Jewish Scene
Nazi's relative turns Israel lover
Eyal Marcus
Published: 20.01.06, 12:00
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
51 Talkbacks for this article
31. God is one for all humans
anton ,   victoria   (01.23.06)
Very interesting story, which tells that it is important the mind and soul, the God in them, inside the human being not the outside mask or cloth, flag which can be anything else but not important.
32. ARABS LEFT ISRAEL IN 1047 AND >>1947
DACON9   (01.23.06)
33. Very enchanting Deca'on
Sam ,   Alquds, Palestine   (01.23.06)
You really made me think how bad I am, and how much I need to get your acceptance as one of the chosen people in order to be accepted by god. Did you believe what I wrote? Don't. If anyone compares between the Nazis and anybody else in the world, the first people to stand up and call them antisemitic are you and your friends. And you did say that supremacy ideas are peaceful, we all saw how peaceful they were in mid 20th century. I was not impressed by your speech, and concerning the Iraqi jews, maybe you should go back to the memoires of the leaders of the Jewish Agency to see the schemes drawn by its leaders in order to make a prosperous jewish minority leave Iraq, and the bombs planted by Zionist agents in Baghdad and other cities' jewish clubs in order to scare them out. I wonder how can you really believe that the Zionists are the martyrs of Arab arrogance and misjudgement. The Arab countries were really the safest refuge European Jewry could take after the inquisition in Spain, and their decision to go to Arab countries was made because the Jews had their best days living under the Arabs rule in Andalus. As for me hating Jews, don't make me feel you do not understand english when you read it. I never ever attacked Jews, or any of their beliefs. I always attack the Zionist ideas, which try to twist Jewish beliefs in order to suit their objectives. Zionists have nothing to do with true Judaism, and if you can't see that then you must be really blind, like a man who is blindfolded and drawn to his death. The Jewish state in Jewish prophecies is not to be established by a couple of Eastern European socialists, who only believe the Torah is merely a history book, unless the Torah you read is different to that sold in the bookstore. Finally, I do not see any blows in your comments, and this piece of Propaganda saying that Palestine was empty is clearly denounced by the report Herzl got from a group of Rabbis he sent here when he was trying to convince them to call for the Jews to go to Palestine. One of the Rabbis said: "The bride is beautiful, but she's taken". I wonder which bedouin tribe he meant???
34. AS I SAID.THERE WILL NEVER EVER BE PEACE
DACON9 ,   WAR WILL BE SOON   (01.23.06)
IF ONLY PRES BUSH AND SHARON AND SHADOW LEARN THIS.
35. to Sam
mordy   (01.23.06)
Sam- I usually don't participate in these discussions, but your last posting was fairly polite indicating that you are interested in serious discussion. One thing you are very deeply mistaken about and that is the relation between Zionism and Judaism. True, there are non-Zionist Jews, but their existence does not preclude the fact that Zionism today is the movement of Jewish people for their statehood in Eretz Yisrael, the expression of the ultimate national will of the Jewish people. Additionally, the goals of the Zionist movement in its origins were never expulsion of the Arabs from Eretz Yisrael-rather it was peaceful settlement with ultimate goals of statehood with full rights for ALL its citizens. This goal was originally supported by some Arab leaders, for example Emir Feisal who later became the king of Iraq. Unfortunately, however, you guys started the war against us AS early as 1920s that included brutal killings of largely non-Zionist Jews who lived in Hebron in 1929. Yiftach al-Yehud (kill the Jews) has been and is still largely is the goal of the Palestenian arabs. The only thing you were condusive to was to keep us in the status of the dhimmie (2nd class citizens) that we were held as in your countries since the expulsion from Spain and before. Well, we were not willing to accept that. We believe we have historical and ianaliable rights in Israel and you should learn to accept this because, I hate to say this, you tried to throw us out and lost multiple times. You think we are some kind of colonists, but this is a very deeply erroneous belief-the love of the land and people of Israel is inherent in every Jew, especially after the Holocaust. I grew up in Russia and had that love for no reason for a very long time before I even knew Israel existed. Love of Israel is within our blood-you can't win, especially after 60 years of trying we will not leave. The best you could hope for is peaceful co-existence and sharing of the land which has always been the goal of the majority of Zionists and the every official Israeli government. Your attempts to destroy us only delay it further.
36. Dacon-great post
Mike   (01.23.06)
he could not argue with facts only pathetic slogans and familiar rhetoric.
37. Mordy, and Mike
Sam ,   Alquds, Palestine   (01.23.06)
Well Mordy, I am always open for a polite and thorough discussion, but some people here are not. A good example is our friend Mike here, who says I could not answer Dacon's "facts" and was writing slogans... I dare him to point out any slogan in my comments, and I asked him to go to historical references I named where he could find information which destroys all his well-built "facts". It's his choice if he wants to enlighten himself. Well mordy. I wonder what class the Arab Palestinians who still are inside the 1948 borders, i.e. Israel have? Are they first class citizens? This is the same argument you are trying to impose about the jews being second class citizens in Arab countries. I lived in Europe for a long while, and as a foreigner I had also to pay taxes which the indigenous people did not have to pay, I had less rights in all aspects of life, and as a foreigner I accepted that, do you expect Arab countries to treat foreigners better than European countries? I don't. But you are treating the Palestinians who refused to leave their country in 1948 as third class citizens, deprived of many rights, and there is no need to count them right now. As for love for the land, why do you assume that we have less love in our hearts than you do for this land? I think it is unfair, but if you want to entertain yourself with this idea, please do. Last but not least, you seem to be very proud of Israel's power, and the fact that it never lost a war that meant something, but the questions which come to my mind, is Israel stronger than the Roman Empire? Is it stronger than the Pharaoes of Egypt at their time? Actually is it today stronger than King David's kingdom? Is it stronger than the Soviet Union? Sadly not, moreover without the ambilical cord from the US, Israel could have never done it, whether you admit it or not. Where are those Empires now? This kind of rhetoric is the beginning of the end of Israel actually. You have the power, so you rule in Palestine now, it is the right of might, but do not deceive yourselves with such ideas of (this land was empty, we made the desert bloom, etc...).
38. SAMMY BABY
DACON9 ,   ALL ISRAEL AFTER 67   (01.23.06)
THE KINGDOMS YOU MENTIONED AND MANY MORE THAN THAT FELL BECAUSE THEY WENT AGAINST ISRAEL. JEWS ANSWER TO 'GD' THROUGH THE MIGHT OF THE MORTALS. BUT THOSE THAT CARRY OUT THE EVIL WILL ALSO PAY THE PRICE. ITS A BIT DEEP AND A BIT KABALLISTIC MAYBE AND A BIT ABOVE YOUR INTELLECT. THE ANSWER IS THAT THESE ARABS SQUATTING IN ISRAEL EXCEPT FOR THE ORIGINAL ,(250,00 was it.?) MUST GO BACK TO THE DETENTION CAMPS IN JORDAN .!!! AND YOU SHOULD GO BACK TO DISNEY WORLD. I AM SHARPENING MY SHIELD AND SWORD TO JEWS TO KNOW. OUR SHIELD AND SWORD IS PRAYER. THROUGH PRAYER AND REPENTANCE ''GD'' WILL HEAR US AND COME TO OUR NEEDS. TO YOU ARABS. OUR SWORD AND SHIELD THROUGH OUR 'GD' OF ISRAEL IS POWER AND MIGHT OF MILITARY SUPERIORITY. ''GD'' PROMISED THAT ISRAEL WILL ALWAYS EXIST. SAMMY .... YOU ARE A GOOD MAN FOR YOUR CAUSE... YOU WILL NOT SOFTEN AND NOT BACK OFF NOT EVEN AN INCH. YOU HAVE NO COMPASSION FOR HUMANITY. THAT IS THE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN JUDAISM AND ALL OTHER NATIONS. JEW BALANCE MERCY AND JUSTICE.. THAT IS THE WAY OF 'GD'. SAMMY IF I WAS OF MILITARY AGE... AND A WARRIOR TODAY.. I WOULD HAVE GREAT JOY AND PLEASURE.. TO LOCK AND LOAD AGAINST YOU. WHILE I DO THAT I WOUILD LOOK IN YOUR EYES AND SEE YOU PLEADING ASKING BEGGING "WHY, WHAT DID I DO TO DESERVE TO DIE.?" YOUR PEOPLE ARE INCAPABLE OF UNDERSTANDING,,WHETHER YOU WEAR ARMANI SUITS OR EDUCATED IN HARVARD. THE CAMELS ARE THIRSTY SAMMY THE END.
39. to sam
mordy   (01.24.06)
Sam, You are distorting the truth in your reply. To start with, yes, the status of the dhimmie that Jews had in Arab countries is a very, very far cry from Arab citizens' status in Israel. A dhimmie had no basic rights, such as to own certain kind of property, could not own horses, i.e. pose any kind of competition to a Muslim. In addition, dhimmies were subject to killings and beatings by Muslims way before Israel was created, as is for example in Iraq in 1941,and for thousands of years before. Needless to say, you showed special love of dhimmies that had nothing to defend themselves with in 1929 in Hevron when your bros killed mostly probably Jews that had no interest whatsoever in Zionism. For further "beautiful" status of the dhimmie, here is the passage for you: The concept of toleration [of the dhimmie] is linked to a number of discriminatory obligations in the economic, religious and social fields, imposed by the shari'a on the dhimmis. The transgression by the dhimmis of some of these obligations, abolished their protection, and threaten them with death or slavery. Dhimmis suffered many legal disabilities intended to reduce them to a condition of humiliation, segregation and discrimination. These rules, established from the eight to nine centuries by the founders of the four schools of Islamic law, set the pattern of the Muslim's community's social behavior toward dhimmis. (from http://www.dhimmitude.org/d_history_dhimmitude.php) So please spare me: Arab Israelis have full civil rights, including full Kenesseth repreentation. Including in those rights is free ability to call for Israel's desctruction as your arab MKs have recently done. Arab Israelis are a minority and they do experience discrimination as that minority, something Israel is not proud of and will hopefully successfully address with time. But the status of the Israeli Arabs is bascially that of full citizens, while Jewish status in Arab countries was that of someone who was tolerated because they were useful, and otherwise could be disposed of. I am not suggesting you love your land less than we do ours. The fact of the matter is that I do accept your love, but the reality is that you do not accept mine. This is why your bros started the war against us in 1948, left mainly at the instigation of your Sirian, Jordanian, Iraqi and Egyptian bros and were not allowed back to kill more Jews.Those who stayed had faired much better than in any other Arab country, thriving on Israeli social system and world-class education. The fact of the matter is that probably so do you since you live in the East Jerusalem that allows you to collect National Insurance Institute payments as an Israeli and hold anti-Israeli views at the same time. So please spare us all your rhetoric. This is the rhetoric that has gotten your Arab brothers nowhere-look at where you are and where the rest of the world is. I am not enamored with the Israeli power, neither are the Israelis. Most of them would gladly not serve in the army if your brothers and sisters did not want to kills Jews so badly. The reason why I think you will ultimately lose again is because you have always lost-you never seem to get us. We survived Hitler, certainly we will survive you. You are underestimating Jewish ability to persevere, to build, to be a community. If you did not, long time we would have an agreement, you would be drinking your coffee while watching your stocks go up on Tel-Aviv stock exchange. You do not get this though-you can be miserable for the rest of your life, live with the hope of throwing Jews to the sea, deny our basic historical rights and continue to be miserable. Or you can recognize that we have to share the land, stop trying to kill us and try to work out the solution that each party could agree to, not the one that is meant to destroy Israel if not by military, but by demographic means.
40. Keep dreaming Deca'on
Sam ,   Alquds, Palestine   (01.24.06)
41. Mordy
Sam ,   Alquds, Palestine   (01.24.06)
You keep on entertaining yourself with those prejudices and moulded ideas about the Arabs trying to kill every jew yada yada yada, but do you see me holding a gun to your head? I am trying to get some sense out of you and the people here, and if I were trying to kill you why should I bother talk to you here? Wouldn't it be more effective to go buy a gun? Min famika Udinok is an Arab proverb, and it means, I indicte you from your mouth. Mr. Mordy, havce you ever read the memoires of Ben Gurion? He was talking about the war Israel had to wage in 1947-1948 in order to get rid of the largest number possible of the Palestinians who lived inside the 1948 borders, because that was viable for the jewish state to be established, so think it over when you say over and over again that the Arabs tried to throw us in the sea. As for the Palestinians inside Israel getting world class education, last time I checked the number of Palestinian students in Hebrew universities was to be kept to a minimum, and the policy is to direct them towards studying abroad as part of a larger scheme, making them leave and as soon as they are outside for a certain number of years they would be deprived of their right to citizenship, not to mention the possibility of them staying anyways abroad due to the fact they find open doors in contradiction to their situation back home where everything is preserved for the first class citizens... If you want to continue fooling yourself, please do, but I suggest more readings. Have a nice day.
42. AS I SAID PT11, THERE WILL NEVER EVER BE PEACE
DACON9 ,   PEACE,NO WAY JOSE   (01.24.06)
43. the inside of a bitter grape is sweet
hanina ,   usa   (01.24.06)
Hashem enjoys answering the prayers of the innocent who decend from evil. It's his way of turning around the clock and making something good out of something bad.
44. HANINA
DACON9   (01.25.06)
NOT A GOOD UNDERSTANDING OR TRANSLATION WINE COMES FROM A BITTER GRAPE MEANS ANYONE CAN TURN AROUND AND BE GOOD. 'GD' WILL WAIT FOR YOU. SIMPLY PUT
45. Nazis? This only proves that someone has a good soul
R. Walter Franco ,   Belmont, CA. USA   (01.25.06)
Matias' story is one of many that gives humanity hope to be redeem from darkness. He is right not to feel guilty for the stupidity of others and to choose the path of a mensch. Those that belittle and hate the "Settlers" rush to judge them without knowing History, motivations and the human right to choose where you live. You may disagree with their politics or their significance but you do not have the right to go so low and call them "Nazis." Have you ever studied the nazi past of the Arab leadership? Please enlighten yourself.
46. i don't know if to believe him or not...
(01.26.06)
maybe he's just doing such to avoid any confrontation with the jews nowadays because of his past...
47. matias goering
Mark dowding ,   england   (02.04.06)
Relatives of Hermann Goering interest me, because my grandfather, A.C.M. Dowding, was his counterpart in the Battle of Britain.
48. CORRECTION
Paul Gilmar ,   D-Aglasterhausen   (04.18.06)
Correction !! The articles, published following the interwiew of our brother Matthias Göring by Ruth Elkin on different internet sites in february and march 2006 contain errors and quotations. The interview is concerning statements of our brother on his family and his family life. The description and comments concerning our parents are wrong and erroneours. Therefor we, as the brothers and sisters of Matthias would like to rectify the following items: 1. The great grandfather of Matthias Göring was not the brother of Hermann Göring’s grandfather. Indeed, the the great-grandfather of Matthias Göring, Peter Johann Göring (1852-1927), did some research on his greater family. The common ancestor with Hermann Göring was the lawyer Christian Heinrich Göring (1740-1805). 2. Our father was never a prisoner of war of the Russians. On the contrary, the Russians only checked his identity for a few days. After 1945 he was imprisoned by the Americans and French for some days due to denounciation. He was released after the context had been clarified. 3. It is wrong to affirm our parents had espressed antisemitic views. On the contrary our father was very sceptic concerning the Nazi regime after 1933. There is evidence that he only joined the party in 1938 in order to be able to support his lecturers in psychologie and psychotherapie at Munich university. 4. It is wrong that we were opressed by our parents. On the contrery we had a joyful childhood and our parents supported us as much as they could. Indeed they were very ambitious and requested our participation for example, they supported the author of these lines (Michael Christian Göring) in his dispute with his highschool for democratic reasons. Afterwards he left school and his parents payed for a three year private training to prepare his A-levels. 5. The articles wrongly state:”In my family we all learned to hate them, not to love them. Wo grew up understanding that Israel and the Jewish people are to blame for the fact that our family had no money”. On the contrary except our brother Matthias, none of us, neither our relatives or friends have had this kind of experience. In our family there was no antisemitic athmosphere. We have not experianced hatred against other human beings. 6. The statements in the articles, that we were told that there was no money for new toys because all our money had gone to the jews, is wrong. On the contrary we had many and often quite expensive toys for every age. For example kits for physical and chemical experiments, roller skates in summer, slay and ice skates for the winter and even horses. We, as the brothers and sisters of Matthias are unable to explain how our brother could have had such experiences. Inparticular we don’t know why our brother concludes that there was constant antisemitism in our family, as a doctor and psychotherapist our father had jewish patients among others. Even they were in contact with our family and haven’t observed observed any antisemitic tendencies. Peter Christoph Göring, Christiane Charlotte Göring, Dr. Michael Christian Göring, Hemma Christina Koepplin-Göring
49. help pls.
Daisy ,   United States   (04.28.06)
hey i need info about the nazi's pls.
50. More oil to the fire...
leo ,   usa   (01.13.07)
http://www.frontpagemag.com/media/pdf/BigLies.pdf
51. Matias Goering
sb ,   ohio, usa   (09.19.09)
Be careful as he may be putting on this charade in order to get investment capital from the Jewish business community.
Previous talkbacks
Back to article