say it over and over until they start defending it as a fact. Go back to your history books and find out when the first municipality of Jerusalem was founded. I don't think nomadic tribes need a municipality, not in jerusalem and not in Jaffa and not in Ramla. Why am I actually bothering to answer your screwed version of history? Read some real books of history first.
30. Sam , Alquds, ISRAEL
DACON9 ,   ISRAEL''IS'' FOREVER   (01.23.06)
i will be honest with out sarcasm on this posting OK? 1) **YNET DOESNT PUBLISH EVERYTHING FOR ANYONE., NOT YOU AND NOT ME. IT IS THE SCREENERS JUDGEMENT IF THE COMMENTS ARE NOT INCITING UNDUE HATE OR HARSHNESS I GUESS. 2) NAZIS I DETEST OF COURSE , I AM A JEW, I AM A SYRIAN JEW SO WE HAD OUR OWN ATROCITITES COMMITTED BY QUEEN ISABELLA THEN THE ARABS AS WE MOPVED LOOKING FOR REFUGE FROM THE KILLING SOCIETIES THAT PREACH FREEDOM OR HONESTY OR TRUTH. BEING I MENTIONED SYRIAN , MY PEOPLE KNOPW YOUR PEOPLE VERY VERY VERY WELL. THERE WILL NEVER EVER BE PEACE BETWEREN US. SADDAM WAS A MURDERING TYRANT TOLD TO ME FROM MANY IRAQI JEWS. 3) ISRAEL IS NOT MADE UP OF EUROPEAN JEWS THAT HAVE NO RIGHT TO BE IN ISRAEL. JEWS WERE THERE BEFORE WE WERE CHASED ALL OVER THE CONTINENTS SEARCHING FOR SAFETY..SOME JEWS WENT TO EUROPE SOME WENT TO SPAIN SOME WENT TO SOUTH AMERICAN. THE EUROPEAN JEWISH POPUL;ATION OF ISRAEL MEWRELY WENT BACK HOME WHERE THERE GREAT GREAT GRANDPARENT WERE BORN AND LIVED, 4) YOU KNOW THAT THERE IS NO SUCH THING AS PALISTINIAN ARABS ENTITLED TO A LAND CALLED PALITISTINE. AND YOU KNOW THAT THE ARTABS LEFT ISRAEL IN 1047 AND WEREINVITED BACK BY THE JEWS TO LIVE IN PEACE SIDE BY SIDE AND ONLY AFTER ISRAEL MADE THE DESERT BLOOM DID ARAFART VREATE A VERY SUCCESSFUL CAMPAIGN FOR A PALISINTIAN LAND . YOU CANT MAKE A DIG ANYWHERE TO FIND ANCIENT ''PALISITINIAN ARTIFACS'' BUT YOU WILL FIND ANCIWENT HEBREW COINS AND POTTERY. *** NOW FOR THE MAIN BLOW TO YOUR bELIEF SYSTEM**** MANY MANY CHILDREN AND/OR GRANDCHILDREN OF THE NAZIS REGIME THE SS THE GESTAPO DID IN FACT CONVERT TO JUDAISM BECAUSE OF THE EXTREME FAITH AND SURVIVAL OF THE NATION OF ISRAEL , THE ABOVE STORY MOST LIKELY IS VERY TRUE. I AM SURE THAT YOU WILL SEARCH FOR ANSWERS BECAUSE YOU ARE NOW COMPLETLY EMBARRASSED TO FACE ME OR COMMENT ANYMORE WITH YOUR HATE FOR US JEWS.. IF YOU ARE A MUSLIM , BE REMINDED THAT ISLAM CAME 1500 YEARS AFTER TORAH. HAR HABAYIT WHICH YOU CALL THE TEMPLE MT WAS BUILT IN & ON OUR HOLY TEMPLE , THE HOLIEST SPOT ON EARTH FOR JEWS. NOW SHOW ME ANY EFFORT THAT THE ARABS OF TODAY HAVE TRIED TO REASON / CONCEDE / MAKE EFFORT OR GESTURES FOR PEACE . IT HAS NEVER BEEN DONE BY ANY ARAB SINCE ISHMAELS SONS . YOU HAVE REWRITTEN BIBLICAL HISTORY WHERE YIZTHAQ WAS TO BE SACRFICED AND REPLACED HIM WITH ISHMAEL.BUT LIKE THE XTIANS, YOUR REWRITE CAME THOUSAND OF YEARS AFTER TORAH. WHERE IS THE CREDIBILTY IN THAT? NOW FOR HEBRON. ABRAHAM ''OUR'' FATHER OVER PAID FOR THAT LAND HE BOUGHT . THE REASON 'OVER PAYMENT IS EMPHASIZED IS BECAUSE ABRAHAM DID NOT WANT ANY DISPUTES IN THE FUTURE GENERATIONS OF WHO OWNED THAT LAND. OF COURSE I DONT EXPECT YOU TO ACCEPT ANY OF THIS,, BUT THE WAY OF THE JEW IS TO TRY TO EXPLAIN THINGS WITH REASON AND SENSE BEFORE WE GO TO WAR. THE PROPHESIES OF THE ARAB NATION IS NOT TO GOOD EXCEPT FOR ANY RIGHTOUS AMONGST YOU.I SUGGEST THAT YOU TRY TO BE KIND TO EVERY JEW YOU MEET AND BE IN PEACE WITH THEM BEFORE THE END COMES. WHEN WE DIE, IT IS TO LATE TO MAKE RESTITUTION. THATS WHEN WE ARE ON TRIAL IN THE HEAVENS FOR OUR WAYS IN THIS MORTAL EARTHLY MATERIALIST SKIN . YOU PUKE FROM NAZIS YET YOUR NATION ACT LIKE NAZIS... IN YOUR SOUL YOU ARE A GOOD MAN I AM SURE. LET YOUR GOOD OUT , DONT BE EMBARRASSED IF YOU SOFTEN YOUR STANCE ..SOME NAZIs DID.
Next talkbacks
Back to article